What to know after Day 1 of the Kelsey Fitzsimmons trial

Summary

Summary of "What to Know After Day 1 of the Kelsey Fitzsimmons Trial"

Podcast: The Kelsey Fitzsimmons Trial: Commonwealth Confidential
Host: NBC10 Boston
Date: March 23, 2026
Episode Theme:
This episode delivers a comprehensive recap and legal analysis of Day 1 in the Kelsey Fitzsimmons assault trial. Fitzsimmons, a former North Andover police officer, is facing charges after being shot by a colleague during a confrontation in her own home as officers were serving her a restraining order. The show breaks down opening statements, key testimonies, evolving narratives from prosecution and defense, and the strategic choice of a bench trial.

---

Main Topics and Key Discussion Points

1. Case Background and Stakes

• Incident Overview: Fitzsimmons is charged with assault with a dangerous weapon (a firearm) after a confrontation with North Andover police colleagues. The incident involved the serving of a restraining order and led to her being shot in her own bedroom.
• Consequences: If convicted, Fitzsimmons faces up to 5 years in prison.
• Timeline Recap:
  • Sworn in as an officer: May 2024.
  • Became engaged; child born early 2025.
  • Incident occurred June 30, 2025.
  • Fitzsimmons jailed, later released on bail, preparing for trial.
    (04:45–05:29)

---

2. Opening Statements & Competing Narratives

• Prosecution's Case:
  • Argues Fitzsimmons pointed a gun at Officer Patrick Noonan and pulled the trigger; gun misfired.
  • “The credible evidence in this case, your honor, will prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty.” — Legal Analyst Michael Coyne (01:45)
• Defense's Case:
  • Claims Fitzsimmons was suicidal, pointed gun at herself, not at officers; paints shooting officer as untruthful.
  • “You need to adjust the narrative to save yourself.” — Attorney Timothy Bradle (01:56)

Notable Moment

• Officer Patrick Noonan’s dramatic testimony:
  • “She reappeared with a gun and pointed it right at me and pulled the trigger.” (02:07)
  • “She had the drop on me and I was yelling at her, don’t do it, don’t do it.” (12:02–12:10)

---

3. Key Testimony Highlights

• Officer Patrick Noonan:
  • Firsthand description of feeling threatened.
  • Described having “the drop” put on him and firing in response.
  • “After she successfully got around in the chamber, her right arm started to come up and I shot twice in rapid succession.” (12:13–12:21)
• Former Fiancé Justin Elaine:
  • In court for custody handover. On leave from fire department for drug policy violations.
  • Witnessed the situation escalate when gunfire erupted and fled basement.
• Officer Sean Daly (Prosecution witness):
  • Recounted Fitzsimmons repeatedly saying, “I’m sorry and I want to die.” (03:54, 10:05)
  • Testimony bolsters defense assertions of Fitzsimmons’ suicidal state.

---

4. Trial Structure – Bench Trial Decision

• No Jury Present:
  • Strategic choice to have a judge, not a jury, decide the outcome.
  • Analyst Perspective:
    • “This judge has shown fairness to both sides... and has a background as a criminal defense attorney.”
    • “Criminal defense lawyers who are now judges have a better chance at putting not and guilty in the same sentence.”
      — Legal Analyst Michael Coyne (05:40–06:34)
  • Judges, while human, are seen as more focused on facts and law, less swayed by emotion than a jury might be.
    — Attorney Margo Lindauer (06:50–07:14)

---

5. Legal Analysis & Trial Tactics

• Changing Legal Strategy:
  • Prosecution must prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt irrespective of whether Fitzsimmons testifies.
  • Defense expected to highlight Fitzsimmons' mental state and postpartum depression.
  • “With a jury, you can rely on the emotions of everyday people… with a judge, you change your tactic… because it is the classic he said, she said. The problem for the government is she doesn’t have to testify at all.”
    — Legal Analyst Michael Coyne (08:28–09:31)

Memorable Quote:

• “She made a decision for herself, and it’s a decision that takes your breath away. It’s a young mother who just minutes before they got there, thought she had everything going for her. She decides to end her life with her firearm in her bedroom.”
  — Defense Attorney Timothy Bradle (09:44–10:01)

Analysis of Mental Health Element:

• Multiple references to postpartum depression.
• Defense and panel question why no mental health professionals were present during the restraining order service.
• “The actual serving of the restraining order is a very dangerous time... even more so when there's a removal of custody.”
  — Attorney Margo Lindauer (13:54–14:03)

---

6. Police Response Critique

• Lack of Procedures:
  • Absence of a mental health professional during the serving of a restraining order.
  • Questions about why the ex-fiancé was allowed inside the home during the high-stress situation.
  • No body camera footage, which is criticized as an investigative gap.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments (with Timestamps)

• “She reappeared with a gun and pointed it right at me and pulled the trigger.”
  — Officer Patrick Noonan (02:07)

• “She kept saying, I’m sorry and I want to die.”
  — Attorney Timothy Bradle quoting Fitzsimmons (03:54, 10:05)

• “It is the classic he said, she said. The problem here is, though, from the government standpoint is in this case, she doesn’t have to testify at all.”
  — Legal Analyst Michael Coyne (08:44)

• “If there are bad facts, you want to be the one to get them out...The facts are the facts. And multiple people testify to that, that she said, I want to die, I want to die.”
  — Attorney Margo Lindauer (11:13)

---

Key Segments by Timestamp

| Time | Segment Summary | Key Points/Quotes | |-----------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------------|-------------------------------------------------------------------------| | 01:28–02:23 | Case introduction/Charges | “Kelsey Fitzsimmons goes on trial… faces up to 5 years in prison.” | | 02:51–04:45 | Courtroom recap, initial testimony from key witnesses and ex-fiancé | Details on incident, custody removal, officers’ actions | | 05:29–07:14 | Trial strategy discussion: bench trial choice | “This judge has shown a fairness…” | | 09:44–10:21 | Defense framing: Fitzsimmons’ mental state and suicidal intent | “She made a decision for herself…” | | 12:02–12:21 | Noonan’s dramatic testimony on the shooting | “I screamed her name… I shot twice in rapid succession.” | | 13:33–14:03 | Debate on police procedures/mental health interventions | “This was not handled well… serving of the restraining order is dangerous.” | | 14:32–15:00 | Show wrap-up and preview of next episode | Preview: police response, lack of body cams, upcoming expert analysis |

---

Panel & Legal Expert Analysis

• Michael Coyne (Chief Legal Analyst): Provides context on judicial strategy, reasonable doubt, burden of proof, and critiques of procedure.
• Margo Lindauer (Attorney): Focus on emotional dynamics, mental health issues, and process flaws during the intervention.
• Mary Marcos (Court Reporter): On-site details from the courthouse and witness interactions.

---

Conclusion

The first day of Commonwealth v. Kelsey Fitzsimmons revolves around dueling narratives: was Fitzsimmons attempting to harm a fellow officer, or was it a suicide attempt driven by tragedy and postpartum depression? Dramatic testimony from officers and the ex-fiancé shaped both sides, while legal experts critiqued tactical choices and response procedures. The episode underscores a theme of systemic gaps—lack of mental health intervention and body camera footage—as the bench trial proceeds toward a judge’s verdict.

Stay tuned for deeper dives into police protocol and body camera policy in the next episode, featuring additional expert perspectives.

Transcript

[Narrator/Announcer]

Your new home is now ready. Dr. Horton, America's builder has new homes that are ready today. With new construction communities throughout the puget sound and central Washington areas and more coming. Dr. Horton has the right home for you at Dr. Horton. We're still building with more construction, more communities and more homes available every day. Tap your screen now or visit drhorton.com to find your new home now ready. Dr. Horton, America's builder, an equal housing opportunity builder. Lifelock. How can I help?

[Reporter/Host]

The IRS said I filed my return, but I haven't.

[Narrator/Announcer]

One in four tax paying Americans has paid the price of identity fraud.

[Reporter/Host]

What do I do?

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

My refund though.

[Reporter/Host]

I'm freaking out.

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

Don't worry.

[Narrator/Announcer]

I can fix this. Lifelock fixes identity theft guaranteed and gets your money back with up to $3 million in coverage.

[Reporter/Host]

I'm so relieved.

[Narrator/Announcer]

No problem. I'll be with you every step of the way. One in four was a fraud. Fraud paying American. Not anymore. Save up to 40% your first year. Visit lifelock.com Special offer terms apply Ryan Reynolds here from mint mobile. I don't know if you knew this, but anyone can get the same premium wireless for 15amonth plan that I've been enjoying. It's not just for celebrities. So do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to mint mobile today. I'm told it's super easy to do.

[Reporter/Host]

@mintmobile.com Switch upfront payment of $45 for

[Reporter Mary Marcos]

3 month plan equivalent to 15 per

[Reporter/Host]

month required int rate first 3 months only then full price plan options available. Taxes and fees, extra fee.

[Narrator/Announcer]

Full [e-mail] Tonight Kelsey Fitzsimmons goes on trial.

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

We are now set to the bar to be tried before the honorable justice Jeff Carr.

[Narrator/Announcer]

The prosecution says she pointed a gun at a fellow north andover police officer.

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

The credible evidence in this case, your honor, will prove beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant is guilty.

[Narrator/Announcer]

But the defense alleges the colleague who shot her is lying.

[Attorney Timothy Bradle]

And when you do that, you quickly realize, your honor, that you need to adjust the narrative to save yourself.

[Narrator/Announcer]

That officer takes the stand to give his side of the story.

[Officer Patrick Noonan]

She reappeared with a gun and pointed it right at me and pulled the trigger.

[Narrator/Announcer]

Our legal experts are live in studio to recap. Day one Commonwealth confidential. The Kelsey Fitzsimmons trial starts right now.

[Host/Anchor]

Welcome to Commonwealth confidential. Day one of the Kelsey Fitzsimmons Simmons trial saw dramatic testimony from the officer who shot her.

[Reporter/Host]

We also got a look at how this case will play out. Fitzsimmons is Charged with assault with a dangerous weapon following last year's incident. If convicted, she faces up to five years in prison.

[Host/Anchor]

With opening statements today, both sides began making their case to the judge. No jury in this case.

[Reporter/Host]

Also taking the stand was her former fiance. Our Mary Marcos has the latest from Lawrence Superior Court.

[Reporter Mary Marcos]

Today we learned a trip to Maine leading up to the shooting took a sudden turn.

[Attorney Margo Lindauer]

It was a Jack and Jill bachelor party.

[Attorney Timothy Bradle]

Yes.

[Reporter/Host]

And did the week end early? Yes, it did.

[Reporter Mary Marcos]

The next day, three North Andover officers went to serve Kelsey Fitzsimmons a restraining order.

[Attorney Timothy Bradle]

Justin A. Told us that he had concerns that she would potentially harm the baby.

[Reporter Mary Marcos]

U.S. lt. Sean Daly says he quickly called Fitzsimmons ex fiance Justin Elaine to come pick up their four month old. And today we learned why. He's now on leave from the fire department.

[Attorney Timothy Bradle]

You have been caught on video many, many times using drugs that are in violation of your department apartment and the town policy, correct?

[Reporter/Host]

Yes, sir.

[Reporter Mary Marcos]

Clips show police holding the baby before Elaine and his sister get there and take him out of the house. Then Elaine goes into the basement for a suitcase. And when gunfire erupts, he bolts outside.

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

I heard an officer scream out, stop. Don't do it. At that point, I.

[Narrator/Announcer]

What?

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

I believe I heard several gunshots ring out and I heard Kelsey's mother screaming.

[Reporter Mary Marcos]

Officers rush in with medical gear and carry Fitzpatrick Simmons out on a stretcher.

[Attorney Timothy Bradle]

She kept saying, I'm sorry and I want to die.

[Reporter Mary Marcos]

Inside the upstairs bedroom is where the two narratives split. Prosecutors say Fitzsimmons grabbed her service weapon, pointed it at Officer Patrick Noonan and pulled the trigger. But the gun didn't fire.

[Officer Patrick Noonan]

So when she came around the frame here, she. She came up and click. I screamed her name. I was completely shocked. She had the drop on me.

[Reporter Mary Marcos]

The defense argues she never aimed at anyone. She pointed the gun at herself.

[Attorney Timothy Bradle]

He took away her baby. He likely cost her her career. He publicly betrayed her as her fiance. He walked away from their impending marriage.

[Reporter Mary Marcos]

The judge will ultimately decide Fitzsimmons fate in this case. But we will be back here tomorrow to bring you what happens on day two. Reporting in Lawrence, Mary Marcos, NBC 10 Boston.

[Reporter/Host]

Let's get you up to speed on how we got here. Fitzsimmons was sworn in as North Andover police officer in May 2024 SW she became engaged to Justin alliance that fall. Their son was born in early 2025. Now, months later, on June 30, she was shot at her home. She was hospitalized and released from custody, but days later, after a judge ruled that she could not comply with court ordered alcohol testing. She was sent back to jail. She spent more than 100 days behind bars until being released from custody. She has been out on bail ever since, preparing for trial. So now let's bring in our panel. We're joined by NBC 10 Boston Chief Legal analyst Michael Coyne, as well as attorney Margo Lindauer. Okay, my fellow friends, day one. And we now know that they have chosen a bench trial rather than have a jury. We're going to talk about that with both of you. Michael, can we start with you? Why do you think they made the decision and is it a good one?

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

Well, time will tell if it's a good one, first of all. So we'll all Monday morning quarterback, depending on how it comes out. But is it a good one on the face of it? I think the answer is yes, he is. This judge has shown a fairness to both sides as the cases move forward. He also has a history both as a prosecutor for some period of time, but more importantly to the defense, a criminal defense attorney for many years. You know, we lawyers like that as you're defending your case, because criminal defense lawyers who are now judges have a better chance at putting not and guilty in the same sentence. And so I think they feel comfortable that he will understand what reasonable doubt means to a greater extent than a jury. And also because of his background, he will have sympathies to both sides. But especially I think they're hoping it will lean to the defendant.

[Reporter/Host]

Can you, Margo, just assume that a judge will strictly stick to the law and not have the emotions that a jury would have? Because it is that's what this case really is about underneath it all, the concurrent emotions on both sides that led to this.

[Attorney Margo Lindauer]

Well, a judge, like everyone else, is a human. However, judges have a lot more experience and to Michael's point, especially a judge who's had actual litigation practice, both from the prosecutorial side and the defense side. And so, yes, I think at this point it does seem like this trial is going to go much quicker with a judge and the judge is going to be able to zero in on the charge in question.

[Host/Anchor]

Let's talk about opening statements. The prosecution highlighted the background of Patrick Noonan, the officer who shot Fitzsimmons. Let's hear some of that.

[Officer Patrick Noonan]

He knew Pat had the experience, the

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

temperament and was cool, calm and collective no matter what happened.

[Host/Anchor]

Margo, as we've been talking about, there's no jury to sway here. But as I listen to the prosecution sort of build up the credibility of this Witness. It's a lot like what you would see in a jury trial. So ultimately, do these lawyers have to advance their case in the same way as if they were trying to convince 12 people, as if they're trying to convince one?

[Attorney Margo Lindauer]

So, no, I think that the buildup is going to be much shorter. And we've seen that play out today. They went through many, many witnesses with backgrounds on each of them, and that would not go as quickly if there were a jury. However, they are setting the stage, and the prosecution is going to be proving, is trying to prove that this officer in question had a ton of experience and had the reasonable response that someone who had had that experience with weapons did. However, of course, the defense is going to say something different.

[Host/Anchor]

Well, let me ask in a different way to you, Michael, because this is ultimately a he said, she said case. And with a jury, you can rely on the emotions of everyday people in a way that perhaps you can't with a judge. So do you have to change your tactic because of it?

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

You're going to change your tactic somewhat, of course, because you are playing to a single audience here. And the fact is, is that it is the classic he said, she said. The problem here is, though, from the government standpoint is in this case, she doesn't have to testify at all. They have the burden of proof, and they're the ones that are going to have to satisfy the charges beyond a reasonable doubt. So we may not hear her story in full other than as it comes out on cross examination of these witnesses. My expectation is based on what I heard today from attorney Bradle and the eliciting of the testimony is that at least presently, she anticipates testifying and telling her story so that the judge can weigh it very carefully as to whether there is, in fact, reasonable doubt.

[Reporter/Host]

Let's talk more about the defense. They're stressing that Fitzsimmons was suicidal and was trying to take her own life. Here's a snippet of what attorney Timothy Bradle said in his opening statement, followed up with testimony from the first witness.

[Attorney Timothy Bradle]

She made a decision for herself, and it's a decision that takes your breath away. It's a young mother who just minutes before they got there, thought she had everything going for her. She decides to end her life with her firearm in her bedroom.

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

When I got into the room, when

[Host/Anchor]

she's on the ground.

[Attorney Timothy Bradle]

Yes.

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

Yeah.

[Attorney Timothy Bradle]

She. She kept saying, I'm sorry and I want to die.

[Reporter/Host]

Okay. That was North Andover officer Sean Daly, a witness for the prosecution. So between what Officer Daley said, and the fact in opening they're going to stress the defense that she was suicidal, have we already started to chip away at the prosecution?

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

I think without a doubt. I mean, that was the government's first witness. And in fact, he helped to lay an essential part of this case that she was anxious to die. That would tend to support the defense that she didn't point the gun at anyone other than herself. So, yeah, I think we've already seen the start of what could potentially be reasonable doubt. You know, there's plenty more left of this case, but at least right now, we have at least some evidence that she was a danger to herself. The question is, was she a danger to Officer Noonan as well?

[Host/Anchor]

Margo, on that testimony in particular, where the prosecution's witness, Lieutenant says, I heard her say I want to die. Do you expect that the prosecutor knew that was going to be his answer and wanted to get it out in his direct questioning, or was it a surprise?

[Attorney Margo Lindauer]

Yes. You think, you would think that he would know and if there are bad facts, you want to be the one to get them out. Right. So he wants to get ahead of that and say that he's not running from that and he's not trying to kind of massage the facts. The facts are the facts. And multiple people testify to that, that she said, I want to die, I want to die. But I do think, to Michael's point, that it is already chipping away and also bringing up a very common issue, which is postpartum depression. And we know that that is going to be something that comes out in one way or another in the defense's presentation of the case.

[Reporter/Host]

I will say they did even mention why wasn't there a mental health counselor when they went and brought the affidavit.

[Host/Anchor]

Yeah, we should talk more about that. Officer Noonan was still on the stand when the day ended. Some of his testimony was dramatic.

[Officer Patrick Noonan]

I screamed her name. I was completely shocked. She had the drop on me and I was yelling at her, don't do it, don't do it.

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

And then what happened?

[Attorney Timothy Bradle]

She.

[Officer Patrick Noonan]

After she successfully got around in the chamber, her right arm started to come up and I shot twice in rapid succession.

[Host/Anchor]

So Noonan was one of the three officers who responded to serve the restraining order on FitzSimmons. And as JC mentioned, there was no mental health professional with that team of officers that went in. We know from Lieutenant Daley's testimony they do have social workers who are part of the team. So I guess a two part question here. Michael should they have brought somebody with them who could handle the mental health aspect of this. And in the eyes of the law, does it matter?

[Legal Analyst Michael Coyne]

The latter point is probably not. Now, it may help again to create reasonable doubt, but with respect to the first part, I do think that they should have handled this situation far differently. Now I'm not in law enforcement. I'm looking at it from a. A lawyer and a father's perspective, actually, is that. And it may be sexist to say, shouldn't one of the female police officers also have been present who she might have had a relationship with and might have been able to de. Escalate the situation a little better? I think, unfortunately, that yes, it could have been handled far better. And there has to be some accountability for that as well as the lack of body cameras.

[Reporter/Host]

What about the fact that they let the ex fiance into the house during those tense moments? Here he was. This was my interpretation that he's saying, I feel threatened. I'm putting out this restraining order. Please help me. And the officers come to take the baby and then say, come on in the house and get all the stuff to me. If I was, if I was scared of someone, I'm not going in the house, nor would I want people to invite me in in those moments.

[Attorney Margo Lindauer]

Absolutely. That was very, very strange. And what we know when the data proves this is that the actual serving of the restraining order is a very dangerous time.

[Host/Anchor]

Sure.

[Attorney Margo Lindauer]

Right. Because emotions are heightened and even more so when there's a removal of custody, and even more so when a small child is removed from the custody of their mother. So to Michael's point, this was not handled well. And because not only is it law enforcement, on law enforcement, we know that there are multiple guns in the home. Everyone knows each other. Right. These are her colleagues, and then it's his colleagues who remove her from her home.

[Reporter/Host]

Right, Right. No, excellent point.

[Host/Anchor]

That's the end of day one. Michael, Margo, thank you very much. It was a lot to digest after one day of this trial.

[Reporter/Host]

We got three, four people on the stand.

[Host/Anchor]

All right, be sure to tune in every weeknight of the trial at seven for a full recap of the day's testimony. We'll have legal analysis from our team of experts.

[Reporter/Host]

Tomorrow night. We delve deeper into the police response as well as the lack of body cameras. This case just another example of how important that technology is to investigations. Former State Trooper Todd McGee will be joining us to break it all down.

[Host/Anchor]

And of course, stay with us for continuing coverage. You can watch the Entire trial on NBC. Ten's YouTube channel. Or you can catch it all on our sister station necn. And if you have any questions, email them to commonwealth.confidentialbcuni.com we may end up in answering your questions right here on the air.

[Open Door Advertiser]

Cash now, more later from Open Door gives you cash up front for your home, plus all the profit later. That's no chaos now. No cash left behind later. Skip the showings now. Pocket extra profit later. This is so simple now. This is so awesome. Later. Or sell fast now and pop the champagne later. Cash now, more later. Now available nationwide. Start your [e-mail] radio profits calculated after fees and costs. Eligibility and offer price may vary.