← The Knowledge Project
Loading summary
Transcript276 lines
- [00:02]
Logan Urie
Your dating app profile is sort of like your billboard. You are telling a story about who you are. Am I ready to date? Who should I date? Should I keep dating this person? Should we move in together? Should we get married? Each of these is a pivotal point in your life. The thing that we think makes us unlovable is often what makes somebody feel comfortable around us. But if we truly feel like we're unlovable, we never open up and give somebody the chance to see that for themselves. The sooner you learn how to date, the sooner you can stop dating. It's not about gathering information, it's about having an experience with them. Imagine that you spend 50 years with someone. The day that you meet is 0.0055% of your total time with them. You have to shoot your shot. You have to approach people in public. You have to take foreign.
- [01:06]
Shane Parrish
Welcome to the Knowledge Project. I'm your host Shane Parish. If you want to take your learning the next level, consider joining our membership program at FS Blog Membership. As a member, you'll get my personal reflections at the end of each every episode, early access to episodes, no ads including this exclusive content, hand edited transcripts and so much more. Check out the link in the show notes for more. Today's episode is all about rethinking modern relationships, from first dates to breakups and everything in between. My guest is Logan Urie, a behavioral scientist, dating coach and the director of Relationship Science at Hinge. She's the best selling author of how not to Die Alone and a leading expert in how we form, maintain and end relationships. Logan challenges some of our biggest myths about dating, including the idea that you need to wait for the spark Instead. She shares what really matters in a long term partner, someone you're genuinely interested in, who makes you feel good and who brings out the best in you. We cover how to approach dating apps and first dates with the right mindset, why clear communication is everything, and how to navigate a difficult conversation in love and beyond. I've got to be honest, I feel a bit vulnerable putting this conversation out there. I share more about my personal life and mindset than I have before, but I'm hoping someone out there can relate and feel less alone in their journey to find a partner. So whether you're looking for that partner, trying to strengthen your relationship, or just hoping to better connect with the people in your life, this conversation is filled with insights to help get you there. It's time to listen and learn. I want to start at the beginning, which would be a first date. Great You've reframed this from I want to find my soulmate to do. I want to spend more time with this person. Walk me through that.
- [03:04]
Logan Urie
A lot of people on a first date put so much pressure on themselves. They're really thinking about, could I spend the rest of my life with this person? I'm really busy. Would I want to see them again? I'm going to treat this like a job interview where I ask, what's your five year plan and what did you study in college? And really interviewing this person for the role of spouse. And then, of course, people don't feel any spark or any excitement. And so I like to take the pressure off of a first date and say, this is really an opportunity to have an experience with somebody else, to have some fun. And then if you have a good time, you can see them again. And you don't have to overthink it and think, is this person who I want to spend the rest of my life with?
- [03:44]
Shane Parrish
So I've been guilty of this in terms of the spark. You know, you walk away from a first date and you're like, yeah, they're a nice person, but maybe they're boring, or you didn't feel that instant romantic connection. And what do you think about the spark? I mean, we all look for the spark.
- [04:01]
Logan Urie
Yeah. So the spark is very exciting. Who doesn't want to have that feeling of fireworks and instant chemistry with someone? But through the work I've done, I've actually come to see the spark as a bit of my nemesis. Because I have coaching clients who say to me, logan, I went out with this guy, he was great. We had a good time. Oh, I'm not gonna see him again. Like, what are you talking about? And they say, I just didn't feel the spark. And so in our culture, people have come to expect that if you don't have that instant feeling, then it must not be your person. And instead, I teach my coaching clients about the three myths of the spark. So the first myth is that if you don't have the spark, then it can't grow. And that's absolutely not true. So we know from research that only 11% of people feel love at first sight. And that means many people are getting to know someone over time. Maybe they live in the same apartment building, they work in the same place, and that attraction and appreciation grows over time. So the spark can definitely grow. The second myth is that if you feel the spark, it's definitely a good thing. And actually, sometimes certain people give us the spark because we Actually don't know how they feel about us. So sort of that hot, cold feeling makes us wonder, does he like. Does he not like me? And through that, we end up feeling what we think of as butterflies or chemistry, but is actually anxiety, and it's actually alarm bells in our head going off. Do they like me? Do they not like me? Am I accepted? And so sometimes it's actually a sign of either the person giving you a hot, cold feeling, or it can be somebody who's a narcissist. I've also found that, let's say I go to an event and I talk to some of my girlfriends later, and I'll say, oh, I really like that guy. We really hit it off. And then they're like, wait, I really hit it off with that guy. And we realized we all had what felt like unique connections to this person, but they were actually just really sparky. And I imagine you meet a lot of people through doing this that are really sparky. And so certain people just give off that spark. And it's not about your dynamic with them. It's about who they are. And then the third myth is that if you have a spark, the relationship is viable. We also know that that's not true. Just because you met the right way doesn't mean that it's the right relationship. And so you can have a very sparky beginning, but it can fizzle out quickly, and you shouldn't stay in the relationship because you had a really good we met story. And so my antidote to the spark is going after the slow burn. And the slow burn is somebody who you like them more and more as you get to know them. They may not be instantly the most charismatic person that you've ever met, but they're really a quality person, and they really grow on you. And. And not because you're settling, but because you're looking for love in a different package than you originally thought. You're not just looking for the life of the party person that's immediately as charismatic. And so I feel like I'm married to a slow burn. I met my husband in college. We met again at Google a number of years later, and now we've been together for almost 10 years. And so he's somebody where I really feel like as I got to know him more and more, I liked him more and more. And so I really encourage people to go after the slow burn.
- [07:17]
Shane Parrish
But wait a second, because what ends up happening in this is, like, you go out on a date, and you're like, maybe. Maybe Not. And back in, you know, 1950, you'd have that maybe. Maybe it was good enough to go out again, and then you'd see the person again. But now you go home and you. You pick up your app and you open hinge. You open whatever app you're using, and you had a average, but maybe slightly above average date. That could be a slow burn. And now you got 16 new messages from all these people who are more exciting. And how do you do a slow burn in that case? When all of these people, oh, like, look at this person. They're hot. Oh, they want to text me and they want to see me, and, you know, this guy or girl that I just went out with is like, oh, they set something up next week. But that's the slow burn. How do you date in this environment?
- [08:07]
Logan Urie
Yes. So when I wrote my book, I have a chapter called make the second date the default. And this was influenced by one of my mentors, Dan Ariely. And the idea here was that if you go on a first date and you think about it as I'm gonna be evaluating you the whole time, and you're gonna either win a second date or not, it puts you in this evaluative mindset. Instead, I want people to be in this experiential mindset where they're asking themselves how the moment feels for them if they're connecting with the person. And so in the book, I say assume that every first date you go on, you'll go on a second date. And that will help you identify the slow bur and to really take the pressure off the first date. Well, since the book has come out, I feel like that advice is not that realistic. People are busy. People sometimes feel like I had no connection with that person. I'm not gonna go on a second date with them. So I have changed my advice since the book came out, and instead of thinking about it as make the second date the default, my go to advice here is really to do the post date 8. So the post date 8 is a series of questions that I came up with for a client who was having a hard time deciding if she wanted to see someone again, and also somebody who was having a hard time spotting the slow burn. So when you finish the date, you look at this, you can have a screenshot on your phone or, you know, memorize the questions, and they ask you things like, how did I feel in my body during the date? Did I feel stiff? Did I feel relaxed? Did this person make me laugh? Did this person make me feel heard? Did I feel curious about the person and probably the most important one, what side of me did they bring out? Because whatever side of you you are with that person is who you'll be for a big majority of your life if you end up with that person.
- [09:54]
Shane Parrish
This episode is brought to you by Indeed. When your computer breaks, you don't wait for it to magically start working again. You fix the problem. So why wait to hire the people your company desperately needs? Use Indeed sponsored jobs to hire top talent fast. And even better, you only pay for results. There's no need to wait. Speed up your hiring with a $75 sponsored job credit@ Indeed.com podcast terms and conditions apply. Imagine what's possible when learning doesn't get in the way of life at Capella University. Our game changing flexpath learning format lets you set your own deadline so you can learn at a time and pace that works for you. It's an education you can tailor to your schedule. That means you don't have to put your life on hold to pursue your professional goals. Instead, enjoy learning your way and earn your degree without missing a beat. A different future is closer than you think with Capella University. Learn more at Capella.
- [10:52]
Logan Urie
Edu and so the post date 8 is a great way to see if it was really a dud and you were zero percent interested. Forget it. Don't go on the second date. But if there was maybe not the most charisma that you've ever encountered, or there's been people that you've been more attracted to in the past, it's fine to acknowledge that. But to think there was a seed of something that was planted that I'd like to give another chance to. And so the post 88 is a great way to see when there's potential and to really spot those slow burn people.
- [11:23]
Shane Parrish
Talk to me a little bit more about what side they brought out in you. I've never thought of it that way, but looking back through some of my dates through this lens, I'm like, oh, I was defensive, I was confrontational, I was, yeah, go through that a little bit more.
- [11:38]
Logan Urie
Yeah, I'm glad that you're double clicking into that because it's really something that I think about in a lot of areas of my life. So when I was just making this career shift into the work that I do now, I met with a lot of different people to learn from them. And I'm not gonna say her name, but there was one person in particular that whenever I met with her I would just come home and sort of collapse into the couch and wanna watch TV for the next few hours. And I was like, what's going on with me? And I was like, there's something about the way that she communicates that makes me feel and anxious and like I don't know what I'm doing and not good enough. There was just something about the words that she used or the questions that she was asking. And so that's a platonic situation or, you know, it's about career. But in that moment I understood. I don't really enjoy being around this person because she brings out a side of me that's insecure. Then I think about my friend Mikayla, who's one of my favorite people in the world. When I'm around her, she laughs a lot. She makes me feel hilarious. We wanna stay up all night talking because she makes me feel creative and gener. So I really will do whatever I can to be in the same room as her because she brings out a side of myself that I love. And so when people are dating, especially as they get older, their checklists of what they think they need get longer and longer. So that checklist might look like must be financially independent, must own their own home, must be this tall, must want exactly this lifestyle. And so when they go into that date, they are really looking at those things which are often who that person is on paper. And then they ignore how they feel around that person. Because sure, you need some basic biographical data to decide if you want to go out with someone or not, but once you're on that date, it's really about paying attention to who am I around them.
- [13:25]
Shane Parrish
I love that. And that applies to all areas of your life. Is it your job in that moment to dissect why you're having that response or is it to just, I just don't want to be around this person. And that's okay.
- [13:39]
Logan Urie
I mean, my cheeky answer would be, it's my job as your dating coach to tell you that. But no, I think that in life it really is great to dig into things like that. So it might be. I'm just remembering this story where like early on when I shifted into doing the dating and relationship stuff, I met up with this guy and I thought it was like a peer to peer conversation. And when I got there, he kind of leaned back and said, so what can I do for you? And it was like that one statement kind of created a power dynamic which was like, I have power and I can help you. And I remember it really threw me off. And so When I went home and I didn't feel good and I reflected on it, I was like, oh, maybe our expectations weren't the same going into it. Or the person who did the intro didn't set us up for success. And so I made changes so that in the future, when I had an intro like that, I was clearer with the person introducing us, you know, what our goals were, things like that. Or I find that if I'm really tired and I push myself to go to an event, I may not have a good time there because I don't have energy to give. And so I think for everyone, being more in touch with who you are, how you show up in different situations, what personality traits trigger you to feel more anxious or insecure, all of that is data that just helps you be a happier person. And so something that I really promote people do is date like a scientist, which is this idea of have hypotheses. So a hypothesis could be, I need to date somebody with a graduate degree, but then test that hypothesis. Maybe what you actually care about is intellectual curiosity and somebody who listens to the knowledge project, not somebody who has a master's degree or a Ph.D. and so really having a hypothesis, testing it, and then being willing to be willing to be proven right or wrong. I think if we all live like a scientist and date like a scientist, we learn so much about ourselves, we push ourselves, and we actually wind up in a much happier place than if we just follow all the assumptions in our head.
- [15:42]
Shane Parrish
I want to double click on the date like a scientist thing a little bit and maybe I'll bring an anonymous friend into this who runs a business, very successful, very ambitious, very wealthy. In theory, he checks all these boxes that women would want, but in reality, I mean, his saying is they don't want. What comes with that is that what do you mean by dating like a scientist in the checklist? And maybe I'm loosely working around this.
- [16:08]
Logan Urie
Yeah. So I would say a majority of my clients at this point are sort of more powerful male CEOs. And I feel like it is interesting to just hear, you know, women are excited about what they have access to, but then they may not understand that this person works 18 hours a day or that maybe this person has a chip on their shoulder because when they weren't successful, they felt like they didn't get a lot of attention. And so I feel like the unique problems of that situation are something that I've dealt with. So just breaking down date like a scientist. When I work with people in my coaching in my courses, people walk in with assumptions of what they need. So it might be, I need to date somebody who's 6ft or taller because I'm a taller woman and that's what makes me feel feminine. So then I might say to them, hey, in the United States, only 14% of men are 6ft or taller. So now you are eliminating 86% of the male population you've been actively dating for 12 years. This has not worked out for you so far. Why don't you change your filter on the dating apps, be willing to date somebody who's shorter and see maybe what you actually care about is somebody who's confident where your height doesn't feel like a factor. Maybe you'll end up with somebody a lot shorter than you. And this is what happened to a man and a woman that I know because it's not about how tall the guy is, it's about how they make you feel. And so her dating like a scientist moment would be changing her filters on the app, dating some men who are shorter, seeing if she can feel attracted to them and attractive with them, and then understanding it wasn't height that was the deal breaker. It was confidence or how attracted she was to them and how attractive they made her.
- [17:54]
Shane Parrish
That 6ft thing is like such a killer. I'm like 511 and 3 quarters. It's like, what do you do? Do you say six feet or do you do five'eleven in which case every woman has this like six feet.
- [18:06]
Logan Urie
The height thing is really interesting. So I would say over the last few years, the posts of mine that have gone the most viral are reels where I've posted about this stat because in the comments you have a lot of women saying, well, guys lie about their height anyway. And then guys say things like, yeah, you should change the height filter. And then women say, well, you filter based on weight. And so anyway, it's just really interesting to see how much this bothers people. And I wish that I could kind of shout from the rooftops to everyone and say, imagine that you were in a bar and you were sitting next to somebody and you're both sitting on stools and you have a 45 minute conversation that is incredible. It's deep, it's soulful, it's mind blowing. And at the end of the date, the guy stands up and he's 5 7. Are you telling me that you're not giving him your number now? No, of course you're gonna give him your number because you just saw who this person was and what an incredible connection you had. And in that moment, you're not thinking height first, you're thinking connection first. And I really want people to change their framework and to understand, yes, the filters exist, but you are filtering out so many great potential connections. Why not date like a scientist? See if these things that you think are deal breakers are really deal breakers, when of the time they're not, and move them to the pet peeves or nice to have column.
- [19:28]
Shane Parrish
It strikes me as a difference between how we used to date and how we date now. So we used to date in a way that, like, a guy would call on you. You might not know him well, you might have friends, you might have met through your parents or something, but you don't know much about him. And then you spend time with him. So your first impressions. But now we're filtering before you even get to that point. We're filtering based on a dating profile, we're filtering based on pictures, we're filtering based on politics, we're filtering based all of these things. I wanna come back to the spark thing. Is there a difference between the spark and lust?
- [20:01]
Logan Urie
I've thought about this a lot, because when you write a book, you're writing it alone. Maybe a few people read it and your editor reads it. And then when it's out into the world, you really get to see what takes off with people. And so I would say a few things have taken off, and one of them is this concept of fuck the spark. And so people have really strong reactions when I say that because they feel like, oh, Logan's telling me I shouldn't be attracted to the person. Or it doesn't. Logan's telling me to settle. Wait. I said, fuck the spark. And then I met someone I wasn't interested in and I dated them for six months and it didn't work out. And so I really wanna talk about what the spark is. The spark is a huge emphasis on instant chemistry and instant connection versus allowing it to grow over time. I would say that lust is about attraction. And a lot of times, you know, I wanna have sex with this person. I hope this person wants to have sex with me. And I think being sexually attracted to someone is of course, something that you should look a relationship. But it's slightly different from the spark, which is this overall feeling of, like, when I meet someone, I want to be around them more and more. And the big message I'm trying to get across here is that that feeling of chemistry can grow over time.
- [21:15]
Shane Parrish
What should a first date look like to maximize information Gathering or connection? I guess.
- [21:22]
Logan Urie
Yeah. You know, I will even push on that question and say I don't think it's about information gathering. Imagine that you spend 50 years with someone. The day that you meet is 0.0055% of your total time with them. And so it's not about gathering information. It's about having an experience with them. So one thing that I've done through my research is look at people who are consistently getting asked on second or third dates. Look at people who people really are drawn to. And when I talk to these people, it's not what you might think. They're the tallest people, they're the hottest people. It's often that they're very fun. They meet up with you on a date and they tell you a funny story, or they have a silly interaction with the bartender, or they tell you about what happened at work that day and the funny situation that they got into. There's something about them that's very vibrant and lively. And when people are around them, they feel like they are also having an experience. They're not just exchanging information. And so I think if we think that a first date is really about I need to leave and know your biography, that's not really fun for either person. If it instead shifts to what I was talking about. Our first date is about seeing how does it feel to be around the person. What side of me do they bring out? Those dates end up being so much more successful because even if they don't lead to a relationship, they lead to you knowing how would it feel to be with this person?
- [22:49]
Shane Parrish
I like that a lot. What are the indicators that I should be looking for on a date that would lead to emotional connection?
- [22:58]
Logan Urie
So one thing that I've looked at a lot is this idea of what matters more and less than we think for long term relationship success. So a lot of the things that people think matter more than they do include things like looks and money. So of course looks matter. We just talked about lust. You want to feel attracted to the person. But I wouldn't give anyone the advice of try to date or marry the hottest person that you've ever met or the person maybe who you've had the hottest sex with in your life. Because like many things in life, our brains adapt to them over time. And so if you think about some of the most beautiful celebrities in the world, there are often people kind of known to humanity who have cheated on them. And so it's like if even these people that are considered the most attractive by cultural Standards are being cheated on. There's this idea that people adapt over time to somebody's life, and even if someone's really attractive will get used to that over time. The same thing is true with money. I know this amount of money has changed over the last few years, but, you know, they used to say, happiness doesn't change over $75,000. Now I think they've raised it. But it's this idea that whatever amount of money you have, you get used to a few more things that matter less than people think they do. So people think we need to have all the same hobbies. If I love wine, I want someone who loves wine too. And you don't actually have to share the same hobbies. You just need to support the other person's hobbies and have them support yours so that you can continue investing in that hobby. And you don't have to have the same personality. Sometimes people will say, I have a big personality. I love to go out. I want to find a woman who does the same thing. And I'm like, no way. Two of you in a room, two of you at a dinner party, two of you in a relationship, that's way too much. I want you to find somebody who grounds you. And it's often about being complimentary versus being the same. So that was really the category of matters less than we think it does for the things that matter more than people think they do. So the first one is loyalty. Really? Is this somebody who will stick by you? Of course, that's a hard thing to find out on a first date. But one proxy for that that I've found is asking people about old friendships. People who have friendships from different phases of their life. Do they hang on to people, or when they do, they let those go, or are they social climbing and always trying to trade up? So does this person keep friends from different phases of their lives? Another one is emotional stability. And that's also hard to figure out on a first date. But how does this person deal with adversity? How does this person deal with frustrations? Are they somebody who can sort of pause and think before they react? Another one is the ability to make hard decisions together. So early in dating, you're maybe not making a lot of hard decisions together, but pay attention to how you talk about things. Like if one person wants to meet up near their house and the other person wants to meet up near their house, are you debating it? Are you compromising it? Are they listening to your needs? There's so many ways to really perceive who Someone is if you're actually looking for these things and then the one that I've been talking about, which is what side of you they bring out and really thinking about the dynamic itself and that understanding that a relationship is not about two instruments on their own, but it's about the music that you're making together and really paying attention to almost this third object of the dynamic between the two of you as opposed to just who that person is on their own.
- [26:31]
Shane Parrish
I had a friend who made this comment, well, we just adjust to what we have and then we kind of like we are human so we yearn for something different than what we have.
- [26:42]
Logan Urie
Yeah. My husband is very scientific and he's worked in a lot of different labs and when we first started dating early on he said some quote to me or he was telling me about some study which is like, there's a male rat in a cage and they put in a female rat and at first they have sex, but over time the male rat gets sick of having sex with that female rat. But then if you keep replacing the rat with new female rats, that male rat will have sex with those female rats until it literally passes out from exhaustion. And so it's just this idea of yes, a lot of what is sexually exciting to people is novelty. And so instead of being disappointed or frustrated by that in a monogamous long term relationship, you can just think about the fact that I acknowledge that that will happen. And so I'm not gonna spend all of my partner choosing coins just on looks because that's not a good long term strategy.
- [27:34]
Shane Parrish
Do you think we've sort of broken dating in a way where, I mean, I've been on dates with people, we all know people who are. I wish people would come up to me and ask me, I, I wish I didn't have to use a dating app. And my defensive, you know, thinking immediately in this is like society has taught guys not to approach women anymore. What's your reaction to that?
- [27:55]
Logan Urie
This is something that I'm thinking about a lot, specifically with Gen Z and Gen Alpha. So I was recently speaking to somebody, she's a 16 year old entrepreneur and she's trying to deliver help for teen daters. And she said by far the number one thing that she gets questions about is, is how to deal with rejection. And so I am genuinely concerned that because of different societal factors, because of people who maybe lost out on some social skills during the pandemic, because of people who live a lot of their lives online, there is not that rejection resilience that many of us need in life. So if you want your dream job, you need to go out there, get a lot of no's, and go after it. You don't just sit at home waiting for a LinkedIn recruiter to message you about your dream job. That that doesn't happen. You have to make it happen. And the same thing is true with dating is that you have to shoot your shot. You have to approach people in public. You have to take a risk. And so I'm encountering a lot of people who are very afraid of rejection and are not taking those risks. And I think that it's leading to fewer relationships.
- [29:02]
Shane Parrish
I'm a make it happen kind of person. I can tell in work and in life. I also know that that can come off as aggressive or assertive. How do you deal with that?
- [29:13]
Logan Urie
That's interesting. So what's a scenario that you feel like could come across the wrong way?
- [29:18]
Shane Parrish
Well, I'll make it happen. Is like, you have a great first date or something, and then you're instantly onto the next date. You know, you're like, I want to see you again. How about tomorrow? And then the other person, I don't know. I feel like we're just in a society now where you're supposed to wait till tomorrow almost. And. And I hate personally waiting. I'm sure there's other people out there like me too, where it's like, no, you're in charge. You have agency, and you can make the world happen.
- [29:45]
Logan Urie
I love this question because I think it speaks to a really real phenomenon where people are experiencing excitement about somebody, but they feel like they need to hold it back to seem cool. And so I love to talk to people about attachment theory. Has that come up on your podcast before?
- [29:59]
Shane Parrish
No. Let's go into it.
- [30:00]
Logan Urie
Okay. So attachment theory is something in the world of relationship science that's truly backed by the research that first came about around 60 years ago with someone named John Bowlby. And this research was originally done with children to see their attachments to their primary caregiver. But now we have an entire field of adult attachment, specifically around relationships. And so there are people who are anxiously attached. What happens for them is their story of love is that I'm gonna chase you. I have to convince you to like me. You might pull away, and we're gonna have this chase dynamic and that I'm constant worried that you're not gonna be interested in me and you're gonna disappear. So how those people show up in relationships. And I know because I really Was one of these daters is if you don't hear back from somebody, you start spiraling. They met somebody else, they don't like me anymore. You send a bunch of texts to try to reconnect with them, and you're often just in this danger zone where you're not being the person that you want to be because you're trying to have this reconnection moment. You think somebody's gonna pull away. Then there's people who are avoidant attached. They sort of have the opposite experience. Their version of love is, I'm gonn, I'm gonna lose my independence. And when they get too close to somebody, they are the ones pulling away. So they're the ones, you know, great sleepover on a Saturday night, Sunday morning, they wake up, the person hasn't left, and they're like, damn, should I call her an Uber?
- [31:26]
Shane Parrish
Oh, my God, that's me.
- [31:27]
Logan Urie
That's you? Yeah. You have that feeling of like, I need my space.
- [31:30]
Shane Parrish
Well, I need my space and I don't wanna get hurt. There's like an element of vulnerability.
- [31:35]
Logan Urie
Absolutely. What you're talking about is completely true. It's not that those people don't wanna be in intimate connection. It's that the fear of being or the fear of being hurt causes them to pull away. I'm gonna reject you before you reject me. And so for those avoidant attached people who think that they're gonna be smothered, and then for the anxiously attached people who think they're gonna be abandoned, what ends up happening is they often date each other and they reinforce this idea. So I think that love is a chase. You think that love is being smothered. So when I go after you, you pull away. That reinforces mine and that reinforces yours. And anxious attached and avoidant people keep dating each other in this anxious avo that leaves both people feeling pretty unhappy. But there's a third type of securely attached people, and these are people who have a healthy relationship with independence and with intimacy. I wanna be close to you, but I also respect and need my alone time. And so often the way that people get out of the anxious avoidant loop is they either become more secure themselves or they date someone who's secure. And so that's what happened for me after, you know, 10 years of chasing after different people, being rejected, being disappoint, thinking, well, if only I could prove my value, then this guy would like me instead. When I dated somebody who was secure, it broke a lot of those patterns, and we formed what I feel like, is my first really healthy relationship. What happens is 50% of the population is secure, which sounds like a good thing. But those people are so good at being in relationships that they often get snatched up. And you have the anxious and avoidant people dating each other. But in the example that you described, it can actually be very secure for somebody to follow up after a date and say, hey, hey, I really enjoyed getting to know you. I'd love to see you again. When are you free? And in that moment, somebody who's used to dating somebody who's avoidant might be like, whoa, they're coming on too strong. Or, that's so obvious. They're so obviously interested. That's boring. But a ton of the work that I do is training people to identify secure partners and to reestablish them in their heads. Not as boring, but as secure. And to know that those are the people to go after. So sometimes that person who pulls away is exciting, that sparky feeling, because you don't know if they like you or not. But instead, really honoring the person who says, I like you, I'm interested. When can I see you again? And so the slight tweak that I would have to yours is not, I like you. Can I see you tomorrow? That does kind of feel a little bit intense. But being clear about, like, hey, that was a really great date. I feel like we really connected. I'd love to see you again. And then, like, working together to come up with the next date. And a lot of dating that people miss is that it's about matching somebody's momentum and matching somebody's speed. So it's a dance where I take a step forward, and then you need to take a step forward. If I take 10 steps forward, you might feel overwhelmed and take a step back. So just paying attention to, are you always the one reaching out? Are you always the one making plans? There needs to be momentum matching for the speed to feel right to both people.
- [34:40]
Shane Parrish
So last year, I realized something was getting in the way of myself. What sparked this in our conversation was freedom. And so I decided to do therapy for the first time as my adult life as a single person. I did marriage counseling as well before my divorce. But it was so fascinating to me because one of the things that led to this was I would. Wouldn't accept compliments from people.
- [35:06]
Logan Urie
Oh.
- [35:06]
Shane Parrish
The minute somebody started to say something positive, my brain would turn off, and I would instantly move to the groceries. What's next in the conversation? I'd stop listening.
- [35:16]
Logan Urie
Yeah.
- [35:17]
Shane Parrish
And what came out of this Is that compliments in my body, I had somehow associated compliments with power over me, because at some point they were taken away. And so it was like, I'll compliment you as long as you do what I want. And then all of a sudden. And so I would associate these things. And so I developed this really strong aversion to people having power over me. And so loss of freedom is a great example of, like, how that manifests itself in dating, where it's like, no. Like, that's really hard in dating context, because I default to this state of I want to continue to do the things that I'm doing and the way I'm continuing to do them. And that makes it really hard to find somebody and build a life together and adapt to each other.
- [36:07]
Logan Urie
That's super interesting. So for the compliments, was it that you grew up in a home where there was a strong sense of external validation if you did the right thing, and then you felt like you constantly had to please someone and the compliments were a sign that you were doing the right thing, but then they could be taken away if you didn't do the right thing.
- [36:26]
Shane Parrish
I don't quite know. A lot of people remember a ton about their childhood. Yeah, I don't. I remember certain moments and, like, not a lot before grade eight, to be honest with you. And I was like, I got into a ton of trouble as a kid. I was a bit of a misfit. But the thing that I learned at a very young age was just not to pay attention to them.
- [36:45]
Logan Urie
See. Cause that could also be a positive thing where you have an internal locus of control that's not looking to other people. Like, even my daughter is one. And she started doing this toy. Maybe you remember it where it's like, you know, there's a stick and then you put the different round things on top of it. And when she does it, every time she puts one on, she claps and she doesn't even smile. She just thinks that that's part of how the toy works. You put it on and then you clap for yourself. Because when she does it, we clap for her. I was like, she's a brand new human in the world and she's already learning that, that she's doing things for external validation. Or it's. The clapping, to me, is really bothering me, where I'm like, we're not gonna clap anymore. We cannot reward her for every single thing, because then she will be doing it for us and not for herself. And so it's so interesting that compliments shut you down.
- [37:33]
Shane Parrish
Well, they used to. I've done much better since then at sort of being vulnerable. Like, I never wanted to be vulnerable. I would get to this point, and this goes back to the attachment styles is I needed to feel like somebody else couldn't hurt me or take something away because I'm giving them power over me in a way, power to hurt me.
- [37:51]
Logan Urie
But was that.
- [37:51]
Shane Parrish
I don't know. I'm messed up. If you're listening to this.
- [37:54]
Logan Urie
Okay, I'm just gonna push this topic. Cause I think it's so interesting, but on my first date with my husband, he told me that when people tease him or troll him or it actually makes him feel very close to them. Because something inside of him was like, I'm a piece of shit. So if somebody likes. If somebody sort of calls that out, it makes him feel known and like, I don't know.
- [38:16]
Shane Parrish
Oh, it's like, you see me.
- [38:17]
Logan Urie
Yeah. So I don't know that that happens all the time. But, like, it is something that I've seen with certain people who are maybe more powerful or dominant, is that when somebody actually calls them out on stuff, it makes them feel like, oh, I can trust that person because they see my flaws and they know from the beginning what my flaws are. I don't have to put up a front of seeming perfect all the. And then disappointing them. Like, this is a whole rabbit hole of like, I don't wanna let somebody in. Because if they knew the real me, then they would reject me.
- [38:48]
Shane Parrish
Yeah, totally. If you saw all of me, then you wouldn't. I'm not lovable is effectively what you're doing.
- [38:53]
Logan Urie
That is such a big part of the work that I do is this idea of people come to me and they think I'm undateable.
- [39:00]
Shane Parrish
Yeah.
- [39:00]
Logan Urie
Do you feel that way generally?
- [39:03]
Shane Parrish
Yeah.
- [39:03]
Logan Urie
You feel undateable?
- [39:04]
Shane Parrish
Well, I feel unlovable.
- [39:05]
Logan Urie
Like, I. Yeah, let's use those words synonymously.
- [39:08]
Shane Parrish
If somebody saw all of me and could see my inner monologue and just had, like, full access to me, then they wouldn't love me. Of course.
- [39:17]
Logan Urie
I think that's extremely common. And it has different ways that it comes up. So some people say to me, you know, I have a chronic illness. I'm unlovable. I have an sti. I'm unlovable. I've never been in a relationship. I'm unlovable. I've been in too many relationships. I'm unlovable. And so many people have this inner narrative around how if somebody really, really knew them, they wouldn't love me. And what's so hard for people to understand is, like, it's often that vulnerability and that imperfection that connects people. Because I think about friends of mine or people I know who come across as perfect, and I'm like, you have such a glossy exterior that there's nothing for me to grab onto. I actually need cracks in the wall to grasp onto and to have a connection with you and to feel like I can be my full, imperfect self. And so it's like the thing that we think makes us unlovable is often what makes somebody feel comfortable around us. But if we truly feel like we're unlovable, we never open up and give somebody the chance to see that for themselves.
- [40:19]
Shane Parrish
Go further with the American Express Business Gold Card earn 3 times Membership Rewards points on flights and prepaid hotels when you book through amextravel.com whether your destination is a business conference or a client meeting. Your purchases will help you earn more points for future trips. Experience more on your travels with AMEX Business Gold. Terms apply. Learn more@american express.com Business Gold AmEx Business Gold Card built for business by American Express I want to come back to sort of dating just a little bit and profiles, like how you end up on a first date. One thing that I think everybody does these days is they Google the other person. And for whatever reason, I mean, people think this doesn't happen. I don't know why. Like, you can upload photos from dating websites and find out who the person is fairly easily. How does that work for you and against you?
- [41:15]
Logan Urie
It's so interesting. So there's research on the brain that shows when our brain gets an incomplete picture of something, we fill in the gaps in a way that makes it more positive. So have you ever seen a black and white photo of yourself and think, huh, I look pretty good in that?
- [41:33]
Shane Parrish
I've never seen a photo of myself or I think I look pretty good.
- [41:36]
Logan Urie
Okay, well, take a photo of yourself and make it black and white and you might be like, huh, Photoshop it. Looking pretty good there. And the point is that by taking out the color and actually some of the information, our brain fills in the gap and it actually often looks more attractive than it does. The same thing happens on dating app profiles. So if somebody says, I love music, our brains fill in the gap and think, oh, they love music. You know, I really like hip hop. I bet they like the same music that I do. And with this incomplete picture, we start building up this fantasy in our head. And that's why People get into this really bad situation where they start talking to somebody and they're almost pen palling and having all these text conversations and building up this fantasy. And by the time they meet in person, that person's great. But they're not the fantasy you had in your head. And so you reject them because they're different from who you thought they were. And that's why it's so important that people get to the date faster. Honestly. Meet on hinge and a few days later we've actually found that the sweet spot is after three days of chatting, just say, hey, I always walk my dog at 6pm Can I give you a phone call? Or do you wanna FaceTime for a few minutes tonight? And instead of turning the digital courtship phase into this weeks long thing, make it much shorter. Get on the phone, get on FaceTime, see if you have a connection, and then meet up in person as quickly as possible. And so I actually think the point is to, to learn who the person is by talking to them directly versus either having your brain fill in the gaps or doing all this external research that might be incorrect or outdated.
- [43:06]
Shane Parrish
So two rabbit holes I want to go down here. Well, actually, one comment. It's interesting that you said we fill in our own gaps. Matthew Dix, who's the Olympic storytelling champion of the world, effectively was on the podcast and one of the things that you said that just triggered this is when he was describing, he's like, I describe, but vaguely so everybody sees their own thing. If I say kitchen floor, I don't describe like green linoleum tiles because the minute I say that, people might have a hard time picturing it, but everybody knows what their kitchen floor is. So he used this example of I'm in the back of my school, my back is up against the wall. And he's like, it doesn't matter what my school looks like because everybody has this own image of their school. And I don't know why, but I.
- [43:51]
Logan Urie
Connected those two things just to comment on that. Like, I definitely wanna listen to that episode. Was it an episode you recorded with him? Yes, because I'd love to learn from that because you know, a big part of my job is communicating. And it's so true that stories are really the filing system of our brain.
- [44:07]
Shane Parrish
Totally.
- [44:08]
Logan Urie
And I was thinking last night about the story of the boy who cried wolf. And I was like, it's so smart that we teach kids fables because if somebody had sat me down and said, if you raise a lot of false alarms when it's A real alarm. No one's gonna listen. Like, I wouldn't remember, but the Boy who Cried Wolf. It's so memorable. It's like, that's why we have these oral storytelling traditions. And even, like, you know, why the Bible is the greatest meme of all time. People really remember these stories. And so that is a good tip that I'm going to use, which is, you know, you want to be speaking about visuals, but maybe vague enough details that people can insert their own version of the kitchen floor. I love that.
- [44:45]
Shane Parrish
You should listen to the episode I did with Becky Kennedy, too. She talks about how she made up stories to teach her kids lessons.
- [44:52]
Logan Urie
That's really cool.
- [44:53]
Shane Parrish
Which it is so powerful. It's such a powerful. Because we remember stories, we don't remember facts, not at all digits.
- [44:58]
Logan Urie
And that's actually part of dating advice that I give people. So, you know, I have people who come in who are amazing communicators, really charming. They just kind of have a few things holding them back from connecting. And we work on that. I have other people who come in who have never been on a date in their life. From that starting point, we really have to start talking about, like, how do you have a good conversation? And so one of the key ideas there, you basically just said these words is share stories, not facts. And so what's an example of that? Well, a fact would be that you have a younger brother. A story would be your younger brother lives across the country from you. You haven't met your niece yet. You feel sad about the lack of connection with that person. And one of your resolutions is to really get closer to your brother. And so I think oftentimes when people are less experienced with first date conversations, they share the facts about their life lives, and it's not memorable and it's boring. And really think about the emotions and the feelings and the stories behind those facts, because that's what a good conversation is.
- [46:00]
Shane Parrish
Walk me through a little bit more about good conversations on a first date. I think a lot of people tend to just have this list of questions almost that they're like, it doesn't quite feel like an interview, but it kind of feels like an interview. On the same token, how do you get out of that?
- [46:18]
Logan Urie
Okay, let's think of examples. So I think a bad question would be, what did you study in college? I think then you're just finding out about a fact about somebody about their major. I think a good question would be something like, oh, you just told me that your job was a marketing manager for this tech company, how is that different from what you thought it would be? Or. Or can you see yourself doing that for a long time? Or, like, what changes would you want to make to it? And that one might be a little interview y. But I think the point is that if you go on a first date and you're information seeking, then what you will get is facts. If you go on a date and you're connection seeking, then what you will get are stories.
- [47:03]
Shane Parrish
I like that. That's a good way to do it. One of the things you brought up was having a phone call first. Is that like the recommended product?
- [47:11]
Logan Urie
Yeah. So before the pandemic, I did not like the idea of video dates or phone calls before a first date. To me, it triggered this idea of like a tech job and a phone screen, like that 15 minute call with the Google recruiter to see if you're crazy or not. And I felt like it was going to create too much of a feeling of, okay, I saw who you were, I'm not interested in you, I'm out. But during the pandemic, that was the only way that people could really date for a while. And so there was this proliferation of video chats or phone dates. And I actually felt like they were a great technique for people to just see, can we hold a conversation? Are they who they say they are? It makes people feel more safe before meeting up for the first time. It helps people who are really busy, like executives or single parents, feel like, is this somebody who I want to get a babysitter for in order to meet up with them? And so now I actually think that it's a really helpful technique for a lot of.
- [48:07]
Shane Parrish
And what do you cover on that call? Like, say it's 15 minutes. Like, you're just trying to get a feel for the person, like the awkwardness. Or like, what do you.
- [48:15]
Logan Urie
Yeah, you know, I think that you could start the conversation and just start talking about your day. So, for example, I like to tell people about this concept of in media res, which is a Latin term that means in the middle of things. So a play might open up in the middle of a battle scene, and then it sort of zooms out and later you find out who's in the battle, why are they in the battle, what's going on. But it really just captures your attention right away. And so you could enter a date or a phone call and say, hey, I'm Logan. This is where I live, this is what I do. And like, I'm already asleep just talking about this. But Instead, if you walk in there and you say, so my sister called me this weekend and she's having this issue at work, and she told me this, but I thought that she was handling it the wrong way. What do you think about that? It's like, boom, we're friends. We're having an experience. I'm hearing how you think I'm hearing. If you give good advice, I'm learning about you. I'm not trying to glean information from you and facts about your life. I'm truly trying to get to know you as a person and how you think. And I feel like, for me, as someone who's been with my partner for 10 years, who has a new baby, so much of my life is how my partner thinks. That influences my life. That influences the decisions we make together. It influences whether or not I trust him. And so I really think just creating these conversational dynamics where we're expressing ourselves, we're responding to situations. We're not just repeating the same tape in our head that we press play on in every boring first date. That, to me, is so much more fun and provides such deeper information.
- [49:57]
Shane Parrish
No, I love that. I want to, like, also come back. We're sort of in a rabbit hole here to attachment. You know, I feel like I've taken steps individually towards more secure and away from avoidant attachment. What are the things that we can do short of finding a partner who's safe and secure? Yeah, that reinforces the best in us and gives us patience and tolerance for the worst in us. What are the things that people can do individually to put themselves in a better place? And, you know, you don't have to make that leap overnight, but what are the steps that we can take to get to a better place?
- [50:32]
Logan Urie
Right. So people do tend to have one attachment style, and it's a mixture of genetics and how they were raised. But around 25% of people are able to shift their attachment over time. So if you are insecurely attached, there is hope. It's not just, oh, I need to find one of those securely attached people that's already in a relationship. So for people who are anxiously attached, it's really important to understand triggers for you. So a trigger for somebody who's anxiously attached might be, I text the person I'm seeing all day, but I just sent them a meme. They usually respond to that right away. They haven't responded in four hours. Okay. So a trigger was not hearing back from somebody. What usually happens in that moment is you sort of go down into the Danger zone. And you start texting them a bunch of times, hey, what happened? Or you spiral in your head, they don't like me anymore. They met somebody else. When I said this thing two days ago, they thought it was super weird and they're pulling back. And then they sort of do these behaviors to try to reconnect with the person, which can really turn the other person off. And so instead, set yourself up for success by not getting to the danger zone in the first place. So when you feel like, oh, no, they didn't respond to my text, what are other things you could do? So you could text a friend and distract yourself with the conversation with them. You could even tell a friend, oh, this is what I'm feeling. And make me feel better about it. Give me a pep talk. You can give yourself a pep talk. There's this concept called disconfirming evidence. So basically explaining to yourself, no, they just have a busy day. They're at that conference. They told me that they weren't gonna be in touch. Why am I jumping to conclusions? Let me just wait and see what happens. And so there's different things that you can do to sort of catch yourself before you start doing those protest behavior things like sending them a million texts or calling them and then turning your phone off. For avoidant attached people, it's the same thing. The danger zone is when you feel really overcome by them and that you're losing your independence. And you might notice strategies that happen for you. So with anxiously attached people, it's activating strategies, and with avoidant attached people, it's deactivating strategies. So in your head you start thinking, oh, they're not really that cute. I'm not interested in them. Or, I can't believe she pronounced that word that way. She must not be that smart. So it's almost like you're giving yourself a reason why you don't like them to push away. I wonder if you ever do that.
- [52:56]
Shane Parrish
Oh, totally.
- [52:56]
Logan Urie
Yeah. And so instead, what to do in those moments is to really realize that you need space and just ask for it. So, for example, if you have that Saturday night sleepover and Sunday, you want your space, you can just say, I had so much fun last night. I actually have a big project at work tomorrow that I was gonna spend the majority of today on. Let's make plans for seeing each other later this week. So you are creating that space for yourself. You're not assuming that they are a mind reader and they know that you don't wanna spend the day together, but you're basically stopping the problem before it starts.
- [53:28]
Shane Parrish
I wanna come back. You said texting. What are the rules around texting and dating?
- [53:33]
Logan Urie
What do you think the rules are?
- [53:35]
Shane Parrish
I don't know. What are the rules?
- [53:36]
Logan Urie
Do you think you're a good textbook?
- [53:38]
Shane Parrish
No, I don't think so.
- [53:39]
Logan Urie
What do you think you could work on in your texting with anybody or in dating if you're actively dating?
- [53:47]
Shane Parrish
Just communicating better. I think I'm of an era where I don't pick up the phone.
- [53:52]
Logan Urie
Okay.
- [53:53]
Shane Parrish
And so, like, I. I think I've answered like five phone calls in the past, like two years. They're all from my mom.
- [53:59]
Logan Urie
We've had a phone call.
- [54:00]
Shane Parrish
I know.
- [54:01]
Logan Urie
Was that shocking?
- [54:02]
Shane Parrish
You know, unless it's scheduled, like, if it's unscheduled, I just don't really answer the phone. And I try to communicate over text, but sometimes your nuance doesn't come across. I'm a visual person, so, like, when I make a joke, I usually, like, do something funny with my face. But over text, that can come off as like very dry or cold because there's no emotion attached to it. No emoji. Sometimes it's just like a dry, almost sense of. Of humor or very pointed.
- [54:32]
Logan Urie
Are you a voice note guy? Sometimes I do feel like that helps with sense of humor.
- [54:36]
Shane Parrish
Yeah, totally. So it gets better. But what are the rules around here? And by rules I mean, like, okay, if you've sent two texts and you haven't got a reply, like, are you. You gotta wait. Is it like there's three? Is it five? Is it six? Is it one for one at the start? Like, what is the etiquette around this?
- [54:53]
Logan Urie
So one of my favorite projects I've done over the last five years was a big Gen Z research project at HIND where I followed this group of international Gen Z daters for around six months. And one of the things that came out of it was this idea of digital body language. The fact that we talk a lot about body language. Right. I'm sure this is something that you've thought about in your own life. So if I'm sitting forward, I am really interested in what you're saying. If I'm leaning back, I might feel defensive. Am I averting my eyes? And that your brain is subconsciously interpreting that as whether I'm a threat or whether I'm interested in. In you. And so there's a ton of digital body language, these unspoken cues as to my intentions. And so the hard part about digital body language is we don't all Interpret it the same way. So through this research, there was a woman I remember who said if somebody says K instead of okay, then she thinks they're mad at them. And she's like, specifically, I want them to say okay. Which is like, who would know that that's what she wants? But a K seems rude to her.
- [55:58]
Shane Parrish
Oh, it's just like, sure. Like, if you say sure to somebody, oh, my God.
- [56:01]
Logan Urie
If my sister says got it. I'm like, having a mini panic attack because I'm like, you don't got it. You're mad at me. You're just giving up on this conversation. So I think we all have versions of that. But we did do research at Hinge, looking at to what are the most commonly agreed upon parts of digital body language. So one of them is that actually the double text is okay. So if I text you and we're early dating and I say, hey, I'd love to hear about that show you were talking about. How was it? And then you don't respond, I might feel like, oh, he's not interested. I can never send another text. But sending one more text that either, like, follows up on it or says like, hey, do you wanna go out this week? People don't mind that people are busy, and they understand that sometimes messages get mixed. Another one is one word. Answers are seen as very rude or curt or the person's not interested. So if our text messages look like a lot of blue and a little bit of gray, there's probably a problem there. And so making sure that our messages seem pretty equal. This is kind of going back to the idea of I take a step forward, you take a step forward, building the momentum together. The other thing that comes up around text messages, and it might surprise people how often people talk to me about texting, but a common thing that somebody might say is, I hate texting. I have a job where I keep my phone in my pocket. I love deep work. How can I tell somebody that I am interested in them? I just don't like texting. Or the opposite, which is, I really love spending time with this guy in person, but he's terrible over text. And so the way that I've thought about it is I think that you need to understand as a person the maximum amount of text that you're willing to give and the minimum that you're willing to take. And if the minimum that you need is not within somebody's maximum, you may not be a fit. And it sounds so crazy because it's like you're really not gonna date someone because of your texting styles. But look, that's how a lot of people talk for a lot of the day. And as parents, as busy people, it's like I'm texting with my husband more than I'm really talking to him every single day. And so you need to have some overlap in your minimum and their maximum. And so, you know, kind of a long winded way of saying, I do think that texting styles are really important since that's such a big part of digital courtship. And it's really good to express to somebody what your texting style is and to maybe give them a heads up. Like in the past, I found that sometimes people, like, can't read my tone over text. Just to let you know, like, I'm not the biggest text, but I will do my best to call you or just to make plans and don't read too much into my texting.
- [58:41]
Shane Parrish
Okay, let's come back to mind reading, because you said that, and I've always had the opinion, I would say until maybe the last year, that if somebody knew me and liked me and wanted to be in my life, that they would be able to read my mind and know exactly what I was thinking.
- [58:58]
Logan Urie
Yeah.
- [58:59]
Shane Parrish
Talk to me about how that gets in the way in relationships and how we can be more comfortable just telling our partner or prospective partner what we want.
- [59:07]
Logan Urie
It's so funny because one of my closest friends in the world is a professional mentalist or a mind reader, and we lived together as roommates for a number of years. And it's just, I love the concept of mind reading. And people would say, oh, you live with David. Like, what's it like? Is he always reading your mind? And I would say if he was always reading my mind, he would unload the dishwasher a lot more often. And so I just think it's so funny how there's this sense of, well, we're close and you know me, so you must know what I want. And that's something that I've personally worked on a lot in my life. So I've found that with a lot of my female friends, they get frustrated that their husbands or partners didn't give them what they wanted for their birthday of why didn't they know I wanted a surprise party? And what I'd say to them is, it's much more important to get what you want than to have the person guess what you want and then not get it right and be disappointed. So I feel like I try to be really explicit with my Husband and say, like, hey, like, for Mother's Day, like, this is what would be a really great day for me. And, like, it's not like he always delivers on that, but I'm kind of sharing what matters to me. Or I have friends. One guy is an economist, and they have a pretty complicated system, but it's basically like when one of the people in the couple invites the other person to an event at their work, they'll basically say how much it matters to them. On a scale of, you know, 0 to 100, to basically say this invite, I care about it 90 out of 100, please come, or I care about it 10 out of a hundred, if you don't come, it doesn't matter. And so I just think that if people get over this kind of romanticized idea of, if you really knew me, you'd know what I want into what I think is much more romantic, which is, I feel safe enough to tell you what I want, and I hope that you'll be able to honor it to the best of your ability.
- [60:54]
Shane Parrish
I have a theory that the people who expect unconsciously, other people to be able to read their mind, they do that because they're very good at reading other people's minds, but not actually reading their mind. They're just. Yeah, they tend to be maybe more thoughtful or they pay attention to a lot more nuance or details. Do you think that's true?
- [61:13]
Logan Urie
I haven't thought about that before, but it resonates with me. Something that I'm working on with my business coach is I make a lot of assumptions about what people want, and then I get really nervous about saying something that I think will disappoint them, and then I just avoid the conversation. But the feedback that I'm getting from my coach and from these people that I'm dealing with is you're actually getting wrong what I want. And so by not having the conversation with me, you're making decisions on my behalf. And if you actually just told me what was going on, we could come to a happy medium of. But because you think you know what I want, and then you want to avoid discomfort, for me, you're not even bringing it up. And so I think for me, the work that I'm doing there is to have uncomfortable conversations sooner instead of saying, well, I'm so good at knowing what everyone wants, I must be right. And instead being more curious and asking them what's going on.
- [62:06]
Shane Parrish
It's kind of like a kind versus nice thing, right? Like, a kind person will tell you, you have spinach on your teeth. But a nice person will tell.
- [62:13]
Logan Urie
Oh, I haven't heard of that, but I do like that. And I absolutely resonate with that. Where I always want to be the person who's telling somebody that there's food in their teeth. And rather than finding that it embarrasses people, I find that especially like a first meeting, that it really makes them feel closer to me because it's like they feel comfortable enough to tell me the slightly embarrassing thing, therefore I am safe with them.
- [62:35]
Shane Parrish
Yeah, I like that a lot. I want to come to priorities in terms of life and dating, especially post, I don't know, 30, a lot of people are divorced. Maybe they have kids.
- [62:46]
Logan Urie
Not in San Francisco.
- [62:47]
Shane Parrish
I mean, fewer and fewer people have kids. We'll ask.
- [62:50]
Logan Urie
I just feel like it's like, you know, In San Francisco, 30 and single and dating is kind of the norm. Okay, without kids.
- [62:57]
Shane Parrish
But I mean, you're at a point in your life where you have a lot of competing partners. Like, you could make an argument, at the risk of offending people, that having kids younger is better because you learn to be less selfish and that's better for society. And all of a sudden the world's not about you. But if you go through your twenties, you can also make an argument that you tend to be more focused on your career and you have priorities and dating has to fit into those priorities, but it's not the number one thing anymore. How do you think about priorities in dating?
- [63:28]
Logan Urie
So many of the people that I work with are very career oriented. These maximizers who are trying to strategize their way through life and oftentimes they come to me when they have been prioritizing their career for the last 12 years and then are like, oh, wait, I'm not where I want to be, relationship wise. And that's why when I do get the opportunity to speak to younger people, I really encourage them start prioritizing dating. When you're younger, you have a more flexible lifestyle, you have a bigger population of single people to choose from. And you know, in the last few years, as there's been more and more layoffs, I feel like a lot of people have had the reality check of this company that I dedicated 10 years of my life to and that I missed a lot of dates because I had to travel for my job. Guess what? What? We were not in a long term relationship. We were in a 10 year long relationship. And now I'm single and I don't want to be. And so sometimes when I talk to people. It's not just what do you want to add to your plate a day to week, it's what are you willing to take away from your plate in order to make time for that. And so work is such a compelling system, right? If I work harder, I get promoted. If I get promoted, I make more money. If I make more money, I get to have a nicer apartment and my mom gets to brag about me, I get to update my LinkedIn. It's like it's the perfect gamified system to find self worth through achievement. And dating is a lot harder. There's a lot of constant rejection. It costs time, it costs money. It might take away from that gamified career. And so I love to help people understand that the sooner you learn how to date, the sooner you can stop dating. And why not do that when you're younger and there's a larger pool of people too date?
- [65:15]
Shane Parrish
Is there an age difference that it becomes too much? You probably see everything at hinge from like the 60 year olds going for the 20 year olds to everything in between. What's an appropriate age gap that people should be looking for?
- [65:31]
Logan Urie
Most of my research has been with Gen Z and millennial daters who are sort of dating for their first marriage or dating to have kids, depending on the situation. But then, then when I that covers.
- [65:43]
Shane Parrish
Up to maybe 50, right? Like, I mean, they're younger, but their partner, the person that they're looking for.
- [65:49]
Logan Urie
Might be older potentially. But what I was gonna say is, you know, I did this Netflix show, the Later Daters, and that was where I worked with people 55 plus. And so that was sort of my first exposure to that age group. And it was really interesting to see the different age differences and if people were dating somebody at the same life stage. And so I think what came up a lot on the show and in the kind of coaching conversations that maybe didn't make it onto the show was that sometimes if you look younger, you might go on a date with somebody younger. And that feels really good from an ego perspective. But then you're just in a different life stage. And so I think what really matters is do you have the same values? Do you like spending time the same way? You know, if you're retired and you can travel and the other person is hustling and building their business, then maybe you just aren't a good match because you're not going to be spending the majority of your time together. And so I think instead of one of those funny calculations, I don't even remember it, but it's something like half of your age minus seven. I don't believe in any rules like that. I think people mature at different rates. People have different life experiences, but instead really tuning into, am I dating this person because they're younger and hotter and an ego boost, or do I actually feel like this is somebody I want to partner with in life?
- [67:04]
Shane Parrish
Okay, so we go on a first date. We're not interested. What do we say?
- [67:08]
Logan Urie
We say in a text, probably, and not ghosting. Hey, it was really great to meet you. It was so fun to hear about your podcast and the cool people that you're interviewing this year. I don't think we're a romantic match, but it was great meeting you. I don't owe you feedback. I don't need to get into a long conversation about what you did, right or wrong. I'm acknowledging you that you're a person. We had an experience together, and I don't want to move forward.
- [67:40]
Shane Parrish
And that's it? You just leave it there?
- [67:42]
Logan Urie
Yeah. I think the most important thing, kind of going back to your word of kindness, is to be kind but firm. So if you write back and say, I really don't think I was my best self, you know, I was kind of jet lagged, I want to see you again. You know, maybe that's not what feels right for me. And so I can respond or not respond, but I feel like I did my duty by saying to you, I met you, we had an experience. I'm not interested. And what's so hard about ghosting, and it truly has become more and more common over, say, the last five years that I've been tracking it, is that it leaves people in this ambiguity. Oh, maybe he likes me, but he just is busy and he hasn't gotten back to me, so I'm not gonna get back to this person in case this person wants to. And so in the research that I did on this at Hinge, what we found is that 86% of people say, when it comes to rejection, I'd rather you tell me it hurts, but I want to know. So you have this problem where people want the facts, they want the truth so that they can move on. But then the other people don't share the truth because they say, oh, I don't want to hurt their feelings, but you're actually hurting them more by not being upfront from the beginning about how you feel.
- [68:52]
Shane Parrish
Do you block the person after you send this text?
- [68:55]
Logan Urie
I don't think that's necessary. Do you block the person, Well, I don't know.
- [68:59]
Shane Parrish
We're going to come back to this maybe later. Actually, let's dive into this now. A lot of people text their exes.
- [69:04]
Logan Urie
Yeah.
- [69:05]
Shane Parrish
Is that healthy?
- [69:08]
Logan Urie
In general, the research shows that moving on from your ex is the best way to find a new relationship. Because when we keep all of these doors open, it actually prevents us from. From finding a new door to open. And so if you have these five people from your past that you sleep with when you're in a certain city or you wonder, oh, maybe I should get back together with her. I'll keep her on the back burner. What we call like, orbiting, it can actually prevent you from focusing and finding somebody new. And I even find this is especially true with sex. So if you are somebody who craves a lot of sex, but you occasionally sleep with your exes, you almost don't have the motivation to find somebody new to be in a partnership with because you're getting some of those needs met by other people. And what if you actually were dating in a different way where you're like, I'm going to focus all of my time, energy, really, even life force on a new person because that's aligned with my goals versus just getting some of those needs met in the short term.
- [70:06]
Shane Parrish
Well, let's double click on that again. So if your needs are getting met outside of a relationship, then there's no incentive to be in a relationship, is there?
- [70:13]
Logan Urie
You know, living in the Bay Area, there is such a big community of people who are polyamorous or in open relationships. And I'm personally not in one of those, but I see a lot of value in it. I think that with the divorce rate being at 40 to 50% over the last 40 years, we've really seen that this one size fits all version of marriage doesn't work for most people. So if you have a product and 50% of people are returning, then maybe you need to rework that product. So anyone who's rethinking the structure of marriage, I am a fan of. So relationship fluidity. All those things I think are great. And so in a polyamorous relationship, you might have somebody where you have more of a sexual relationship with them, somebody where you have more of an intellectual connection with them. There's so many different ways of doing it. And so I wouldn't say that you need to get all of your needs met by one person, and you should not get those needs met by other people, because I believe in these open relationship structures. But what I'm Saying here is, when you're single and you have limited time and you really want to find someone, ask yourself, is this ongoing relationship with my ex something that's pushing me forward or pulling me backwards? And if the answer is that it's pulling you backwards, then I would cut ties for the time being and really focus on the next person that you could have a relationship with.
- [71:30]
Shane Parrish
Interesting. I have a friend who's a gp, and she's mentioned in the past that one of the biggest reasons that people come into our office for antidepressants is because they're in a open relationship, really. And they don't want their partner to know that it's causing them all this anxiety or all this. And I don't know if that's true or not. I mean, I'm personally not a fan of them.
- [71:55]
Logan Urie
Okay.
- [71:56]
Shane Parrish
But I. Yeah.
- [71:57]
Logan Urie
I feel like your body language changed a little bit.
- [72:00]
Shane Parrish
Oh, interesting. On the body language. But I'm all for people doing whatever they want to do. You know, as long as everybody's a consenting adult, like, I'm in favor of it. You're not breaking laws, you're not hurting people, and everybody's aware of the situation. That's fine. I do wonder what emotional toll it takes on people over time.
- [72:17]
Logan Urie
I'm very far from an expert on polyamory, but I'm just thinking about one of my friends who's very proudly polyamorous, and I can hear her in my head sort of being like, that person may not be a good fit for an open relationship. And why are they in one? Because in an ideal world, there's this concept of compersion. Have you heard of that?
- [72:37]
Shane Parrish
No.
- [72:37]
Logan Urie
It's a word that. That means, I get pleasure when you get pleasure. So, like, kind of the first polyamorous couple that I got to know about 10 years ago, I remember the guy describing to me, oh, tonight my wife has a date with her boyfriend, and I'm really excited for her. And, like, my anxious brain, my jealous brain was like, I cannot relate to that on any level. That is a nightmare.
- [73:00]
Shane Parrish
That's instantly where my brain was.
- [73:01]
Logan Urie
Right? And I think I'm just way too jealous and anxious and insecure of a person to really be a good fit for an open relationship. Because I think. I think that the part of my brain that would be thinking about, am I gonna be rejected? Am I gonna be abandoned? Would just be so loud in my head that it would overcome any pleasure that I might get from having my own relationships outside the marriage. For other people, they are truly not there. That's not where the brains are. I know people very intimately who feel like, I'm so happy when my partner gets this other need met. Or maybe it's. It's like, I'm really busy at work right now, and I'm not feeling that sexual. I'm so happy that my partner has this outlet. And so that story about the gp, I would say that doesn't resonate with the experiences that I've heard. And it kind of goes back to, why is that person in an open relationship in the first place? Is it because they think that that's the only way their partner should stay? And probably, instead of talking to the GP about it, or maybe in addition, they should talk to their partners and say, either this isn't working for me, or. Or we need to change the stipulations of this because it's currently causing me more pain than it is pleasure.
- [74:11]
Shane Parrish
Just thinking out loud, I wonder if it would feed the side of me that doesn't feel enough or doesn't feel lovable. And so it would just cause, like, this endless torment in my head.
- [74:22]
Logan Urie
That's what I think it would feel like for me. But I find polyamory really endlessly fascinating because it's basically alerting me to a different brain chemistry. And it's sort of like in our society, we've accepted extroverts and introverts. So, like, I know that I could be in a terrible mood and then go to a party and then have the time of my life, and it's like, why was that party bringing me so much energy? Well, I'm extremely extroverted. For my husband, it's the opposite. So why can't we all think there are people for whom conversion is possible and amazing? For them, it's okay that I'm not like that. Instead of this assumption that for everyone, they would have the same experience around it.
- [75:02]
Shane Parrish
And the other term that you mentioned that I've never heard of before is orbiting. What does that mean?
- [75:08]
Logan Urie
Okay, so orbiting is a term that a reporter from Mashable, Anna Iovine, came up with. And it's about this idea of keeping a bunch of people or several people in orbit around you, sort of to increase your opportunities. So you're sort of not committing to any of them, but they're all there, sort of on your bench as people that you could interact with. And instead of keeping all of these balls in the air. Sorry, I'm like, totally mixing metaphors here. It's much better to commit to somebody See how the relationship goes, then decide if you wanna stay in the relationship or not, and then move on. Versus feeling like, well, the more possibilities I have, the more freedom I have, the more chances of success I have. Actually, success comes from committing to something, seeing if it works, and then moving, moving on if it doesn't.
- [75:55]
Shane Parrish
There's so many parallels between that and business, right, where, you know, a lot of people just tend to dabble in all of these different projects and they don't actually get things done versus people who commit to a project, focus on it and make it a priority.
- [76:09]
Logan Urie
There's a great concept from Dan Gilbert of Harvard called changeability. So we often crave the ability to change our minds because it makes us feel more free. So in this experiment that he ran on the Harvard campus, he had a bunch of students take a photography workshop. And one of the weekends that students took the workshop, they would get a call at the end of the weekend and say, hey, we're actually gonna have an art show in London in a few weeks. Pick one of your pictures from this weekend of taking pictures, and that's gonna be sent to London. And they didn't have the opportunity to change their mind. In a different scenario, they would call the students and pick one of the pieces to be sent to this art show in London. And I'm gonna call you in a few days and see if you wanna change your mind. Most of the time, people didn't change their mind about the photos. But when you asked people in which situation, they were more satisfied. The people who didn't have the chance to change their mind were actually more satisfied because they made a commitment and they immediately rationalized it and they felt good about it. When you can change your mind, you start wondering, well, that picture's a little sharper, but this one's a little more original. And maybe people in London, this one more. And so you sort of start making this pro con list in your head that actually works against you because you start doubting your original answer.
- [77:28]
Shane Parrish
But this comes back to almost what we were talking about earlier in dating multiple people and having all these options available, and you're sort of like, oh, making these choices all over again every day.
- [77:38]
Logan Urie
Absolutely. And that's something that Hinge is thinking about. So my favorite feature that's come out in a long time is this thing that came out last year called you'd. And basically the idea is that people were thinking, I want to get as many matches as possible. I really want to get this ego boost from attention and see how Many people will like me. And instead it's about connection over attention. So now if you have eight conversations where you owe somebody a response, you cannot match with anyone else until you respond to one of those people. So either you close out the conversation and show that you're not interested, or you keep the conversation going with them. And I was with my cousin over Christmas and he was like, oh, Logan, this feature is so challenging. I'm just trying to meet some new people. And I'm like, dude, look at your matches. Who are these women? Do you like them? Then ask them out on a date. And I think that in general, the brain just has such a natural tendency to want options and choices, when in reality, limiting those options or going through things one at a time makes it much easier to make a choice. And so I think in the age of dating apps, having this your turn limits feature is actually a really smart way to kind of nudge people towards making decisions instead of endlessly trying to match.
- [78:48]
Shane Parrish
And then once you've had a date with somebody, what does the science say about whether you should. Should I be dating three people at once for a first date? Or should I date one person and then be like, oh, I kind of like this person. I'm going to like, pause the app or hide my profile or whatever.
- [79:05]
Logan Urie
I found that it does differ by person. So there are people out there that are really anxiously attached, and when they meet someone, their brain goes into, I need to lock it down. I don't want to date anymore, so I just want to date them. So how can I become exclusive with them? And for those people, sometimes having multiple people that they're seeing in the beginning is actually a way to sort of ease some of that and just makes it a little bit easier for them to be a bit more relaxed and have a bit more of an abundance mindset. There are other people for whom seeing multiple people at the same time in the beginning either feels immoral or uncomfortable or just too exhausting. And so I would say for the person, really explore what are the patterns that have held you back in the past? What feels hard for you, what makes you feel like you're dating successfully and then do what's right for you, while of course, keeping in mind things like making it clear to someone if you're not exclusive or if you're not sexually.
- [79:55]
Shane Parrish
Exclusive, how do you have that conversation on maybe your first date or your second date? Do you just ask outright, like, hey, are you dating other people? Like, how do you bring that up?
- [80:06]
Logan Urie
I would say that in Modern dating, it's sort of assumed that you're not exclusive until you have the conversation. And that pain can come from somebody making an assumption. Well, oh, we've been dating for six months, we must be exclusive. Oh, we've had sex, we must be exclusive. And there is a lot of heartbreak that happens when people don't have that explicit conversation. So in life, in relationships, in dating, I am such a big fan of just checking in with the person because there's really this natural tendency, kind of going back to mind reading, of, well, if I really like you, then we must think the same way and be on the same page. And when you bring it up, you're afraid, well, what if I find out information that makes me sad? Then I'll be sad. It's like, no, that information is power and you need the data to make an informed decision for yourself. And if you find out information that's disputed, yes, it hurts. But now you can decide if that's the right person for you or not.
- [81:00]
Shane Parrish
What are women not getting from men and men not getting from women?
- [81:04]
Logan Urie
That's a question that I'm going to be researching more this year, so stay tuned. But it's really on my mind.
- [81:10]
Shane Parrish
What's your intuition?
- [81:12]
Logan Urie
I don't know if it's gender specific things where there's a lack of connection or just maybe cultural things going on where you. There's big differences in religious institution attendance or political divergence. But when I think about the issues in dating, I tend to focus less on what does this gender or that gender think. And I tend to focus more on patterns of behavior or blind spots that people have. And so of course there's gonna be different advice that I give to a woman in her late 30s who wants to have biological children versus a guy in his 20. Like, those conversations sound different and they have different timelines. But I think so much of the work that I do is really about helping people understand who they are, understanding these patterns, holding them back. And those are sort of universal things. But I am interested in what's happening in dating right now. And I am sort of at the beginning of a research project that will dig more into sort of what are certain groups not understanding about other groups?
- [82:12]
Shane Parrish
What makes somebody good at dating and maybe bad at being being a partner and then the opposite. What makes somebody bad at dating but like good at being a partner?
- [82:22]
Logan Urie
What do you think you are?
- [82:24]
Shane Parrish
I think I'm terrible at dating but good at being a partner.
- [82:28]
Logan Urie
What do you think makes you bad at dating?
- [82:31]
Shane Parrish
I get bored I. The opportunity cost of being on a first date is incredibly high.
- [82:41]
Logan Urie
Okay, so, so going back to priorities.
- [82:42]
Shane Parrish
Like if you think about my priorities, sort of like the kids and then work and those two things matter a lot to me. And between those two things it doesn't leave a lot of time for anything else. And the difference between running a business and working for somebody else often is I could be working and earning money like you at 6pm Right. So if I'm on a date or something with somebody, then there's all these things and you start thinking about that and then you just get caught up in your day sometimes and you extremely focused, which is part of what makes people successful is extreme focus. And then I think, and I don't know if I'm right or wrong. Correct me on this. If you come home to a person, I value connection, I value that time. But it's really hard to make that time in your day versus it exists naturally because you're coming home, you're going to bed, you're cleaning the kitchen together, you're making dinner together, you're doing these things together, which becomes a natural part of your day versus I'm not going to text you and I'm like with the kids and I'm making dinner and I'm not going to. And so by that time it's 9pm and I don't know about everybody else but 9pm I'm pretty much ready for bed. Maybe 10 I can go up till. But how does that work? And maybe this is the wrong way to think about it. I don't know.
- [83:58]
Logan Urie
It's very interesting that you said you're good at being in a relationship but sort of not as good as getting into one. And it sounds like once somebody has jumped through the hoops necessary to kind of make it into the top priorities in your life, you will give them the time and attention. But you find that hard to do in the early stages where maybe they haven't earned that spot yet.
- [84:20]
Shane Parrish
Totally. So I mean that's a bit more extreme than I would word it, but I think you're generally on the right track.
- [84:26]
Logan Urie
Right. And so what are your long term goals in dating and relationships?
- [84:31]
Shane Parrish
I want to be in a relationship, you know, I want to be happy and I want, want a life. Post my kid like right now, one of the things that's top of mind for me or has been for a while is sort of the kids. They're 14 and 15. The path to them going to university is very clear. And then what I have A great, amazing group of friends. I'm very close with my family, I have a very full life. But then what? They move out and now I'm alone.
- [85:02]
Logan Urie
The reason why I asked you what your long term goals are are that if you're really clear on your goal, I think it helps you prioritize your life differently. So it's like for the next five years, as you have kids at home, it's very clear what your evenings look like. But what happens when you don't have any kids at home? Do you then suddenly start dating and then do you feel behind? Do you feel like I'm a little rusty on my dating skills? I don't know what kind of person I like. I actually wanted to have more kids, but now I feel like I've aged out. And so by getting super clear on your long term goals for you, for anyone else, I feel like it helps you make those adjustments in your life. And so if you told me I want to run a marathon, but I don't have time to train, then I would say, I don't really think you want to run a marathon.
- [85:52]
Shane Parrish
Totally.
- [85:52]
Logan Urie
Or you're not going to run a marathon this year. But if you said I really want to run a marathon and I'm willing to lose an hour of sleep every night or be slightly worse at my job, or even have a few fewer hours a week with my kids, and I would say it sounds like this is something that you're willing to do. And so instead of thinking this is something that'll happen in the future, I think it does look like making sacrifice is too strong a word, but making adjustments now to how you spend your time so that you are getting close enough to somebody to even decide if you want to be in a relationship with them.
- [86:27]
Shane Parrish
Dating is a bit of a show though. Like, you put on your best face, right? You might have had a bad day at work, you sit down and all of a sudden you just want to be in your sweatpants at home, like watching trashy tv, but you're, you're doing something that you don't want to do. And so like not, not want to do, but you're putting on a bit of a mask, right? You're hiding part of yourself through dating. And I feel like it might be better if people just saw all the different sides of you rather than this, this pretend little dance.
- [86:55]
Logan Urie
So what would that look like?
- [86:56]
Shane Parrish
I don't know, like you're, you're the expert.
- [86:59]
Logan Urie
No, but why I'm pushing you on that point is like Your job right now is flying to different locations to have deep one on one conversations with somebody.
- [87:10]
Shane Parrish
Yeah.
- [87:10]
Logan Urie
Isn't that a little bit of a show? Isn't it a little bit like a first date? It's like I'm meeting a stranger. I want to have a connection with them. I want to have an. There's cameras here. But I don't think we're thinking about the cameras. I think we're thinking about the fact that we are getting to know each other, changing information.
- [87:27]
Shane Parrish
And that's why I prefer to do them in person.
- [87:29]
Logan Urie
Right, Me too. So my assumption is that you must enjoy this if you've built a life around it. How can you reframe dating to be something where it's like, I get to meet somebody, have an experience with them, go deep, have thoughts I've never had before because we're playing a conversational game of ping pong and I'm having a good time. Whereas right now it sounds like the frame is dating is draining. Dating is time away from my kids. Dating is I can't be in my sweatpants as opposed to reframing it to this is aligned with my goals and I can actually make it fun.
- [88:01]
Shane Parrish
Maybe the way to think about this is I feel broken in a lot of ways. Right. And this is part of the reason I went to therapy last summer and spent a lot of time. I did immersive therapy, which is kind of crazy. Spent.
- [88:12]
Logan Urie
Tell me about it.
- [88:13]
Shane Parrish
10 hours a day with this woman who like flew to Ottawa.
- [88:17]
Logan Urie
Cool.
- [88:17]
Shane Parrish
And we walked. We walked like 20 miles a day.
- [88:20]
Logan Urie
This is like my dream for five days.
- [88:22]
Shane Parrish
Oh, my God.
- [88:23]
Logan Urie
That's healthy. That's what I mean.
- [88:24]
Shane Parrish
And by the end of the day, she's like totally energized. And I'm like, oh, my God, I'm ready for sleep.
- [88:28]
Logan Urie
Okay. This is a new modality that I need to pursue.
- [88:31]
Shane Parrish
She was amazing. It was the best thing ever. I didn't want to do this like every two weeks thing. And I definitely didn't want to do therapy over zoom.
- [88:37]
Logan Urie
I love this.
- [88:38]
Shane Parrish
Hired this world class therapist from Ottawa and spent like four or five days with her. Incredible, totally immersed. And I figured, you know, from my point of view, the worst thing is like, she knocks on the door, we don't get along. I've already paid for the week. You know, it's sort of like, just go home and I'll do work or whatever. But we really hit it off. And part of what came out of this is, I don't know, maybe I'm alone in this, but I feel like when I get broken up with where a relationship doesn't work out, I feel like I'm constantly telling my friends, oh, it didn't work out. And then there's a part of me on the inside that just feels like I'm broken. What's your reaction to that?
- [89:19]
Logan Urie
That you are so not alone. Rejection sucks. Having somebody spend time with you, evaluate you, and tell you that you're not what they want is so painful. And I think that if you apply for a job and you don't get it, it's, oh, I wasn't right for the position, and they had an internal candidate and it' one slice of your life. But there's something uniquely painful about rejection in dating because it's like, I've met you and I don't want you. And so I'm just validating that. I think many, many, many people find this whole process very painful. Especially people who've been dating 10, 15 years and are just like, my body, my soul, I can't go through this anymore. So I just have a lot of empathy for that. But what is so interesting about the conversation that we're having is you sort of start with, it's hard for me to make time for dating when I think what's actually going on is it's very painful for me to feel rejected. So I don't wanna subject myself to that. And so the time is an excuse for a much deeper thing that you're experiencing.
- [90:20]
Shane Parrish
There's definitely an element of that. I feel broken even when I break up with somebody. Do you know what I mean? Like, I feel like maybe I pushed them away or did something to, like, cause the fracture and then eventually mandate up and called off the relationship or something. But then I walk away from that feeling, like I'm like, why did I do that? Why?
- [90:42]
Logan Urie
So what's the story in your head?
- [90:46]
Shane Parrish
I mean, it comes back to vulnerability at a point, right? Like, I think you get to a point in any relationship where you have to make a decision. And for me, it's more binary, maybe, than other people. And that decision is, do I trust this person to not hurt me? And for whatever reason, post divorce, that's been really hard for me to get to that point and then trust somebody. So when I have got to that point and I do overcome it, it hasn't worked out. And so it's like, oh, gosh, so.
- [91:16]
Logan Urie
You did these five days of immersive therapy?
- [91:19]
Shane Parrish
Oh, yeah.
- [91:21]
Logan Urie
What are you currently doing to kind of heal that Inner wound, which is I am broken. Because if your analysis is that until. Until you feel less broken, both when you break up with someone and when they break up with you, I think you're not gonna be able to connect with someone.
- [91:37]
Shane Parrish
Walk me through how you made your decision about your husband, because that was not a love at first sight. That was a slow burn. How do you decide between falling into a relationship with inertia and choosing to be in a relationship?
- [91:52]
Logan Urie
Thank you for indulging me and letting me talk about my husband, who I love so much. And it's so cliche, but I feel like I love him way more now than I did in our first year. Our second year, our lives are just so much more enmeshed. And so my husband and I met in college, and we only know this because we became Facebook friends at the time. So I have this vague memory of sitting next to him in the dining hall and we had a mutual friend, and he wrote on my Facebook wall, which back. You know, maybe he was flirting or maybe he wasn't. And then we met again at Google, and I saw him on a dating app, and I looked at his photos. I can just remember exactly where I was, exactly what the photos looked like. And I swiped left. I said no, because from his pictures, he just looked like this unsmiling bro. They were sort of all from this, like, one hiking trip and maybe one wedding he went to. Wasn't smiling in any of them, and I was just like, oh, this guy's, like, wearing tank tops and a backwards hat. Like, not for me. And I like that part of the story because I think it shows how quickly we make judgments and how incorrect a lot of those judgments are. So then some period of time later, I held this lunch at Google, which was people who had gone to our college who worked at Google. And in retrospect, I think I was expanding my network. I was doing it for the interns from our school, but it was also a way of just, like, meeting more people and maybe meeting more potential partners. And so I sat next to my then husband at this lunch, and I was talking about how I was trying to learn the statistical programming language of R, and how it was very hard. And he said, oh, I just dropped out of a math PhD program where I wrote R every day. I will tutor you in it. And now that I know this person extremely well, I feel like that was out of character for him.
- [93:48]
Shane Parrish
He was totally, like, hitting on you.
- [93:49]
Logan Urie
Like, I think he must have been. But that's not like what either of Our versions of it are, he didn't like.
- [93:54]
Shane Parrish
It's not how it's felt.
- [93:56]
Logan Urie
That's not how it felt. But it's so interesting. It's like, even using my language of, what side of you does the person bring out? I feel like in that moment, I brought out a generous side of him that he maybe doesn't always access. My husband is not the person going through the world asking people if he can do them favors. And I don't know if it even was romantic for him or a feeling of, like, I want to be around this person more, or like, I'm lonely. I just dropped out of a PhD program. I want to make new friends. And so over the next year, we did have these r tutoring sessions. And I remember them so well. And I remember these, like, celebratory moments where I'd figure things out. And he was a good tutor, and it really put him in a good light. Right? He's just so smart. It was a chance for him to chime. At the same time, there was this guy that I had met at Burning man who I was obsessed with and definitely pursuing. And every textbook example of anxious attachment was coming true for me. So it was like he would pull away, so I would chase him more. He. He rejected me. So I thought, how can I prove to him that I'm worthy of his love? This guy who I was obsessed with, I had a mutual friend with him. We were sort of in the same extended group of friends. And somebody who knew the guy that I was chasing was just witnessing how in pain I was and was like, hey, this isn't working out. I think you should see a dating coach or, this isn't working. And so I started seeing this dating coach. And it was so helpful because a lot of what we did was kind of pull back the curtain. And so I started to understand when she asked me, the person who you're gonna end up with, how do you want them to make you feel? And so a lot of that stuff was, I wanna feel desired. I wanna feel smart. I wanna feel cared for. And how does this guy from Burning man make you feel? Well, he makes me feel anxious. He makes me feel not good enough. He makes me feel not attractive enough. And it's. And it's like in continuing to pursue him, I was continuing to pursue those feelings that felt really bad. She said, well, do you know any guys? Have you ever dated anyone who makes you feel this way that you want to feel? And this guy from work popped up in my head. I was like, wow, those tutoring sessions are really fun. And we've gotten closer and now we have lunch at work. And sometimes I call him after my dates with other people, but why am I not dating him? And so pretty quickly, you know, being a goal oriented person, I was kind of like, hey, I don't have plans this Friday night. Like, you know, you should ask me out. And we quickly went on a first date and, you know, a number of dates. And now we've been together for almost 10 years. And I just feel like on paper there were some reasons why we wouldn't have. So, for example, like, at the time, I was very into Burning man, and he not only didn't go, but he would say, I don't really trust anyone who goes to Burning Man. Well, guess what? We went to Burning man together multiple times. It's like I felt like the deepest parts of us that were connected. So sort of same sense of humor, which is a huge part of a relationship. Mutual intellectual respect, really trusting each other deeply. Like, those things were there from the beginning. And I've. And we still have parts of our lives where we're not the same. He's vegan and I'm not. I like traveling a lot more than he does. But we've built a life where the Venn diagram of the middle is super strong, and we each also have the parts of our lives that are separate and we're not trying to be 100% merged.
- [97:29]
Shane Parrish
What was the transition from friendship to dating? Was it seamless or was it awkward?
- [97:35]
Logan Urie
I think in my head, it's so mythologized that, like, I don't know if I can give you a truly honest answer, but I think it was kind of pouring gasoline onto the chemistry that we already had.
- [97:46]
Shane Parrish
There was tension already.
- [97:47]
Logan Urie
Yeah. So it was, like, it was really exciting. I mean, it felt so exciting. Like, especially, you know, we both worked at Google. It's this big company with thousands of people. So I would go to his cafe instead of my cafe and, like, hope that I would see him or, like, you know, I would. What did we call it back in the day? Like, Gchat him? Like, on the shuttle. Like, there was just so much excitement in the beginning or around, like, wow, like, I have a lot of chemistry with this person, and we're gonna take that friend chemistry and see if there's something romantic there. And it was not smooth sailing all the way. Like, there was definitely a moment a few years later where I kind of blew up my life, where I left this steady job that I had at Airbnb, and I moved to New York for a few months to do this TED program, and just a lot of changes were happening. And we definitely hit a moment of like, we're either gonna break up or get engaged. And we navigated that moment, and, you know, clearly.
- [98:40]
Shane Parrish
How did you navigate that moment? That is like, such a decision where there's a fork in the road.
- [98:46]
Logan Urie
Absolutely.
- [98:46]
Shane Parrish
You're in a relationship. You have a lot of sunk cost in relationship.
- [98:50]
Logan Urie
Absolutely.
- [98:51]
Shane Parrish
How did you make that decision?
- [98:52]
Logan Urie
I think people often assume that relationships are smooth sailing and that you just keep dating until you're married. But as somebody who does these, like, breakfast consultations and has really talked to a lot of people over the years, that idea of breakup or get engaged is pretty common because it's like, we either keep going and it escalates to marriage soon, or there's no marriage at the end of this, in which case we should break up because we both wanna find other people to marry. And so I think just like normalizing that that happens or that people put ultimatums or deadlines on things, I actually think that's happening all the time for us. It was a lot of conversations about things that we wanted long term. So, for example, one of the conversations that we had was I said, here are three values of mine. I really like travel, and I want to travel more with you. I want you to get to know my friends better because my friends are so important to me, and I want those people to really know you, and vice versa. And I probably want to live in community at some point, and I want to know if you would be open. And now, six or seven years after that conversation, it's like, we've done a ton of international travel together. Most of my closest friends are his closest friends, and we lived in this amazing communal environment for two and a half years during the pandemic. And so my husband is super stubborn. He's super independent. It's not that he changed himself. It's that he understood things that were important to me and he was able to give them to me in a way that felt genuine. And there's plenty of things that I've done over the years, such as, you know, I'm not vegan, but, like, there's not a lot of meat in our home, and, like, I'm closer to that. Or we're currently raising our daughter to be vegan. And so I just feel like we just kept finding that our values were aligned and that we loved hanging out together. And, like, I can't even emphasize enough this idea of mutual trust. Like, it's almost annoying to think about it, but it's like, I think my husband's right most of the time, and I think he's right about really big issues. And so I, I feel so lucky that I have this person as my decision maker partner where I can really say, like, I have this opportunity. This is how far away it is. Do you think I should do it? And when we talk through it, at the end of the conversation, I either agree with him or he's helped me come to the right decision for myself. And when people have partners where they don't really trust or admire or respect them, I couldn't be in that relationship. And so I think as parents, you're just constantly making decisions. And that's why I feel even closer to him than ever before because I'm like, we're really basically partners in this big class project. And it's been really fun.
- [101:33]
Shane Parrish
That's awesome. Do you agree with the timeboxing or the ultimatum, I guess, as you called it, or sort of like these points where you artificially create this one point for people who are not younger and, and maybe dating again is, do you meet the kids?
- [101:49]
Logan Urie
Yeah. So I think that the ultimatum, I mean, that term is even loaded at this point. Cause there's like this Netflix show about the ultimatum. And I think when people hear that, they probably have a negative assumption of somebody being like, if you don't propose by the end of the year, we're breaking up. Like, that doesn't sound collaborative to me. But I actually do think that decision points are very important in life and in relationships. So there's this great research about people eating cookies. So in one part of the experiment, people just eat cookies in a sleeve, and they just eat the whole sleeve of cookies until it's over. And then they're like, damn, I just ate a lot of cookies. In another part of the experiment, in between every few cookies are these colored pieces of wax paper. And when you get to the piece of colored wax paper, you think like, do I want to keep going or not? And it creates a decision point that makes you consciously decide, do I go forward or not? And so I think that relationships do offer these decision points. Do we want to be exclusive? Do we want to move in together? Do we want to get married? Do we want to have kids? And each of those is an opportunity to check in with the other person. And so sometimes creating that by saying, hey, let's go away for a weekend and talk about Our future. You're really shining a light on an important topic that impacts both of you. And so maybe I'll take back the word ultimatum and instead say, I want people to make conscious choices. I want them to be deciding, not sliding through relationship transitions.
- [103:18]
Shane Parrish
How do you have those hard conversations in a secure way where a lot of people might interpret them as like, oh no, the relationship's over, they close up, they get defensive. How do you structure them in a way where both people stay open and they're trying to solve the problem together? It's like we have a problem or we have a decision point, but we're both on the same side of the table. How do we deal with this versus the perception that one person might have that, oh God, it's over, I'm going to start protecting myself. And the minute they do that, it becomes almost a self fulfilling prophecy.
- [103:50]
Logan Urie
So there's definitely people who are more experts on this than I am. Like a lot of people love Marshall Rosenberg, who wrote Nonviolent Communication or even I think some of the work by different negotiations experts is really helpful because you say, how can we solve this together? So I would really encourage people to seek out those resources. But some of the things that I can say are really approaching things from being a team. So we as a team are thinking about our financial future. And this is, you know, I don't know if you know Ramit Sethi, but sort of some of Ramit's work where it's like, what is our rich life life? Let's sit down together and have a fun, generative conversation around our rich life? And isn't that fun to think about what we could achieve together versus hey, I save a lot more money than you do. I don't want your debts to be mine. It's like we're adversaries. And so how can you come at it from a place of we get to do this really exciting thing of design our lives together, let's have a conversation about it versus this is a negotiation where one of us wins and the other loses.
- [104:55]
Shane Parrish
There's no one size fits all. But how do you. The money is a great point, right? Like, how do you have those conversations when maybe there's a huge income gap or do you have a joint account or do you have separate accounts? And how does that work? Does having a large income gap correlate to problems in a relationship?
- [105:12]
Logan Urie
I truly do pull on Ramit's work for a lot of this stuff. You know, he has this great podcast where he interviews couples and money and he has interviews, new book, Money for Couples. And I just did a newsletter with him where it was about how to have the first money conversation. And some of the key tips are things like, it's the first conversation, it's not the only conversation. So maybe it's just where you open up and you talk about, what does money mean to you? What was your family's relationship with money? When you think about money, what feelings does it evoke? And so just having a conversation where more people are sharing versus having a conversation that needs to come to a specific outcome, like, well, I make two times what you make, so I should pay two times the rent. It's like, you don't have to get into all the tactical stuff right away. I think approaching it as the first of one of many conversations is a really healthy idea, because I just went to this event that Ramit had, and he said, a lot of times, people don't even know what somebody else makes or how much money they. They have, you know, until something like having a kid or, you know, buying a house. And it's like, we should be having conversations about sex, money, spirituality, children, a lot earlier.
- [106:24]
Shane Parrish
I like that. Politics has become very divisive in the last, I don't know, 10 years, let's say. What's the difference between having different political views and a deal breaker?
- [106:37]
Logan Urie
It's been so interesting in the 10 years of doing this to see how this has changed. So 10 years ago, I did an event with Christian Rutter, one of the founders of OkCupid, and we talked about this question that they have on an OkCupid survey of do you care about politics? And what he told me at the time was it was way less important if the person had the same political views as you, as if they cared about politics or not. And now fast forward to this year. I would say that's no longer the case, that people really do care, care about political views because it's moved into the category of values. And so people are really thinking about, if we share political views, that's a proxy for do we share values? And so for a lot of people, it's as important or more important to them than something like religion. And so at the end of the day, it's about understanding what really matters to you in your life, what really matters to you in a partner. And if politics are something that's at the top of that list, I think that that's a legitimate deal breaker.
- [107:38]
Shane Parrish
Interesting. I remember being on a date right before COVID and politics came up and I was like, oh, I'm moderate. And she instantly replied, oh, so you can't make up your mind?
- [107:48]
Logan Urie
Oh, that's interesting.
- [107:49]
Shane Parrish
And I was like, whoa, that's not what I said. I was like, I'm just sort of like, center, you know, I'm not extreme. I'm not extreme left. I'm not extreme right. I'm policy based. I'm not party based. And it turned into. Into this really interesting discussion about politics. But it was clear from her point of view that that was never going to work.
- [108:09]
Logan Urie
Did that change how you presented your political views on future dates?
- [108:14]
Shane Parrish
Yeah, I was more hesitant to sort of bring them up because it could be such a contentious point, but maybe you should bring them up earlier if you know it's going to be a source of contention. But I always think, like, let's avoid some of the more nasty stuff, at least in the first. First, like, few dates, and then get into more understanding the person and how they approach life versus what do you think of abortion? What do you think of politics? What do you think of xyz? Cause then you're just. You're almost looking for an argument, right?
- [108:44]
Logan Urie
Yeah. You know, I think it depends on how important those things are to you. So if somebody said, I'm Muslim, I really want to raise my kids to be Muslim. Talking about that on a first date feels completely, totally. So if you feel the same way about your political views, then I'm totally fine with somebody talking about that on a first date. I don't think it's, let's debate the role taxes play in America. And it sounds like to you, having political views in common isn't as important. So I could see you talking about it later.
- [109:13]
Shane Parrish
But it's also shocking. Like, I had a Jewish woman once on a date ask me if I would convert, and I'm like, it's a first date. Like, wow. I don't know. I've never thought about this. You know.
- [109:22]
Logan Urie
Yeah, but then when you.
- [109:23]
Shane Parrish
But that's important to you.
- [109:24]
Logan Urie
But what did you think? What did you say?
- [109:27]
Shane Parrish
Exactly what I just said. I don't know. I've never thought about that. I understand from you bringing it up so early that it's clearly important to you.
- [109:35]
Logan Urie
That's a really interesting one because I could see it going a few ways. So I could see it being where the guy, not just you, but in general, is like, that's way too forward. That's way too intense. The truth is that if I was in love with somebody, I might consider it. But being Asked on the. It makes me so turned off that I'm not interested.
- [109:53]
Shane Parrish
That is a much better response than what I'm saying.
- [109:54]
Logan Urie
But I could see. No, no, no. But I could see another argument in which the person says, like, oh, you know what? Actually being Catholic is just such a big part of my family that, like, I just cannot ever see that. And then the woman gets the information that she needs. And so I think a lot of times it's about how you bring things up. You don't want to paint somebody in a corner where they feel like there's a wrong. You want to sort of share and model and make them feel safe saying whatever's true to them. And so, for example, she could have said something like, you know, I've been dating for a while, and the older I get, the more I realize my Jewish identity is really important to me. And I grew up celebrating the holidays. I really want to celebrate the holidays with my kids. How important is your religion to you? Then you get a chance to talk about your experience versus feeling like there's a right answer, like, what would you say to that question on a date?
- [110:49]
Shane Parrish
I like your response, which is, you know, if I was in love with somebody, I don't think it would really matter. I haven't thought about it at this point because I haven't reached that point with somebody. But it wouldn't be a. I don't think it would be a deal breaker for me, but I don't know, like, I haven't got to that point.
- [111:05]
Logan Urie
I think that's a great answer because she can either say, that's wishy washy. I think that's probably a no, that's not good enough, or, okay, he's open to it. Religion's not something where he has his own conflicting thing that he's attached to. And so in most of these situations, I feel like we think so much about the strategy and the response and the right thing. It's like, what if we just prioritize communication skills that allow people to ask questions that are true for them and listen to someone's answer and have a conversation around it instead? Instead of like some AI Resume reviewer that's basically saying, well, they didn't have the right keyword, so I'm not gonna pass them on to the recruiter.
- [111:42]
Shane Parrish
I like that approach. Is it a red flag if a guy's best friend is a girl or a girl's best friend is a guy?
- [111:50]
Logan Urie
I don't care about any of that stuff.
- [111:52]
Shane Parrish
No, I knew you were gonna say that, but, like, statistically has that. No, but I'm just wondering, like, what does the science say behind that?
- [111:59]
Logan Urie
I haven't seen science behind that, but just in my own relationship, I feel like a lot of my closest friends are men. And the fact that, you know, just two days ago, I spent like a lot of the day with one of my close male friends and my husband was like, oh, I'm so glad that you're getting to see David. Like, make sure you, like, ask him about this and that. Like, I want the update. And it's like, it's so attractive to me that he's so confident.
- [112:22]
Shane Parrish
But you hang out together, right?
- [112:24]
Logan Urie
Sometimes this is a person. But, like, I have plenty of male friends that he's not particularly close to. And from the beginning, I think he's just understood, like, Logan is a social creature with a lot of deep friendships, and some of them are men. And there's this concept called other significant others, which is this idea that it came from research from Eli Finkel and Elaine Chung at Northwestern. And you basically say to a couple, you know, who are the different people that you go to in your lives for different things? Whether it's like talking about TV shows, talking about, talking about baseball, career advice, and couples that have longer lists of the individual people, they go to tend to have these happier, more successful relationships because instead of putting all the pressure on getting their needs met from one person, they actually have this network that they lean on. And so my husband and I really invest in this idea of other significant others to the point where our WhatsApp channel with 30 of our friends is called OSOS. And this is truly something that we in our community embody. And so I think, I think that when my husband knows I'm having brunch with Mike, he's thinking, oh, Mike and Logan are just like these creative animals that literally have brunch with post it notes and a notebook and like, they're just gonna jam out in a way that Logan and I don't. And he feels like that makes Logan happy and makes our relationship stronger. He doesn't feel threatened. And I think that that's hard. A lot of people do feel threatened or they do feel jealous. But the more you can do in your own life life to feel confident in yourself and your relationship, people just are drawn to that sort of confidence and it's better for both partners.
- [113:58]
Shane Parrish
Tell me more about this OSO WhatsApp group and like, how it's used and how it started.
- [114:05]
Logan Urie
I mentioned communal living, so I have these Friends named Kristen and Phil, who are very visionary people, and they are people that are truly living their values and thinking, like, many steps ahead of most people. So in their 20s, or maybe it was their early 30s when they were dating, they lived in this communal house that they ran in San Francisco, where it was about, like, nine people in a house. They would have dinner together, and there was a lot of, you know, shared activities and close relationships. And none of. None of this is sexual. This is not, like, I don't know if sometimes people's heads jump to, like, orgies. That's really not the vibe.
- [114:40]
Shane Parrish
Mine did not go, okay, good.
- [114:42]
Logan Urie
The vibe is really, like, people who come home from work and, like, want to have an interesting dinner conversation with somebody else and, like, eat the, like, rice pilaf that they made. So then they said, well, you know, we're getting to be in our mid-30s, and people are going to start having kids soon. Well, this house is not going to work for kids. So they bought a piece of property and they said, we're going to turn this into the next phase where if people want to have kids, they can have kids. And in the beginning, everyone's like, like, this piece of land sucks. This is, like, close to the highway and close to bart. But, like, over the years, everyone flocked there, including my husband and me. So during the pandemic, when my husband was going through cancer treatment, that's where we wanted to live. We wanted to live with people, with a community of support, with these other significant others. And so we really had just this group of people who were either old friends or new friends, friends to rely on. And this place now has five kids. It's soon gonna have eight kids. And people are just truly living in a pretty radical way, which is, why do you have to have a concrete house with just you and your partner and your kid? Why do all your resources have to go towards making one dinner and doing all the dishes? What if you only had to cook every 14 days? What if you could pool your resources and have a hot tub, a cold plunge, a. Like, that stuff is doable. When people live in this alternative environment.
- [116:03]
Shane Parrish
It'S incredible because we tend to do that in Western world as we get older. Once we retire, we go to all of them.
- [116:10]
Logan Urie
Yeah, and there's plenty of jokes there about a millennial retirement community, or I think sometimes call it a rave for introverts. They have a lot of funny names for it. But the point is that this is a group of people who have decided life is better when you're living with your friends, they're not optimizing for the maximum square footage. They're not maximizing for the toniest neighborhood. They're really saying, I feel happy when I see a friend in the middle of the day without social coordination. I feel happy when I have an interesting dinner conversation. I love being able to host friends here and now having children there. People just feel like, oh, well, I never had to hire a babysitter because like I'll watch this parent's kid or they'll watch my kid and like I no longer live there. I live like in a house like 10 minute walk away. But I truly feel like the people who are there are way less stressed than the average parent that I know.
- [117:02]
Shane Parrish
I think that that's true even if you're not living in that community. I mean, as a single parent, it takes a village to raise your children and having that help and social support network easily accessible. And I like how you mentioned uncoordinated kind of social events.
- [117:17]
Logan Urie
Totally.
- [117:18]
Shane Parrish
I remember I used to live in the neighborhood of a lot of my close friends and then I moved and I miss those impromptu sort of wines or walk bys or stuff now it requires more coordination.
- [117:30]
Logan Urie
So there's a lot of research that shows that people are happier if they live within a five minute walk of their friends. So Phil, one of the guys who started this community, he's now built an entire company around this premise. And the company's called Live Near Friends. And it's basically either how can you buy property with a friend or near a friend or even like rent something nearby. Is basically like, instead of making your housing based on your commute or your favorite coffee shop, why are we not centering our relationships?
- [117:58]
Shane Parrish
Yeah, I like that. I think often it comes down to commute or cost. Right. We often trade off money to live farther away from the city. Increasing our commute so that we can get a bigger house. Or I don't know what the variables are. I don't resonate with that. So we're in a relationship. What are the questions that we should be asking ourselves as we decide whether we want to commit to this person for the rest of our lives?
- [118:25]
Logan Urie
Yeah, this is really hard. I mean, the reason why I love that I have a background in behavioral science is that it's really about the science of decision making. And so much of a relationship is, am I ready to date? Who should I date? Should I keep dating this person? Should we move in together? Should we get married? And so each of these is a pivotal point. In your life. And so the first thing I would say is just having a lot of honest conversations. So before my husband and I got married, we did. There's a great book called Eight Dates by the Gottmans, who are sort of the kings and queens of relationship science and really research backed. And in the book, there's a series of dates that you should go on to get to know your part. And so there's conversations about money, there's conversations around family, there's conversations about hopes and dreams in the future. And I did all of the dates with my husband sort of as this, like, project where I was blogging about it. But I'm really glad I had that container that forced me to do the dates because we got so much out of them that I think really did lead us to get engaged and kind of build a life together. And so I think that the questions differ per person. But a lot of it just sitting down and think about, like, what does our life look in the future look like in the future? Like, do you plan on working? What are your values? Do you want to have kids? What are things from your childhood that you really want to repeat? What are things about your childhood that you want to do the opposite of? And I think sometimes when we're so in love with someone, we just assume we're on the same page. And so just kind of echoing our earlier sentiment that I think it's about how these intentional conversations to decide, is this somebody who I could really build a life with? The other key thing is to understand that people often think, am I making the right choice? There's not really such thing as the right choice. I don't believe in soulmates. I think that you could have many great relationships with many great people, and you get to decide, is this the person that I want to do it with? And. And so of course, you can think about the lives that you didn't live and all the other stories that you could have written. But instead, I think think about the fact that this is a story that I am excited to write.
- [120:32]
Shane Parrish
Your husband sounds like an awesome man.
- [120:34]
Logan Urie
He's great.
- [120:35]
Shane Parrish
How do we end that relationship if we decide it's not for us, but we've been in the relationship, so it's not after a first date, but maybe we've been dating three months or six months and we reached one of these points. We've had these conversations. Now how do we respond? Respectfully break up.
- [120:49]
Logan Urie
Okay. We talked today about how painful rejection is. And so I think the first guiding principle for breaking up with someone really should be empathy and just understanding and really imagining how painful it is to be broken up with in most situations. And so a few things to keep in mind. So one of them is there's this rule kind of in corporate America that if you're gonna lay somebody off or give them a bad performance review, it shouldn't be the first time that they've gotten that feedback. So I think it's much more fair to let somebody know throughout the relationship if something isn't working. I think it's so painful for people when somebody breaks up with them and says, you know, you love going to restaurants and city culture, and I love camping and skiing, but since we've been dating, I haven't gotten to do any of those things. And then the person's like, what? You never brought that up once? Like, of course we could have made time for that. Why were you. You keeping that from me? And so I think just understanding that as things are happening and coming up, share them with your partner so that you can tackle them together. Maybe it comes to the same outcome of breaking up, but don't kind of hide all of that until the moment that you break up with them. Another thing to keep in mind is I don't think it's the opportunity to give somebody feedback. I think that can be very painful for somebody. So sometimes in a breakup scenario, the person will be like, tell me what I did wrong. Tell me when you fell out of. I don't find that that's helpful unless there's something really specific, like, I constantly felt like you were breaking plans with me, or, you know, something that they can change.
- [122:15]
Shane Parrish
But you were unreliable.
- [122:16]
Logan Urie
You were unreliable, but a lot of times it's like you just weren't a match. And whatever you say to them is really gonna stick in their mind, and they're gonna go over it a million times. So I just sort of find that that's unhelpful. There's also this idea. Do you know Alain de Botton? His work? So he has this concept of, like, the nice breakup process, where it's like, I'll keep being in touch with you after the breakup because it makes me feel like I'm a nice person, which makes me feel better. But it's actually really about respecting your boundaries, which is, like, it's probably better for you if we're not as in touch. And so really letting you define that, or not trying to sort of assuage my own guilt by, like, being in touch with you all the time, which actually Makes things harder for you. So I have a conversation guide. I'm my book for how to have a breakup conversation, which has a lot of things about, like, preparing for it in advance. So when are you gonna have this conversation? You know, if somebody has a big presentation on Monday, like, don't do it Sunday night, is this person able to get in touch with some friends or family to support them afterwards? So just really trying to soften the difficulty of the situation by setting them up to get support from other people, sharing with them kind of how you're feeling, but not giving feedback and. And then I think, honestly, not having sex with them and giving them space to honor the fact that this is challenging and they need to move on.
- [123:37]
Shane Parrish
I like that. I'd be remiss if I didn't ask about dating profiles. What are the tips that people. The most common things that people get wrong?
- [123:46]
Logan Urie
Yeah. So I've done a ton of research on this, and I can tell you some of the main tips. So your dating app profile is sort of like your billboard. And if you were buying a billboard, let's say, on the 101 in San Francisco, like, you would, of course, think a lot about what you're gonna put on it. And I think people should give the same amount of attention to their Hinge profile. So, for example, you are telling a story about who you are. So let's say that you have a side of yourself that loves anime, and there's a side of yourself that's passionate about baseball. If all of your pictures are from Comic Con, I'm not gonna see that. So really, I like to teach people this concept of your three big things. What are three big things about yourself that you wanna express in your profile? And then make sure that through your prompts and through your photos, you're getting those things across. Another thing is having a mixture of humor and vulnerability. You don't want to be all jokes, and you don't want to be all super serious. You want to show people different sides of yourself. You also don't want to fall into these dating app cliches. So there's this one unhinged, like, I'm overly competitive about everything. And people have seen that all the time. So, like, at best, they sort of just ignore it. And at worst, they're like, oh, cliche. Like, I'm not interested in that person. There's actually a new feature that just came out on Hinge called prompt feedback, which uses AI to kind of give you personalized private feedback on your prompt responses. So, like, if you give a one word answer or it's cliche, it'll say, like, dig a little bit deeper. What are you overly competitive about? So hopefully that's gonna kind of raise all profiles. Other do's and don'ts. Don't have one of those Where's Waldo photos where we can't tell which one you are. People don't like that. In general, selfies perform worse. If you have sunglasses or filters or you're wearing ski goggles, it's really hard to tell what you look like. So just like make it easy for the person to tell what you look like. Have a photo of, you know, a clear headshot photo of your full body photo of you doing something that you love, and then a photo with friends and family, but not so many that we. You can't tell which one is you. But in general, it's really about using it as an opportunity to share who you are, what you're looking for, and what kind of person you want to meet.
- [126:01]
Shane Parrish
Should you smile?
- [126:02]
Logan Urie
Smile's good.
- [126:03]
Shane Parrish
Should you have a pet?
- [126:05]
Logan Urie
If you have a pet, sure. But, you know, I think that when.
- [126:08]
Shane Parrish
People, you know, what came to mind there is like, Tim Ferriss did this thing, I think I remember this correctly, where he tested like 8,000 photos or something crazy, and the one that was most successful was him carrying a cat.
- [126:21]
Logan Urie
On the COVID I have seen over the years different research about people with cats, people with dogs. When I hear those things, I'm just like, do you have a fucking cat or dog? If it's really important to you, put it in there. But don't dog bait somebody if you don't. I just made that up. But it's like if you have a friend with a cute dog, putting the dog in your picture, that's not representative of your life. It's like, show us authentically what spent with you would be like. So if you once went on a hike, but you actually spent every Saturday night playing board games, take a picture at board game night. Don't show that one hiking photo. And so I think the dog or cat thing kind of fits into that overall advice of authentically show us who you are. And if that involves your dog, great. But if not, like, don't take 8,000 pictures, some of which have a stranger's dog in them.
- [127:09]
Shane Parrish
I always end on the same question, which is, what is successful for you?
- [127:14]
Logan Urie
Success for me is balance. Feeling like I'm not forsaking my health for the sake of career, not feeling like I'm forsaking my husband. For the sake of our daughter. Not feeling like I'm forsaking my family for the sake of my friends and really just knowing my priorities and having that reflected in how I spend my time.
- [127:38]
Shane Parrish
Thank you so much. This was an awesome conversation.
- [127:41]
Logan Urie
Thanks for having me. I really enjoyed it.
- [127:43]
Shane Parrish
Thank you for listening and learning with me. If you've enjoyed this episode, consider leaving a five star rating or review. It's a small action on your part that helps us reach more curious minds. You can stay connected with Farnam street on social media and explore more insights at FS Blog where you'll find past episodes, our mental models, and thought provoking articles. While you're there, check out my book Clear Thinking through Engaging Stories and Actionable Mental Models. It helps you bridge the gap between intention and action so your best decisions become your default decisions. Until next time.