Transcript
Isabel (0:00)
Marshall's buyers are hustling hard to get amazing new gifts into stores right up to the last minute. Like a designer perfume for that friend who never RSVP'd wishlist topping toys for.
Ali Beth Stuckey (0:11)
Her kids who came too.
Isabel (0:13)
Belgian chocolates for the neighbor, a cozy scarf for your boss, and a wool jacket for your husband that you definitely did not almost forget. Marshalls. We get the deals, you get the good stuff.
Ali Beth Stuckey (0:25)
Even at the last minute. The find a Marshall's near you.
Isabel (0:30)
Limu Emu and Doug Here we have the Limu Emu in its natural habitat, helping people customize their car insurance and save hundreds with Liberty Mutual. Fascinating. It's accompanied by his natural ally, Doug.
Ali Beth Stuckey (0:47)
Uh, Limu is that guy with the binoculars watching us.
Isabel (0:50)
Cut the camera. They see us. Only pay for what you need@libertymutual.com Liberty Liberty Liberty Liberty Savings Ferry Unwritten by.
Ali Beth Stuckey (0:58)
Liberty Mutual Insurance Insurance Company Affiliates excludes Massachusetts hey gang. Happy Monday. We are back From Turning Point USA's America Fest where we spent last weekend in Phoenix, Arizona with now 31,000 of our closest friends patriots from all over the world. I believe there were more than 25 countries represented, more than 50 states and getting a chance to meet so many of you in person. Thank you to those who stopped by our Daily Wire booth went to my meet and greetings last weekend. It was so phenomenal. Getting a chance to give you guys hugs and tell you Merry Christmas and just thank you, thank you, thank you for your endless support of me, my content and our show here with Daily Wire America Fest is a special event for me in particular because I was there at the very first America Fest in 2021 and have seen this event just evolve over the years in really powerful and profound ways, but have been attending Turning Point USA conferences since the summer of 2017. So especially comparing what happened last weekend with 30 plus thousand people, 80% of whom were there for their very first TP USA event ever, 55% of whom were women. We were reasonably told. Which is amazing news and totally brand new. Comparing that to like the first conference that I went to in June of 2017 when there was like 500 to 1,000 young women sitting in a hotel ballroom at the hotel attached to the airport in Dallas Fort Worth with like a sad little paper backdrop for the stage. There was no major production, no nothing. It is amazing to know how many minds are being changed in real time thanks to activism from students on college campuses across the country. Just like I was many years ago from speakers who are dedicating their time especially around the holidays, to influence our culture in all of the most powerful ways possible. And from organizations like Turning Point USA and their new leadership, the beautiful, courageous, fearless and wise Erica Kirk, who is just beyond strong to a level that I can't even begin to wrap my head around, but said something really poignant to Andrew Colvette, the producer of the Charlie Kirk show, who we'll have an episode with next week, which I know you guys will be excited about, said something to him at the end of the conference that he tweeted out this morning saying, look what even from the darkest, most horrifying part of our lives, God is bringing from the ashes. If this doesn't make you believe in God, I don't know what could. So America Fest was amazing. Got to have a one night stopover in Colorado and see my family before the Christmas holiday this week. And now we are back in D.C. snuggled up for an amazing family Christmas this week as well. But before we break for the holidays, we wanted to do an episode today on a topic and that many of you guys have been requesting over the past few weeks, largely because our guest for today has talked about this for the last few years and caught quite a bit of heat and flack for it from her own community, either really, really strongly agreeing with her or vehemently disagreeing with her. We'll be joined in an interview that we filmed at amfest today on the show by our friend Ali Beth Stuckey, which I'm so, so excited for you guys to see, but she just did an episode of her podcast this week on whether or not Christian families should do Santa, do Santa. Da da da da da. It's very intense. I know we have a lot of strong feelings about all of these things and everyone is totally entitled to their own opinion. You're not forced to do any tradition in your own home, especially around very important religious holidays like Christmas, which is our second most important religious holiday behind Easter as Christians. But before we jump into all of the pros and cons and particularly what our family is thinking about as we approach our first Christmas ever as parents, which has been amazing, I wanted to share with you guys something that I learned the other day that may or may not influence your family's decision to honor Santa Claus. I never really considered the history of Santa ever in my personal thoughts of loving Santa when I was growing up and wanting to share that with my daughter and but the church history aspect of this is fascinating. I told you guys last week that one of my all time favorite Christmas movies is the 1994 Miracle on 34th street that was so perfectly well done with Mara Wilson. Could not recommend it enough. If you haven't watched it, you must watch it this week. It is on your homework, as are all the other movies that we talked about last week on the show. But in this movie they talk about all of the different names for Santa Claus during the trial. What's your name? And he says, well, I have many names. I am Santa Claus. I'm KRIS KRINGLE, I'm St. Nicholas. All of these things and I didn't ever really stop to think about until this year. All of those names are vehemently different. There's obviously different cultural traditions of Santa. Depending on what language you speak, you may call him something different. But in particular, zooming in on the St. Nicholas vs. Kris Kringle side of things, I started to think to myself, where did that come from? So I busted out my phone this week and went to our trusty friends at Truthly, literally my favorite AI chatbot that I have loved breaking down different theological questions over the past couple of months. Could not recommend enough. It's basically chatgpt, but for Catholics and it's amazing. So if you haven't played with it yet, you absolutely should for Christmas. And I just asked, hey, when did we like start calling Santa Santa instead of Kris Kringle or St Nicholas? What is the difference between St Nicholas and Kris Kringle? And I discovered something that I've never ever, ever even remotely heard of. Even in all my years of church history class at Catholic school, even with my family's weird, ridiculous obsession with Christmas and loving Santa Claus when we grew up, no movie has ever talked about this. No Christmas book has ever talked about this. I never learned this from any of my priests growing up. Listen to this. This is fascinating. Before the reformation in the 16th century, all Cath, or all Christians in Europe in particular were Catholic, right? There was no concept of being a Protestant Christian before the reformation in the 16th century. So before the 16th century, no one, no Christian, ever gave gifts on Christmas Eve. I had no idea. This had never occurred to me before. The whole tradition of giving people presents on Christmas Eve is post Christmas Reformation Christianity in terms of tradition. Before that, Christian's concept of gift giving always happened on the feast day of St. Nicholas, who is essentially the person that we're honoring when we talk about the modern day Santa Claus, who we Nod to. But St. Nicholas was a real person, right? He was also super based and is also not very well known. But should Be more well known for the fact that he punched Arius in the face to condemn Arianism, allegedly. So we love a based Santa Claus, but St. Nicholas was very well venerated by Christians throughout history until the 16th century with St. Nicholas's feast day on December 6th. And that's where we still have some cultural traditions where people will, like, leave their little shoes out and you'll see oranges and candies and little toys in the shoes to honor St. Nicholas. But we started giving gifts to one another and doing the shoe thing and exchanging gifts around the holidays to honor the generosity of an incredible man, St. Nicholas, who I wish we had time to get into all of his history about today. He's an amazing individual and someone we should all strive to emulate in our lives, which is why we venerate him in the church. But slowly, during the time of the Reformation, it was Martin Luther who was incredibly intent on decreasing the veneration of the saints in Christianity. He found saint veneration very problematic. And some of you might as well. I'm not here to have that particular theological discussion today, although we should do an episode about that going into 2026. But Martin Luther was incredibly intent on decreasing veneration of saints during and after the Reformation. So he started thinking it's really problematic that Christians are giving each other gifts to honor St. Nicholas on Dec. 6 instead of what he perceived to be honoring Jesus Christ, and we should be giving gifts on December 24th. So during the Protestant Reformation in the 16th century, Martin Luther, in shifting that focus, was his intent from St Nicholas to Christ himself to give gifts on Jesus's birthday rather than St. Nicholas's feast day. He promoted the idea of kind of like a mythological creature in an essence, but intent on trying to bring the focus back to the infant Jesus Christ, he invented this idea of the Christkind, or the Christ child. And the Christkind in German eventually transitioned into what we now know as Kris Kringle. But as originally intended, Martin Luther created the idea of the Christkind as the bringer of gifts to children that symbolized Jesus as the true gift of Christmas. This is from our friends at. Truthly, the Christkind was intended to emphasize the theological focus on Christ's birth rather than the veneration of saints, which was a common practice and still is a common practice in Catholic tradition. Over time, in many regions influenced by Protestant Reformation ideas, the Christ kind of kind became a central figure in Christmas celebrations. Particularly in the Lutheran areas of Germany, the tradition of St. Nicholas still persisted independently and evolved variously in different or evolved differently in various cultures. In some parts of the world, St. Nicholas Day remains a separate celebration on December 6, while Christmas rituals tend to emphasize the Christkind on December 25. So Kris Kringle evolved from the Christ kind of. And ironically, even though the intention from Martin Luther, again had no idea this was ever a part of church history, was to try to bring focus around the Advent season away from St Nicholas and towards Jesus Christ. He perceived that to be a problem during the 16th century in European Christianity. In many ways, he achieved the opposite of what he intended, because the evolution from the Christian into Kris Kringle into what we now perceive as Santa Claus created a more secular pathway that many people are interpreting today as why we shouldn't do Santa because it is secular and not honoring Jesus Christ in many of the ways that America or various Western nations are quote, unquote doing Santa. And I find that wildly fascinating. Back to the great Santa conversation of 2025 in a moment. But first, one of the most common questions that I'm getting from parents right now is how we can work together to help keep teens safe on social media as they navigate all of the important content that's out there. The truth is, protecting teenagers online as they navigate social media is something that we can stay ahead of together. And as a new mom myself, I feel that responsibility so deeply now as my daughter Isla grows up, I want to feel empowered to make sure that she's being safe and responsible online. Last year, Instagram became one of the first platforms to truly take this seriously by launching teen accounts. These accounts automatically limit who can contact our teenagers and what type of content they are exposed to. They designed this reimagined experience with parents hearts in mind to support you and bring more peace of mind to all of us. Nearly 95% of parents say that these default protections have helped to keep their teens safe online. And that means everything. Setting thoughtful digital boundaries is not about fear. It's about showing your teens that their safety and their innocence matter deeply to you. When parents like you and I safeguard the spaces that they explore, we're building a foundation of trust and teaching them that they deserve to grow up feeling secure, feeling loved and protected. That's exactly why I'm so grateful Instagram is taking these important, proactive steps in online safety. You can learn more about this incredibly important work ahead@instagram.com teen accounts. Again, I'm not here to tell you whether you should do Santa or not, and I'm going to tell you what we're kind of navigating and thinking about as a family and how we present the idea of Santa to our daughter. She's too young to understand the concept now, but as she continues to grow up on the other end of this interview. But how fascinating is that, right? I had no idea. Also, St. Nicholas is based and we love him and we absolutely should be venerating him in this household and all over the Christian world. That said, Ali Beth Stuckey has gone pretty viral in the last few years, talking about why her family doesn't do Santa because they're presenting the idea as like a fictional character of Christmas, but trying to hone in entirely on the Jesus story for Christmas seasons every single year as she's raising her beautiful three daughters with her amazing family. We had a chance to sit down with her at amfest last week and talk to her about a whole host of things, including her hot take on Santa Claus. So let's check it out. I am so excited to be joined by my beautiful friend and someone who's been a wonderful mentor to me over the past few years, Allie Beth's Stuckey, host of the Relatable podcast with the Blaze. And we have a big, big group of people here to watch you, Alibeth. It is so fun. We are here at AM Fest 2025 and we could talk about a whole lot of things with you, Ali Beth. So I want to get into some of it, but most importantly, I want to talk to you about being a mom, because that's the most fun thing in the entire world. First things first though, there is a new poll that came out from the Manhattan Institute just a few days ago saying among Gen Zers, the two people who best represent them and their values are Charlie Kirk and you. What does that mean to you after all these years in media?
