Summary of "The Jim Acosta Show" Episode Featuring Historian Heather Cox Richardson and Indivisible's Ezra Levin

Podcast Information:

• Title: The Jim Acosta Show
• Host: Jim Acosta
• Guests: Historian Heather Cox Richardson and Ezra Levin from Indivisible
• Release Date: July 18, 2025
• Description: Don't give into the lies. Don't give into fear. Hold on to the truth. And hope. jimacosta.substack.com

Introduction: Setting the Stage

Jim Acosta opens the episode by addressing ongoing concerns about the Epstein files and their disappearance, expressing frustration with the Trump administration's handling of the situation. He introduces Heather Cox Richardson, a renowned historian, to provide a broader historical perspective on current political challenges and the resilience of American democracy. Later in the show, Ezra Levin from Indivisible joins to discuss grassroots organizing inspired by the popular TV show Andor.

Honoring John Lewis and Current Protests

Acosta commends Richardson for her Substack piece honoring the late Congressman and civil rights leader, John Lewis. He highlights a notable quote from Lewis:

"When you see something that is not right, not fair, not just say something, do something, get in trouble, good trouble, necessary trouble." (00:43)

Richardson emphasizes the importance of not letting the actions of a single administration define the nation. She applauds the nationwide protests in honor of Lewis, underscoring their commitment to justice, voting rights, and dignity for all (00:43).

The Epstein Files Controversy

The conversation shifts to the Epstein files and the administration's inconsistent handling of the case. Acosta criticizes former Trump administration officials for their dismissive statements about the Epstein files, calling them a "hoax" and noting Trump's inability to cope with media scrutiny:

"It's kind of obnoxious and insulting to our intelligence... we may be crazy, but we're not stupid." (03:26)

Richardson provides a historical context, detailing Epstein's legal troubles and the role of Alex Acosta in securing a lenient plea deal. She connects the Epstein scandal to broader patterns of abuse by the powerful elite, drawing parallels to historical instances of systemic inequality:

"It's about a group of people whose mindset is that they get to do whatever they want and the rest of us have to live with it." (09:28)

Trump's Diminishing Credibility and Media Manipulation

Acosta discusses recent actions by Trump’s administration attempting to distract from the Epstein revelations, such as comments on Trump's health and directives to public officials like Pam Bondi. He argues that these attempts to shift the narrative are ineffective, especially among the MAGA base, which is increasingly skeptical:

"They think of it as catnip for the media... it's just not working." (05:45)

Richardson adds that internal dissatisfaction within the MAGA movement, fueled by unpopular policies like ICE raids and tariffs, is now converging on the Epstein scandal, providing a unified focal point for dissent.

Impact on Public Institutions and Democratic Norms

The discussion moves to the Trump administration’s aggressive policies, particularly ICE raids and the erosion of due process for migrants. Richardson likens these actions to pre-Civil War Southern practices, highlighting the authoritarian tendencies of targeting marginalized groups to consolidate power:

"They're following the classic authoritarian plan... to put terror into the hearts of the local population." (09:28)

Acosta links these policies to broader concerns about the Supreme Court, criticizing Trump's nomination of Emile Beauvais and fearing further entrenchment of executive power:

"The Supreme Court... should have been the bulwark. It’s an utter failure." (14:37)

The Role of Independent Media in Democracy

Both Acosta and Richardson emphasize the critical role of independent media in countering misinformation and holding power accountable. Richardson compares the rise of independent media today to historical movements in the 1850s and 1890s, where grassroots journalism played a pivotal role in restoring democratic norms:

"We're building a web of information... there are 200 of us, you can replace us." (26:19)

Acosta echoes this sentiment, praising the shift from traditional media to platforms like Substack, which empower journalists to maintain editorial independence and directly engage with audiences.

Indivisible and the "No Kings" Movement

Ezra Levin from Indivisible joins the conversation to discuss their "No Kings" protests, inspired by the Andor TV series. Levin draws parallels between the fictional rebellion against the Galactic Empire and real-world activism against authoritarianism:

"Rebellions are built on hope... it is about fighting tyranny." (44:35)

He highlights the success of "No Kings Day," which saw over five million participants and significant grassroots mobilization. Levin emphasizes the importance of strategic nonviolent resistance and community organizing to sustain democratic resilience.

Building a News Community for Democratic Renewal

Richardson and Acosta both advocate for a collective effort to rebuild trust in democratic institutions through community-oriented media and activism. Richardson envisions a decentralized network of independent voices that can adapt and persevere beyond individual contributions:

"Fairness, community, working together to make the country better." (36:54)

Acosta reflects on the transformative potential of independent media, likening it to the influential legacy of figures like Bill Moyers, and underscores the necessity of maintaining hope and collective action in facing systemic challenges.

Conclusion: Holding onto Hope and Collective Action

In closing, Acosta reiterates the importance of community, truth, and resilience in overcoming the current political turmoil. He encourages listeners to stay engaged, support independent media, and participate in grassroots movements to preserve democracy:

"Don't give into the lies, don't give into fear. Hold on to the truth and hope." (System Description)

Richardson echoes the call for agency and community solidarity, emphasizing that democratic renewal is possible through persistent and collective effort.

Notable Quotes:

• John Lewis on Good Trouble: "When you see something that is not right, not fair, not just say something, do something, get in trouble, good trouble, necessary trouble." (00:43)
• Richardson on Authoritarian Plans: "They're following the classic authoritarian plan... to put terror into the hearts of the local population." (09:28)
• Andor Inspiration: "Rebellions are built on hope... it is about fighting tyranny." (44:35)
• Acosta on Resilience: "Don't give into the lies, don't give into fear. Hold on to the truth and hope." (System Description)

This episode of "The Jim Acosta Show" weaves together historical insights, contemporary political analysis, and grassroots activism, presenting a comprehensive look at the challenges facing American democracy and the avenues for its preservation and renewal. Through enlightening discussions with Heather Cox Richardson and Ezra Levin, listeners gain a deeper understanding of the systemic issues at play and are inspired to participate actively in democratic stewardship.