The Kill List

Summary

The Knife: A True Crime Podcast
Episode: The Kill List
Release Date: June 5, 2025
Hosts: Hannah Smith and Paisha Eaton
Produced by: Exactly Right and iHeartPodcasts

---

Introduction

In this gripping episode of The Knife: A True Crime Podcast, hosts Hannah Smith and Paisha Eaton delve into a harrowing experience shared by a woman, referred to as Susan, whose life was upended by the revelation that she was on a terrorist organization's kill list. Through Susan's first-person narrative, the episode explores the profound psychological and emotional toll of being targeted by such a sinister threat.

---

Susan's Story: The Unexpected Encounter (02:07 – 07:30)

Susan begins by painting a picture of her ordinary life. A single mother and successful business owner in the Midwest, she describes her routine: juggling work with her daughter's soccer practice, managing a manufacturing business with around 70 employees, and striving to provide a living wage for her staff.

Key Moment: The Initial Revelation

During the summer of 2016, Susan's normal day took a drastic turn when an individual, claiming to be an FBI agent, approached her at her office.

Susan: "I'm here. The FBI has a duty to inform you that we have learned that there is a Middle Eastern terrorist group that issues kill lists."
(Timestamp: 06:00)

Despite the claim, Susan immediately sensed something was amiss. The person was visibly nervous, clutching a laptop and folders, which contradicted her perception of an FBI agent's demeanor.

Verification Attempt

Suspecting foul play, Susan took a prudent step by consulting her CEO.

Susan: "I need to go talk to somebody... He doesn't seem like it. He's really nervous."
(Timestamp: 08:27)

Her CEO confirmed the authenticity of the agent, but shockingly, Susan learned that she was one of only two individuals in her state on the kill list. The agent provided no apparent reason for her inclusion, leading Susan to question:

Susan: "I am in this by myself."
(Timestamp: 13:20)

---

Law Enforcement's Response: A Mixed Bag (07:30 – 16:23)

Upon receiving the confirmation, Susan reached out to her father, who then contacted the FBI. The FBI advised Susan to inform her local sheriff's department, hoping to keep the threat confidential and manageable.

Dismal Reactions:

However, the responses she received amplified her fears rather than alleviating them.

Susan: "The sheriff's dispatch person... we spent like 20 minutes talking about my cat."
(Timestamp: 15:57)

Her partner remained unconcerned, further isolating Susan in her distress.

Introduction of the SWAT Team:

The situation escalated when a county SWAT team arrived at her home, offering tangible security but simultaneously intensifying her anxiety.

Susan: "They walked me around my yard because I have a lot of landscaping... It's so real."
(Timestamp: 18:56)

---

Escalation of the Threat: From Abstract to Concrete (16:23 – 27:43)

Susan's fear deepened as she received information about a local sympathizer involved with the terrorist group. This individual lived merely 45 minutes away, rendering the threat immediate and personal.

Real-Life Parallels:

The hosts contextualize Susan's experience by referencing real cases where individuals were targeted by terrorist sympathizers within the United States:

• 2014: Ali Muhammad Brown killed four people in retaliation for U.S. policies in the Middle East.
• 2019: Rondell Henry's thwarted attack in D.C., inspired by a 2016 terrorist act in France.

Susan's Realization:

Susan: "I was starting to be in this very weird suspended place... I was in a big vat of trauma."
(Timestamp: 26:41)

Desperate for safety, Susan temporarily relocated, where she attempted to reclaim some semblance of normalcy, albeit through distressing means.

---

Coping Mechanisms and Emotional Fallout (27:43 – 46:04)

Over approximately three weeks, Susan's life became dominated by fear and uncertainty. The constant surveillance and lack of concrete answers eroded her sense of security and well-being.

Mental Health Struggles:

Susan: "I felt so alone... I could hardly eat, I could not sleep."
(Timestamp: 24:02)

Through sleepless nights and relentless fear, Susan grappled with feelings of isolation, compounded by the dismissive attitudes of those around her.

Turning Point: Acceptance:

Ultimately, Susan reached a psychological breakthrough by choosing to no longer allow fear to dictate her life.

Susan: "I'm not gonna participate in your little terrorist shenanigans... I'm done."
(Timestamp: 45:13)

---

Discussion and Insights (46:04 – 53:57)

The hosts and Susan explore the broader implications of terrorist kill lists, highlighting their potential purpose to incite lone-wolf attacks among domestic sympathizers. Research cited by Matthew Levitt suggests these lists are strategic tools for terrorist organizations to leverage domestic support for their violent agendas.

Purpose of Kill Lists:

Paisha Eaton: "They [terrorist organizations] would love to take responsibility for an attack... in your own state."
(Timestamp: 50:23)

Real-world examples underscore the lethality of these threats, emphasizing the critical need for effective law enforcement responses and psychological support for victims like Susan.

---

Conclusion: Moving Forward (53:57 – End)

As the episode wraps up, Susan reflects on her journey from fear to acceptance. She emphasizes the importance of taking control of one's emotional response, even in the face of genuine threats.

Susan: "I live alone with my animals, and I can lay in bed and be afraid, or I cannot. And at this point, there's no way in hell I'm going to let somebody else dictate whether or not I'm laying in bed feeling afraid."
(Timestamp: 43:51)

Hosts' Reflections:

Hannah Smith and Paisha Eaton commend Susan's resilience and discuss the importance of empathetic responses from those around victims of such terrifying experiences. They highlight the psychological burden of feeling dismissed and the critical need for supportive networks.

Hannah Smith: "It's so scary to be in your home and think that someone might be actively trying to kill you."
(Timestamp: 52:03)

Susan's story serves as a poignant reminder of the unseen battles many face and the profound impact of true crime on individual lives.

---

Key Takeaways

• Psychological Impact: Being placed on a terrorist kill list can have devastating effects on one's mental health, leading to anxiety, insomnia, and feelings of isolation.

• Law Enforcement Response: The mixed reactions from law enforcement can exacerbate victims' fears, highlighting the need for better support systems.

• Purpose of Kill Lists: Terrorist organizations may use kill lists to inspire lone-wolf attacks, leveraging domestic individuals to carry out their agendas.

• Coping Mechanisms: Personal resilience and acceptance are crucial for victims to regain control over their lives amidst ongoing threats.

• Support Systems: Empathetic and understanding responses from family, friends, and authorities are essential in helping victims navigate their trauma.

---

Notable Quotes

• Susan on the Initial Encounter:
  "The FBI has a duty to inform you that we have learned that there is a Middle Eastern terrorist group that issues kill lists."
  (06:00)

• Susan on Feeling Alone:
  "I am in this by myself."
  (13:20)

• Susan on Acceptance:
  "I'm not gonna participate in your little terrorist shenanigans... I'm done."
  (45:13)

• Hannah on Fear:
  "It's so scary to be in your home and think that someone might be actively trying to kill you."
  (52:03)

---

Final Thoughts

Susan's ordeal underscores the complex interplay between genuine threats and the psychological aftermath they produce. The Knife: A True Crime Podcast not only sheds light on the mechanics of such threats but also delves deep into the human experience of living under constant fear. Through empathetic storytelling and thorough analysis, the episode invites listeners to reflect on the broader societal and psychological implications of true crime beyond the headlines.

---

Follow The Knife:

• Instagram: @theknifepodcast
• Bluesky: @theknifepodcast.bsky.social
• Email: theknifexactlyrightmedia.com

Transcript

[Paisha Eaton]

This is exactly right.

[Trey Ferro]

Pro paint days are back at Lowe's and Mylo's Pro Rewards. Members can save even more with limited time deals right now. Buy one, get one half off select HGTV Home by Sherwin Williams Primer and Ceiling Paint. Plus get free same day delivery to your job site when you order by 2pm Offer valid through 6 13. Delivery by 8pm Subject to driver availability. Additional terms apply. Ceelo's.com SameDayDelivery for details.

[Paisha Eaton]

Wanna pull off the season's freshest trends? You just need the right shoes. That's where designer shoe Warehouse comes in. Loving wide leg jeans. Pair them with sleek low profile sneakers. Obsessed with the sheer trend? Try it with mesh flats, Feeling Boho comfy sandals. Nail the whole free spirited thing. Find on trend shoes from the brands you love like Birkenstock, Nike, Adidas and.

[Hannah Smith]

More AT D.

[Susan]

Career changers including veterans and active duty service members. Your transition starts here. Go from GI to IT In a matter of months. Become a Certified Cyber Warrior with training at my computer Career cybersecurity specialists are in high demand, offering IT pros great.

[Paisha Eaton]

Opportunities and a rewarding lifestyle while protecting.

[Susan]

Our people, liberty and treasured institutions from cyber threats. Deploy your career in IT today. Learn more at my ComputerCareer.edu, cWP Skillbridge and other VA benefits are available to those who qualify.

[Paisha Eaton]

This story contains adult content and language. Listener discretion is advised.

[Susan]

And I will tell you that the fact that they are called terrorists is because that is what they do. I was completely terrorized.

[Hannah Smith]

Welcome to the Knife. I'm Hannah Smith.

[Paisha Eaton]

I'm Paisha Eaton. This week we speak with a woman that we're calling Susan. We are not using her real name or identifying her location because she asked us not to. And after hearing her story, we understand why.

[Hannah Smith]

Sometimes one moment can shift so much in a person's life. For Susan, that moment came unexpectedly when a routine day at the office ended with her fearing for her life and she's never told her story before.

[Paisha Eaton]

Now let's get into the inter.

[Hannah Smith]

Susan, thank you so much for joining us on the podcast.

[Susan]

Thanks. It's interesting to be here.

[Paisha Eaton]

How are you feeling about it?

[Susan]

I feel nervous. I think this is something that needs to happen and it feels like this big secret that I've been holding. I don't know that I've really mentally understood how heavy it's been, but now that I've agreed to do this, I can really feel it's been in my system. So I'm hoping to let this be kind of A purge?

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah. So you reached out and, you know, your message to me was a little bit cryptic. You were like, something very weird happened to me, and you wanted to talk about it finally. But before we get to that point, give us just a little bit of a snapshot of what was going on with you.

[Susan]

I couldn't be more boring. You know, I live in the Midwest, and I had a pretty normal, you know, upbringing. After I had my daughter, I started a business that was totally different than what I had studied in school and didn't really think it would go anywhere, but it did, and it was. It was really successful. Like, nothing unusual to report in my life at the time that this happened. I was just working a ton. I was a single mom. I was going to soccer practice with my daughter. You know, I mean, just, like, things could not have been more normal. So I had a manufacturing business. And, you know, I think at the time this happened, I had about 70 employees. The corporate offices were right there on the manufacturing site. So I had a lot of interactions with my employees. It was production work, and frankly, it was people who were living under some pretty hard circumstances. We tried really hard to pay them a living wage and to, you know, make life better for them, but, you know, things happen, and, you know, people would show up. We had law enforcement show up a few times, and so it's just kind of. Yeah. So when this. When this initially happened, I was just like, oh, yeah, the, you know, law enforcement's here. Well, I wonder what's up today. We'll see who's getting in trouble today, you know, so it was summer of 2016, kind of early summer. I was at work. You know, I was just working away in my office, and one of my front office people came up, and she kind of leaned around the corner and said, the FBI is here and they want to talk to you. And I was like, the FBI? Oh, my gosh, somebody's in deep trouble, you know, so we got him into the conference room. It was this guy who came in. And so I went in there and said hello and sat down with him. And right off the bat, I noticed that he was so nervous. He was holding a laptop and he was holding some folders. Like, he did not look like an FBI agent. He was a very unimposing, kind of this very soft, gentle looking person. Not like official or anything like that. And his hands were shaking, and I could see his hands sweating.

[Hannah Smith]

Wow.

[Susan]

And I thought, this is really weird.

[Hannah Smith]

I mean, it's so weird. Patia and I know we've interviewed multiple FBI agents at this point, and we're.

[Paisha Eaton]

Always just, like, blown away by their confidence. Like, you did what, for how long? And you thought that was fun? Yeah, it's, like, definitely atypical of an FBI agent to come off as nervous, even if they are.

[Susan]

Yeah. I just kind of chalked it up to, you know, maybe. Maybe I've seen too many movies, because I haven't ever, to my knowledge, met an FBI agent before. So I thought, well, okay, I guess we're all human. But, you know, he was rattled. He seemed like he didn't know how to start the conversation, and he just said, I'm here. The FBI has a duty to inform you that we have learned that there is a Middle Eastern terrorist group that issues kill lists. He called it a kill list. And he said, the people who are on that list, the FBI, you know, we come and inform you that you're on that list. And I was thinking, well, who's on that list? I was trying to rack my brain to remember if somebody on my crew was Middle Eastern or something. And he said, you're on the list. I looked at him, and I just started laughing. I mean, it just was so absurd that I started laughing. He was. Poor guy. I mean, he didn't know what to do with my reaction. I think he was ready to be very serious, and I think he was ready to have me fall apart and, you know, get all. You know. But I was just laughing, and he said, let me just lay this out for you. Let me tell you what we know. And he opened up his laptop, and he pulled up a website which was in an Arabic language, and he translated it, and he scrolled down a little bit, and there I was. And it was my name, my full name, and my address. And I thought, oh, my God.

[Paisha Eaton]

Just a few minutes earlier, Susan had been going about an otherwise normal day, and now she's being told that a violent terrorist organization wants her dead. None of it makes sense, especially coming from this scared, sweaty man sitting in front of her. Was he really with the FBI?

[Susan]

Like, who is this guy? What's going on? And when he had come in, he had shown me his badge, and he had given me his card. And so I said, hang on just a minute. I need to go talk to somebody. And he said, no, you can't talk to anybody. This has to be completely confidential. And I said, no way. I don't even know how to understand this information. I'll be right back. So I went in, and I talked to my CEO. He'd been working for me for, like 10 years. I knew him really well. And I said, I need you to check out this guy. Call the FBI. Don't call the number that's on this card. Call them and see if this guy is actually an FBI agent. He doesn't seem like it. He's really nervous.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah, that's so smart to double check because it's like a random person walks in, he's sweating, and tells you shocking information.

[Paisha Eaton]

So you go and you talk to your CEO, and did he or she already know that the FBI was in the building? Supposedly?

[Susan]

Yeah, he did. So when I went in and said, call the FBI and check this guy out, I didn't tell him what was going on. I just said, make sure this guy's real, and then come into the conference room. So he did. And he came in and said, yep, this guy's the real deal. And I said, well, sit down because we need to talk. And so the FBI guy said, I don't recommend this. He said, this cannot get out. So he sat there. My CEO received this news. Hey, Susan's on this terrorist kill list. And so they told me that there was one other person in my state that was on the list.

[Paisha Eaton]

Susan asked the question anyone in her position would ask, why me? Her life was, in her own words, boring. It didn't make any sense that this terrorist organization would want to kill her. But this FBI agent, he didn't have an answer. And when Susan pressed him on it, it almost felt like he was guessing.

[Susan]

They couldn't figure out why we had been picked for the list. They didn't know if it was randomly generated. The other person who was in my state didn't have anything to do with my business industry that I was in. You know, the only thing that he said, because I have a little bit of an online presence because of my business, and we do a lot of marketing. I'd been in a women's magazine about women who accomplish stuff. And so he, you know, maybe because you're a woman in leadership, but it really felt like he was just taking stabs in the dark or whatever that saying is.

[Hannah Smith]

So really, he had no idea necessarily. But you're just getting the information that your name is on a kill list and this is a well known terrorist organization.

[Susan]

Yeah.

[Hannah Smith]

How are you even processing that information in that moment? What are you thinking?

[Susan]

Well, I couldn't stop laughing. I mean, my CEO and this guy, they were looking at me like I was nuts because I think I had so much adrenaline going, and I Just was laughing.

[Paisha Eaton]

And so you're receiving this like mind blowing information that is both, like incredibly scary and makes no sense at all. He has no reason why you would be on the list to offer you. How do you leave off? Is it just like good luck?

[Susan]

Basically. I mean really? He said, you know, I said, what should I do? And he said, well, you need to call your local county sheriff's department because if something happens and you need to call 91 1, they're going to think you're nuts. And so you need to alert them. And I was thinking you alert them, you know, like you're just coming to tell me, like, I, I can't believe that law enforcement isn't hearing about this. So he said, you know, call your sheriffs department, have a conversation with them and then just be safe. And he said, call me if you need anything. And he slides this like sweaty kind of damp current across the table at me. And I'm thinking, dude, you are the last person that I'm going to call if there's any kind of a threat. So he left. And my CEO and I went into our office and shut the door and just stood there and looked at each other like, what the hell? And it was funny because I was looking at my CEO and there was this switch that flipped that was like, okay, this isn't real. This totally isn't real. And got very busy and kind of went back to work and was bustling around his desk and all this kind of stuff. And I was thinking, wow. I all of a sudden felt very alone. And I went outside and I was just sitting on the ground trying to figure out what to do next. And I called my partner and told him what had happened. And he was. It was the very first experience of, oh, it was. They got you mixed up with somebody else.

[Paisha Eaton]

Sweaty and nervous or not. This amateur agent was verifiable FBI. Which meant the government thought there was good reason to warn her. As the adrenaline wore off, it was all sinking in. This was real. Susan was on a hit list. An organization that she'd read about in the news articles about violent acts and extreme tactics such as beheadings was now targeting her. This was so scary, she could hardly process it. But the two people she trusted to tell her CEO and her partner, they didn't seem scared at all. In fact, they blew it off as a mistake. This didn't help her calm down. It just made her feel even more afraid.

[Susan]

I've thought about this so much. It's not victim blaming. It's just Dismissal. So I thought, okay, I am in this by myself.

[Hannah Smith]

Can I ask, though, like. Cause you do have kind of a common name. So how are you sure? Because I think you did know it was actually you, right?

[Susan]

Yeah. I mean, they had my name and address on the website.

[Paisha Eaton]

Yeah.

[Hannah Smith]

So they have your address there. Like, how can that be a mistake? Especially when your life is. This is talking about the potential of your life being in danger.

[Susan]

Yeah. It was heavy on my mind that the FBI had said, don't tell anybody, because there was no way that I was going to be able to deal with it or figure out what to do by myself. So I called my dad, who is just like the loving, most sweetest, most protective dad ever. And he ended up going to the FBI and saying, okay, somebody showed up on my daughter's doorstep. What the hell is going on? And all they could really do is confirm. They showed him all the information that they showed me. They gave him the same instructions about get a hold of local law enforcement and just let us know if anything happens. I was kind of stunned. I mean, I don't even really remember the next couple of days. And my partner was continuing to be like, you know what? I'd say I'm so scared. Aren't you scared? And he'd say, no, I'm not scared.

[Paisha Eaton]

In moments like this one, Susan started to feel like she was living in the twilight zone. But the FBI had left her with one more piece of advice that might help her stay safe. Call your local sheriff's office. The idea was that if she could update them and let them know that she was on this hit list, then they could be on high alert, they could be prepared if she ever did need their help.

[Susan]

So I called my local sheriff's office, and I remember talking with the dispatch person, and she was like, okay, so what you're saying is, like, this is not an emergency. But, you know, she was just trying to get the whole story straight. And she was just like, yeah, okay, we'll have somebody call you. And so somebody did call me back a couple days later, and they had somebody from the sheriff's department come to my house. And he thought I was nuts. I mean, he just thought, this is the biggest waste of my time. He didn't even really ask me any questions. He didn't want to talk about it. I have two cats. One of them jumped up on the counter. So we spent like 20 minutes talking about my cat. He was telling me about his mom's cats, and he had zero interest, zero curiosity. There was no sense of urgency. I was so freaked out and scared that nobody was responding to this.

[Paisha Eaton]

Because this is now the third time you brought it to your CEO, who sort of, you know, maybe did his best in the moment, but didn't fully process it, was not sort of rallying to help you figure it out. Your partner, who dismisses it as a mistake and doesn't show any real concern. And now the local sheriff's office that the FBI instructed you to contact is showing you the same sort of nonchalance.

[Susan]

Yeah. And just disinterest. He was a little bit older, and it was kind of like I was the hysterical woman, and I wasn't being hysterical. I was talking to him. I wasn't crying. I wasn't upset. But he was just like, don't worry, hon. You know, this is fine. So I talked to him about my cat for a while, and he left and just, you know, gave me his card and said, let me know if you need anything. So I'm still kind of in this place where I'm just, this is nothing. This is silly. And then feeling just so stunned. I was just in shock. I'm nobody. I have not done anything controversial. I've been totally kind of apolitical my whole life. I've not done anything that would be a threat to anyone. And so I'm trying to balance that. And I was home one afternoon, and there's a knock at the door, and I go answer it, and it's this guy. He's my area SWAT team guy. And I'm thinking, okay, here we go. Here we go again. And he turned out to be an angel. I mean, he turned out to be such a grounding force, and he was so helpful. He had two guys with him, and he showed me his card, showed me his badge. He was like, if you want to check this out, we'll wait right here. And at that point, I was like, come on in. I'm done checking people out. So he came in and he said he was from my county's SWAT team. And he said, we have just been debriefed by the FBI. We. We know that this is happening. We know that you talked to your local sheriff's office, and they didn't know about it at the time. They know now. We have some things that we need to do today, and we're here to help you. And it was such a relief to have somebody take this seriously. I just thought, holy shit, I am in deep trouble. I am in really deep trouble here. So they kind of broke up. You Know, this guy, the main guy was talking to me. I'll call him Alan. He was talking to me, talking through what they knew about the website, what they knew about the kill lists. And then the other two guys went around my house. They took pictures of every square inch of my house. And then they walked me around and said, okay, a person could hide here, A person could hide here. They walked me around my yard because I have a lot of landscaping in my yard. And they said, you need to cut all this down because it'd be so easy for somebody to hide right here.

[Paisha Eaton]

Susan's daughter was away at college while all of this was happening, but Susan thought about her all the time. She wanted someone to take this seriously, to make her feel safe again. And now someone was. At the same time, the very presence of this local SWAT team made her nightmare more real. They walked her through her house, pointing out places a trained assassin could hide. They told her to cut down trees and bushes in her yard so an attacker couldn't use them for cover. This was no longer a theoretical threat. Every moment of her life now carried the weight of potential violence.

[Susan]

They said, when you're in your car, make sure your car is always locked. When you pull up to your garage, you're in your locked car. Open up the garage door, drive in, close the garage door right away, look around as you're still in your locked car, and then unlock your car and go into your house. I was so afraid. Everything that they were saying was making it so real. They had thought through how this organization was going to carry through with their threat. And it was kind of like, you know, things that I had been thinking about in the middle of the night, but they were actually playing out scenarios. And then at the end, they were about to leave, and he said, we're going to have people surveilling your house. They put this. I can't remember what the word is, but it's. It's a designation that they put on my house, and it's. I think it's called Hazard 1. When the SWAT team was leaving, you know, I said, what should I do? Should I get a gun? I didn't know what to do. And he said, the reality is that they're very good at what they do, and if they want to get you, they will get you. And you will not see it coming. They will pick you off in a parking lot or somewhere where you least expect it, because that's what they do. I think at that moment, I just. I felt so exposed. I felt like a sitting duck. And I felt very isolated. You know, all the people that I told were men and I don't have anything against men, but I wish that I told somebody who had a little more capacity for empathy because everybody was so, I think overwhelmed by the information that they didn't know how to think about what was needed at the time for me. And so at that point I just stopped. I couldn't work. I was afraid to go to work because I didn't want to put anybody else in danger.

[Hannah Smith]

Get this Adults with financial literacy skills have 82% more wealth than those who don't. From swimming lessons to piano classes, us parents invest in so many things to enrich our kids lives, but are we investing in their future financial success? With Greenlight you can teach your kids financial literacy skills like earning, saving and investing. And this investment costs less than that. After school treat start prioritizing their financial education and future today with a risk free [e-mail] iheart greenlight.com iheart Think advertising.

[Susan]

On TikTok isn't for your business? Think again.

[Hannah Smith]

We've generated over 100,000 leads which has converted into over 40,000 sales for our pet insurance policies.

[Trey Ferro]

My name is Trey Ferro.

[Hannah Smith]

I am the CEO of Spot Pet Insurance.

[Trey Ferro]

TikTok Smart Plus AI powered automation takes.

[Hannah Smith]

The guesswork out of targeting, bidding and optimizing creative. If I can advertise on TikTok, you can too.

[Susan]

Drive more leads and scale your business. Today only on TikTok. Head over to get started.TikTok.com TikTok ads.

[Trey Ferro]

You'Re great at protecting your own personal information. You probably even use things like two factor authentication, strong passwords and a vpn. But as much as you try to be in control of how your information is protected, there are lots of places that also have it and they might not be as careful as you are. That's why LifeLock monitors millions of data points every second for identity threats. If your identity is stolen, a LifeLock US based restoration specialist will help solve identity theft issues on your behalf, guaranteed or your money back. Plus, all LifeLock plans are backed by the million dollar protection package, meaning LifeLock will reimburse you up to the limits of your plan. If you lose money due to identity theft, you might not be able to control how others handle your personal information, but you can help protect it. With LifeLock, save up to 40% your first year. Call 1-800-LIFELOCK and use promo code IHEART or go to lifelock.com iheart for 40% off terms apply.

[Paisha Eaton]

As life continued around her, Susan's reality completely shifted. She couldn't eat, couldn't sleep, couldn't walk to her kitchen without looking over her shoulder. Every creaky floorboard, every hum of a car engine, it all made her heart race. The SWAT team was surveilling her home and her work, which brought its own mix of emotions. Imagine looking outside and seeing a man in your yard, knowing he's there to see if anyone else is there trying to kill you.

[Susan]

They were watching my facility. This big black Suburban, like three times a week at night would drive by. And you know those spotlights that they have on their cars? There would be these big spotlights that would go on as they drove by. I think early on I hadn't remembered this until yesterday, but sometimes they would walk around my backyard, which it was comforting knowing that somebody was taking this seriously, but it also was terrifying. And I just started to fall apart.

[Hannah Smith]

And.

[Susan]

And I'm like a strong person. I'm in manufacturing and it's a male dominated world and I have to deal with a lot of rough people. And I really started to fall apart. And I think it was because I could hardly eat, I could not sleep. And I would be laying in bed and I would be kind of like in this semi, almost falling asleep. And then I would hear like the slightest sound and it was like somebody was shocking me right in my solar plexus. It was just like this huge shock of adrenaline. So it was just over and over and over again. And I felt so alone.

[Hannah Smith]

Alone.

[Susan]

And I would say to my partner, are you afraid? And he'd say no. And he'd say, don't worry, I'm right here. And then he would fall asleep. And I knew that he couldn't help me.

[Paisha Eaton]

Susan's home was no longer a place she felt safe or in control. She knew what it was like to be tired. She'd been a single mother, she ran her own company. But this kind of sleep deprivation was different. It was worse.

[Susan]

It got to the point where I live kind of close to some foothills. And I got so unglued from lack of sleep that he would take me up there and he would just like sit on the hood of his car, spread some blankets out, and I would just sleep because I needed sleep so desperately. And I was so afraid to fall asleep because it was. I felt like I was the only one watching. I felt like I was the only one that was taking it seriously. And this guy from the FBI would check in. He called me and he said, I'm going to send you an email, and it's got some information in it, and there's a photograph of somebody that's a sympathizer, you know, or maybe part of this terrorist group who were watching. And they live like, 45 minutes. They're a town that's like 45 minutes away from me. And he said, we want you to know what he looks like.

[Paisha Eaton]

Up until this point, the terrorist group behind the hit list was still just made up of nameless, faceless people thousands of miles away. It was scary, but now here was this person who lived just a short drive away, a sympathizer who agreed with and supported their mission and ideologies. It's a very real threat. In 2014, a US citizen and terrorist sympathizer, Ali Muhammad Brown, killed four people for what he described as vengeance over over US policy in the Middle East. In 2019, a man named Rondell Henry was arrested after plotting attacks in D.C. he'd rented a U Haul and planned to run into a crowd of pedestrians, but abandoned his plan at the last second because he thought the crowd wasn't big enough. Maryland prosecutors determined Henry had been inspired by a terrorist attack in France back in 2016. This email from the FBI alerting Susan of a nearby sympathizer included both his photo and the make and model of his car. He was real and he was close.

[Susan]

I started seeing those cars everywhere. You know, it's like it all of a sudden comes into your awareness. And they were everywhere. It was a minivan. My God, there are minivans all over the place. So I was starting to be in this very weird suspended place, which I know now is just like, I was in this big vat of trauma that was going on. And so I decided I needed to go someplace where nobody knew where I was. So I went about two hours away and just rented this little place. And I'm not a big drinker, but when I got up there, I ended up getting really drunk the first night that I was up there, which is like two and a half drinks for me. But it did the job. I remember vaguely it was around the time when Dennis Miller was a really popular comedian, and he would do those top 10 lists. Do you remember that?

[Hannah Smith]

I'm not familiar. Is this a comedian?

[Susan]

He was a comedian, yeah. And he would do these top 10 lists, and that was very popular at the time. And so as I'm getting plastered, I started making up this list about the top 10 things that are worse than being on a terrorist hit list. And I started to laugh, and it kind of started to break up a little bit. Like, I couldn't be afraid anymore. I couldn't sustain that level of terror. And I will tell you that the fact that they are called terrorists is because that is what they do. They terrorize people. I have never had a hair on my head touched, but I was completely terrorized. It's interesting now that I look back on it and I see how effective that was to do that.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah.

[Paisha Eaton]

How much time had gone by between this first meeting with the FBI agent at your place of work to this moment in the rental two hours away, where you're like, okay, something's gotta give here.

[Susan]

I think it was probably like three weeks.

[Hannah Smith]

That's a long time to be feeling that afraid and not sleeping. I mean, it just really does sound like a nightmare. I mean, I think that, like, a lot of people can identify with being home, being afraid, having those thoughts of, what if someone breaks into my house? Yeah.

[Susan]

I mean, it was all orchestrated so well, and maybe that was accidental, but, like, the method of what they did to be terrifying at every step of the way. There was no good solution. There was no way to resolve it. So it's just kind of hanging out there. So the point where I got to, I cannot sustain this terror any longer. I cannot do it. I can't do it physically or mentally, emotionally. I can't do this anymore. And then I woke up the next morning with, of course, a hangover. But I heard on the news that there had been a shooting at a concert in Dallas, Texas, and a bunch of police officers had been shot. It was like we were receiving this news of, oh, my God, there was a shooting. It was like, that was when the last piece broke free or I let go. It's like, okay, not even police are safe. And then my mind just started going there of, like, none of us are safe. I could do everything. This could be resolved, and I could die in a car accident on the way home. I could have a massive stroke and fall down dead right here. The fact that I have a little bit of information about this has to just be a side note, because at the same time that everything is okay, we all are going to go at some point.

[Paisha Eaton]

This is the moment that everything shifted for Susan. She had done all she could do to protect herself, but had also been told, if they want to get you, they will, and you will not see it coming. From the moment that FBI agent walked into her office, her sense of safety had been shattered, replaced by a constant gnawing fear, A fear so great and so powerful that it was overtaking her life. She knew she could not go on like this. She realized that she wasn't more or less safe than she had been before, because every day was full of unknowns, risks, and surprises. No one knows when they're going to die. In the end, it wasn't taking control that gave Susan a sense of peace or safety. It was accepting how little control she was in.

[Susan]

So I kind of went back to my life, and, you know, I did all the things. I got an alarm system, and I cut down a lot of my landscaping. And I did those things because it felt good to me to feel like I was doing something for myself and that I was taking action. Slowly, over the years, some of those habits have melted away, which was such a jarring experience. When I, you know, went to my front door the other night to turn off the lights, and I saw that it was unlocked, and I was like, oh, my God. You know, I have slipped that far.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah.

[Susan]

I've tried to tell a couple of people over the years. I think, like, maybe two people. And so trying to tell people about a trauma and then trying to convince them of its authenticity at the same time, it's horrible. I can't do both. And that's why I wanted to tell this story to you, because it's real. And how could I make this up? When I went back to work, we decided to. Because I was so concerned about putting other people, you know, in harm's way. And I thought, you know, maybe it won't be an attempt that is like, maybe they're not going to shoot me sniper style. Maybe they'll send a bomb to the building. And then I was thinking about all these people who, you know, oh, my gosh, this is terrifying. So we put a lot of protocol in place. We changed the format of the building in a way, so, you know, you had to have a badge to swipe in. All the packages were checked in a particular part of the building before they came. Anything that was not, like, clearly marked from a vendor that we knew was not opened.

[Paisha Eaton]

And so when do you decide to tell your daughter and what is her reaction?

[Susan]

I told her about four years ago.

[Paisha Eaton]

That's 2021. This happens in 2016. That's a long time.

[Susan]

It is, yeah. I actually told a friend of mine about it, one of my best friends, and she is very logical. She's very research minded. You know, she's like, okay, I'm looking this up. And she's like, well, yeah, I see that there are articles about these lists and I see that there is stuff out there. And she and I kind of problem solved. When I told my daughter about it, we were in person and I told her in a way that was framed around, you know, I'm safe, this is okay, it's over. But I just want you to know that this happened. And she was very initially upset. She was very scared. You know, she and I are really close. I think she was able to process through it. But it's like, what do you even process through? I have not found a good way to resolve this yet, really. So you just kind of have to let it age and diminish.

[Hannah Smith]

I think you're a hustler. You get things done, but you don't always do things for yourself. With JLO Beauty, it takes just a few minutes a day to look like facials are a regular part of your routine. JLo Beauty's Fresh and Flawless skincare kit includes six skincare products that work as hard as you do. They'll hustle to brighten, firm and hydrate.

[Susan]

Your complexion morning and night.

[Hannah Smith]

This skincare kit is a one and done solution that is clinically proven to visibly tighten and lift for instant and long lasting results. Cleanse, treat, moisturize, protect. The fresh and flawless Skincare Kit does it all. See why the kit's a best seller today? Visit jlobeauty.com deluxe and get an extra 25% off your first shipment plus free gifts with code DELUXE. If you're not satisfied, return the bottles within 60 days for your money back. See the website for details. That's JLo Beauty.com Deluxe to get that JLO glow. At Amica Insurance we know it's more than a life policy. It's about the promise and the responsibility that comes with being a new parent.

[Trey Ferro]

Being there day and night.

[Susan]

And building.

[Hannah Smith]

A plan for tomorrow today for the ones you'll always look out for.

[Trey Ferro]

Trust Amica Life Insurance Amica Empathy is.

[Hannah Smith]

Our best policy for period protection. You can put on and forget about nothing. Beats Nyx Leakproof Underwear, North America's number one leak proof underwear brand. Let's face it, life can be unpredictable. But your leak proof underwear shouldn't be. That's why millions of people choose Nyx for periods for light leaks for everyday freshness. NYX undies are super comfy, super absorbent and made to handle whatever your day throws at you. Day two of your period covered your daily run. No problem. That big sneeze? You know the one? Yep. We've got You. And with styles like bikinis, boy shorts, thongs, and high rise plus sizes from extra small to 4XL, NYX makes it easy to find your perfect fit. Say goodbye to stress and leaks and say hello to undies that work just as hard as you do, no matter the leak. Find the style and level of protection you [e-mail] and use code flow15 for 15% off. That's kn Ix.com code flo15 for 15% off. Nyx for your leaks for your life.

[Paisha Eaton]

The list Susan was on is real, and it's not the only one. In fact, terrorist organizations have been making these hit lists for years. Some targeted names of people who worked for Homeland Security or were members of the US Military. Others seemed totally random. Susan never got an answer as to why her name was on a list. How long did that SWAT team or the FBI surveil your home? How long did that go on for?

[Susan]

It went on for about a year and a half, but it got less and less. At first it was probably, you know, three times a week. Then it kind of went to once a week. We have to be really careful at work because if we call 911, the way that they explained it to me is they come guns drawn. So they're not going to just come up and knock on the door and say, oh, did you call 911? You know, they're coming expecting action, I guess. So at one point I did have to call my local sheriff's office for something that was totally unrelated and it was non emergency, but they came. And when they came, a SWAT team guy showed up too. And after I had talked to the sheriff about what my business was, the SWAT team guy said, how are you doing? We're watching this. We're on this. Every time that you call, it's routed directly to us, so we will always come. And I was like, oh God, can't you take this thing off my house? And he said, no, we're not gonna do that. I'm glad that people know. But I, it's, it's, it feels over.

[Paisha Eaton]

This decision to stay anonymous on this podcast and sort of relatively anonymous in your life with this story, although you've told some trusted loved ones why I.

[Susan]

Don'T want to get the attention of anybody. I don't want to make myself a target again. That feels very important. Yeah, I don't want to say, oh, we forgot that person. Well, somebody go get her.

[Paisha Eaton]

Right.

[Susan]

And I also don't want to put myself back in that place of feeling exposed that is a bad feeling.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah, that makes sense.

[Susan]

Yeah.

[Hannah Smith]

Just thinking about the whole ordeal and everything that you had to go through and sleepless nights and all the fear, you know, how do you think back now about the FBI's decision to inform you of this threat? Like, are you glad that that happened? Were you glad that you knew? What is your thinking around that?

[Susan]

That is such a tough question. It's kind of like yes and no. I think that I have a right to know. And I also think that I went through a lot. It's easily one of the worst things that's happened in my life. And I think it was all a terrorist ruse. And I think it was designed to put me through what I went through. I wish they had told me in a different way. I wish they had brought me in so they didn't send like some nervous newbie out to drop this in my lap and then say, good luck. I wish they'd told me in a different way. And you know what? I also want to say that to everyone, from the initial guy who came to talk to me to the sheriff's department and the SWAT team, I know that everybody was trying to do their best. No one was unkind to me. Maybe dismissive. Yes. But I think that no one had been through this before and they didn't know what to do. So I don't want to sound like I'm trying to disparage any of those people who tried to help.

[Paisha Eaton]

When the FBI agent who initially came to speak with you gave you the information that there was one other person in your state on the list, were you given that person's name? Did you ever speak with them?

[Susan]

No. They did tell me that they were a doctor or dentist or something. I kind of wish that I had asked for that information. If there's someone out there that hears this, I would love to talk to them to see what their experience was. The main SWAT team guide has sent me information. It stopped probably about five years ago, but he would send me some follow up information. And another list was posted on the website, on the terrorist website, probably two years after the one that I was on was published. And all those people were on the east coast and they were all either current or ex military. So he's trying to piece together, like, how did I get on this list? And he said, but at this point, my best guess is that it was just random, that it was just a random thing.

[Paisha Eaton]

I'm so curious how putting random names on a list, although it is terrifying for the people who are those names on the list, how it benefits that organization? I mean, I don't know if you have any insight on this after your experience, but is it just to say, you know what, FBI, I'm gonna occupy your time with this random civilian. Did they ever offer you anything about why you?

[Susan]

No. I mean, they had some guesses. I think I've already mentioned it was because women in leadership and that I have a little bit of an online presence. But, like, I mean, compared to the average, I'm the same as everybody else.

[Paisha Eaton]

Everyone has an online presence now.

[Susan]

Yeah. Right. Yeah.

[Paisha Eaton]

And so when did you first start really feeling like you were in control of your life again? Being able to sleep at night? You know, you said that your relationship ultimately ended, which I assume then means you're sleeping alone in your house with your cats.

[Susan]

Yes, my cats and my dogs. I have two dogs with big, loud, scary, vicious sounding barks, which is great.

[Paisha Eaton]

Love that.

[Susan]

And they would definitely defend me. I think it just goes back to. I used to be really afraid of the dark. I mean, up until, like, long after my daughter was born. And I realized when my daughter was born that I had to get over it because you get up in the middle of the night a lot when you're a parent. Now it feels like a choice for me. I live alone with my animals, and I can lay in bed and be afraid, or I cannot. And at this point, there's no way in hell I'm going to let somebody else dictate whether or not I'm laying in bed feeling afraid. That's up to me. That maybe sounds kind of simple, but it's the only place I've been able to make a change, to make an actual change in how I feel.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah, that makes sense. Like in your own mind. Well, it's tricky, right, because the threat was real. So it's not like this was just in your head or your mind. You know, this was a real thing that the outside world was like, this is a real threat. You know, having a SWAT team come to your house is terrifying, I imagine. But then beyond that, what you do with that, it's like, yeah, it's so much about your own mind and your own fear.

[Susan]

I don't know how to talk to people, people even yet without having it sound totally crazy and phony. I've never heard anyone talk about anything close to this, so that's why it was very hard for me to figure out how to email you guys. But I will tell you that listening to the podcasts that you've already put Out. I wanted to tell my story in a way that somebody would thoughtfully investigate what happened and not try and rip me apart over it. Because, like I said, that dismissal is really tough, and I wanted to talk to somebody who would be responsible about handling this information in a safe way.

[Paisha Eaton]

It sounds like in your case, you've just learned to live with this obscure, terrifying threat and manage that fear in a healthy way. But there is no, okay. It's over. And what does that feel like?

[Susan]

I think I had to create an over for myself because I don't want it to be part of my life. I don't want to carry this around inside anymore. I don't want to have this feeling like I have this thing that's so scary and so big, but I have to keep it a secret. I'm just not willing to do that. And the over part for me is just choosing not to. Like, I'm not gonna participate. You know, it's. If I could talk to the people, I would say, I'm done. I am not gonna participate in your little terrorist shenanigans that you are doing. I'm not gonna do it anymore. So that has been my delineation of it being over.

[Hannah Smith]

Well, that was our conversation with Susan, and I have to say, I really enjoyed talking with her. One thing that really stands out from that conversation was this idea that she brought up of. I think she called it victim dismissal. You know, she was experiencing this terrifying situation, and yet everyone around her, for a period of time, kind of acted like she was making too big of a deal of it.

[Paisha Eaton]

Yeah, I loved the way she put that, because even in her own mind, she was trying to assess the threat that was, you know, what this FBI agent had told her and how vague everything was, but how real it also was, because the actual FBI was there, and the people that she trusted didn't really know what to make of it. I mean, I think that even someone with the best of intentions could think that they're doing someone good by trying to, like, put their mind at ease. Oh, it's nothing. It was just a mistake. There's no way.

[Hannah Smith]

But don't worry.

[Paisha Eaton]

Don't worry. But then the SWAT team's at your house, and it is worrying.

[Hannah Smith]

How do you not worry when a SWAT team is literally at your house?

[Paisha Eaton]

I would be very, very concerned.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah. And I want to quickly mention as well, even though Susan didn't want to use her name or her location, which I totally understand, she mentioned that if anything came out of this, it would be interesting to her to connect with someone else who had been through this similar situation of being on a terrorist hit list. So, you know, I don't know if someone is listening to this and you're like screaming at your phone right now, I've been through this too. Send us an email@the knifexactlyrightmedia.com and we would love to speak with you and hopefully be able to connect you with Susan.

[Susan]

Yeah.

[Paisha Eaton]

And so initially Susan reached out to us via email and you were like, okay, we have to do this interview, but I don't even wanna tell you too much about it because her story is one that we've never heard before. And I was totally game. Sometimes I love going into interviews like that because, you know, you can find yourself asking different questions than maybe if you had prepped yourself ahead of time. And I certainly wasn't expecting the story that she told. And one of the major pieces that came with Susan agreeing to speak with even though she had reached out was that we not identify the organization that had put her on this target list. And after researching these sorts of target lists, there have been multiple terrorist organizations that have made them. And so we're just going to talk about a few examples. A well known organization, isis, created multiple lists just like this one. You know, one thing Susan told us in the interview about these lists in general and why the FBI reached out to meet with her was that these lists weren't really considered to be an actual threat to people. And so when they first started popping up, the FBI wasn't alerting the people who were on them.

[Hannah Smith]

What do you mean they weren't considered a threat?

[Paisha Eaton]

They weren't sure to what to make of it. Like they didn't think that notifying people was necessarily in their best interest. Maybe.

[Hannah Smith]

Okay.

[Paisha Eaton]

And I wasn't able to verify that, but that is what she told us as to part of the reason why the FBI came to tell her this, even though they had very little else to offer in that first meeting.

[Hannah Smith]

Right. I remember that like that they had gotten some pushback because maybe they had not notified people about being on hit lists. So then they're notifying people. And you know, that's also scary. I don't know what you're supposed to do necessarily.

[Paisha Eaton]

So scary. And that FBI agent didn't know either. And so now years have passed and some research has come out about the actual purpose of these lists. Okay, and so what is the real threat? In one of the articles I read about this, a man named Matthew Levitt from the Washington Institute for Near east policy. He said he believes that these lists are trying to spark the interest of lone wolves. So sympathizers, you know, which we talked about during the interview, people who believe in the mission of a terrorist organization, but might live domestically and have access to people on this list that the people overseas in some foreign country do not.

[Hannah Smith]

Wow. Yeah. So it's like this message to sympathizers, if you want to join our cause, you don't have to fly across the world. Here's a mission for you to do in your own state or something like that.

[Paisha Eaton]

Right. Because they would love to take responsibility for an attack. And so that is the real threat. And that to me, learning that both partially in our interview with Susan, when she was alerted of a nearby sympathizer, and then making even more sense of what that threat really meant after researching it, that's really scary because, I mean, we were able to pull up multiple examples of those threats being carried out, almost carried out, and resulting in senseless tragedy.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah, it is scary. It makes it more real. And, yeah, that was a clear escalation in the story when there was a name and a vehicle. It wasn't just this sort of theoretical threat from an organization that was across, you know, the world. Suddenly, it was, there could be someone carrying this out right now. And as you said, there's been a few examples of this happening, right?

[Paisha Eaton]

Yeah. And the surveillance that was happening at her home and at her work, you know, it wasn't 24 7. It wasn't like she had security detail following her around, although they were checking in. You know, it wasn't like this total relief. It was almost just reaffirming the fear without making her feel any safer. So this idea that these target lists, the purpose was to instigate these lone wolf attacks, it's real.

[Hannah Smith]

You know, she talked about, like, being terrorized, feeling terrorized, and how horrible that was for her and how really she just wanted someone to kind of acknowledge it in her life and say, yeah, that's really scary. And it's really scary to be in your home and think that someone might be actively trying to kill you.

[Paisha Eaton]

Yeah. I mean, just someone to confide in about your fear, even if they're not going to be able to offer you a solution. To have to sort of carry that emotional burden on your own would be really, really lonely.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah.

[Paisha Eaton]

Another moment of the interview that I wanted to touch on is Susan mentioned to us that her house is labeled a hazard one. I had never heard that term before.

[Hannah Smith]

I had never heard of that either.

[Paisha Eaton]

Yeah. So when this whole ordeal happened, the purpose behind it is great. It's like, okay, we're alerting local law enforcement of this threat so that if you ever meet us, we're ready for the threat. But all these years later, her house is still labeled a hazard one. So even if someone slips and falls, she has to be ready for, you know, people to come, guns drawn SWAT team, if she calls 911, if she goes to sell her house.

[Hannah Smith]

That's what was really interesting when she said that she would have to disclose that to the potential buyers. That, hey, this house is a hazard one. So FYI, let's say you have little kids and you need to call 911, just like be prepared that there will be. There's going to be a SWAT team coming to your house.

[Paisha Eaton]

Terrifying.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah.

[Paisha Eaton]

I mean, it's not a small consequence. It's small relative to the fear that someone's going to kill you, but it's just another consequence of this happening to her.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah. And she had asked for that to be removed because it's been almost 10 years since this happened, I believe, and she feels like it's really not a threat anymore. But technically, since her name was on that list, it's not like there's an end point of like, okay, officially this is wrapped up and your name is not on this list anymore. So it's kind of this open ended thing where they're going to keep her house and her workplace listed as Hazard 1 just in case, I guess. Right.

[Paisha Eaton]

Because it's not like this terrorist organization is going to say, you, Susan, are released from the list. The list just lives now.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah.

[Paisha Eaton]

And actually I do want to mention, and we touched on this in the interview, Susan's a listener of the podcast and reached out to us and we absolutely love that.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah, I'm so grateful she reached out and wanted to tell us this story. Such a unique, strange true crime story where like no one's getting hurt really.

[Paisha Eaton]

But it's that human experience we talk so much about where you're like, okay, someone gets dropped into this nuts situation and now what?

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah, I'm grateful that she wanted to talk to us about it because she had not told very many people at.

[Paisha Eaton]

All about this to this day.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah. One of the things I wanted to talk to you about in this wraparound specifically was your thoughts on the part of the story where Susan talked about being a parent, being a mom. You know, in the beginning when she was telling us her story, she said she's a single mom and Then when we got to the point of her talking about being on this hit list and the SWAT team coming to her house, you know, the idea of a kid being in the house was really scary. It turned out that her daughter was away at college at the time. Still scary, but, you know, she didn't have a kid in the house at that moment. But I'm just curious if you have any, like, reflections or thoughts about that.

[Paisha Eaton]

Well, I'll say that before I knew her daughter was living out of the house. At the time, it was my first question. What do you do? I mean, I feel like my instinct would be to just leave. My kid is a toddler, so I've been a parent for much less time than she has. But I think that, like, the fear you have for something happening to your child is just. You cannot even compare it to any fear you might have for something happening to yourself. But also, you know, Susan is a single parent, so she's always having to consider that if something did happen to her, that is a different situation than if you're not a single parent. That was something about her interview that I found really touching, is how much thought she even gave to when to tell her daughter about this target list, because you also don't want to burden your children with the fear that they're going to lose you. And she had, you know, not that much information to give her and didn't want to relay the same vague but serious threat that this FBI agent had put on her.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah, I can't imagine also being the child in that situation. Let's say you're away at college. The last thing you want to hear is your parent calling you up and saying, by the way, this terrorist organization that you've been reading about at the news knows who I am and has my address and wants to kill me. So, I mean, it makes sense that she didn't tell her daughter at that time. I think she said it was, like, years later that they spoke about it.

[Paisha Eaton]

And even then, it was kind of sad and scary for her to take in. But by that point, Susan had a more sort of measured perspective on it herself and was probably in a better position to guide her daughter through that same experience.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah, I've thought about this interview a lot since it happened. We have two different experiences, or maybe more than two. But when we're interviewing someone, there's that experience of interviewing them. Usually we're on zoom. We see their face. You know, it's a long conversation that ends up in the final episode. And so there's that experience. And then there's the experience of editing it and the final piece that ends up coming out. There was a lot of time to think about it. And I don't know, the visuals of the SWAT team coming into her house and the reality of them saying things like, well, an assassin could be hiding in your pantry. So that's something to think about. And it's so scary. And it's like, I've thought about that in my house so many times since. Where would someone hide? Like, this is the stuff of nightmares. And then to be told that it's real. Like your worst nightmare, like the monster under your bed is actually a real thing. So be careful. Cause it's gonna get you.

[Paisha Eaton]

Oh my gosh. Or just, you know, My toddler wakes up at night, it's so dark. I'm walking to her room and I'm like, I'm not scared at all. You should go back to sleep.

[Hannah Smith]

I'm fine. Yeah.

[Paisha Eaton]

The day we did that interview happened to also be the day that I got these baby proofing door alarms because we have a door that goes to our firescape, a door that goes to our balcony, and it's just like a magnet. If you open the door, there's a loud beeping that happens because we keep those doors closed for obvious reasons. And I couldn't install those fast enough.

[Hannah Smith]

Yes. Yeah. But I have to say, I also have really thought about the conversation we had with her about how she mentally sort of moved past, which was surprisingly sort of deep and touching to me.

[Paisha Eaton]

Yeah, she drew this pretty definitive line in the sand for herself just based off of like a shift in perspective. And I think that's so powerful that she was able to do that. Was this recognizing that no one was gonna do it for her. This organization wasn't gonna say, nevermind, wrong, Susan. That was a joke. It was just all going to go on forever. It was up to her to move on or not move on. And obviously moving on doesn't happen completely, but she now is to the point where she can talk about it. And she wasn't for a long time.

[Hannah Smith]

Yeah. Thank you so much, Susan, for trusting us with your story. Thank you for listening to this episode. Let us know what you think. You can always leave us a comment on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. You can also reach us directly on Instagram at the Knife podcast. We check our Instagram. So if you have something you want to tell us, we will get the message. We will try to reply. And thank you so much for listening. We'll see you next week.

[Paisha Eaton]

If you have a story for us, we would love to hear it. Our email is the knifexactlyrightmedia.com or you can follow us on Instagram at the Knife Podcast or bluesky at the Knife Podcast.

[Hannah Smith]

This has been an exactly right production, hosted and produced by me, Hannah Smith.

[Paisha Eaton]

And me Pasha Eaton. Our producers are Tom Breyfogel and Alexis Amorosi.

[Hannah Smith]

This episode was mixed by Tom Breyfogle.

[Paisha Eaton]

Our associate producer is Christina Chamberlain.

[Hannah Smith]

Our theme music is by Birds in the Airport.

[Paisha Eaton]

Artwork by Vanessa Lilac.

[Hannah Smith]

Executive produced by Karen Kilgariff, Georgia Hardstark and Danielle Kramer.

[Trey Ferro]

You're great at protecting your own personal information. You probably even use things like two factor authentication, strong passwords and a vpn. But as much as you try to be in control of how your information is protected, there are lots of places that also have it and they might not be as careful as you are. That's why LifeLock monitors millions of data points every second for identity threats. If your identity is stolen, a LifeLock US based restoration specialist will help solve identity theft issues on your behalf, guaranteed or your money back. Plus, all LifeLock plans are backed by the million dollar protection package, meaning LifeLock will reimburse you up to the limits of your plan. If you lose money due to identity theft. You might not be able to control how others handle your personal information, but you can help protect it with LifeLock, save up to 40% your first year. Call 1-800-LIFELOCK and use promo code IHEART or go to lifelock.com iheart for 40% off terms apply.

[Hannah Smith]

For some of us, personal finances aren't just personal, they include a lot more people than ourselves, loved ones, neighbors, the communities we call home, and the causes we hold in our hearts. At Thrivent, we help plan your financial picture with the bigger picture in mind. Because even though our business is helping.

[Paisha Eaton]

Guide your finances, our ambition is to make it mean so much more.

[Hannah Smith]

Thrivent where Money means more Connect with [e-mail] hello, it is Ryan and I.

[Trey Ferro]

Was on a flight the other day.

[Hannah Smith]

Playing one of my favorite social spin slot games on jumbacasino.com I looked over.

[Susan]

The person sitting next to me and.

[Hannah Smith]

You know what they were doing.

[Susan]

They were also playing Chumpa Casino. Everybody's loving having fun with it. Chumba Casino is home to hundreds of.

[Hannah Smith]

Casino style games that you can play.

[Paisha Eaton]

For free, anytime, anywhere.

[Susan]

So sign up [e-mail] to claim your free welcome bonus. That's chumbacasino.com and live the Chumba life. Sponsored by Chumba Casino.

[Paisha Eaton]

No purchase necessary.

[Susan]

VGW Group void where prohibited by law. 21/ Terms and Conditions apply.