The Reckoning

Summary

Podcast Summary: The Last Appeal – Episode 4: "The Reckoning"

Podcast: The Last Appeal
Host: Lester Holt (NBC News)
Air Date: October 9, 2025

---

Overview:

This urgent episode, "The Reckoning," investigates the case of Robert Roberson—a Texas father facing execution on October 16th for the 2002 death of his 2-year-old daughter. With mounting questions about the evidence, scientific validity of "shaken baby syndrome," and the fairness of the original trial, Lester Holt brings forward exclusive interviews that unearth new information, reveal critical missteps in the prosecution, and highlight the emotional and ethical weight of potentially executing an innocent man.

---

Key Discussion Points and Insights

1. Robert Roberson’s Near Execution and Current Situation

• Last-minute Stay: Robert recounts his experience awaiting execution, detailing the preparation, emotional toll, and eventual last-minute reprieve by the Texas Supreme Court.
  • Quote, Robert Roberson (00:24): "I had to strip and they gave me some, some other fresh clothing... then they gave me a pair of cloth, cloth slippers for my feet... had to put the belt of the chain around me and handcuffs and lock it in place."
  • Quote, Robert Roberson (01:41): "It was a very, very, very long day, sir."
• Do-Over: Now, with a new execution date set, Lester asks if Robert regrets not taking a plea bargain.
  • Quote, Robert Roberson (02:02): "No, I'm glad that I, that I didn't... It's about the truth. It's about the truth."
• Robert remains hopeful, though he is again counting down the last days of his life.

2. Legislative Intervention and Judicial Resistance

• Legislative Panel: Texas lawmakers made an unprecedented move to summon Robert for testimony to potentially stall his execution ([02:35]–[03:25]).
• State Intervention: The Texas Attorney General’s office blocked Robert’s testimony, arguing it violated the law, yet the legislative hearing continues without him.
• Outside Expert Support: John Grisham (author, Innocence Project board member) testifies about the dangers of wrongful “shaken baby” convictions and questions the fairness of Robert's trial.
  • Quote, John Grisham (03:50): "I know what it takes to have a fair trial. Robert's trial was grossly unfair."

3. Critical Juror Testimony—Doubts Cast on Conviction

• Juror’s Change of Heart: Original juror Terry Compton reveals she would have voted not guilty if presented with evidence about Nikki’s medical history and Robert’s autism.
  • Quote, Terry Compton (05:01): "Very much difference. I would have found him not guilty."
  • Discusses the personal guilt and anguish over the possibility of executing an innocent man:
    • Quote, Terry Compton (05:14): "It'll be a certain place of guilt that I'll have to carry around with me for the rest of my life."
  • Quote, Terry Compton (05:29): "My actual hopes or feelings is that they should let him go because I think he is innocent."

4. Prosecution’s Stance and Media Silence

• District Attorney and AG Unavailable: DA Allison Mitchell and AG Ken Paxton both decline interviews. In press statements, Paxton alleges unproven claims of violence and sexual assault, still denying the “shaken baby” syndrome was central to the conviction.
• Juror Terry Compton disputes Paxton’s version:
  • Quote, Terry Compton (07:08): "It was all about shaken baby syndrome. I remember them just keep going over and over that it had to be from this shaken baby."

5. National and State Reckoning Over “Shaken Baby Syndrome”

• Recent Exonerations: The Burns and Roark cases are highlighted, showing a national trend of overturned convictions as “shaken baby syndrome” comes under fire.
  • Josh Burns (Michigan case): Convicted due to a child abuse diagnosis, later exonerated when the diagnosis was proven medically unsound.
    • Quote, Josh Burns (10:07): "The doctor said retinal hemorrhages are diagnostic of child abuse... it was just a theory... that the only thing this could be is shaken baby syndrome."
  • Andrew Roark (Texas): Conviction vacated in 2024—same pediatric specialist involved as in Robert’s case.
    • Quote, Andrew Roark (13:31): "Had the child died in my case, I would be in the same position he's in because they sure as hell would have put me on death row for this, for sure."

6. Lead Detective’s New Stand

• Brian Wharton: The detective who originally helped convict Robert now pleads for clemency, calling him a friend and professing both doubt about the original verdict and deep concern for justice.
  • Quote, Brian Wharton (14:24): "If we can't save someone like Robert, who is so clearly innocent, then truly we're lost."
  • Quote, Brian Wharton (14:36): "I will die a little myself."

7. Legal Breakthroughs and New Evidence

• Conflict of Interest News: Gretchen Swinn (Robert’s lawyer) uncovers that Judge Bascom Bentley—who presided over Robert’s trial—had previously intervened during Nikki’s final hours regarding parental rights, suggesting judicial bias.
  • Quote, Gretchen Swinn (16:46): "Now we have a name. It's a big name... he was the judge that signed the arrest warrant and went on to preside over the entire trial."
  • Quote, Gretchen Swinn (17:36): "The trial itself should be null and void."

8. Persistent Hope and Final Reflections

• Robert’s Hope: Despite everything, Robert remains hopeful about exoneration.
  • Quote, Robert Roberson (17:59): "I'm hoping and praying that they would do the right thing, that I'd be fully exonerated, you know?"
  • Quote, Robert Roberson (18:12): "No, actually, I'm still hopeful. I still got a lot of hope."
• Juror and Supporter Pleas: With only days left, calls for mercy and for Texas not to "kill an innocent man" are passionate and pervasive.
  • Quote, Terry Compton (18:23): "Texas... do not kill the innocent man."

---

Notable Quotes and Memorable Moments

• "It's about the truth. It's about the truth."
  — Robert Roberson (02:02)
• "I would have found him not guilty."
  — Terry Compton, Juror (05:01)
• "If we can't save someone like Robert, who is so clearly innocent, then truly we're lost."
  — Brian Wharton, Detective (14:24)
• "Judicial process has failed us, has failed Robert. And I have nothing but righteous rage..."
  — Gretchen Swinn, Attorney (15:06)
• "The trial itself should be null and void."
  — Gretchen Swinn, Attorney (17:36)
• "I'm still hopeful. I still got a lot of hope."
  — Robert Roberson (18:12)

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 00:12–01:41: Robert recounts the day of his near-execution
• 02:35–03:50: Legislative maneuvers and expert testimony (John Grisham)
• 04:20–05:37: Juror Terry Compton describes her regrets and belief in Robert’s innocence
• 06:28–07:16: Prosecution’s position and juror’s rebuttal
• 09:42–10:27: Josh Burns’ case and the problem with shaken baby science
• 11:37–13:46: Andrew Roark’s exoneration; parallels to Robert’s case
• 14:47–15:20: Detective Brian Wharton and Gretchen Swinn rally at the Capitol
• 16:10–17:36: Revelations about Judge Bentley’s involvement and legal implications
• 17:59–18:12: Robert expresses hope despite imminent execution
• 18:23–End: Final pleas and reflections

---

Conclusion

"The Reckoning" exposes serious flaws in the case against Robert Roberson, foregrounding personal accounts from those who now believe the state is on the brink of killing an innocent man. It chronicles last-minute legal battles, shifting views from jurors and investigators, national shifts in medical consensus, and the emotional toll for everyone involved. Listeners are left with urgent, haunting questions about justice, truth, scientific uncertainty, and the irrevocable consequences of capital punishment.

Transcript

[Lester Holt]

Foreign. Last year, Robert Roberson was less than two hours away from dying when he won a last minute stay.

[Robert Roberson]

That was a long day.

[Lester Holt]

He recently shared with me what hardly anyone lives to describe the choreography of an execution, the hours leading up to his own death.

[Robert Roberson]

I had to strip and they gave me some, some other fresh clothing and stuff and stuff. And then they gave me a pair of cloth, cloth slippers for my feet, you know, and had to, had to put the belt of the chain around me and handcuffs and lock it in place.

[Lester Holt]

Officers loaded Robert into a van bound for the 50 mile drive to Huntsville, the death chamber. He was led to a tiny cell.

[Robert Roberson]

So I was walking back and forth, kind of pacing and stuff, you know, I was talking to the Lord, praying to the Lord, you know. Then they brought me some supposed to be last meal and stuff, you know, had a choice between two of them. One of them has like a hamburger Salisbury steak on it and the other one had some rice mixture, looked kind of like Spanish style. I picked that one and stuff, you know.

[Lester Holt]

Robert was counting down the final minutes of his life not knowing if the next footstep would be news of mercy or death.

[Robert Roberson]

I believe it was around six or somewhere around there, gotta stay or something. But then I heard they took it.

[Lester Holt]

Back right until shortly after 10pm when the execution was called off. The Texas Supreme Court had issued a last minute stay.

[Robert Roberson]

It was a very, very, very long day, sir.

[Lester Holt]

You know, Robert's prayers were answered. That was then. But now the clock is ticking again.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

And now the state of course has a new death date for you.

[Robert Roberson]

Yes, sir.

[Lester Holt]

Do you wish you had taken the plea bargain?

[Robert Roberson]

No, I'm glad that I, that I didn't.

[Lester Holt]

But look where you are.

[Robert Roberson]

Yeah, look where I'm at. Thank you. It's about the truth. It's about the truth.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

Have you thought about last words, what you'll say?

[Robert Roberson]

Well, that's a good one there. And it's a hard question, right?

[Lester Holt]

I'm Lester Holt and this is the Last Appeal, a podcast from Dateline. Episode 4 the Reckoning.

[Committee Member / Legislator]

I move as follows.

[Lester Holt]

In October 2024, lawmakers had successfully saved Robert's life using an unprecedented and deliberate maneuver.

[Committee Member / Legislator]

Robert Robertson to provide all relevant testimony.

[Josh Burns]

And information concerning the committee's inquiry.

[Lester Holt]

They had summoned him to testify, but there was a catch. The hearing was set after Roberson's scheduled execution. Robert was eager to tell his story, but when the date came, he never made it to the capitol. Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton blocked him, arguing to the state's top court that the subpoena violated the law, and he said transporting Robert to the House chamber could be dangerous. Still, the legislators pressed on with the hearing.

[Josh Burns]

The House Committee on Criminal Jurisprudence will come to order.

[Brian Wharton]

The.

[Lester Holt]

Instead, they called other witnesses to testify.

[Brian Wharton]

Mr. Grisham, are you able to hear me?

[Committee Member / Legislator]

I can hear you, yes.

[Brian Wharton]

Can you hear me okay? Perfect.

[Committee Member / Legislator]

All right.

[Lester Holt]

Among them, bestselling author and lawyer John Grisham, who. Who spoke with the committee through a video call.

[Committee Member / Legislator]

It's my honor to be here to speak for Robert Roberson.

[Lester Holt]

He's been closely following Roberts case.

[Committee Member / Legislator]

I've been on the board of the Innocence Project in New York for a long, long time. And for the past 15 years or so, we have been more and more concerned about the shaken baby syndrome. Shaken baby convictions. And I know what it takes to have a fair trial. Roberts trial was grossly unfair.

[Terry Compton]

It is a great honor to be here testifying before this committee.

[Lester Holt]

Another witness, Someone you've already heard from in this podcast.

[Terry Compton]

My name is Terry Compton. I was One of the 12 jurors on the case of Robert Robinson's trial, and I took that position very seriously.

[Lester Holt]

Terry Compton, the juror, had gotten a visit from Gretchen Swin, Robert's lawyer. She said she was furious after Gretchen told her details that the jurors didn't know about Nikki's medical history, about Robert's autism. Now, Terry made a stunning admission.

[Committee Member / Legislator]

If you had known that, would that have made a difference in how you voted in this case?

[Terry Compton]

Yes, sir.

[Josh Burns]

How big of a difference?

[Terry Compton]

Very much difference. I would have found him not guilty.

[Committee Member / Legislator]

This must have weighed on you over the last few months.

[Terry Compton]

Very much.

[Lester Holt]

When I spoke with Terry recently, she told me if Robert is killed, it's going to take a toll on her.

[Terry Compton]

I know it's gonna be something that I will have to live with for the rest of my life. It'll be a certain place of guilt that I'll have to carry around with me for the rest of my life.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

So what are your hopes now in this case?

[Terry Compton]

My actual hopes or feelings is that they should let him go because I think he is innocent.

[Lester Holt]

With so much uncertainty surrounding Robert's case, discredited science, missing evidence, the lead detective admitting he was wrong, and now a juror changing her mind. We wanted to ask the prosecutor why Texas seems so intent on killing Robert. I stopped by Allison Mitchell's office, the Anderson County District Attorney.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

So we're just here to talk about the Robert Robertson case.

[Gretchen Swinn]

Yes, Yes, I remember.

[Andrew Roark]

You called.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

So she's actually in a jury trial right now.

[Lester Holt]

I was in the car when Mitchell sent an email.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

I heard from Allison Mitchell.

[Lester Holt]

She says, sorry I missed you today. I was in a jury. She said she couldn't talk because the case is pending and suggested I reach out to the Attorney General's office. The AG is currently handling the case.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

On behalf of this office.

[Lester Holt]

We asked the ag, Ken Paxton, for an interview. We never heard back. But in a press release earlier this year, he called Robert violent, said he confessed to a jailhouse informant that he sexually assaulted Nikki. Allegations that have never been proven. He said all that talk of shaken baby syndrome was a red herring, that Nikki was beaten, a. A victim of blunt force trauma. Paxton wrote, quote, the jury did not convict Robert on the basis of shaken baby syndrome. We asked Terry, the juror about that.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

Do you remember what the essence of the state's case was?

[Terry Compton]

It was all about shaken baby syndrome. I remember them just keep going over and over that it had to be from this shaken baby.

[Lester Holt]

Despite all the controversy and pleas for mercy this past June, Paxton asked a judge to set Robert's new execution date. Gretchen pleaded with the judge not to, pointing out Robert still has an appeal pending and the courts have not been responsive. Why now, she asked, when there was no legal reason to do so? The judge told Gretchen he was sympathetic about the lack of response, but said, quote, a justice system that doesn't move is unjust. The judge said it was time to move and scheduled Robert's third. Third date with the death chamber.

[Gretchen Swinn]

A judge has set a new execution date for the Texas man who could.

[Lester Holt]

October 16, 2025. Nikki's brother, Matthew Bowman says it's time. Do you think that Robert's execution will.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

Bring closure or simply start another difficult chapter?

[Committee Member / Legislator]

Be honest with you. I mean, it would. If they do go ahead and do this, yes, my family will be finally able to breathe.

[Lester Holt]

If Texas kills him, Robert will be the first person in United States to be executed because of a shaken baby diagnosis. So if Robert is about to be killed, his supporters want to know why others convicted under the same outdated medical theory have been exonerated.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

How could it be that you were exonerated in the state of Texas and Robert Roberson is now facing death?

[Andrew Roark]

That's what we're all asking, Lester.

[Lester Holt]

In Texas, science, faith and justice are colliding.

[Gretchen Swinn]

Do not execute an innocent man, please.

[Lester Holt]

With just 12 days left for Robert to live, his supporters gathered at the Texas State Capitol. One of them was Josh Burns.

[Josh Burns]

I learned about Robert Robertson, who is a father on Texas death row and now scheduled to be executed under the same scientifically unsound shaken baby syndrome hypothesis that has caused my family so much harm.

[Lester Holt]

In 2014, Josh, a commercial pilot from Michigan, called Nine One One after his two month old daughter became listless and unresponsive at the hospital. He told doctors that a couple of days earlier she may have bumped her head.

[Josh Burns]

He came and did a bedside eye exam and found retinal hemorrhages, one leg.

[Lester Holt]

Of the triad that once defined the shaken baby syndrome theory.

[Josh Burns]

The doctor said retinal hemorrhages are diagnostic of child abuse. We're referring your daughter to a child abuse pediatrician who then accused us of shaken baby syndrome. It was just a theory from the child abuse pediatrician. She says that the only thing this could be is shaken baby syndrome.

[Lester Holt]

Based on that, Josh was charged with second degree child abuse, convicted and served a year in jail. His appeals were denied. But a decade later, the Michigan Attorney General's Conviction Integrity Unit reviewed Josh's case. Last year, he was exonerated. There had been no crime, just a bad medical diagnosis. Josh Burns isn't alone. Across the country, a reckoning is underway. According to the National Registry of exonerations, more than 40 people have been exonerated due to a shaken baby diagnosis. Courts have taken notice. In Illinois, a federal district judge wrote that new developments arguably suggest shaken baby syndrome is more an article of faith than a proposition of science. A New Jersey appellate court held that shaken baby syndrome lacks scientific reliability. And last year in Texas, where Robert Roberson is on death row, a man was exonerated in a shaken baby case. Andrew, can you just please introduce yourself?

[Andrew Roark]

Yes, my name is Andrew Roark.

[Lester Holt]

Robert's supporters say the two cases are strikingly similar. In 1997, Andrew Roark was home alone watching his girlfriend's 13 month old daughter Brooke. Like Robert, who said Nikki had fallen from a bed, Andrew said Brooke had also fallen a short distance.

[Andrew Roark]

She had slipped and hit her head in a tub very lightly.

[Lester Holt]

Andrew put Brooke down for a nap, only to later find her on the floor.

[Andrew Roark]

She's gasping for breath and unresponsive. So I picked her up, ran to the phone, called 91 1.

[Lester Holt]

Like Nikki, Brooke ended up at Dallas's Children's Medical center where she was evaluated by a pediatric specialist who diagnosed her with shaken baby syndrome. That specialist was the same one who saw Nikki, Dr. Janet Squires. She declined our request for an interview. Unlike Nikki, Brooks survived. Andrew was arrested for child abuse. While leaving the hospital, we end up.

[Andrew Roark]

At an elevator bank and there's five DeSoto police officers jump me and arrest me right there in the hospital.

[Lester Holt]

Andrew was convicted of injury to a child and sentenced to 35 years in prison. He served 2:13 before being released. Last year, the same week Texas was preparing to kill Robert, Andrew's conviction was vacated. In a statement, the Dallas County DA said, quote, current advancements in medical and scientific understanding would no longer support the state's theory at trial.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

How could it be that you going through a situation like this, were exonerated in the state of Texas and Robert Roberson is now facing death?

[Andrew Roark]

That's what we're all asking, Lester. Had the child died in my case, I would be in the same position he's in because they sure as hell would have put me on death row for this, for sure.

[Brian Wharton]

Robert has never wavered.

[Lester Holt]

Brian Wharton, the detective turned minister who once helped build the case against Robert, is again fighting to stop the clock.

[Brian Wharton]

Robert is my friend. I care about him deeply. I wouldn't go so far as to.

[Lester Holt]

Say I love Robert. Bryan was at that rally on the steps of the Capitol, begging the state for time and the crowd for faith.

[Brian Wharton]

Robert is a very good man, full of grace and joy and forgiveness.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

Can his life be saved at this point?

[Brian Wharton]

Gosh, I pray it can. If we can't save someone like Robert, who is so clearly innocent, then truly we're lost.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

How will you feel if he does not receive a stay?

[Brian Wharton]

I will die a little myself.

[Gretchen Swinn]

I thank you. Thank you for braving the really brutal son.

[Lester Holt]

Gretchen Swinn was there, too. She climbed the steps and addressed the crowd.

[Gretchen Swinn]

It's a perfect metaphor for what we need. We need the sunlight. We need noise.

[Lester Holt]

Reason.

[Gretchen Swinn]

Judicial process has failed us, has failed Robert. And I have nothing but righteous rage on behalf of my client Robert, because I know he's in the Queen.

[Lester Holt]

She is still furiously working to save Robert.

[Gretchen Swinn]

We have countless appeals. It feels pending, trying to plan out what happens if a door slams. What other door can be opened.

[Lester Holt]

She thinks this podcast may have opened a door. I called Gretchen to find out why.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

Thanks for doing this on short notice.

[Lester Holt]

First of all, describe the significance of what you heard and how it figures into your case.

[Gretchen Swinn]

I listened to the first episode of your podcast on Monday morning, and quite shockingly, is a revelation about an unknown fact.

[Lester Holt]

What caught her ear was a detail Nikki's grandfather, Larry Bowman, told me about the final hours of Nikki's life in the hospital.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

Did you have to make the decision to take her off support?

[Lester Holt]

Yeah, we did. Larry told me that a judge spoke with the hospital and informed them that he and his wife, not Robert, would make decisions about Nikki's medical care. Gretchen knew that. What she didn't know was the judge's name.

[Josh Burns]

Matter of fact, Judge Bentley told him.

[Robert Roberson]

That we were the parents.

[Lester Holt]

Judge Bascom Bentley, the same judge who presided over Robert's murder trial. He passed away in 2017. Now you have a name.

[Gretchen Swinn]

Now we have a name. It's a big name. I'm sorry if I sound agitated, but it was quite the shock to realize he was the judge that signed the arrest warrant and went on to preside over the entire trial.

[Lester Holt]

To Gretchen, that was proof of something powerful that Judge Bentley had decided Robert was guilty of before he'd been arrested.

[Gretchen Swinn]

I find it hard to imagine how someone wouldn't believe that. This information shows that this judge had already made a decision that Robert was guilty.

[Lester Holt]

Over the summer, Gretchen filed a motion about the parental rights issue. The state responded, arguing it was speculation that no judge ever spoke with the hospital. Within 24 hours of listening to the podcast, Gretchen raced to court and amended her motion with the name of the judge that Larry had given us.

[Gretchen Swinn]

The trial itself should be null and void.

[Lester Holt]

The Attorney General has yet to respond to the filing. Gretchen won't give up, and Robert knows it.

[Robert Roberson]

To me, she's perfect. She's real compassionate, real kind, and real committed to this type of work.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

You know, Robert, where and how does this story end in your mind?

[Robert Roberson]

How does it end? I'm hoping and praying that they would do the right thing, that I'd be fully exonerated, you know?

[Interviewer/Reporter]

You know, when we talked last time, I think we talked a little bit about hope.

[Robert Roberson]

Yes, sir.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

Is it harder to be hopeful now?

[Robert Roberson]

No, actually, I'm still hopeful. I still got a lot of hope.

[Lester Holt]

Once again, Robert is counting down the hours of his life.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

The whole world is watching.

[Terry Compton]

Texas.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

Do not kill the innocent man.

[Lester Holt]

October 16th is nearly here. Robert's third date with death. Will it be his last? The Last Appeal is a production of Dateline and NBC News.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

It is written and produced by Dan.

[Lester Holt]

Slappian, Liz Brown Kurloff and Lynn Keller. Our field producers are Nick McElroy and Rachel Yang, with production help from Sam Springer. It's edited by Colin Dow, Greg Smith, Deb Brown and David Varga. From NBC News, audio, sound mixing by Rob Byers, Joe Plourd and Rich Cutler. Head of audio production is Bryson Barnes. Paul Ryan is executive producer and Liz Cole is senior executive producer of Dateline.