The Knife: A True Crime Podcast
Episode: Off Record: Deadly Greed
Date: February 5, 2026
Hosts: Hannah Smith & Patia Eaton
Episode Overview
In “Off Record: Deadly Greed,” Hannah and Patia dive into the true story of a shocking and tragic double crime set in Ontario, Canada: murder, a victim on the run, and a botched getaway—all fueled by reckless ambition and a shocking lack of accountability. Through unpacking the rise and fall of Oliver Karafa and Lucy Lee, the hosts examine privilege, greed, and the ripple effects of violence. The episode shines a light on how both perpetrators’ disregard for consequence escalated from youthful irresponsibility to deadly crime, resulting in lifelong prison sentences.
Key Discussion Points & Timeline
Introductions & Case Origins
[02:12-03:17]
- Patia teases a story involving “murder, and then they flee the country.”
- The case takes place in North York, Ontario, beginning in 2008 with high school/prep school acquaintances, Oliver Karafa and Lucy Lee.
Profile of Oliver Karafa
[03:40–05:14]
- Oliver, originally from Slovakia, grows up wealthy, is left living independently with his sisters from age 16 when his parents move back to Slovakia.
- He quickly adopts a “fast and loose” lifestyle: “Credit cards and free reign. It was a free for all.” – Patia ([04:46])
[05:14–07:35]
- In 2012, at 19, Oliver kills his friend David in a drunk driving incident—blood alcohol nearly four times the legal limit. David, a personal trainer who befriended Oliver working at the gym, is killed instantly.
- “He looks like a child… I think he was 19 at the time.” – Hannah ([07:06])
[07:43–11:24]
- Oliver’s remorse appears superficial; quickly more worried about jail than his friend’s death.
- sentenced to five years for impaired driving causing death, banned from driving for 15 years, paroled after only three years.
- Both hosts remark that his lenient sentence and behavior reinforce the idea he faces “no real consequences.”
Profile of Lucy Lee
[15:52–17:00]
- Lucy is described as “introverted and studious,” comes from a wealthy family, also followed a privileged, pressure-free path after school.
- Later receives a $5,000/month allowance from her mother as she experiments with social media and TikTok fame alongside her two triplet sisters.
Failed Ambitions & Reconnection
[12:42–15:52]
- Post-prison, Oliver leads a string of failed businesses—restaurant, dropshipping, and even a supposed subscription insulin service—mostly funded by outside investors.
- “He’s hellbent on making a lot of money really quick.” – Patia ([15:51])
[15:52–18:59]
- Oliver reconnects with Lucy Lee in 2018; both are drawn by a taste for wealth, social media attention, and fast living.
- They move in together after just two dates.
Marriage of Convenience and the COVID-Era Scam
[22:27–23:43]
- To circumvent COVID travel restrictions, they marry via Zoom at the airport.
[24:00–27:00]
- In Europe, Oliver schemes to profit from the pandemic by securing PPE deals. He meets Tyler Pratt, an alleged drug dealer, who invests $470,000.
- Tyler wants his money back as Oliver’s business once again falters.
Escalation: The Murder Plot
[27:27–33:13]
- Facing pressure from Tyler to repay, Oliver and Lucy lure Tyler (and his pregnant girlfriend Jordan Romano) to a fake business meeting at a remote warehouse, under the pretense of a future marijuana grow-op.
- Oliver shoots both Tyler and Jordan (five shots at Tyler, three at Jordan), takes their cash and phones, drags Jordan from a car, and abandons both at the scene.
- Jordan, critically wounded, manages to flag down a motorist and survives; her unborn child does not.
Notable Moment:
- “If you shoot a gun at someone multiple times, your intention is to kill them.” – Hannah ([43:31])
Attempted Escape & Apprehension
[33:14–37:11]
- Oliver and Lucy hurriedly dump evidence, use pre-purchased fake IDs, and flee Canada, eventually reaching Slovakia and then Hungary.
- Authorities quickly identify them; they’re apprehended in Budapest in June 2021, months after the crime.
Legal Proceedings and Aftermath
[37:51–44:23]
- Lucy is extradited without contest, Oliver fights extradition.
- Lucy tries to claim Tyler was dangerous and that the murders were not premeditated. Her story is inconsistent and not believed.
- Both attempt to blame Tyler at trial; their stories diverge but neither is seen as credible.
[44:23–45:46]
- In May 2024, both are sentenced to life in prison, not eligible for parole for 25 years.
- Jordan, survivor of the shooting, testifies powerfully at trial and receives a civil judgment after her ordeal.
Notable Quote:
- “On this night, [Jordan] lost both Tyler and their baby.” – Patia ([42:30])
- “It’s so gross. The crime seems so clearly premeditated, so horrible to cover up what was probably already an illegal operation of an investment fraud." – Hannah ([45:01])
Reflections & Ripple Effects
[46:03–48:27]
- Both hosts reflect on how neither Oliver nor Lucy ever truly experienced consequences until this final crime.
- Jordan’s survival and testimony become pivotal for justice.
Notable Quote:
- “They both have this same affliction, which is inflated self-intelligence or a view of themselves. And clearly they're not good together. Like, talk about toxic relationship.” – Hannah ([47:31])
Notable Quotes and Memorable Moments
- “Credit cards and free reign. It was a free for all.” – Patia ([04:46])
- “You need a burner phone, stupid. You need two burner phones.” – Patia, on their botched cover-up ([34:50])
- “I do not drive my husband. I am there to relax and give feedback.” – Patia, humorously drawing boundaries ([20:02])
- “They go around the city dumping any evidence… Lucy had a wig on at some point, like a blonde wig.” – Patia ([33:46])
- “It doesn’t seem like even today, Oliver [and] Lucy have accepted responsibility. They're both still trying to appeal.” – Patia ([46:22])
Timestamps for Key Segments
- 00:00–02:12 — Ads, episode disclaimer
- 03:00 — Story Introduction: North York, Ontario, and main characters
- 05:14–07:35 — Drunk driving death and its aftermath
- 12:42–15:52 — Failed businesses and rekindled romance
- 17:10–18:59 — Lucy’s social media persona & wealthy upbringing
- 23:43–27:00 — COVID marriage, bogus business, meeting Tyler Pratt
- 27:27–33:13 — The murder at the warehouse
- 34:15–37:11 — Escape, European hideout, and capture
- 39:22–44:23 — Legal fallout, bail, and shifting stories
- 44:23–45:46 — Sentencing and the survivors’ response
- 46:03–48:27 — Reflections on accountability and consequences
Recommendations & Closing
[48:33–59:29]
- Hannah recommends “Valley of Shadows”, a Pushkin podcast about an LA sheriff’s deputy’s mysterious disappearance, and “Heartwood” by Amity Gage, a thriller about a missing hiker.
- Patia reminisces on previous cases, the challenges of searches in the wilderness, and the importance of thorough investigations.
Episode Tone
The discussion is empathetic yet candid, as the hosts don’t shy away from criticizing systemic privilege or the calculated (if flawed) planning of the perpetrators. They use moments of humor and personal reflection to break up the heavy content and offer a solution-oriented, victim-centered perspective.
Summary Takeaways
- Privilege and a lack of consequences for youthful recklessness can, if unchecked, become lethal.
- The murder and attempted murder were driven by greed and arrogance, with the perpetrators believing they could outsmart the justice system.
- Survivor Jordan Romano’s resilience and testimony were critical to justice being served.
- Both Oliver and Lucy were ultimately sentenced to life imprisonment—closing a case whose ripple effects devastated multiple families but also saw some measure of justice and healing.
This summary is intended to cover all core content and context, preserving the conversational and empathetic tone of the original hosts, while emphasizing key details and insights of the case.