Loading summary
Dr. James Nestor
Joe Rogan Podcast.
Jamie
Check it out.
Podcast Announcer
The Joe Rogan Experience.
Dr. James Nestor
Train my day. Joe Rogan Podcast by night, all day.
Jamie
Yep.
Joe Rogan
All right. Very nice to meet you, man.
Dr. James Nestor
You too. Thanks.
Joe Rogan
Thank you. And thanks for doing this work because you want to talk about a subject that's confused so many people. Is the sun good for you? Is the sun killing you? Why does it give you vitamin D if it's bad for you? Why do people get skin cancer if it's good for you?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, it's super complicated. And the messaging has not sort of admitted that. And that was, yeah, a big impetus for the book.
Joe Rogan
What was your opinion of sun exposure before you started writing this?
Dr. James Nestor
So I had, you know, I had inherited the conventional wisdom from the institutions that it was really bad. At the same time, I will admit that my instincts were that maybe it wasn't as bad as they were leading me to believe, because whenever I was in the sun, I felt good. And I live in Vermont. By the time winter was reaching, like, month six, I felt bad. Right, Right. So I was like, there's more here than we're being told.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, that was my wife's opinion. She's like, the sun can't be bad. It always feels good when you go out there. I'm like, oh, no, it's a little more complicated than that. But that is the instinct. Like, it feels great when you're in the sun. Like, ah. It's like your body wants it.
Dr. James Nestor
Your body wants it. I mean, we now know that it literally triggers the release of opiates in the brain. Sunlight. So, yeah, your body wants it, and your body rewards you when you get it.
Sponsor Voice
So what is the issue?
Joe Rogan
Well, let's go back to the beginning. So you had this idea that sun exposure is probably giving people cancer. And sunscreen is good. You need to wear sunscreen, stay out of the sun. So when you started going into the research, what made you shift your opinion?
Dr. James Nestor
So it really started for me, like, seven or eight years ago. I was on this science journalism fellowship. So I was just doing research, and some of those studies hit the one about opiate release in the brain. Other studies showing that when light hits skin, cognition actually improves. Like, your metabolism cranks up a little bit when the body feels sunlight coming in. And I thought, that's interesting. That's all good stuff. Then I came across a couple other studies that seemed to indicate that sunlight could lower blood pressure, which was really interesting. So then I still had the sense sunlight bad. Right. So then I remember just like, googling, like, so how much does sunlight shorten your lifespan? And like, the punchline is sunlight seems to extend your lifespan. So when I hit that, I was like, why are we not hearing this? So that was the beginning.
Joe Rogan
And so then.
Sponsor Voice
So what is the problem?
Joe Rogan
Like, what is the issue with sunlight? Like, when you think about skin cancer, what are the confounding factors that lead to skin cancer? Are we completely aware of that?
Dr. James Nestor
It's more complicated than we thought. So sunlight does increase your risk of skin cancer, but it depending on the type of skin cancer you're talking about, it's not necessarily like a linear relationship. So, yes, in general, too much sun increases your risk of skin cancer. But yeah, the question is, what are the confounding factors? How important is skin cancer compared to these other things? If sunlight reduces your risk of other diseases, how does that weigh against the risk of skin cancer? So it's not the type of thing that can be done in a 32nd PSA.
Sponsor Voice
Right. So.
Joe Rogan
So sun cancer, that does cause skin cancer. Excuse me, sun exposure, that does cause skin cancer. What is causing it? Why is it happening?
Dr. James Nestor
So ultraviolet light, which is the most energy intense part of the solar spectrum, when those photons of light hit your skin, they go inside. Right. We absorb all wavelengths of light to a greater or lesser degree. And that super high energy ultraviolet light, if it hits a DNA molecule, it can mess up the DNA molecule and then that can lead to mutations and skin cancer. Then it can also indirectly cause skin cancer by creating what are called reactive oxygen species, which are free radicals, basically. So it energizes these atoms that start to steal electrons from other atoms and causes a little chain reaction, which is what a free radical is. So ultraviolet light can increase your free radicals and it can directly damage DNA. So that's why it can cause skin cancer. So it was basically that learning that one fact back in like the 40s and 50s that made scientists start to say light skin cancer. Maybe we should think about how much sun we're getting.
Joe Rogan
But this wasn't universally accepted.
Dr. James Nestor
Right.
Joe Rogan
There were some people that even back then thought that sun exposure was very healthy for you. Like, when did we figure out that sun causes the body to produce vitamin D?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, that was an important part. And it's a big part of the story, I think, because that was really back in the 20s that we figured that out. And then even a little earlier, we realized that sunlight could prevent rickets. Rickets? Yeah. So rickets is a soft bone disease. Like if you don't get enough calcium into your bones, when you're a kid, when you're a baby, you get soft bones. You get rickets. Really bad disease. And in the Industrial Revolution, kids started getting rickets. Farm kids never got rickets. Then suddenly, kids are working in factories. They're living in cities that are choked with coal smog. They're living in tenement buildings. They're never seeing the sun, and they all start getting rickets. Late 1800s.
Joe Rogan
Is nutrition a factor in that?
Dr. James Nestor
Vitamin D? It was all vitamin D. At first they thought maybe it was vitamin A, but it turned out that was how vitamin D was discovered, was some doctors figured out that it could solve rickets in kids. And then they figured out that if sun hit skin, that's how we made vitamin D. Then they figured out.
Joe Rogan
How did they figure that out?
Dr. James Nestor
They tested. They did some tests on
Jamie
dogs.
Dr. James Nestor
Actually. One of the guys who figured it out, he had a hunch that that's what it was like. They noticed that kids in the country wouldn't get rickets, and kids in the city did get rickets. So, like, I wonder if it's sunlight. So then a guy took dogs, and this was. I think Scotland stuck them in a. They actually thought it was dietary. He stuck them inside in this, like, little, like, warehouse and fed them oatmeal, which is what everyone in Scotland ate at the time. And the dogs got rickets. And he thought it was the oatmeal. He's like, okay, so something about diet. But then he got lucky because he had deprived the dogs of sunlight, and that's why they got rickets. So then eventually they realized that light hitting cholesterol molecules in the skin actually converts the molecules to vitamin D. So vitamin D is, like, downstream of cholesterol, but it takes that same ultraviolet light that can screw up your DNA. It actually breaks a bond in the cholesterol molecule, which allows it, gives it some movement, and it flips around into a new form that's vitamin D. So once they figure that out, then they're like, sun's really good for you. So we had this era in the 20s, 30s, and into the 40s, when everyone thought sun would cure everything, and they went after it hard.
Jamie
Really?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. Parents would send their kids up into the ALPs in the 20s to institutes for heliotherapy. Kids would ski around in their underwear, take classes in their underwear. There's awesome photos from this era. The instructors are in their underwear in the mountains outside in Switzerland, teaching the kids. And everyone looks really healthy, right? So there's kind of like this idea that you couldn't get too much light. So people are literally burning themselves on purpose for health.
Sponsor Voice
This episode is brought to you by creat, the leading brand in creatine. You love their gummies, but now they've also launched Creatine plus Electrolytes Mix, perfect for hot summer months. Creatine is proven to support gains in strength, lean muscle mass and and aid recovery, but it also has cognitive benefits, more energy focus and neuroprotection. Plus they're NSF certified for sport and third party tested for safety and potency. Visit try create co slash rogan or use promo code rogan for 20% off and free shipping on your first subscription order. This episode is brought to you by Zip Recruiter.
Joe Rogan
When you hire a landscaper to create
Sponsor Voice
your perfect outdoor oasis, you want someone who cares. That's true for every role you hire for and luckily it just got easier to find that thanks to ZipRecruiter. Try it for free at ZipRecruiter.com/rogan Longtime listeners, you might already know that ZipRecruiter uses powerful matching technology to find qualified candidates fast. But now they also have a new feature that shows you candidates who are interested in your role first. You can even hear why, in their own words. Find candidates who really want your job on ZipRecruiter. Four out of five employers who post on ZipRecruiter get a quality candidate within the first day. Try it for free at ZipRecruiter.com Rogan that ZipRecruiter.com RogAN Meet your match at ZipRecruiter. This episode is brought to you by the Farmer's Dog. Here's a fun fact. Research shows that dogs who maintain a healthy weight can live up to two and a half years longer on average
Joe Rogan
than dogs who are overweight. Isn't that wild and also kind of obvious at the same time?
Sponsor Voice
So why is feeding vague scoops of ultra processed kibble still the status quo? For most dog owners, healthy alternatives exist. And trust me, I know. I buy one. The Farmer's dog.
Joe Rogan
I use it for both my dogs.
Sponsor Voice
They love it. They eat it up quick. It smells good to them. It smells good to me. It's human grade food. The Farmer's dog makes fresh food for
Joe Rogan
dogs and my dogs love it.
Sponsor Voice
Their recipes are made with real meat and fresh vegetables that are gently cooked to retain vital nutrients.
Joe Rogan
They also portion out the meals to your dog's nutritional needs, which helps avoid
Sponsor Voice
overfeeding and makes weight management easier. And isn't getting more time with our four legged best friends Something every dog owner wants. The answer to that is yes, obviously. So try the farmer's dog today and get 50 off your first box of fresh, healthy food, plus get free shipping. Just go to the farmersdog.com rogan this
Joe Rogan
offer is for new customers only. Is that the issue? Is burning a giant part of the issue?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. So to give it away now, it looks like for melanoma, which is the most dangerous type of skin cancer, it's associated with burning strongly but not with like gentle, moderate everyday sun exposure.
Joe Rogan
So how much of a factor is skin type? Like people that are pale or have freckles and red hair, blonde hair, like how much of a factor is that in skin cancer? And can they mitigate that by like gentle slow exposure? Like a little bit here, a little bit there and slowly build up?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, huge. Like, skin type is kind of everything. People have really dark skin basically don't get sun induced skin cancer almost never. And the authorities don't tend to talk about that because they want things to be. They want to have these one size fits all recommendations. But those recommendations to basically always avoid the sun are written for the super fair people. Especially if you have red hair, orange freckles, then you actually have a mutation in your melanin gene that makes you super susceptible to skin cancer from sunlight. So if you've got that phenotype, lots of moles, red hair, freckles, you do have to be really careful. And you can't, you can only do so much. Like you're not going to tan that much anyway. Your melanin's just different. Everybody else. Yeah, you're much less susceptible. And you can tan. You know, you can make more melanin pretty easily through tanning.
Joe Rogan
I wonder what, if any, effect. Have you ever heard of that? I can't remember the name of the peptide, but there's a peptide that people are taking now that causes their body to generate melanin and they get really dark.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, yeah.
Joe Rogan
It's really weird.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. And I don't know what's going on there exactly. It seems like that peptide is maybe making you. There's things called photosensitizers that make your skin super sensitive. You just absorb solar radiation really well then, but not necessarily in a good way. And that can make you make tons of melanin to try to compensate. So I wonder, that peptide might be triggering melanin as a compensation mechanism for extra protection from sunlight. Or maybe it's just making melanin happen independently of sunlight.
Joe Rogan
Did you put it into perplexity all Right. Here it is. Mela. Melaton. Melanoton. Melanotan. Melanotan. Synthetic peptide analog of the naturally occurring hormone, a melon. Melanocyte stimulating hormone. Stimulates the body's melanocytes to produce melanin, resulting in a dark tan. It's largely unread. Unreal. Excuse me? Unregulated. Illegal in many regions for cosmetic purposes and carry significant health risks. Or what's the risks? It's not approved by the FDA for cosmetic use, and unregulated market means purity. Okay, but that's unregulated. Notable risks include dermatological issues, rapid and uneven darkening of existing moles, the emergence of new moles, and hyperpigmentation, concerns that could mask or accelerate the development of melanoma. What is this? Potentially damaging erections. What? Oh, that's right. This apparently gives people raging erections.
Dr. James Nestor
Why?
Joe Rogan
Prolonged, painful and potentially damaging. Damaging. Imagine you get an erection that goes so hard you redline the penis. Medical and dermatological organizations strongly advise against the use of Melaniton Melanitan because it's unapproved. There are no clinically established safe dosages.
Dr. James Nestor
Well, weird, because that. So Alpha msh, the thing that it is mimicking is that's how your body makes melanin. That's how your body's supposed to do it.
Joe Rogan
You gotta see the before and afters because they're kind of bonkers. I've seen some people get super. Well, the problem is, it's Instagram. You never know what's real. That guy got a little tan. Let's see if there's any. Okay. Look how pale that. See? But that's not. How do we know if that's real?
Jamie
Just like, there's like a light on him, right?
Joe Rogan
And then he's in a dark closet.
Jamie
In the last picture, before and after photos I've seen.
Joe Rogan
Is there that one right there? The low. The. No, the one. Yeah, that one. Look at that guy.
Dr. James Nestor
Well, you know, it's a look. It's an interesting look.
Joe Rogan
He injected himself with unregulated tanning peptide. Melaniton. Melanitan 2. Click on that.
Jamie
Seems like a joke.
Joe Rogan
No, no. This guy. This is the guy that I saw online. This guy's. He's the test rabbit. This dude went hard.
Dr. James Nestor
Did he get an erection, too?
Joe Rogan
Yeah, he died from that.
Jamie
I don't know.
Joe Rogan
So his before and afters. So let's see. What. Is he just. Okay, yeah, he just got darker and darker and darker. But I wonder if, like, if I understand that it's unregulated but if it was regulated. And this is something they're trying to work with right now with peptides and make them regular. See, that's. The photo's dark, though. I mean, that's like a shitty iPhone. One camera. That's crazy. If that's like, this is nuts. There's something going on there. Like, you know what it looks like? It looks like those bodybuilder guys who he's. That. That ink, that dye on their skin to make themselves darker so their muscles pop out more. So here's better tanning log photos. These are better photos. That's crazy. But I wonder if that offers skin protection.
Dr. James Nestor
It would definitely offer skin. I mean, if it's melanin, definitely. I mean, that guy can probably be outside all day.
Joe Rogan
Yeah. So that's the question. Is that available to someone who's pale? Like, and if someone is pale, see if you can find an example of someone who's pale who took it. Because you would think, like, oh, well, maybe that maybe just. We need to do studies and figure out what the dosage is and figure out how to activate that aspect of it.
Dr. James Nestor
Melanin clearly protects you from skin cancer. Like, if you have super dark skin, like African ancestry, you're blocking, like, your melanin is absorbing like 97, 98% of the UV rays. It's super effective.
Joe Rogan
But didn't Bob Marley die from skin cancer?
Dr. James Nestor
He did.
Joe Rogan
That's pretty crazy. Okay, this is one.
Sponsor Voice
Wow.
Jamie
It looks like the same person. Hard to tell without the face.
Dr. James Nestor
Same mold.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, it looks like the same mole. That looks pretty good.
Jamie
But I would just also wouldn't. If you were trying to sell some of this stuff and maybe nefarious ways, this would be an easy one to market. Tough.
Joe Rogan
And, you know, definitely, look, this is part of the unregulated market. Problem is, we don't know. And also, you know, you're getting 99% bro science on this stuff. You know, like
Dr. James Nestor
what screams bro screams
Joe Rogan
it from the top of the hills. What legitimate scientist is out there injecting himself with melanitan?
Dr. James Nestor
But the other thing is, if you do it naturally, right, if you just get a little sun every day and slowly build up, you're not just making melanin, you're also increasing your body's damage repair system. Like, you have all these nucleotide excision repair things that fix your DNA and fix cells that have gotten screwed up and that will also ramp up every day. And it's not just. Not just sunlight, like exercise, same thing. Anything that, that stresses the body a little bit. It's like hormesis. Right. So all those things are gonna cause your damage repair system to crank up and be ready. So you probably want those to like, the melanin and the damage repair to like go up together.
Sponsor Voice
Right.
Joe Rogan
So you would wanna, if, let's say studies were done, let's say we found what the effective and safe dose is and how to administer it, you would wanna do it along with sun exposure slowly to try to ramp up your body's ability.
Jamie
Added note on this, this happened 14 years ago.
Joe Rogan
Whoa.
Jamie
Which is strange. Here's some of the side effects, he said. But he also said he's pretty much impervious to UV at this point.
Joe Rogan
Increased libido. Didn't see that one much either. He said he didn't get it. Okay, sides are. Decreased appetite, very mild nausea, more for some. None for me. Decreased libido, increased libido. He said it didn't see that one much either. Some get facial flushing, like a niacin dose. Never got that either. And the most strange thing is that it feels really good to stretch, like when you first wake up. Interesting, huh? Did you do it for the skin coloring? Yes, I did it for skin coloring. I'm pretty much impervious to UV at this point. I have faded about 25% since returning from Florida January 31st. We'll be dosing again probably in March. Is this guy still alive?
Dr. James Nestor
That's my question.
Jamie
14 years. What is that, 20 years?
Joe Rogan
Click on that link. Where his. His profile. Well, let's see if homeboy's alive. Is this Reddit?
Jamie
See, a year ago, he's commenting. I never did it. Subtle.
Joe Rogan
Okay, so a year ago, he's still alive. Or someone has taken over his account. In theory, you could use an old school quartz tanning lamp. Okay. So you could tan with it.
Jamie
And he's in a weird Reddit there, so we gotta stop looking.
Sponsor Voice
Why?
Jamie
I don't. I mean, this is not for the show. But he's in a weird.
Joe Rogan
Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah. Okay.
Dr. James Nestor
That's why I was afraid to go that way.
Joe Rogan
That's the problem. Well, only crazy people are willing to try something like that. Like, do you remember that there was a guy. God, I think it was on Oprah or one of those shows where he was taking. Was it silver?
Jamie
Yeah, colloidal silver.
Sponsor Voice
That's right, colloidal silver.
Joe Rogan
And his whole. His skin turned blue permanently. Yeah, Like a Smurf.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Poor guy.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
And he wound up dying. Yeah.
Dr. James Nestor
And how did it Kill him.
Joe Rogan
I don't know if it killed him, but he's. I believe he died young. That's homeboy. Not good.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, that's just not a good look.
Joe Rogan
You would think you'd start turning a little blue and you'd go, hey, maybe I need to back off. This colloidal silver Papa swerve dies. Yeah. I mean, what the fuck, dude? That guy. I mean, maybe he could have gotten some melanitan and evened that out. It's just been a nice chocolate, you know, like a bluish chocolate.
Dr. James Nestor
I mean, he looks delicious, I'll say that.
Joe Rogan
Yeah. This is Argrea. Argyria. Argyria, the rare disease that turns people blue. Caused by a buildup of silver in the body which discolors the skin.
Jamie
Wow.
Joe Rogan
2013, he died from unrelated causes, whatever that means. I mean, anybody's taking that much colloidal silver, you're probably making a lot of other mistakes.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, like, you're a risky dude. So many options.
Sponsor Voice
This episode is brought to you by Ketone iq. Here's something cool. Ketone IQ is giving five lucky listeners the chance to win custom autograph gloves signed by John Bones Jones the goat, the absolute legend of mma. But first, you know, I've been studying ketones for years. The US Military spent years researching one question. What is the best fuel you can give the brain? They landed on ketones. Your brain's natural super fuel. The guys at Ketone IQ helped bring it to market and make it accessible. And I'm telling you, this stuff is great. My brain works on another level when I take it. There's never been a better time to try it out yourself.
Podcast Announcer
And.
Sponsor Voice
And because when you order now through my link, you get 30% off and you're automatically entered to win a pair of custom MMA gloves signed by Ketone IQ co owner John Bones Jones and gold medal wrestler Gable Stevenson. So go to ketone.com rogan today. Claim 30% off your first order and enter to win some autograph gloves.
Dr. James Nestor
Back to Bob Marley. Yes, he did die of skin cancer, and that confuses a lot of people. So he had melanoma on his toe, and that was a kind of melanoma that's not caused by the sun. And everybody gets it, no matter what race you are. Everybody gets it at the same rate, which is quite uncommon. They know it's not caused by the sun, but it complicates things for people because people are like, I got melanoma on my toe, and they think it's from the sun and they're like, how did that happen? Right. Like, what's a melanoma doing on there? But so it does. Not all melanomas are caused by the sun. Most probably are, but it gets really weird with melanoma. It's associated with burning with like intermittent sun exposure. Like you work in an office all year and then you go to Cancun and get fried. That's a pretty good recipe for melanoma. History of sunburns also will double your risk. Chronic exposure, where you have an outdoor job every day, lower than average risk of melanoma.
Jamie
Really?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. So it gets weird.
Joe Rogan
Like landscapers or something.
Dr. James Nestor
Landscapers have. Outdoor workers have fewer have a lower incidence of melanoma than office workers. Wow. And we don't hear that.
Joe Rogan
No, no. I mean, I was, I was looking at Instagram the other day and some poor guy had this. I don't know what happened to his face, but he had some sort of skin cancer and they had to take a graft. And his. It was on his nose, so it was like a flap of skin was like almost covering over his eye. And you know, his message was, wear sunscreen. This is what happened to me.
Dr. James Nestor
Well, so, I mean, yeah, so I don't want to downplay skin cancer because it sucks when you get it. You know, they have to cut off a hunk of your ear or something. That definitely sucks, even if it's not life threatening sucks.
Joe Rogan
Yeah.
Dr. James Nestor
And so, yeah, like, but that's generally from overexposure. Like burning. Burning. All the experts I've spoken with said don't burn.
Joe Rogan
Right. Burning is the one that people always say that it's not just burning, it's burning causes damage that starts to appear years later.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. And they're dialing in on that more and more. It can start like burns during childhood is actually the highest association for melanoma. Don't burn when you're a kid. So we're all screwed.
Joe Rogan
Oh, that sucks. That sucks because I fucking cooked myself as a kid.
Dr. James Nestor
Same here. I grew up in Florida. Fried, you know.
Joe Rogan
Well, when I was a kid in the 70s and 80s, you know, you wanted to get a tan. Especially when I lived in Boston, it was cold as shit in the winter when it got warm. You know, you're a Vermont guy.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
You got out there like, ah, put baby oil on. We fried.
Dr. James Nestor
Totally. I was just looking at some of those Johnson baby oil ads from like the 60s and 70s. Oh my God. Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Yeah. It was basically cooking lube.
Dr. James Nestor
Totally.
Joe Rogan
Yeah. It just helped. Helped you cook better.
Dr. James Nestor
But you remember, you know, George Hamilton, like the actor, Mr. Tan? Yeah, he was all about that just the other day. I was like, how's he doing? 87 and ridiculously healthy right now.
Jamie
Really?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, he's going strong.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, I met that guy. He was. He did an episode of Newsradio once. Yeah, he was tan as fuck. Yeah, that was his thing.
Dr. James Nestor
That was his thing. It became. Yeah. What he was known for. And still. He's still going.
Joe Rogan
That's. So he's still tan.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, you should see him. He looks great.
Joe Rogan
What do you look like? Pull up a photo of George Hamilton.
Dr. James Nestor
I mean, great for an 87 year old.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, look at him, still tan.
Dr. James Nestor
How does he tan and shiny?
Joe Rogan
What a weird thing to be known for. He's the guy who gets tan, you
Sponsor Voice
know what I'm saying?
Joe Rogan
I mean, try to remember a role that he played.
Dr. James Nestor
That's true. I think he was Dracula in some bad 1970s, like comedy. Look at that. That's a tan right there.
Joe Rogan
Right. So how was he getting it though? Like, I remember when I was a kid in Boston, a lot of people use tanning beds, especially in the wintertime,
Dr. James Nestor
and they still do. Like those are actually like on the rise. And they do. They seem to raise your risk of melanoma for sure. There you go. That's how he did it.
Joe Rogan
Ah, look, he's got a reflect a tan thing. So he's just out there getting sunlight all the time and he didn't look bad. That's, you know, that's a weird one, right?
Dr. James Nestor
He claims he's never had skin cancer. I think.
Sponsor Voice
Well, he probably was doing it so
Joe Rogan
often that his body was prepared for it. Right. Look at that photo of him with that lady in the corner. Yeah, look at that. That's nuts.
Dr. James Nestor
See, that's the thing. I think if you're getting that regular dosage, your body is producing all of these compounds whose entire job is to make sure your cells don't turn cancerous. Because living things have been working on this for 500 million years. They get hammered by the sun every day and they got to deal with it.
Joe Rogan
Right.
Dr. James Nestor
So it's when it seems like when your skin is totally unprepared and you shock it with like a massive dose that, that it's not ready for, then. Then you're in trouble. Like that's the kind of thing that triggers trouble.
Joe Rogan
Was there any pushback on this research? Like when, when you first started examining this and realizing that sun exposure has a lot of benefits. But were any dermatologists saying hey, this is dangerous information. You shouldn't say this.
Dr. James Nestor
Hell, yeah. I've been denounced multiple times by the American Academy of Dermatology. Like, officially. They send an official letter when I write an article and they say nobody should be getting any sun exposure.
Joe Rogan
That's their opinion. No one should be getting any sun exposure. Regardless of the benefits. The vitamin D. The no sun exposure
Dr. James Nestor
without protection from either sunscreen or clothing.
Joe Rogan
Wow.
Dr. James Nestor
And if that makes you vitamin D deficient, take a pill. So that's what needs to change, because those pills haven't panned out in tests. They don't work like natural D does for whatever reason.
Joe Rogan
Really?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. They don't work at all.
Joe Rogan
What do you mean?
Dr. James Nestor
So everyone thought, like back in the 80s, 90s, everyone started noticing, scientists started noticing that people who naturally had lower amounts of vitamin D in their blood had higher rates of all, like, the classic chronic diseases. So I started thinking, okay, vitamin D, it's like a magic pill almost. It'll cure, it'll reduce everyone's risk of all these diseases if we raise their rates of D. So they started recommending vitamin D pills, which I think are still like the number one supplement in
Joe Rogan
the world, I take it.
Dr. James Nestor
So then they did all these clinical trials to prove that it would help. Huge, huge clinical trials. Tens of thousands of people follow ups that went for many years. None of them showed a benefit.
Joe Rogan
No benefit in terms of your immune response.
Dr. James Nestor
No benefit for any condition.
Joe Rogan
Now, did they take vitamin D along with vitamin K2 and with magnesium, because that's what's recommended.
Dr. James Nestor
So I don't. I mean, there were a bunch of different.
Joe Rogan
Apparently vitamin D by itself is not effective, that you need vitamin D with K2 and magnesium. And I think there might be another one. Put that into perplexity, please. See what it says, like, what are the benefits of vitamin D and what should it be taken with? Because I think magnesium and K2 are the big ones and that together they have a sort of a synergistic effect.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, that could be like. Yeah, I'd be curious.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, I think vitamin D by itself, the body has a problem absorbing it. It's like, there's a lot of things like that. Like zinc is like that. You need a N to absorb zinc, so you take it with quercetin.
Dr. James Nestor
Well, one thing, D, you know, the way you. It naturally comes in through the skin and it comes in with a whole bunch of related compounds. And so, yeah, I do think there's sort of a synergistic effect when it's combined with the Right things.
Joe Rogan
But D from the sun has always been known as the best way to get it. The best way to get vitamin D, the most effective, the healthiest way is through sun exposure.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, like, that's how the design's supposed to work.
Joe Rogan
Perplexity says vitamin D helps your body absorb calcium, build strong bones and teeth, support muscles and nerves. Plays a key role in immune function. Best absorbed when taken with a meal or a snack that contains some fat and often paired with calcium for bone health. So please put in what are the benefits of vitamin d taken with K2 and magnesium. See if it says that, because this is what my doctor, who is a vitamin specialist recommends. Benefits when taken with K2 and magnesium. Okay. Taking vitamin D together with vitamin K2 and magnesium can make each of them work more effectively, especially for bones and heart. As long as the doses are appropriate for you. The trio mainly improves how your body handles calcium. Interesting. D helps you absorb it. Magnesium helps activate D. And K2 helps send calcium into bones instead of arteries. D increases calcium absorption from your gut and supports bone, muscle and immune function. Magnesium required to activate vitamin D. Low magnesium can blunt vitamin D's effect and also directly support bone structure and many enzymes. K2 activates proteins that move calcium into bones and teeth and keep it out of the arteries and soft tissues, helping bone and cardiovascular health. Potential benefits of the combo, Better bone support, heart and artery protection, more efficient vitamin D use. Okay, so the doctor is correct. So maybe that's the problems that these people were taking it with. Low magnesium, low calcium, didn't have K2.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, I thought, like, I'd be curious if, like, if there was an effect on disease incidence for the combination. I don't know, because the D on its own, yeah, it didn't show any effect, but sun exposure.
Joe Rogan
Let's put that in. Does vitamin D taken on its own have any health benefits? Let's see what it says to that. Because I'd never heard that that D on its own was not effective at all. I just heard that it was minimally effective, that you had to take it with other.
Dr. James Nestor
It seems like it only helps people who have. Who are really deficient. Like, if you're. If you're super low, like below like 16 nanograms per milliliter, then probably it's a good idea. But, like, for people who already had, like, at least 20 nanograms per milliliter, it didn't seem to have any of these benefits that they were seeing in people who naturally had high rates through sinus nature.
Joe Rogan
It says yes Vitamin D on its own has several well proven health benefits, especially for bones, muscles and immunity.
Jamie
Just like a general answer, huh?
Joe Rogan
Bone strength and fracture prevention, muscle function adequate.
Jamie
I didn't add on.
Joe Rogan
Sorry, what's that?
Jamie
I didn't. I missed the word own.
Joe Rogan
Taken on it on its own.
Jamie
That's probably why the answer was weird.
Joe Rogan
So let's see. Yes, as clear, proven benefits, especially for bones, muscles and correcting deficiency.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. So that's going to be for people
Joe Rogan
who have super low levels preventing rickets. There it is.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. So they had thought that it might reduce incidence of all these other diseases based on what they're seeing for people who naturally had high levels through sun exposure and it didn't then.
Joe Rogan
People who had high levels through sun exposure.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, because your natural level of vitamin D is sort of a direct meter of how much sun exposure.
Joe Rogan
Right, but this is natural level. You're not talking about supplementation.
Jamie
Right.
Joe Rogan
Okay.
Dr. James Nestor
So that was why people who had high levels of D without supplementation have lower rates of every disease you can think of. So the hope was that raising everyone's D to those levels would have the same effect. And it didn't. Like, New England Journal of Medicine actually did an editorial in 2022 saying, Stop prescribing D, it doesn't work. Which is if.
Joe Rogan
God, that seems incorrect though, because if you're taking it with magnesium and K2, it seems that they do work synergistically and there seems to be proven health benefits that. One of the problems I think is like, I, I think people generally want to avoid recommending supplementation for some reason. It's kind of a weird thing. Like they want to dismiss it. Like, I had a doctor once that told me, don't bother taking vitamins, just eat a balanced diet. And I was like, look at you. Guy looked like shit.
Dr. James Nestor
He didn't look as good as you. Right?
Joe Rogan
He looked terrible.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. I'm amazed how poor what poor health. They generally like seem to take it.
Joe Rogan
I mean, it's so hard to take seriously a guy with a gut when he looked terrible and he was telling me that I just need a healthy diet. And I'm like, okay, I do have a healthy diet, but also I feel different when I take vitamins and my blood work. It reflects that.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, I noticed that when I started going to all the conferences of the sun researchers and they're all in like the basements of hotels and those guys all are as pacey as it gets. Like, do none of you guys practice what you preach? Really?
Joe Rogan
How strange is it that human beings, with all of our knowledge with, I mean, obviously there's much more to learn. We're still confused about how we interact with our environment.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, absolutely, 100%.
Joe Rogan
With sun, which seems to me like
Sponsor Voice
it's there, it's everywhere. It's like you're always in the sun
Joe Rogan
in the normal world environment outside of cities and all that stuff. It seems like we would have an understanding of what happens when you're interacting with sun.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. And light period. Like light of all kinds. Like, it seems like there's the sense in biology that light didn't matter. It's like just ephemeral. Which, you know, the quantum physicists 100 years ago understood that light and matter are just like two halves of the same coin. Right. And that light totally affects the behavior of molecules. We're made of molecules. Light's going to matter. So I actually think, like that's where I eventually got to with the book. I was like, we need to think about our light diets and our like, lightscapes that we're, you know, surrounding ourselves with, like more seriously than we have.
Joe Rogan
Well, it seems like your work is based entirely on the data. So what did these dermatologists have to say about the data? If they're denouncing you and they're saying that, you know, this guy should not be listened to, the things you're saying are dangerous, like, but you're talking about data. So I don't understand how they can just make those flat statements like that.
Sponsor Voice
This episode is brought to you by SimpliSafe. One thing you probably don't think about when you're planning the perfect summer getaway is protecting your home. But if disaster strikes you, be prepared. Even better if it can be stopped before it happens. So check out SimpliSafe. They're the smarter option when it comes to home security because their systems help prevent and stop crime in real time before it starts. There's also no long term contracts and no technician appointments. You can get a custom system and set it up in one afternoon by yourself or even sooner. It's one of many reasons why millions of people continue to trust and use Simply Safe. Everyone deserves to have peace of mind. Which is why I'm happy to partner with Simply Safe again and offer an exclusive discount. Right now you can get 50 off your new system by visiting simplisafe.com rogan that's half off@simplisafe.com rogan there's no safe like simply safe. This episode is brought to you by Squarespace Once you've got a great name for your business, you need a great domain. And Squarespace makes it easy to lock in a domain. You just search the name you want, buy it, and then you're ready to build. No hidden fees, no weird upsells. Go to squarespace.com/rogan for a free trial. And when you are ready to launch, use the code ROGAN to get 10% off your first purchase of a website or domain.
Dr. James Nestor
Right. And what? I think we just need to have a conversation about the data and, you know, there's no, like, right answer ahead of time. But they don't. Like, their job is to prevent skin cancer. So if that's your only job, you're gonna tell people, stay out of the sunlight forever. Forever. Right. And no one can call you on that. No one can say, hey, like, I got skin cancer. It's your fault.
Sponsor Voice
Right?
Joe Rogan
But doesn't sun exposure improve cardiovascular health and lower blood pressure? And isn't cardiovascular disease a far more dangerous problem than skin cancer? In terms of numbers, it's number one,
Dr. James Nestor
20 million deaths a year. Cardio. So anything that moves the needle on that is awesome.
Joe Rogan
And it does.
Dr. James Nestor
And it seems to. All the studies show it does. But they're all observational studies, right? You look at populations, you're like, oh, these people have more sun exposure, lower blood pressure, lower rates of cardiovascular disease. But then the other side will say, correlation does not prove causation. Prove. Show us that it's, you know, do your giant clinical study where you stick half the people in the sunlight and they live longer. Which is not gonna happen, right?
Joe Rogan
Yeah, but it's like, are they willing to have a conversation with you?
Dr. James Nestor
They're not. They're not willing to. They don't wanna look outside of the sun and skin cancer question. Like, they're not willing to entertain any of the other benefits that are outside of their field. So there's gotta be somebody out there who can be the generalist, who can, like, think about it holistically.
Joe Rogan
That seems so ignorant.
Dr. James Nestor
It's the state of science now. Like, the science is, you know, like a field of micro specialties.
Joe Rogan
Would you like some coffee?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, I'll take a little. That looks good when you're pouring it. It's also a very shiny press.
Jamie
Oh, yeah.
Joe Rogan
Cheers, sir.
Dr. James Nestor
Cheers.
Joe Rogan
Is coffee good for you?
Dr. James Nestor
Coffee's awesome. Coffee is shockingly good for you.
Joe Rogan
Talk to me.
Jamie
Let's go.
Dr. James Nestor
It is fucking crazy how good coffee is for you. I've been startled by the power of the evidence.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, I'VE read both. I've read it's bad for you, and I dismissed it because I'm biased and I love coffee and I just. It just tastes too good, it feels too good. I like it. But I've read a lot of benefits about it.
Dr. James Nestor
I think it's the best possible supplement, really. Do you think of it as a supplement? It's the best. And I think it's all due to mitochondrial function. I think it makes your mitochondria just spin, you know.
Joe Rogan
And is it particularly because of caffeine or coffee itself?
Dr. James Nestor
Is the coffee bean, you know, I mean, caffeine? I think it's caffeine. But I wouldn't be surprised if there's other stuff in coffee that's contributing because, you know, like, tea doesn't seem to quite like, deliver the goods like coffee does. No, but caffeine is actually. The plants are making it to kill bugs, right? Because it makes the bugs, mitochondria run out of control and they basically, like, blow up. It does that to us. But we have these other, like, governors like that come in and slow down, that ramp up. So we get the nice ramp up without the explosion. So it's good. So it makes, you know, we produce energy more efficiently with less wear and tear.
Joe Rogan
That's all I need to hear. I'm in. I just love coffee. I'm not giving it up. But I've heard many people say that Michael Pollan had a really interesting anecdote. He laid off coffee for, I think, three or four months as an experiment. And then he had a cup of coffee and he said it was like taking a psychedelic. He said, I just felt so amazing and the effect was so profound. He said, I really wanted to do it only that way where I only take it, you know, very rarely, because. But then I fell right back into my.
Dr. James Nestor
He went right back. Yeah, like, I remember that article. It was great. And also you said none of the, like, the caffeine researchers touch the stuff. I'm like, that's not good. But, yeah, he went right back to it. And I think he's a proud coffee drinker.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, he is. He went right back to it. So have you had any conversations with these dermatologists that are denouncing you?
Dr. James Nestor
No, but I'd like to, actually. I think.
Joe Rogan
Are they willing or have they avoided them?
Dr. James Nestor
They have so far, really avoided. Like, they just say, you know, we're not ready to look at any of that research.
Joe Rogan
God, that's so weird.
Dr. James Nestor
I think it's going to change. I Think, actually, like I said, I think light medicine is actually going to become very important in the next 10, 20 years. And dermatologists are kind of positioned to be the leaders on that stuff because skin is the primary interface with light for our bodies. And, you know, they should be experts on all this. You know, red light therapy is a big thing now, and dermatologists are doing that, even though the evidence isn't great for that. But I think there's probably something there. But they should basically, I think they need to be thinking more about all these different wavelengths of light as healing modalities and how to, you know, work them into, like, regular, like, programs.
Joe Rogan
I've talked about this before, so I apologize to anybody listening, but I've essentially completely stopped my macular degeneration with red light therapy.
Dr. James Nestor
Wow. Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Not just stopped it, but reversed it. Like, I don't need reading glasses anymore. I've been using a red light bed for about two years now. And from the time I started using it, within about a month, I started seeing benefits. And so Gary Breco was on the podcast and explained it to me. And so I went out and bought one of these really expensive. It's like a tanning bed, this thing you lie in. And I do it three times a week for 20 minutes.
Dr. James Nestor
So all over?
Joe Rogan
Yep. Naked. Just lie down in there and I keep my eyes open. And they. You know, I went to a tanning bed once. Not a tanning bed, a red light bed once at a health clinic. And they were like, gotta wear these goggles and make sure you close your eyes before the light goes on. I was like, okay, I did all that. And apparently there's some benefit that even when blindfolded, it increases your vision.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, for sure, it's. And again, I think mitochondria are part of the answer. There's a guy at University College London, Glenn Jeffrey, who this is his whole field, optometry and red light. And he has shown in multiple different animals, including humans, that red light improves mitochondrial function and improves vision.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, I mean, I'm 58, and for me to be 56 and saying, I'm fucked. I had these fucking things everywhere. I had these. All these reading glasses. I had them all over my house. I'd gotten up to 3x. These are the cheap Amazon ones. I had a nice pair, but I keep losing them. So I just. I went out and bought cheap ones. They seem to work. And it was just fine for looking at a computer, you know, reading my emails, reading my phone. And I needed them to Read my phone. I don't need them anymore, like at all. I don't use them anymore. My, my vision's not perfect. It's not as good as it was when I was 20, but is way better than it was when I was 56.
Dr. James Nestor
And yeah, I think so. The mitochondria in the eyes have to fire faster than any mitochondria anywhere else in the body. The eyes burn through energy like no other cells because it's like, you know, it's kind of the toughest task. It's like they gotta go super fast. So they, yeah, those mitochondria need to be on top of their game. And it seems like red light benefits
Joe Rogan
that in particular, it seems so close minded that these dermatologists aren't willing to say. Maybe we're looking at just insufficient amount of data. Maybe we're looking at this wrong. Maybe the whole thing is much more nuanced and maybe there's benefits if done correctly. I just don't understand why they're not. If there's all this data, which clearly you show in your book that there's a tremendous amount of data.
Dr. James Nestor
Why, you know like, so there's this saying attributed to Max Planck, who's this like quantum physicist. Science advances one funeral at a time. Right. I think we got to let the old guard die off a little bit. But I guarantee there's a young generation coming in who's going to be really interested in light and how they can use it.
Joe Rogan
Oh certainly. Well, I think there's so many conversations available online now from actual researchers and people that have put in the time and put in the work and explored things from this position that like hey, maybe the old guard are not correct. And the data seems to show that that's true.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, and it's fun. I mean playing with light, it's super fun. So like this is a way you can make your world a little bit richer. Is starting to think about this stuff.
Joe Rogan
Well, it's also like, don't you want to be informed? And if there's, if we do understand that it has an effect on mitochondria and there is all this evidence that red light seems to have some benefits. Like I just don't understand how someone could be an expert in skin and ignore that.
Dr. James Nestor
Well, I think that. And they won't object to the red. Some of them are using red light therapy because there's no risk of skin cancer for red. It's only the UV and maybe a little bit of the blue that contributes to skin cancer. So it's the UV where they get a little wigged out.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, but even that it seems like there's like in your book you show there's a tremendous amount of data, there's health benefits to it. So I just don't understand.
Dr. James Nestor
And that data, it's coming from all different other fields like immunology, cardiology. And scientists are sort of increasingly hesitant to trespass on their other domains. They're not going to walk across campus to the other building anymore. Yeah, that needs to change, you know.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, we've had those discussions too with scientists that are super frustrated, especially when they try to get interdisciplinary groups together to study one particular thing. And yeah, everyone's resisting because they have their own work that they're working on. They don't want to get involved. And it's like, guys, this is what you're here for. There's not a lot of scientists. You got to do your job because like you're the only ones that are doing it. There's. Without you guys, we're fucked. And if you're out there relying on old insufficient data, or you have this very small data set that shows that there's negative outcomes to sunlight and so you just throw the baby out with the bathwater, you're doing the whole field a massive disservice.
Dr. James Nestor
And the other part of it is that science, it's sort of very self reinforcing. It's all grant based essentially. Like if you're a scientist, you want to do a study, you have to apply for a grant to get the money to do the study. And there's generally a handful of entities that are handing out the grant money. And it's the old guys waiting to die who are going to approve what they think is the truth. They're going to fund the study that fits with what they already know about the world. So it's this kind of crazy system where the only way you can get money to do a study is if you're already telling them what they know. So it's very difficult to get funded to do something that goes against the grain increasingly so. And that's a problem.
Joe Rogan
And so much of it is dependent upon the ego of the people that are at the top of the organization.
Dr. James Nestor
Ego's definitely part of it.
Joe Rogan
It's a giant part of it. Because if they've based their entire career on telling you one thing that turns out to be incorrect, they're very reluctant to correct themselves.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, there's not just. It's very rare to find the individual who's well known in the field and is eager to self correct, you know.
Joe Rogan
So have you had any conversations with any of these dermatologists?
Dr. James Nestor
No, but I'd love to.
Joe Rogan
Not one that seems crazy. Have you reached out to any of them?
Dr. James Nestor
I have, I've reached out and I get the boilerplate like, we don't want anyone in the sun. Take your D pills, doesn't matter. And the one that really that I think has got to change is the skin color question. Because fine to, you know, go with the recommendations for avoiding sun for people with fair skin, but for people with dark skin who have almost no risk from sun induced skin cancer and can benefit hugely from things that will lower blood pressure and lower cardiovascular disease, it seems like you're not being fair to those people.
Joe Rogan
Not only that, it makes you feel better, which is very important. Just for sanity.
Dr. James Nestor
I mean, I think that gets underplayed. Mood and happiness is kind of the whole deal. Right. And there's just no question that sun exposure makes you happier.
Joe Rogan
I spent a week with my friend Brian Callan and Steve Marnella in Alaska and Prince Edward's island. And it rains there like 350 days a year. And we got rained on for the entire week. And then when I came back to la, I was driving around and the sun was magnificent. It felt so good. I stood outside, I closed my eyes, I like stretched my arms wide like I was just taking it all in. And I called my friend Steve up and I said, dude, because we were in the rain for like a week. I go, I'm in LA right now in the sun and it feels amazing. I never felt the sun like this before. It's just like my body was saying, you didn't get enough of this for a week. Now take it in and we're gonna reward you with all these amazing endorphins and good feelings. Like if that was a drug, that drug that I like, if depressed people could take whatever I felt when I was out in the sun after a week in the rain, they would take it every day.
Sponsor Voice
They would change the world.
Joe Rogan
Like I could feel like this all the time. And it went away, you know, it went away because la, it's sunny all day long every day, Right?
Dr. James Nestor
Right.
Joe Rogan
So eventually I got accustomed to it. But that feeling that I get that I got after the week in the rain and coming back just be like,
Sponsor Voice
ah, it was incredible.
Joe Rogan
It was like a drug, an amazing drug, a happy drug.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, it's an awesome drug. And I've felt it for sure. Especially like early spring, if I leave Vermont and I have something in la. I'm just like, why is everyone not just dancing on the streets? This feels so good.
Joe Rogan
But the problem is Los Angeles, they're so used to it. They're so spoiled. Everyone there is so spoiled weather wise. It's the perfect weather on earth. It's, it's incredible.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Especially if you live in like Malibu where it barely even gets hot. So you're dealing with that cool ocean breeze and it's sunny every day, you know, like. Oh yeah.
Dr. James Nestor
But how about here? Like, do you end up spending a lot of time outside here?
Joe Rogan
Oh yeah, oh yeah, I do. But I'm outdoors all the time. I work out outside. I do a lot of farmers carries outside. I, I practice archery. So I shoot my bow outside every day and I love it.
Sponsor Voice
I.
Joe Rogan
It feel, I feel better even when it's hot out. I don't mind because I'm really kind of accustomed to it because of sauna use. I use the sauna every day. I'm pretty religious about it. So my body's really acclimated to heat, so it doesn't really bother me that much. I just bring a big jug of 64 ounce jug of water with ice and electrolytes and I just drink that while I'm out there.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
So I shoot my bow for an hour and a half, two hours and 105 degrees and I'm fine. I love it.
Dr. James Nestor
I actually love it too. Yeah, like as a kid in Florida, you know, we'd play basketball after school for hours. Or in summer it would be 105 degrees and then you just kind of turn the hose, you stick out of your mouth for quite a long time, you know? Yeah.
Joe Rogan
I mean it feels great. It's just you have to make sure you're not dehydrated and you have to make sure you don't burn. That's kind of all it is.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, yeah, exactly.
Joe Rogan
That's all it seems to be. But we do see like truckers that. Have you ever seen those?
Dr. James Nestor
You're talking about that famous photo? Yeah, that is a crazy photo.
Joe Rogan
Crazy photo. So what we're referring to is there's a photo of this trucker and the left side of his face from the sun coming in from the window. Looks like he's 20 years older on his left side than it is on his right side.
Dr. James Nestor
It's like special effects. Somebody melted the left side of his face.
Joe Rogan
What's that all about? Yeah, there's the guy.
Dr. James Nestor
There he is.
Sponsor Voice
That's literally nuts.
Joe Rogan
That's literally nuts.
Dr. James Nestor
Like left side is just sloping off.
Joe Rogan
Basically his left side looks like a hundred year old man. Truck driver face. Years behind the wheel, driving a truck. Damage typically limited to the left side of the face. So it's literally called truck driver face.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. Now, so that photo and that study got used to like scare the shit out of a lot of people. Try to keep them out of the sun.
Joe Rogan
Especially people that are vain and don't want that. That up wrinkly face.
Sponsor Voice
This episode is brought to you by Paleo Valley.
Joe Rogan
You guys know I live a super busy lifestyle, so I need snacks that don't slow me down. And Paleo Valley is the perfect on the go snack.
Sponsor Voice
That's why I keep a couple beef
Joe Rogan
sticks in my bag. Not just any beef sticks.
Sponsor Voice
Paleo Valley 100 grass fed beef and finish sticks.
Joe Rogan
Because let me tell you, beef sticks are not all equal. Most on the market use preservatives and additives like encapsulated citric acid and lactic acid to keep them shelf stable.
Sponsor Voice
But not Paleo Valley. They naturally ferment their beef sticks to
Joe Rogan
preserve freshness and flavor without using any
Sponsor Voice
chemicals or questionable ingredients.
Joe Rogan
That natural fermentation even supports a healthy gut.
Sponsor Voice
No msg, no gluten, no sugar, no additives, no junk. Just clean, high quality beef. These are tender and perfectly seasoned, not
Joe Rogan
dry or tough like most sticks.
Sponsor Voice
And they've got five flavors.
Joe Rogan
Right now I'm all in for the jalapeno.
Sponsor Voice
Go to paleovalley.com rogan and use the code rogan.
Joe Rogan
That's paleovalley.com rogan oh, that's crazy. Look at the difference between. Wow, that's literally bananas. So what they're showing back and forth is they're just taking the skin from the left side of the face and switching sides so you can see how much damage he's received on that side. The driver's side.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. And so there's a couple of interesting things there. One that is shocking. But the question to ask is why doesn't every trucker look like that? Right. Like, if that's the problem, why does. Why, why him? Like, because I've been driving in a car for 45 years and you know, my face is the same on the
Joe Rogan
left as it is on the right,
Dr. James Nestor
kind of hanging in there. But. But the other thing is window glass I think is actually a really interesting problem to talk about.
Joe Rogan
Yeah.
Dr. James Nestor
Because window glass blocks UVB, but not uva. And there's two different wavelengths of uv. The UVB is the super high energy one. UVA is a little bit lower. It's kind of on the way to blue. And they used to think back in the day that UVB was the only one that caused skin cancer. And those old sunscreens that we used in the 70s and 80s only blocked UVB. Window glass blocks. UVB blocks only part of the UVA. So anytime you're driving or you're hanging out in a window in your house, you're getting a bunch of uva, you're not gonna burn. Cause UVB is the one that causes burning. But you're still gonna get a bunch of UVA, which they figured out, like in the 90s, does cause skin cancer.
Joe Rogan
Oh, wow. So sun through the windows.
Dr. James Nestor
Sun through the windows is not as
Joe Rogan
good as sun outside.
Dr. James Nestor
It blocks the uvb, but the UVA comes through. But you'll never have a burn reaction because of it.
Joe Rogan
But you might be getting damaged.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. And so like in the us people get slightly more. Slightly higher rates of skin cancer on the left side of their body. In the uk, they get slightly higher rates of skin cancer on the right side.
Joe Rogan
Aha. Because they drive on the opposite side of the road.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. So window glass is slightly. Slightly. It's like 52, 48. It's not huge.
Joe Rogan
Okay. But it's statistically significant.
Dr. James Nestor
Statistically significant. Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Huh. So do you think it's this guy's particular genes?
Dr. James Nestor
There must be something weird about that guy.
Guest or Listener
Right.
Joe Rogan
Well, how many instances of truck driver face do they have?
Jamie
I just googled the condition, and it's only him coming up in the photos.
Dr. James Nestor
So this is the thing.
Jamie
There's one lady, but she clearly doesn't seem to have the same issue.
Dr. James Nestor
There's a lot of truck drivers that have been doing it for 50 years.
Jamie
That's not the same thing.
Joe Rogan
Oh, that's not real.
Jamie
Is that real? It's a different thing. She's got something wrong with her jaw.
Joe Rogan
Oh.
Jamie
But it's coming up as the same condition. Unilateral derma. Dermatota.
Sponsor Voice
I can't say.
Joe Rogan
Oh. So she had some sort of cancer that made her way its way into her jaw, but I can't.
Jamie
I would have assumed that more cases would pop up, but it's literally just him.
Dr. James Nestor
So that's the thing. It's the real question is what's up with that dude?
Joe Rogan
Yeah.
Jamie
Interesting. That's not the. I don't think that's the same guy.
Joe Rogan
No. It doesn't seem like the same person, but might be. It's hard to say because of different
Dr. James Nestor
lighting, but so the thing is, so those sunscreens that were acting kind of like window glass in the 70s and 80s and even into the 90s before we got the broad spectrum sunscreens, they're blocking the uvb, so you weren't going to ever burn. And that's what SPF actually measures is how many more times you can be out in the sun without burning. So if you got. But it's based totally on UVB, so if you've got SPF 30 in theory, you can spend 30 times as long outside before you start to burn. That's a long time. Right. But all that time UVA is just pouring into you. And they now know that UVA is the one that probably is most likely to cause melanoma.
Joe Rogan
Oh, that's crazy. Wow. So sunscreen now I use a natural sunscreen when I use it at all. It's this stuff that's like beef tallow based and has zinc in it. It's very white and obvious. You know, it's the, the spray stuff goes on clear. You can't even tell you have it on. Yeah, but it's very effective. But I'm always like super hesitant. I'm like, what, what's in that stuff? That we're gonna find out 15, 20 years from now, like if it can block the sun. So it's a chemical. And you're spraying this chemical on an organ which is your skin, so your, your skin's absorbing it. I'm like, what? What's going on there?
Dr. James Nestor
And they used to say, oh no, no, it's not absorbed very much. And then the FDA CDC did studies a few years ago and discovered that it's absorbed at very large amounts. It turns up at high doses or higher doses than they would like it to in blood, breast milk, urine, you name it.
Joe Rogan
And what specifically turns up and what's dangerous about it.
Dr. James Nestor
So they're suspected to be hormone disruptors, all those classic chemical filters like oxybenzone. There isn't much proof that they're dangerous in the amounts used, but they definitely are absorbed at much higher rates than we thought. And the FDA has refused to approve them as safe, pending more testing. And nobody's done the testing, but they're about to get phased out anyway. Just as of a couple months ago, the government changed the rules and is going to let in for the first time in 30 years new ingredients which they've been using in Europe and Asia and Australia for decades. And the Sunshine companies have been asking to use them and haven't been allowed to but they're finally going to get to use one of the main ones
Joe Rogan
and one of these ingredients.
Dr. James Nestor
So it's called like Bemotrizenol or something. And there's another one that you see in Europe called like Mexaryl 400 but they're way better. Like basically US sunscreens are a generation behind everyone else because in the US sunscreens are regulated as over the counter drugs. Bamotrizenol.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, Bamotrizenol. Highly effective broad spectrum UV filtered blocks. Both UVA and UVB. Approved by FDA's over the counter sunscreen ingredient in June of 2026. Oh, wow. So this month just happened. Celebrated for being highly photo stable. Doesn't break down the sun. Transparent on the skin without leaving a white cast and gentle on sensitive skin. So this is RFK junior Stuff.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, this one looks really good.
Joe Rogan
So this other stuff that has been in there, why didn't it get examined if Europe and Asia and all these other places were using these different, safer versions?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, they all bailed on it long ago because it was all we had.
Joe Rogan
God damn it. That drives me crazy.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, well, so fda, so in the US sunscreens are regulated as drugs over the counter drugs. So you have to do all this safety testing if you want to get a new ingredient in everywhere else they're just cosmetics. So you can use kind of whatever you want with more minimal safety testing. So the companies wanted to use this stuff in the US forever, but the FDA said, sure, just do the testing. But they didn't want to do. It was too expensive to do the testing. They would have to test it on animals. They didn't want to get the blowback on that. There are a bunch of reasons that they weren't willing to do it. Also, I think they're a little scared what they might find. So anyway, our sunscreens have not been nearly as good as what's used elsewhere, both in terms of performance and maybe safety suspicions. So that's going to change by the end of this year. It's going to get better.
Joe Rogan
Well, that's good. With the traditional sunscreen ingredients that we used to use, is there any negative health consequences of using them that they've shown? Like is there any diseases that occur more readily or more frequently?
Dr. James Nestor
Not that have been proven. Toxicologists are a little suspicious about some of them. They've definitely been shown to mess up coral. Right. Like people coral reefs.
Jamie
Right.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, that's one of the things they found after Covid. Right. They used to think. They used to think that it was the warming of the environment. This was one of the things that climate change. People used to say the climate change was destroying the coral reefs. And then it turns out actually it's all these people that have sunscreen all over their body and they jump in the ocean and they're essentially poisoning the reef.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, I mean, it's all the above, I'm pretty sure. But yeah, the sunscreen at that kind of concentration, if you got a bazillion snorkelers in the water, can definitely mess up the coral pretty badly.
Joe Rogan
Wasn't there some sort of a study that examined what happened to the reef after Covid? There was one particular reef that was in this highly visited area where people would jump in and they showed a massive increase in the reef after Covid.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, Hawaii banned use of those sunscreen. A bunch of places banned that style of sunscreen. But the.
Joe Rogan
But they don't really check your bags, though.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, right.
Jamie
You know what I mean?
Joe Rogan
When they say banned, people are gonna take it anyway.
Dr. James Nestor
But it doesn't look like. I don't think it has much impact on us unless you're using a ton of it, which of course now some people.
Joe Rogan
So it's not great for you, but it's not the worst.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, there's been a bunch of studies that just looked at like, lifespan, and sunscreen doesn't seem to have any impact whatsoever, like positive or negative on lifespan.
Joe Rogan
So it just might have some sort of an impact on hormonal function.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, it could. Well.
Joe Rogan
Endocrine disruption.
Dr. James Nestor
Endocrine disruption. There's a guy named Graham Peasley at Notre Dame who found that many, many cosmetic products of all kinds of are actually contaminated with forever chemicals. And even if they don't have it on the ingredients, like anything that's water resistant or super smooth is quite possibly going to have forever chemicals in it. And some of it is actually coming from the plastic containers because those get. They basically get fluorinated fluorine gas before they get anything in them, which is supposed to make them a little smoother, the inside of the containers. But it turns out that actually leaks forever chemicals into the product, whatever's in there. That's what he found.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, that makes sense. I mean, this is a problem with hot coffee when you're drinking it out of a paper cup.
Dr. James Nestor
Very similar. Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Yeah. People don't realize, like, the paper cup is not capable of keeping that liquid. It would turn to mush. And the reason why it doesn't turn to mush is because there's essentially A condom, like around the inside of the coffee cup. And, you know, Paul Saladino broke a coffee cup down to show what it looks like on the inside. And you're like, oh, no, you're pouring hot liquid into plastic, which you're never supposed to do. And it's also like most coffee machines, like a giant percentage of coffee machines have just plastic everywhere. I got rid of mine. That's why we use French press at the studio and I use that at home too. And I have one of those little aeropresses to make an individual cup of coffee. It's like the plastic is a real problem and heating it is terrible.
Sponsor Voice
We know that about water bottles.
Joe Rogan
Like, you're never supposed to drink out of a water bottle that you leave in the hot sun in your car.
Dr. James Nestor
So now picture that bottle of sunscreen that's sitting in your car, right? Cooking and leaching into the material.
Joe Rogan
Yuck. Yeah. Not good. People don't think of the skin as an organization. And I was explaining to a friend of mine the other day, he was using hand wash, that, that hand sanitizer stuff. And I'm like, man, I don't think that's good for you. I mean, I think if you want to wash your hands, you should just use soap and water. And then I read this article about it, like, oh, yeah, that's a toxic chemical like hand sanitizer. When you're using it every day, you're essentially exposing your skin, your organ to this. Like, what exactly is in hand sanitizer? And is it bad for you? Because I remember this article, but I just went over the headline and briefly started reading it. And then I had to do something and I put a bookmark to it that was going to go back to it later and I never did.
Dr. James Nestor
Oh, okay. I thought you're gonna say like, something happened to the bookmark.
Joe Rogan
No, no, no, no. I just, I never went back to it. But I remember during the COVID times, everybody was just like, hand sanitizer everywhere. I'm like, I just don't think that can be good for you.
Dr. James Nestor
I mean, anything that's antibiotic, right? Anything that's killing biological life, probably you want to be at least a little bit hesitant with mostly alcohol.
Joe Rogan
Mostly alcohol. Well, even alcohol going through your skin like that. Isopropyl alcohol, sometimes used instead of or with ethanol, similar levels. And then this word benzalka chloride in many alcohol free products. All right, but see if you can find articles on the dangers of using hand sanitizer, because this is what I had read Briefly, just say, overuse it.
Jamie
You're gonna fuck up your skin biome. But I don't.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, that's what it's saying. Overuse.
Jamie
I just. That's. I just know that.
Joe Rogan
I know a guy's got OCD and he's, you know, hypochondriac a little bit, and he uses hand sanitizer all the time. It's kind of crazy. And a friend of mine, without knowing, went to look at his house because his house was for sale. And he's looking at the house, he's like, this is a very nice house. And he opens up a closet, and one of the closets was filled with hand sanitizer. And he got so freaked out, he didn't want to live in the house anymore. He's like, I don't want to buy this house. Like, this guy, like, whatever weird thing, he's possessed with that, he needs 50,000 fucking bottles of hand sanitizer.
Jamie
Hand issues are just classic overuse. And then don't not use it on your hands, obviously. Don't breathe it. Don't drink it. Right.
Joe Rogan
Only use it on your hands.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, but Jamie's right on the skin biome. Skin biomes turning out to be really important. They call it the gut skin axis, where your skin microbiome and your gut microbiome are chatting all the time. And you can change the composition of your skin microbiome based on all kinds of stuff like products, sun exposure, everything. You do probiotics. Probiotics, yeah.
Joe Rogan
Well, in the jiu jitsu world, in the early 2000s, people started really getting into probiotics. They started really getting into acidophilus yogurt, kimchi, fermented vegetables, and stuff like that, just to prevent skin issues.
Dr. James Nestor
Interesting.
Joe Rogan
Because jiu jitsu, because you're. You're getting scratched up and you're rolling around, and there's a lot of infections. And a lot of people get not just infections like staph infection, but they also get ringworm and a bunch of stuff like that. And so some people started using antibacterial soap. And the problem with that is it just nukes all the good flora of your skin.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
So then there's a company called Defense Soap, and they developed a soap specifically for grapplers. And this soap has tea tree oil and eucalyptus, and it's very healthy for the skin, so it promotes healthy gut flora. But it does kill all the cooties. It kills all the matte cooties.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. Yeah. I think that's basically what you want that microbiome, it can take a lot of natural abuse. It's there, it naturally lives on skin, so it's usually getting and like roughed up by the world. But yeah, chemicals that are too strong can take it out.
Joe Rogan
And the gut flora is important as well. It's like you gotta think of the whole thing as one sort of ecosystem. Your whole body, it all works together. And if your gut biome is all fucked up and you don't have healthy gut flora, it can affect all sorts of different issues.
Dr. James Nestor
And yeah, it shows up on the skin for sure. That, that's, that's well known.
Sponsor Voice
This episode is brought to you by LifeLock.
Joe Rogan
Lots of places can accidentally expose you to identity theft.
Sponsor Voice
Doctor's offices, online retailers, insurance companies, the list goes on. Thankfully, LifeLock monitors hundreds of millions of data points a second for threats to your identity, which is way more than
Joe Rogan
anyone could do on their own.
Sponsor Voice
LifeLock keeps an eye on your personal information, credit applications, finances and more. And if they find anything suspicious, like new loans or changes to your financial accounts, they'll alert you right away, all through text, phone, email or the Lifelock app. Even better, alerts are automatically activated the moment you become a Lifelock member.
Joe Rogan
No extra work on your part.
Sponsor Voice
Get the alerts that could make all the difference. Don't wait. Join LifeLock now. Visit LifeLock.com jre and save up to 30% your first year. That's LifeLock.com jre for 30% off terms
Podcast Announcer
apply for adults with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms. Every choice matters. Tremphya offers self injection or intravenous infusion. From the start, Tremphya is administered as injections under the skin or infusions through a vein every four weeks, followed by injections under the skin every four or eight weeks. If your doctor decides that you can self inject Tremphya, proper training is required. Tremphya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease and adults with moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis. Serious allergic reactions, increased risk of infections or lower ability to fight them and liver problems may occur before treatment. Get checked for infection and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu like symptoms or need a vaccine. Explore what's possible. Ask your doctor about tremphya today. Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more or visit tremphyaradio.com
Joe Rogan
so when you first started getting pushback against this, were you surprised? Did it upset you what did it feel like to get attacked by dermatologists?
Dr. James Nestor
I am naturally conflict averse. I was kind of like, do I even want to talk about this? But it was such interesting information I thought was important. So I wanted to. I wrote an article for Outside back in like, 2018, and I titled it Is Sunscreen the New Margarine? Right. So right there, that's pushing buttons. Yeah, I probably, you know, in retrospect, I don't push as many buttons today. I just point to the data.
Joe Rogan
You just didn't like it. Didn't like the response.
Dr. James Nestor
Well, I mean, it got a massive. It went truly viral, as they used to say. But it actually detracted. I think those old sunscreens really were like, margarine detrimental, like the ones that only blocked uvb. So I think I kind of got it right. But also the title detracted from the information in the article, in a sense.
Sponsor Voice
But why?
Dr. James Nestor
Because Margin sucks, March sucks. Those old sunscreens did suck. The new sunscreens are. They're fine. But.
Joe Rogan
So it's a good comparison.
Dr. James Nestor
It turns out to have been. Yeah, like, the more we learn about those old sunscreens, the more it looks like a sort of like a catastrophic mistake that then got fixed. But yeah, so that. So now the book is out. Suddenly I've got all these, like, beauty magazines contacting me and they have this image of me as like, you know, the Unabomber, like, hanging out. Hanging out in my cabin and firing off these missives. Really?
Joe Rogan
Yeah, from beauty magazines.
Dr. James Nestor
They were nervous to talk to me because they thought I was gonna be, you know, a kook. A kook, yeah.
Joe Rogan
Wow.
Sponsor Voice
So the first.
Joe Rogan
So is Sunscreen the New Margarine? So that was the first one. And what was the response to that? So do you remember the first really negative response and how you felt about it?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. So there was an official letter from the aad. And they're very polite, but they're like, we think this is misrepresenting the information and we think this is dangerous. If you're telling people that they might benefit from more sunlight, that's dangerous. So that's probably. And then, you know, when that came in, I was like, so that needs to change. If we have in our heads that exposure to any sunshine is dangerous, we're not seeing the forest for the trees. We've lost the thread on this one. So then. So I did a bunch of other articles. I did one article that focused specifically on the skin color issue. Like, do people of color. Do we need to stop Telling people of color that they need to protect themselves from the sun. And then I did a couple more recently for the Atlantic just on like what should recommendations be? Can we do recommendations that are not one size fits all?
Joe Rogan
Well, skin color in particular is one of the best signs of adaptation to environment. I mean, that's how human beings were able to get vitamin D from the sun in a place like Scotland. When people moved there, they got pale as shit.
Dr. James Nestor
100%.
Joe Rogan
Completely makes sense.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. And you can track it. It's like the gradations of lightning go with that move northward. So you could tell white skin is a desperate attempt to get enough light in a screwy northern environment.
Joe Rogan
Right. But when those people that have ancestors from that screwy northern environment moved to California or Arizona.
Dr. James Nestor
Australia.
Joe Rogan
Yeah. And Australia is real bad, Right. Because there's all the people that use hairspray in the 80s, they cause a giant hole in the ozone layer over Australia.
Dr. James Nestor
Well, yeah, essentially, yeah.
Joe Rogan
Australia, when I was there, they have these signs on buses, like these warnings that show skin cancer, like these horrible lesions on people's faces and stuff. And it's just this warning to wear sunscreen, protect yourself.
Dr. James Nestor
They're right. That's the textbook case where you've got a horrible mismatch between the population and the place. Like super, super high levels of sunshine in Australia. Weak ozone. Redheads from Scotland who are trying to deal. So their skin cancer rates are literally two or three times what they are anywhere else in the world.
Joe Rogan
Wow. Now how much of that is because of the skin color of the general Australian population other than the indigenous people? And how much of it is because the ozone?
Dr. James Nestor
So the ozone is healing itself slowly. We're getting there. So that's probably less of an issue now. It's a really fair skinned population in a super bright intense environment. So they do need to worry about it. But the problem is the rest of the world has kind of set its rules about sun exposure based on Australia.
Joe Rogan
What's interesting also about Australia is I wonder how long it takes for human adaptation to start to show itself. Do you think in 100,000 years from now, people that live in Australia will be dark?
Dr. James Nestor
Well, David Reich did that great episode with you, right? Did you have David Reich on? David Reich, he's the Harvard ancient DNA guy.
Jamie
Did we?
Dr. James Nestor
No. So he just came out with a new study like two months ago.
Joe Rogan
We had so many people on, I can't remember who ever had on.
Dr. James Nestor
I can't either. I was like, if I didn't hear it here, would I Hear it anyway, might be Lex or Superman. It just, that movement started a few thousand years ago. Suddenly like that pale redhead gene came out of nowhere and like skyrocketed. So it can change pretty quickly when the environmental factors change. Really?
Joe Rogan
That's only a few thousand years old.
Dr. James Nestor
The red headed gene. Yeah, yeah. That's crazy. It was kind of lingering quietly in the background and then like maybe that's
Joe Rogan
why gingers get so much hate because they're just brand new.
Dr. James Nestor
They are like the next new thing. But yeah, four or five thousand years ago it suddenly explodes in popularity, but in a very particular place in northern
Joe Rogan
Europe and most likely as a result to the environment.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, for 100%.
Jamie
Wow.
Joe Rogan
So I wonder how long it's going to take. I wonder if we could go into the future if the same population lives in Australia now.
Dr. James Nestor
Well, except here's the weird thing. So Australians versus uk, right? Similar genetics. Australia, super high rates of skin cancer because of that sunny environment, but also way better lifespan than in the uk.
Joe Rogan
Really.
Dr. James Nestor
So skin cancer is a factor, but that sunlight is actually benefiting Australians more than it's hurting them compared to the uk.
Joe Rogan
I wonder if that's a healthy user bias as well because one of the things about Australia is a lot of outdoor activities. A lot of people are doing stuff outside. Yeah, a lot of activity, period.
Dr. James Nestor
And that could be a factor. And actually that's one thing I come come down to in the book is it's really hard to disentangle all of these factors. But what's really obvious is just outside good, too much inside bad. So whatever, you don't even have to break it down too much more outside, cover it up, whatever you want is probably going to be good for you.
Joe Rogan
One of the things, a friend of mine who's a doctor said that when he was working in New York City in the wintertime, he would find people with undetectable levels of vitamin D. And he said it was a particular problem with people with darker skin because if you have darker skin you're going to get less vitamin D from the sun for whatever exposure you do get. And then these people are all indoors all the time.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, that's a really bad formula. If you have dark skin, you need five to ten times as much sunlight to make the same amount of vitamin D. So you're really, if you have really dark skin, you're kind of designed for a very bright tropical environment where
Joe Rogan
you're, where you're outside all the time.
Dr. James Nestor
Outside all the time. You can handle 12 hours a day of Sunshine. And in fact, you're going to benefit from it. You get moved to a really dark environment that's not going to be good for you. So you probably need to compensate in other ways.
Joe Rogan
It's going to be very interesting when genetic engineering reaches a level where we can turn those things on and off in people. And how do people react to fair skinned people all of a sudden getting dark?
Dr. James Nestor
Like, like, yeah, you know, like.
Joe Rogan
Well, we are one race. We are, it's. We are the human race. There's a bunch of different ancestors where people came from different areas where they adapted to different environments. But the reality is we're just human beings and we all started in Ethiopia and we spread out and that's just, that's what we are. We are the result of whatever environment our ancestors evolved in.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, totally. And with skin tone, it's clearly like very, very specific reactions to that environment and trying to figure out what's best in each situation.
Joe Rogan
But there's so much racial identity that's tied to these characteristics of your appearance and where your ancestors are from. It's going to be very weird if all of a sudden you could like, people get like dark, thick, curly hair and there used to be gingers. I wonder how people are gonna react to that.
Dr. James Nestor
I mean, it's coming, right, right, it's coming. And bets are off.
Sponsor Voice
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
I just wonder how many people are gonna be claiming cultural or racial appropriation with people just deciding to have a healthier skin tone that protects them from the sun more.
Dr. James Nestor
Oh, I see where you go. Yeah, yeah.
Joe Rogan
Well, yeah, like that guy with the melanitan. I wonder, I wonder if anybody got mad at him.
Dr. James Nestor
Right, right. Like, what are you supposed to look like?
Joe Rogan
Yeah, what are you supposed to look like?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, yeah.
Joe Rogan
There was a lady that was on a television show once that was turning herself black. It was in the uk. And this lady looked, she looked like she had other issues. She had giant breast implants. She looked like a kook. Bunch of plastic surgery, but she was
Sponsor Voice
dark as a date.
Joe Rogan
Like that lady. That's a white lady. So that's what she used to look like. And she's getting her boobs bigger and bigger. She wants them bigger. And so look, she keeps getting.
Dr. James Nestor
That's a little too far.
Joe Rogan
Maybe, Maybe.
Dr. James Nestor
Wow. That's her.
Joe Rogan
That's her. So what did she do? Via intense use of tanning injections. Yeah, so she's the ultimate Melanitan hero.
Dr. James Nestor
Wow.
Joe Rogan
I mean, that lady got like Cameroon dark. Like, look at that photo again. Go back to that video.
Sponsor Voice
Like, that's crazy.
Dr. James Nestor
That is crazy.
Joe Rogan
That's crazy.
Dr. James Nestor
I don't know. Maybe if you're in Australia, it works for you.
Sponsor Voice
Maybe.
Joe Rogan
Well, it would. Right. It would protect because it is melanin. But obviously she's got. She's got other things going on, like you.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. At some point you might, Might, might have too much melanin. So here's the funny thing about melanin as well. Like, so it's made by our melanocyte, which are what can become melanoma if they get screwed up. And those are in the very bottom of the epidermis, the outer layer of the skin. And it's an incredibly good absorber of uv, better than anything we've come up with. It's almost perfect at it. But what you want, when your skin gets hit with sunlight, that melanin that's just been produced is at the bottom of the epidermis where the melanocytes are. So it has to migrate to the surface, and then it kind of acts like little umbrellas. It'll cover the nucleus of the cell and protect it. So you get these little, like, umbrellas, a line of umbrellas on the very top of your epidermis. But it has to migrate up because of sunlight. If melanin is lower in your skin, then it's going to absorb all that radiation farther down. And actually it can cause more free radicals deeper in the skin.
Joe Rogan
And what would cause it to be lower?
Dr. James Nestor
So it starts lower and it only goes up in response to sunlight. So if you're never, ever in the sun and you suddenly go out and get hit by a bunch of sunlight, your melon's gonna be down too low and can actually create free. It can exacerbate the problem.
Joe Rogan
So this lady might be exacerbating the problem if he's just getting the melanin that way.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, I don't know, because I don't know about this specifically, but you probably. Yeah. You don't want to just be, like, messing around with melanin, like, to the extent that she is.
Joe Rogan
Oh, boy. That's interesting because, like, the melanitan stuff, I have heard about it before and I never really looked into it, but the idea kind of makes sense that if you can make your body produce more melanin, that would protect itself. But I didn't realize that it has to be melanin from sun exposure you
Dr. James Nestor
want in the right place.
Guest or Listener
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Could both things work? Could you do it that way and with sun exposure, increase both? And would it give some Sort of a benefit to have a higher level of melanin that could eventually get to the surface of the skin. Does that make any sense?
Dr. James Nestor
You're above my pay grade now. I think you might be above everybody's pay grade. I don't know if anyone is looked
Joe Rogan
at that they seem, it seems like something to look into though. If we know that there's a benefit to having melanin.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, I mean it'd be interesting. But I think this stuff's new enough that there probably hasn't been a ton of research on it.
Joe Rogan
So what does a pale person do? What does the old pasty white do?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, so full pasty white, like really pale.
Jamie
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Like my friend, I have a friend, my daughter said he's white. And I said she was really little. And I go, yeah. She goes, no, no, he's white like paper.
Dr. James Nestor
So if you're white like paper.
Joe Rogan
He's from England.
Podcast Announcer
Yeah.
Dr. James Nestor
You do have to be really careful. You're not gonna tan that much. You just don't make that much melanin.
Joe Rogan
Can that change over time? Can they like slowly expose themselves to the sunlight like five minutes a day and just ramp it up?
Dr. James Nestor
It depends on your genetics. If you're like a full on ginger, like true redhead, you're then you have a type of melanin called pheomelanin, not eumelanin, which is what everybody else has. And pheomelanin just does not do a good job of absorbing sunlight.
Joe Rogan
Oh no. There's no hope for gingers.
Dr. James Nestor
There's no hope for gingers in terms of sun exposure. Dam the hope is just avoid that midday sun that's high in the uv, get the morning like the sunrise and sunset stuff that doesn't have the UV in it.
Joe Rogan
Okay. So they can benefit, benefit from sun exposure, but they can't have like full on outdoor sun exposure.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. They're the ones who need to be really careful.
Joe Rogan
So for those people, sunscreen is recommended.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. Or just cover up even, I think better.
Joe Rogan
You know how many other people are working on this stuff and is everybody sort of in agreement with the data, the people that are examining it?
Dr. James Nestor
I mean there's a ton of science coming out, but. But it's early days for sure.
Joe Rogan
Doesn't it seem crazy that sun and our reaction to sun is unknown or at least poorly studied?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, yeah, but. Yeah, but it's amazing how many things in medicine you dive into the research and you dig down a little and you realize that we're just kind of guessing still on Many levels. Like it's early days for a lot of this stuff.
Joe Rogan
Well, certainly for like stuff that they use for antidepressants.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, but that's. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Sun exposure is competitive with antidepressants in terms of lifting depression.
Joe Rogan
Isn't that nuts? And you know what's way better? Exercise. Yeah, many times better than any known antidepressants. Regular exercise.
Dr. James Nestor
I mean exercise is number one for everybody across the board.
Jamie
Ginger people with melod the peptide here, seeing if you post about it changing their hair color.
Dr. James Nestor
Interesting.
Jamie
And this one.
Joe Rogan
Yeah.
Jamie
Permanently.
Sponsor Voice
What?
Joe Rogan
Yeah, click on that.
Dr. James Nestor
Well, that this is.
Jamie
I guess this just takes it to the Reddit. It's just going to show a YouTube video here.
Joe Rogan
But there's multiple changed his hair color.
Jamie
Other posts about it.
Joe Rogan
Whoa.
Jamie
And there's a. I was just seeing
Joe Rogan
what if that would work with people that are old that have like white hair. I wonder what that would do.
Jamie
Like a melanin two page says like how it can affect hair color. Oh, I read through real quick that this is not the best website.
Joe Rogan
Isn't it weird that women with red hair are hot and men with red hair are not? It's very, very weird because women with red hair are considered very attractive.
Jamie
Yeah, this one's this good. I just got spray tan.
Joe Rogan
Okay. But the people that take it, that one guy is he like a one of one where it changes hair color
Jamie
so that this like I said, so this website.
Joe Rogan
Click on that. Click on the video. Let's watch it for a couple seconds, see what this guy's showing. So this is him before and this is him now. His eyebrow and his beard colors changed
Jamie
also we clicked on the. This might not even be him. He could be reporting the video, but someone else too.
Guest or Listener
So before I got all gray and my hair started.
Dr. James Nestor
It looks pretty good.
Joe Rogan
Yeah,
Guest or Listener
gray actually used to be ginger. Now I was bullied a lot as a kid because I was ginger. I was weird and I was chubby. That's the winning trio for being actions from this Going through a lot of changes up here, down there, you know the stuff that happens during purity. So I didn't immediately noticed that my hair had gotten much darker. It was actually other people asking me what the hell I had done to my hairline. You know, on this picture it's probably much clearer. That's a picture of me and my brother. We have the same genetics in regards of skin color and the color of our hair. And as you can see, my hair is now completely different from his. We used to have the same Skin and the same hair, especially the color. Now, this is only from using. Using one vial of melanotan. Two in the span of a year, even more than a year. And it was at low dosages, but with our genetics of big, tall, white ginger, Belgian gingers, it completely changed the color of my hair and my skin. And the effects were very strong, so
Joe Rogan
the effects are permanent. So he still has dark hair, but what's interesting is in the beginning, he had gray hair.
Jamie
He seems older, obviously.
Dr. James Nestor
Right, right.
Sponsor Voice
But he had gray hair.
Joe Rogan
He was showing. And his hair's not gray anymore, right?
Dr. James Nestor
I mean, gray. Gray.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, gray and ginger.
Dr. James Nestor
Gray is a loss of melanin. Like, melanin is what makes your hair dark as well as your skin dark. So he's. He's resupplied his melanin for his hair as well.
Joe Rogan
It seems like that seems kind of nuts.
Jamie
He said one vial for a year. Oh, you said even all over your year.
Joe Rogan
Right. So for a year. So his skin has gotten pale again, but his hair is permanently dark. So that's what he used to look like. He had red hair. He had a red beard, and he had gray hair. His hair had gone gray, and now his hair is dark. I gotta know if this guy's full of.
Jamie
Yeah, that's. Again, it's like there's one.
Joe Rogan
Only one person saying, yeah, that's the problem. It's like you don't know what you're looking at, but that's crazy.
Dr. James Nestor
But it is. Yeah. Melon is the pigment for all of it. Bit.
Joe Rogan
Put that in. Does mellow. Melatonin. How does it say. How do you say it?
Dr. James Nestor
Melanotan.
Joe Rogan
Melanotan. Does melanotan have an effect on hair color? Put that into perplexity. See what they say.
Jamie
Yeah, yeah.
Joe Rogan
What does it say? Because I know a lot of people with gray hair that bums them out, and they dye it, and. And that can't be good for you. You're putting dye in your hair.
Dr. James Nestor
I know.
Jamie
Yeah.
Dr. James Nestor
Stuff makes me hesitant. I'm stuck with the gray hair.
Joe Rogan
I think, well, mine would be gray if I had hair. It's all gray in my beard now. It's gray on my. I'm gonna try it. I want to try some melotan and see if I get dangerous boners. Melanitan does not have good human evidence of changing scalp or body hair color. Its main effect is on skin tanning and freckling, not on turning hair darker or lighter. But how's that guy? Maybe he's like, just a weird case.
Jamie
Yeah, but it's gotta be a hormone dependent.
Joe Rogan
What about the lady with the giant boobs? She had dark hair too.
Jamie
She's saying when I was looking through her thing, it said she went through a permanent tanning process. So I don't know. She would've been taking extreme dosages. But also her Instagram account is a mess. It's even hers. It's the one that Google showed.
Dr. James Nestor
But what's the. What's the erection connection? I don't understand how. You know, making more melanin.
Joe Rogan
What's the Melanitan? Owner erection connection. I have heard that. Though actually Brigham from Ways to. Well, the local wellness clinic was telling me about that. That some people have crazy erections because of melanitan. Yeah, like what? How? And some people don't. Like that one guy that had taken it. He said didn't affect him that way, but maybe. Maybe he's broken. Does it say anything about what's coming up right now? Causes boners. Okay. It can increase libido and trigger erections in some men. But it's not approved for. Well, I know it's not approved. How does it affect. It stimulates melanocortin. Melanocortin receptors in the brain which are involved in sexual arousal and erection control. Not just tanning. Controlled tiles. Controlled trot. Geez, I can't Talk today. Subcutaneous melanitan 2 caused erections in most men with erectile dysfunction, often without sexual stimulation. Same studies found increased sexual desire in a majority of doses compared with placebo
Jamie
increase.
Joe Rogan
Interesting. I wonder what the connection is.
Dr. James Nestor
It's the melanocortin, like you said. The MC. Was it MC4R up there? So yeah. MC1R is the gene that determines whether you've got the red hair or not.
Jamie
Look at this.
Joe Rogan
Common side effects were yawning, nausea, yawning and stretching. Flushing with decreased appetite. Some participants had severe nausea. At higher doses.
Dr. James Nestor
Yawning and sexual desire is an interesting combination.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, that's weird. Yeah, I'm really horny, but I'm too tired to do anything about it.
Jamie
Hypoactive sexual desire for premenopausal women.
Joe Rogan
Interesting. Interesting. Also shows erectogenic. I like that word. Erectogenic effects in men with ED, including those who fail PDE5 inhibitors. What is that? Was a PDE5 inhibitor. Interesting. Someone should. Someone out there with gray hair should give it a go. Find out.
Dr. James Nestor
Find out what's up.
Joe Rogan
Doesn't sound like other than dealing with boners, doesn't seem like there's any real problems. I keep Going back to this you getting attacked thing, and I don't understand how someone could attack you with the data that you're showing. Because, like, it's. You're not making any dangerous or, you know, any claims or any. You're not advising people do anything that's reckless.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, no, I mean, I purposefully have sort of left. I really haven't. I basically tell people to figure it out for themselves. Right. But it's only small amounts of sun exposure that seem to be necessary to get most of the benefits. The jump isn't going from zero to some. You don't need it a lot. Nobody really needs a lot. Unless you have really dark skin, then you can probably get away with a lot. So, yeah, just a little bit of sun exposure doesn't seem like a crazy recommendation, but it's just because the messaging has been sort of so extreme and unyielding, like they've worked for so hard to sort of scare people away from any sun exposure that I think backing that up a little bit is sort of uncomfortable.
Joe Rogan
You know, I understand, but I mean, isn't history filled with new discoveries and changing courses?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, and I think it'll change, but it's gonna be one funeral at a time. It's gonna be ugly all the way.
Joe Rogan
When you do this kind of work, have you discovered any other things that people thought were unhealthy that turned out to actually probably be good for you, at least if used correctly?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, that's such a good question. So the one like the metaphor that I think we're all familiar with and that I think maps pretty perfectly here is diet and fat 25 years ago. Gary Taubes does that article in the New York Times Magazine. What if fat doesn't make you fat? And we were still back in that era of carbs. Cut all the fat out of your diet. Carbs are good for you. Margarine, Right? The margarine era. The top Experts got it 100% wrong back then. And when they got called on it by, like, you know, Taubes and others. Nina Teichels. You guys have had Nina on.
Joe Rogan
I've had Tobbs on as well.
Dr. James Nestor
Oh, yeah. Okay. You know, they fought hard and they were totally wrong. And we now, you know, we flipped, but it took a long time. And, you know, there was little blood in the water during that process.
Joe Rogan
Oh, yeah. I was in the early days of that, and people were just warning me about my cholesterol. What about your cholesterol?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
What's really interesting is during the heart of that When I, you know, I eat a lot of meat, my diet's mostly meat. And I went to the doctor and I got all my levels checked, and he said, are you on some anti cholesterol medication? I said, no, why? And he goes, you have very low cholesterol.
Dr. James Nestor
Interesting.
Joe Rogan
It's weird. And I go, dude, if you saw my diet, my diet's like mostly meat and eggs and bacon. And that's like a giant percentage of my diet. I thought that was really interesting.
Dr. James Nestor
I think. I mean, yeah, I think the evidence is pretty good. Like for keto, I think it's pretty strong. Saladino, I think, is pretty much spot on on a lot of this stuff. But so, yeah, so that, like the ultimate. Experts all said that was gonna kill you.
Jamie
Right.
Dr. James Nestor
You know, Atkins, back in the day. And they were all completely wrong. So there's, you know, there's a long track record of the pros being wrong, I think, on a lot of things. But that's a really good example. And people can wrap their heads around that one because we now, I think a lot of people understand that low carb really works well for them.
Joe Rogan
I mean, they completely flipped the food pyramid.
Dr. James Nestor
Right. Which was a beautiful thing to do. And I can't believe it happened so fast.
Joe Rogan
Yeah. Well, also with very little pushback. It's kind of interesting because the evidence had already compounded to the fact that. Fact that, listen, for sure, margarine is not a good thing. It's not a good substitute. But also that all these healthy fats that you're getting from milk, that you're getting from eggs. Eggs in particular, we've been told eggs are bad for you. The cholesterol. And eggs. Eggs, you could live off just eggs.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. Probably the perfect food.
Joe Rogan
Yeah. Like, eggs are fantastic. I always tell my friends that are vegans. I was like, listen, man, just get some chickens and they're your pets, and they give you free food. It's like, I have 16 chickens now, and I get eggs every day.
Sponsor Voice
And these chickens are pets.
Joe Rogan
Like, I go, hey, ladies. You know, I feed them. I throw the worms down. They're not afraid of me. They listen to me. When I open the door, they come running out and they wander around the yard. It's like a great relationship. You get free food, you take care of them, you feed them, and they eat all the bugs in your yard. And you get these delicious, healthy eggs
Dr. James Nestor
from them with those beautiful orange y eggs.
Joe Rogan
Yeah. So if you're worri. If it's an ethical thing, you don't want Animal cruelty. And good for you, that's a wonderful way to live. But you are sacrificing your health by not eating pasture raised eggs. Just get the real ones, not the bullshit ones, the real ones. Unfortunately, they're tricking people. Now, some companies have been exposed for feeding their chickens turmeric. They feed them curcumin and turmeric and they're make it because it makes their eggs a darker, more attractive yolk.
Dr. James Nestor
I know, right? It's so screwy, so bizarrely backwards.
Joe Rogan
It is. But isn't turmeric good for you? And wouldn't turmeric that you're getting from those eggs also be good for you?
Dr. James Nestor
It's like, yeah, it can't hurt. I mean, right?
Joe Rogan
So it's not like they're giving them food dye. So it's.
Sponsor Voice
You know what I mean?
Joe Rogan
So it's like, yeah, you're getting these darker eggs because people like that and the darker eggs come from turmeric.
Jamie
But
Joe Rogan
still you're getting turmeric then, aren't you? Isn't that how it works?
Dr. James Nestor
I mean, that's fine. But I think the chicken, I think it's the bugs that sometimes help turn them oranges. Yeah, we get eggs from our neighbor, like in Vermont, everybody, there's chickens running around the road everywhere. And yeah, they're delicious. Yeah, you can tell that they're getting it from the bugs and the greens and.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, and it's super healthy. I mean, but that, that color of things is also why they dye farm raised salmon, which is really gross. So salmon are getting that from bugs in particular.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, exactly. Little arthropods. Yeah. Like miniature shrimp kind of.
Joe Rogan
Yeah. That's why they have that wonderful looking pink skin, that orangey pink skin.
Dr. James Nestor
So in that case the dye is maybe a little more suspect.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, well, the dye is very suspect because it's like, you know, these farm raised salmon, they have pale skin because they're eating bullshit.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Guest or Listener
You know.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Are there any other things that you've stumbled across that turned out to be good for you that people were averse to?
Dr. James Nestor
I'm still curious about alcohol. You know how everything is flipped on alcohol. Like first it was like drink or two a day is good for you. And then suddenly they flip like a year or two ago and say any amount of alcohol is bad for you. I looked into those studies and it seems like the takeaway really should have been moderate drinking doesn't do much of anything to you. Maybe it's slightly good for you or slightly bad for you, but For a drink a day or one to two a day didn't seem to have a whole lot of impact on mortality at all.
Joe Rogan
And also probably reduces a little bit of stress, relieves a little bit of social anxiety. And that alone is really beneficial. Like, how do you feel? Like, are you happy or are you stressed out? Sometimes a drink or two, you're like, ah, fuck it, we're fine. Everything's good. Like, that alone has benefits. Like, what it does to your mood, that it's a social lubricant. It'll allow you to, like, maybe laugh a little bit more, have a little bit more fun.
Dr. James Nestor
Totally. Which is why I can't give it up. Like, that social environment is a really nice environment to be in, you know, and if, you know, a couple beers helps make that happen, it's a good thing.
Joe Rogan
I gave it up for about eight months. I completely. I. Problem is, I own a comedy club, and I was there a lot. And so everybody's like, have a drink. Have a drink. Let's do shots. And then next thing you know, you look. I was in the gym the next day, feeling like shit. I got tired of doing that to myself. And so I said, I'm just gonna stop drinking. Not because I'm an alcoholic. Wasn't hard to stop. It was super easy. I just stopped. And then I started feeling way better. I was like, God, why was I drinking for so long? This is so bad. And then out to dinner with my wife, had a margarita, like, eight months later, I'm like, let's have a drink. She wasn't drinking either. I'm like, let's have a drink. And like, this is nice. I like it. So now I limit myself. I just. I won't have more than, like, two drinks. Two drinks is kind of my map. But two drinks is right. Two drinks is like wee. As long as you don't have to drive, you're not going anywhere. You know, if I go to the club, I'm there for hours, completely sober. After it's all over, it's like, I wake up in the morning, I don't feel like shit. Doesn't seem to be affecting my workouts. However, if you wear a whoop or an OURA ring or one of those tracking devices, you will notice in your sleep, in your recovery, you're not sleeping as well. You don't sleep as well. You don't get the same deep sleep.
Dr. James Nestor
I can tell.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, Just one glass of wine can fuck you up a little bit.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. Yeah. And that, for me, that hit in Middle age, like before that wasn't a problem. But now, yeah, like two drinks, two does seem to be the cutoff where life functions normally still. But yeah, the sleep's not as restorative somehow.
Joe Rogan
Somehow. But I wonder if it's the timing of when you're drinking. So I wonder if you have a glass of wine at dinner at 6 o' clock but you don't go to bed till midnight. I wonder if then your body has a chance to process it and then you're okay.
Dr. James Nestor
Well, that Italian style, right. I feel like the Mediterranean lifestyle, they got this pretty much nailed down like 2,000 years ago, right. It seems to work pretty well.
Joe Rogan
Which also brings us back to food.
Jamie
Right.
Joe Rogan
Because the way they eat is so. It's so interesting how thin they are and yet they eat mostly carbs.
Dr. James Nestor
I know, I know. Something's different there.
Joe Rogan
A lot's different. And we know what it is now. We know that there's a lot of additives and preservatives and it's also like they don't use glyphosate. And yeah, they have heirloom wheat. So they have wheat that hasn't been optimized to have a higher yield. So it doesn't have as much complex wheat glutens. And there's a lot of issues with our food, unfortunately. And if you eat American bread, you know, the bromine, all the different additives, all the. That we put in our food, that's so disturbing. Whenever I go to Italy, I'm so angry that when I come back home I can't have food like this. Like you have to seek it out. You have to go to like certain restaurants that only use like Italian flour.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, yeah. But yeah, you look at those Mediterranean cultures and it just works for them. And yeah, like you say, you can't explain it in terms of like macronutrients or anything like that. Like it's something, there's something like synergistic about that lifestyle. I do actually think light is part of it too. Like they got great light there.
Joe Rogan
They have great light. Especially like the Amalfi coast. Those people.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
But the other thing is also less stress. They're not as career focused. They're more family oriented, very tight knit family groups. They eat dinner together. There's a lot of laughing, a lot of drinking wine. A lot of them smoke cigarettes. You go over there like cigarettes never went out of style over there. They're all smoking cigarettes and you're like, how are you guys so fucking healthy? This is weird.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, it Is it's. Yeah, it'll be interesting on cigarettes if it turns out that in a certain context, they're not that damaging, and then out of that context, they're super damaging.
Joe Rogan
I have heard that with polyphenols. I've heard that. And this is a. I think, controversial as well. But it's cigarettes taken along with olive oil and that a lot of these people have high olive oil risk diets, and that cigarettes, along with olive oil, that the olive oil tends to balance out whatever damage that the cigarettes are doing.
Dr. James Nestor
That is super interesting.
Jamie
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Which kind of makes sense.
Dr. James Nestor
And it's gonna be like, everything is gonna be something like that where it's bad in a certain context, and then it seems to have been okay for people in a different context.
Guest or Listener
Yeah. Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Are there any other things that you've noticed? Like, I know you've done work on chocolate, right?
Dr. James Nestor
A lot of work on. Yeah. My first sort of big magazine story, Outside magazine sent me to the Amazon on this crazy hunt with this German guy. It was basically Apocalypse now with chocolate. This German guy was going upriver into the Amazon to try to find this wild cacao to work with some of the indigenous groups to harvest wild cacao and make the world's first wild chocolate chocolate. So I went with him. Crazy, crazy trip. But, yeah, I sort of fell in love with cacao on that trip. But it was like, we landed, we took a small plane, and we were going to land on this river and meet a canoe that was going to take us up river to meet with these indigenous groups. So we found a Runway, right? This is in the Bolivian Amazon. I've been in the Amazon all of, like, four minutes, right? The plane drops us off on this flooded Runway where it was a crazy landing. We hop out of the plane. I'm glad to be alive. And then these four guys with guns come out of this little cabin and we're like, this is actually a landing strip that our Colombian boss owns, and we're guarding it for him. And what are you two white dudes doing here? So all the cocaine traffic comes through this part of the Amazon. And we had just done what people actually have been killed for, which is, you know, like, if a couple of white guys drop in there, they assume you're like, DEA or something, right? So they're super suspicious. And they were speaking Spanish, so I was like, catching every fourth word or something. I'm like, this can't be good because of the guns. But anyway, the guy I was with, the German guy, he negotiated with them and finally they're like, okay, just give us a landing fee. So we're like, sure, but yeah. So that was, but that was the beginning of my chocolate journey.
Joe Rogan
So what part of the Amazon were you, where are you?
Dr. James Nestor
Bolivia. Which Bolivia? You think of like mountains, La Paz, but they have these lowlands which are like straight up tropical rainforest. It's called the Beni. And it's like truly lawless area, like huge swaths of jungle. Bunch of cattle ranching as well. And all the drug traffic comes through there from the Andes.
Joe Rogan
And you went in there just as a journalist?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. So this guy, this German guy, he'd been living there for 20 years and he was trying to get this cacao and he's like, yeah, I'm gonna go meet with these groups, do you want to come? And Outside had just come to me and they'd like something else I'd written and they're like, hey, we're Outside magazine. What's the freakiest thing you ever wanted to do? Well know, we'll send you there. And I had like a little kid at the time, so I was like, you know, I'm not going to be going off a 200 foot waterfall and kayak for you guys. But then this like, you know, heart of dark chocolate thing came up and I was like, I could do that. I could be like the comic guy for them. So it was this like ridiculous journey where like everything went wrong. But we did get some really good chocolate at the end of it eventually.
Joe Rogan
So what is the benefit of wild cacao?
Dr. James Nestor
It tastes really, really good. Better than the industrial varieties of cacao that most chocolate's made with. And it's just like kind of a cool story. And it can be used to support those indigenous groups so that the forest doesn't get cut down and turned into more like cattle ranch. Because cacao grows in the understory of the rainforest, so it's kind of a way to monetize the full rainforest and
Joe Rogan
keep the canopy intact.
Dr. James Nestor
Exactly.
Joe Rogan
What is the benefits of cacao? Like health wise?
Dr. James Nestor
It's right there with coffee, tons of polyphenols, a little bit of caffeine, it seems to be anti inflammatory, gives you a little boost, makes you happy. For some of the same reasons and maybe some different ones as well.
Joe Rogan
And when you say it tastes better, in what way?
Dr. James Nestor
When you try it, a lot more aromatics and less bitterness. Basically what happened with cacao is when it became a global product, the Europeans selected varieties that were high yielding. Same thing that happened with tomatoes and everything else. They were high yielding, but they lost some of the great aromatic qualities that the old Maya cacao had had. That's what gets grown all over the world. Most cacao comes from Africa now, and it's more bitter, less interesting, but way cheaper. So then there's this movement that started like 10, 15 years ago of people trying to go back to Latin America to find the ancient heirloom varieties that had this great flavor and make better chocolate than had ever been made before. Sort of the most ancient is the stuff in the Amazon, which is where cacao originates, still growing wild. So it's kind of cool if you can go back to the primordial days and make chocolate.
Joe Rogan
I mean, the example of tomatoes is a perfect example because heirloom tomatoes are sensational. They're so delicious.
Dr. James Nestor
So much better.
Joe Rogan
They're so much better. And then you have one of those bullshit McDonald's tomatoes that looks like a piece of paper.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Is that cacao? That's what it looks like, yeah.
Dr. James Nestor
So it's these pods that you. And you open up the pod. It's kind of like the size of like a little Nerf football or something.
Joe Rogan
Oh, wow. I had no idea.
Dr. James Nestor
And so chocolate is made from the seeds inside. You gotta ferment them and then roast them, and then you grind them into chocolate.
Joe Rogan
Where can one get heirloom chocolate made from this ancient cacao? Is there a company?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. So the place I send people is Caputos, which is an online site. They're like the main importer of specialty chocolate. There they are.
Joe Rogan
Is that the people?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. So Caputo's has most of the great wild cacaos available on their website. It's just like retail Caputo's.
Joe Rogan
So is it caputos.com? yeah, it's from Salt Lake City.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, they've got a cool shop in Salt Lake.
Joe Rogan
Oh, interesting preserve. Bolivian rainforest.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Ritual chocolate. Yeah. I've heard of people like ritual cacao ceremonies. I'm like, what are you doing?
Dr. James Nestor
So that. What are you doing that? It's. That's a gringo thing. Everyone thinks it goes back to some, like. We're referencing some ancient Maya ceremony.
Joe Rogan
Of course it is.
Dr. James Nestor
It was a white dude in Guatemala. Yeah, there you go.
Joe Rogan
Look at these people.
Dr. James Nestor
It's kind of like ayahuasca with training wheels.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, they do cacao. But, like, what can come out of a ritual where you take cacao?
Dr. James Nestor
I mean, you know, same thing that can come out of ritual where you do anything else. Like, you're focusing, you know, and Some mindfulness. You get a little, you know, you get a little boost from the cacao, but not much. Yeah, it's more about the ritual or.
Joe Rogan
Why is cacao. What is a cacao ceremony? Why are they suddenly showing up all over la? Yeah, you can answer that one on your own.
Dr. James Nestor
So, I mean, Jamie, if you can call up Keith's cacao. There's this guy named Keith. I think he died recently. He's like the classic gringo guru with a big white beard who would have people in Guatemala. And he's just invented this cacao ceremony thing. White people. But he's.
Joe Rogan
Damn it, white people.
Dr. James Nestor
And then everyone else sort of took it from him. There he is.
Joe Rogan
Well, he looks like the type of guy. Look at him. Big old fucking dirty pot of cacao.
Jamie
Dunk it in a couple.
Dr. James Nestor
So he started.
Joe Rogan
Okay. Poor Keith. These silly people. So. But there's, like, antioxidants in it. Like, there's other.
Dr. James Nestor
A ton. Yeah, it's good for you. It's totally good for you. Yeah, it, you know, gets your heart beating a little faster. There's some happy drugs in there. It's got a tiny bit of cannabinoids in it, and it tastes great. So, you know, what's not to like?
Joe Rogan
Anything else? Any other foods or substances or different things that you found out that were beneficial.
Dr. James Nestor
Well, how do you feel about oysters? I wrote a book about oysters, too.
Joe Rogan
I eat them all the time.
Dr. James Nestor
Are you a fan?
Joe Rogan
I like them. Are they okay?
Dr. James Nestor
I mean, they're great, but. There's no but. They're great. But I think. I think we haven't figured out why you're eating like a little living being. So I think there's some Qi factor there where the reason people get so excited and feel so good when they eat oysters, it's not because of the nutrients. It's like there's something else that's in there.
Joe Rogan
Well, isn't there zinc in oysters?
Dr. James Nestor
There's definitely zinc.
Joe Rogan
And they're supposed to have an aphrodisiac effect, right?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. So I think that aphrodisiac thing is it's more about the chi, like this living force that you're ingesting than the.
Joe Rogan
This sounds like hippie talks.
Dr. James Nestor
It does sound a little, you know, like cheese gonna get justified scientifically at some point.
Joe Rogan
You think?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
So you think you're getting what's interesting. There's another friend of mine, made an argument for vegans to eat shellfish. He said, like, if you're eating clams, and oysters, they. They're so primitive. They're more primitive than plants. He said there's more evidence that plants are conscious than there is that these shellfish are conscious.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, I mean, I think. Yeah, plants are pretty damn smart, so.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, weirdly so.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
And mussels and clams and oysters, they're not. They're sort of alive, but they don't feel pain, and they just move. And because they move, they open and close. We've decided that they're animals.
Dr. James Nestor
And with oysters, that's literally the only thing they can do.
Joe Rogan
Yeah.
Dr. James Nestor
The clams at least can.
Joe Rogan
You know, they get the tongue.
Dr. James Nestor
And oysters, they're stuck. They just open and close. There's not a whole lot going on there for sure.
Joe Rogan
Right. But healthy for you.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Unless you get a bad batch and then you die.
Dr. James Nestor
They are definitely a source of food poisoning.
Joe Rogan
Yeah, I've heard people dying.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. Yeah. They kill a few people every year.
Joe Rogan
You know, it's interesting. My wife got food poisoning from oysters once when we were on vacation, we were in Hawaii, and she ate oysters, and somehow or another she got it and I didn't. But then my daughter, who didn't eat oysters, also got the food poisoning, because food poisoning apparently can spread through the air.
Dr. James Nestor
Interesting.
Joe Rogan
And so it's contagious.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, I guess if you're, like, ralphing hard enough, you're flowing it through the air, I guess.
Joe Rogan
But it was really weird. And that's how we found out that food. Food poisoning is contagious. And that's one of the reasons why they isolate people when they're on boats when they have food poisoning.
Jamie
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Because those people could actually spread whatever that is through the air. Fucking weird.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Yeah. But that.
Sponsor Voice
I do.
Joe Rogan
I do love oysters, but I do get nervous when I eat them because every now and then you hear like, houston, man dies from food poison.
Dr. James Nestor
Cold water. Cold water is.
Joe Rogan
Food poisoning itself is not directly contagious, as it refers to an illness caused by eating or drinking contaminated food. However, the specific viruses or bacteria responsible for the contamination are highly contagious and can easily spread from person to person through poor hygiene or shared surfaces. So it's contagious. So the viruses that come from food poisoning are contagious. It's not like, through the air. Oh, so surface contact. Is that what it is?
Jamie
Is.
Joe Rogan
Oh, I see. So coughing and stuff injecting.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
And so you may be interested, the airborne confusion, the confused show more confuse food poisoning with highly contagious stomach bugs like Norovirus, where the viruses are not airborne, they're highly contagious. Can spread through the air in tiny droplets. When someone vomits, there it is. Leading to contaminated surfaces or breathing in aerosol particles. So that's what it is. It's the coughs.
Jamie
Yeah.
Joe Rogan
Okay. I think we covered it. You think?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, I think you're gonna get a lot of interesting responses.
Joe Rogan
Guess what? I don't read them. So good luck to all those haters shouting into the void. I've long suspected that sun exposure is probably good for you. And then it's really just a matter of like how much and mitigating the damage that you could get if you get burnt.
Dr. James Nestor
Turns out you're right.
Joe Rogan
Yeah. It just doesn't make sense that your body produces vitamin D through it. It makes you feel so good. And yet somehow another is bad. I think it's like many things very nuanced. And so I'm really happy that you did so much work on it.
Dr. James Nestor
Thanks.
Joe Rogan
And I'm happy you rode the storm too.
Dr. James Nestor
Well, the storm's just coming, I'm sure.
Joe Rogan
Especially after this show. But thank you very much. And tell everybody where your book is and how they can get it.
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah. So whatever their favorite online place. In Defense of Sunlight, Amazon. Anywhere else.
Joe Rogan
And did you do an audio version of it?
Dr. James Nestor
Yeah, they let me read it.
Joe Rogan
Yes.
Dr. James Nestor
We'll see if that was good news or not.
Sponsor Voice
Nice.
Joe Rogan
I love it when someone reads their own book. It's very important, I think.
Dr. James Nestor
Me too.
Joe Rogan
Yeah. All right, well, thank you very much.
Sponsor Voice
This episode is brought to you by the Farmer's dog. Here's a fun fact. Research shows that dogs who maintain a healthy weight can live up to two and a half years longer on average
Joe Rogan
than dogs who are overweight. Isn't that wild and also kind of obvious at the same time?
Sponsor Voice
So why is feeding vague scoops of ultra processed kibble still the status quo? For most dog owners, healthy alternatives exist. And trust me, I know. I buy one. The farmer's dog.
Joe Rogan
I use it for both my dogs.
Sponsor Voice
They love it. They eat it up quick. It smells good to them. It smells good to me. It's human grade food. The farmer's dog makes fresh food for dogs.
Joe Rogan
And my dogs love it.
Sponsor Voice
Their recipes are made with real meat and fresh vegetables that are gently cooked to retain vital nutrients.
Joe Rogan
They also portion out the meals to your dog's nutritional needs needs, which helps
Sponsor Voice
avoid overfeeding and makes weight management easier. And isn't getting more time with our four legged best friends something every dog owner wants the answer to that is yes, obviously. So try the Farmer's dog today and get 50 off your first box of fresh, healthy food. Plus get free shipping. Just go to the farmersdog.com rogan this
Joe Rogan
offer is for new customers only.
The Joe Rogan Experience #2516 – Rowan Jacobsen
June 18, 2026
In this episode, Joe Rogan welcomes science journalist and author Rowan Jacobsen to discuss his latest book, In Defense of Sunlight. The central theme revolves around the complexities of sun exposure—balancing its risks, such as skin cancer, against its myriad health benefits, including vitamin D production, mood elevation, and improved cardiovascular health. The conversation challenges mainstream dermatology advice, explores societal attitudes and scientific politics, and delves into related topics such as sunscreen safety, genetics, skin tone, and even the science behind foods like oysters and chocolate.
Traditional Messaging vs. Actual Science
Physiological Effects
Risks: Skin Cancer Nuances
Vitamin D Genesis
Supplements vs. Sun
Synergy with Other Nutrients
Skin Tone as a Key Factor
Melanotan and Artificial Tanning
Traditional vs. Next-Gen Sunscreens
Window Glass and UVA
Pushback from Dermatology Establishment
Interdisciplinary Challenges
Adding a New Dimension to Health: Light
Practical Summation
Moderation and Personalization:
Sun exposure is health-promoting for most, particularly outside the "burn" zone; recommendations should be tailored to skin type and genetics.
Institutional Inertia:
Medical guidelines often lag behind emerging data; interdisciplinary, holistic perspectives are needed.
Supplements Aren’t Panaceas:
Vitamin D pills may help those truly deficient but do not replicate the benefits of natural sunlight.
Rethink Sunscreen:
Legacy chemical sunscreens are problematic; advances will improve safety and efficacy.
Beyond Sunlight:
Light exposure—including red light therapies—has profound, underappreciated effects on health.
Enjoy Life’s Pleasures (Informed):
Coffee, chocolate, oysters—all discussed as not only safe but potentially beneficial, especially when quality and context are prioritized.
Final Words
Jacobsen’s work, discussed in tandem with Rogan’s irreverent style, underscores the need to challenge dogma, embrace nuance, and consider evolution, environment, and individuality in all health behaviors—especially when it comes to something as fundamental as sunlight.
“You don’t need a lot… just a little bit of sun exposure doesn’t seem like a crazy recommendation.” — Rowan Jacobsen (101:26)