The Majority Report with Sam Seder: Episode 2453 Summary

Title: Trump’s McKinley Fixation; Free Mahmoud Khalil
Host: Sam Seder
Release Date: March 13, 2025
Guests: David McWilliams, Lily Greenberg-Call

Introduction

In Episode 2453 of The Majority Report with Sam Seder, host Sam Seder delves into two pressing issues: Donald Trump's apparent fixation on President William McKinley and the controversial detention of Mahmoud Khalil. The episode features insightful discussions with economist David McWilliams and activist Lily Greenberg-Call, highlighting historical parallels and current political dynamics.

Trump’s Obsession with William McKinley

Guest: David McWilliams
Timestamp: [28:20] – [55:38]

David McWilliams, an esteemed economist and podcast host, explores the intriguing parallels between Donald Trump's presidency and that of William McKinley from the late 19th century.

Key Points:

1. Historical Context of McKinley’s Presidency:

   • William McKinley, a Republican from Ohio, became president during a transformative era characterized by economic growth, immigration, and territorial expansion.
   • McKinley’s tenure marked the rise of big business influence and the advent of lobbying in American politics, mirroring modern oligarchic influences.

2. Parallels Between McKinley and Trump:

   • Tariff Policies: McKinley was known as the "Napoleon of tariffs," believing tariffs were essential for American economic growth. Similarly, Trump has aggressively employed tariffs, particularly targeting European alcohol, likened to a "regressive sales tax." McWilliams notes, “a tariff is a tax and it’s passed on to consumers” ([13:00]).
   • Oligarchic Influence: Just as McKinley was backed by industrial titans like Rockefeller and JP Morgan, Trump’s administration is influenced by contemporary oligarchs such as Elon Musk and Jeff Bezos.
   • Territorial Expansion and Imperialism: McKinley initiated small territorial acquisitions post-Spanish-American War, akin to Trump’s initiatives like Greenland and his stance on the Panama Canal.
   • Isolationism and Anti-European Sentiment: Both presidents exhibited isolationist tendencies and a strong anti-European stance, reinforcing nationalistic ideologies.

3. Economic and Social Implications:

   • McKinley’s policies led to significant wealth inequalities and set the stage for future economic reforms like the New Deal.
   • Trump’s unilateral tariff policies are criticized for fostering economic uncertainty and potential stagflation, as businesses grapple with unpredictable trade wars.

4. Cultural Reflections:

   • McWilliams draws a fascinating connection between McKinley and the Wizard of Oz, suggesting the film serves as an allegory for the class struggles and cultural wars of McKinley’s era, much like contemporary America’s divisions.

Notable Quotes:

• “A tariff is a tax and it’s passed on to consumers” – David McWilliams ([13:00]).
• “Trump is saying like we can go around that I can do this unilaterally and make it so that everyday people bear this burden” – David McWilliams ([18:45]).

Analysis of Tariffs and Economic Policies

Discussion Between Hosts and Guest

McWilliams and co-host Matt Binder dissect the ramifications of Trump's broad and punitive tariff implementations. They argue that unlike targeted tariffs aimed at fostering specific industries (e.g., the CHIPS Act for semiconductor manufacturing), Trump’s sweeping tariffs on European goods like alcohol serve as a regressive economic burden on American consumers, exacerbating income inequality.

Key Points:

• Impact on Consumers and Businesses:

  • Broad tariffs lead to increased costs for everyday goods, disproportionately affecting middle and lower-income families.
  • Businesses face uncertainty, hindering investment and economic stability.

• Historical vs. Modern Tariffs:

  • While McKinley’s tariffs aimed at protecting burgeoning American industries, Trump’s tariffs appear more punitive and less strategic, lacking the nuanced implementation required for economic growth.

• Potential for Economic Conflict:

  • Tariff wars between the U.S., Canada, and Europe may escalate into broader economic or even military conflicts, reminiscent of historical economic rivalries.

Notable Quotes:

• “If you want to incentivize onshore manufacturing of X product, you slap a tariff on the import of that particular product” – David McWilliams ([17:08]).
• “Tariffs, very, very blunt, very regressive” – David McWilliams ([17:08]).

The Historical Parallels and Implications

Further Discussion with David McWilliams

McWilliams elaborates on the long-term effects of McKinley’s policies, drawing direct lines to potential future outcomes under Trump’s administration.

Key Points:

• Wealth Inequality:

  • McKinley’s era saw a significant rise in wealth disparities, a trend McWilliams warns could intensify under Trump’s policies.

• Introduction of Lobbying:

  • The 1896 election marked the genesis of modern lobbying, heavily influencing policy in favor of big business, a practice further entrenched in today’s political landscape.

• Cyclical Economic Policies:

  • McWilliams suggests that the repeating cycle of economic booms and busts, influenced by protectionist policies, could lead to prolonged economic instability.

Notable Quotes:

• “Tariffs are really gone to the back of the American public” – David McWilliams ([16:54]).
• “This is a regressive sales tax, basically, in terms of how it functions” – David McWilliams ([17:08]).
• “This is their effort to like. It's a very far right libertarian vision” – David McWilliams ([19:13]).

Detention of Mahmoud Khalil

Guests: Lily Greenberg-Call, Ramzi Kassim
Timestamp: [57:49] – [74:53]

The episode shifts focus to the alarming detention of Mahmoud Khalil, an immigrant and Palestinian activist at Columbia University. Former Democratic administration staffer Lily Greenberg-Call and activist Ramzi Kassim address the unconstitutionality and political motivations behind his detention.

Key Points:

1. Circumstances of Detention:

   • Khalil, a recent Columbia graduate, was detained without criminal charges for his activism opposing Israel’s military actions in Gaza.
   • His detention involved a mysterious abduction by Trump officials, who relocated him from New Jersey to Louisiana without notifying his family or legal counsel.

2. Violation of First Amendment Rights:

   • Khalil’s detention is a blatant breach of free speech rights, as he was targeted solely for his political views and activism.

3. Political Reactions and Antisemitism:

   • Democratic leaders like Chuck Schumer condemned Khalil by associating him with anti-Semitic actions, while others like Chris Murphy offered more robust support.
   • The Trump administration has been criticized for using antisemitic rhetoric to justify political repression, exacerbating tensions within Jewish communities.

4. Historical Context and Legislative Abuse:

   • The statute used to detain Khalil was historically intended to target Soviet agents, not for suppressing political speech, highlighting its misuse.
   • This mirrors past authoritarian practices where legislation is weaponized to silence dissenters under the guise of national security.

5. Call to Action:

   • Guests urge listeners to mobilize, advocate for Khalil’s release, and resist authoritarian measures threatening democratic freedoms.

Notable Quotes:

• “Khalil is a recent graduate of Columbia University... there is no evidence he has broken any law.” – Emma Vigeland ([59:46]).
• “It requires the Secretary of State to notify Congress with supporting evidence for why they're making this move.” – Emma Vigeland ([69:21]).
• “This is going to breed resentment of Jews to take away people's rights in our name.” – Ramzi Kassim ([72:48]).

Reactions from Political Figures and Communities

Discussion with Ramzi Kassim and Lily Greenberg-Call

Ramzi Kassim articulates the broader implications of Khalil’s detention, linking it to historical patterns of antisemitism and authoritarianism.

Key Points:

• Community Impact:

  • Khalil’s abduction not only threatens individual rights but also aims to instill fear within activist communities, signaling a crackdown on dissent.
  • American Jewish organizations and leaders are mobilizing to condemn the administration’s actions and protect civil liberties.

• Historical Echoes:

  • The use of antisemitic language and tactics recalls McCarthy-era persecution, highlighting a cyclical trend of using bigotry to justify repressive policies.

• Strategies for Resistance:

  • Emphasis on grassroots activism, public demonstrations, and unified community responses to counteract authoritarian measures.
  • Encouragement for Jewish and allied communities to lead in defending democratic values and opposing fascist agendas.

Notable Quotes:

• “There is no evidence that Mahmoud said anything that would... it's still an illegal detention.” – David McWilliams ([63:40]).
• “We need to be fighting for Mahmoud as if he is one of our own, because he is one of our own.” – Ramzi Kassim ([72:47]).
• “If we don't fight back, then we're not going to have much to fight for.” – Ramzi Kassim ([72:47]).

Call to Action

Throughout the episode, hosts emphasize the importance of listener engagement in combating the administration’s policies. They urge the audience to:

• Contact Senators: Listeners are encouraged to call their senators at 202-224-3121 to express opposition to the continuing resolution that permits budget cuts affecting various sectors.

Notable Quotes:

• “Call your senators. 202-224-3121 is the number.” – David McWilliams ([04:22]).
• “The number is 646-257-3920. We'll open up the phone lines on the other side of this.” – David McWilliams ([77:28]).

Conclusion

Episode 2453 of The Majority Report with Sam Seder offers a deep dive into the historical underpinnings of current political strategies under Donald Trump, drawing chilling similarities to William McKinley’s presidency. Coupled with a critical examination of the authoritarian detention of Mahmoud Khalil, the episode serves as a potent reminder of the fragility of democratic freedoms and the enduring struggle against oligarchic and authoritarian influences.

Listeners are left with a sense of urgency to mobilize and defend democratic principles, ensuring that historical lessons inform present and future actions.

Recommended Listening:

• David McWilliams Podcast: For an in-depth exploration of the historical parallels discussed.
• Ramzi Kassim’s Interview on Democracy Now: Featuring comprehensive insights into Mahmoud Khalil’s case.

For more information and to support The Majority Report, visit Majority.FM.