The Indicator from Planet Money

Episode: "What's going on with men's labor force participation?"
Host/Authors: Adrienne Ma, Waylon Wong, Darian Woods
Release Date: January 10, 2025

Introduction

In this episode of The Indicator from Planet Money, hosts Adrienne Ma, Waylon Wong, and Darian Woods delve into the latest trends and data from the American labor market. Titled "What's going on with men's labor force participation?", the episode explores various indicators from the December jobs report, focusing on wage growth, the duration of unemployment, and the participation rates of men in the labor force.

Latest Jobs Report Overview

The discussion begins with a summary of the December jobs report released by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS).

• Unemployment Rate: The unemployment rate slightly decreased to 4.1% (00:27).

  Adrienne Ma [00:27]: "In December, the unemployment rate ticked down slightly to 4.1%."

• Job Additions: The economy added 256,000 jobs in December, marking a strong finish for the jobs market in the last month of 2024 (00:38).

  Adrienne Ma [00:38]: "The economy also added 256,000 jobs. So for the last month of 2024, the jobs market finished pretty strong."

Despite previous concerns over a potentially softening jobs market—complicated by labor strikes and hurricanes—the latest figures indicate that employers remain optimistic about hiring.

Wage Growth vs. Inflation

Adrienne Ma highlights a significant aspect of the jobs report: wage growth outpacing inflation for the second consecutive year.

• Average Hourly Wage: Increased to $35.69, up 3.9% from the previous year (02:48).

  Adrienne Ma [02:48]: "In 2024, the average hourly wage increased to $35.69 an hour. That's an increase of 3.9% from a year before that."

• Inflation Rate: Rose by 2.7%, slower than wage growth (03:13).

  Adrienne Ma [03:13]: "For the second year in a row, wages increased faster than inflation."

This trend is particularly noteworthy as many Americans have been grappling with the lingering effects of inflation. Adrienne raises concerns about the sustainability of this wage growth, especially in light of potential policy changes under the Trump administration, such as tariffs and mass deportations, which could exacerbate inflation (03:14).

Duration of Unemployment

Darian Woods shifts the focus to the duration of unemployment, an essential indicator of labor market health.

• Median Duration: The median length of unemployment in December was 10.5 weeks, up about a week from the previous year (03:51).

  Darian Woods [03:51]: "The median length of time that people were out of a job in December was ten and a half weeks."

While a duration of ten and a half weeks is relatively standard outside of recessionary periods, the concerning aspect is the upward trend in unemployment duration over recent years (04:06). This prolonged unemployment can signify a cooling labor market and presents challenges for affected individuals.

Further analysis reveals that long-term unemployed individuals (those unemployed for six months or longer) are increasing, although slightly reduced in the latest report. These individuals face harder job prospects and may encounter discrimination from employers or experience skill degradation (04:43).

Darian Woods [04:59]: "Most long term unemployed people actually look pretty similar to short term unemployed people. The types of qualifications don't change much."

Additionally, research indicates psychological impacts, such as reduced motivation and fewer hours spent job hunting, exacerbating the difficulty in re-employment (05:10).

Men's Labor Force Participation

Waylon Wong introduces the topic of men's labor force participation, an essential measure of economic engagement among working-age men.

• Recent Trend: The participation rate for men over the age of 20 is 70.22%, nearing pre-pandemic levels (07:00).

  Waylon Wong [07:00]: "The participation rate for men over the age of 20 was 70.22%. This rate is almost back to pre-pandemic levels."

Historically, men's labor force participation has been in decline for several decades. However, recent data suggests a slight uptick, prompting an exploration of underlying factors.

Key reasons cited for men's exclusion from the labor force include:

1. Retirement: Surprisingly, some men cite retirement as a reason despite being in prime working ages (07:46).
2. Disability or Illness: Health issues, including opioid use, significantly contribute to non-participation.
3. Caretaking Responsibilities: Men leaving the workforce to care for children or dependents.
4. Education: Enrollment in educational programs keeps some men out of the labor force temporarily.

Waylon Wong [07:46]: "One is retirement, which is kind of interesting given their age. But another big factor is disability or illness. And there's research suggesting that opioid use might play a role here."

Darian Woods emphasizes the policy implications of these findings, noting the need for comprehensive strategies to address health-related barriers and support caregiving responsibilities to enhance men's participation in the labor market (08:24).

Darian Woods [08:24]: "If there are a huge group of men who want to be working but can't because of health problems or caregiving responsibilities, that points to some pretty big public policy challenges."

Conclusion and Additional Insights

Adrienne Ma wraps up the discussion by summarizing the key indicators:

• Rising Wages: Outpacing inflation, providing relief to workers.
• Extended Unemployment Durations: Indicating potential cooling in the labor market.
• Men's Labor Force Participation: Showing signs of recovery but highlighting ongoing challenges.

In a light-hearted update, Adrienne shares the results of a recent Family Feud-style poll where consumer sentiment was voted as the top economic indicator for 2024.

Adrienne Ma [09:00]: "In first place with more than half the votes was my indicator, consumer sentiment."

This segment underscores the show's engaging approach to discussing economic indicators, blending serious analysis with interactive elements.

Key Takeaways

• Economic Strength: Despite some cooling signs, the labor market remains robust with decreasing unemployment rates and rising wages.
• Wage vs. Inflation: Continued wage growth outpacing inflation offers positive news for workers but faces uncertainty with potential policy changes.
• Unemployment Duration: Increasing duration of unemployment signals challenges that need addressing through supportive policies.
• Men's Participation: Slight recovery in men's labor force participation is encouraging, yet underlying issues like health and caregiving responsibilities require comprehensive solutions.

Produced by: Angel Carreras
Engineering: Neil Rauch, Jimmy Keighley
Fact-Checked by: Sierra Juarez
Editor: Cait Concannon
Production: NR

Timestamps Reference

• 00:27: Unemployment Rate and Job Additions
• 02:48: Wage Growth Details
• 03:13: Wages vs. Inflation
• 03:51: Duration of Unemployment
• 04:43: Long-term Unemployment Insights
• 07:00: Men's Labor Force Participation Rate
• 07:46: Reasons for Men's Non-Participation
• 08:24: Policy Implications
• 09:00: Family Feud Poll Update

For more insights and episodes, visit plus.npr.org/planetmoney.