The McShay Show: Behind the Scenes at the Manning Passing Academy
Release Date: June 30, 2025
Host/Author: Todd McShay, The Ringer

Introduction to the Manning Passing Academy

In this episode, Todd McShay dives deep into his recent experience attending the Manning Passing Academy in Thibodeau, Louisiana. Established 29 years ago by Archie Manning, the academy has evolved into a premier event for aspiring quarterbacks across the nation. Todd, accompanied by co-host Steve, shares firsthand insights into the dynamics of the camp, the caliber of quarterbacks present, and the broader implications for the upcoming NFL draft.

The Evolution and Foundation of the Academy

Mensch provides a comprehensive background on the Manning Passing Academy, highlighting its growth from a small familial gathering to a massive event hosting 1,500 quarterbacks aged 12 to 18. This expansion underscores the academy's reputation as a foundational step for young talent aiming for college football and eventually the NFL.

Mensch (01:30): "The foundation is at Manning Passing Academy, which is four days, starts on Thursday, goes through Sunday. You drive onto the campus of Nicholls State in Thibodeau, Louisiana, and there's quarterbacks everywhere."

Observing Elite Quarterbacks in Action

Todd recounts attending a high-stakes quarterback competition held during the camp. Surrounded by over 40 top quarterbacks, many of whom are college stars projected to be high NFL draft picks, Todd describes the atmosphere as the "purest form of football."

Mensch (08:00): "I was sitting there on Friday night at this quarterback competition with all those top quarterbacks, like 40 plus quarterbacks who are stars in college football this year, who are going to be the vast majority going to be NFL draft picks."

He emphasizes the genuine competition and lack of overt scouting presence, allowing quarterbacks to showcase their true skills without the pressure of scouts watching every move.

Key Takeaways from the Passing Sessions

Steve interrupts to highlight the importance of fundamental skills observed during the camp.

Steve (11:26): "It was an interesting part of it, watching what they were stressing. So we make sure, at least I make sure that I'm stressing the same things when I'm watching a quarterback."

Mensch agrees, noting that the camp reinforced the importance of basics like footwork and technique, which are crucial for evaluating a quarterback's potential.

Mensch (12:28): "It was interesting watching what they were stressing... the basics and what's really at the core of evaluating a quarterback."

Notable Quarterbacks and Their Impressions

Throughout the episode, Todd and Steve discuss several standout quarterbacks:

1. Arch Manning: Descendant of the Manning family, Arch displays a calm demeanor and exceptional talent. Todd praises his balance between seriousness and lightheartedness.

   Mensch (21:23): "Arch is in a different category because Arch was kind of bouncing around a little bit... he's got a really good balance of serious. We're here for business, let's work."

2. Lenora Sellers: From Oklahoma, Sellers impresses with his physical presence and strong arm, though Todd notes he is still developing consistency.

   Mensch (55:40): "Lenora Sellers was really interesting... tough program... good zip on the ball, moves around."

3. John Mattier: Despite initial impressions of resembling a fullback due to his build, Mattier showcases significant arm strength and adaptability.

   Mensch (60:01): "John Mattier... he's built like his lower body of a guard or something and... he's throwing... ripping the ball."

4. Sawyer Robertson: Baylor's Robertson stands out for his mobility and strong arm, despite transferring from Mississippi State.

   Mensch (60:01): "Sawyer Robertson... confident, smooth stroke, trusts his footwork... his father, Stan, was a first-round draft pick."

The Competitive Edge and Personal Interactions

Mensch shares anecdotes illustrating the competitive nature of the camp, such as quarterbacks strategically waiting to perform their best throws last.

Mensch (43:19): "Nussmeyer waited till the 45th throw to throw, studied every other throw... His deep ball was absolutely beautiful."

These interactions not only highlight individual talent but also the strategic mindset necessary for success at higher levels.

The Role of Coaches and Mentors

The presence of esteemed coaches like Jon Gruden and Charles Davis adds depth to the camp experience. Their hands-on involvement with quarterbacks underscores the academy’s commitment to comprehensive development.

Mensch (54:13): "He's teaching a drill to these high school kids. And he's, like, sweating and, you know, like, he's in the candy store."

Their mentorship provides invaluable real-world insights and techniques that quarterbacks can apply to their game.

Potential Impact on NFL Draft Evaluations

Todd and Steve discuss how the experiences and observations at the Manning Passing Academy may influence quarterback evaluations leading up to the NFL draft. The camp serves as a pivotal point for assessing not just physical talent but also mental fortitude and adaptability under pressure.

Mensch (46:58): "If you're going to do this job... to provide surface level to let people know if a player is going to fall or this is backup... it's our responsibility..."

Future Prospects and Final Thoughts

Concluding the episode, Todd emphasizes the continuous evolution of the quarterbacks and the ongoing development necessary for NFL readiness. The mentorship, competitive environment, and exposure provided by the Manning Passing Academy are instrumental in shaping the next generation of NFL quarterbacks.

Mensch (77:11): "I'm not shifting anything, man... I have a much deeper understanding of all of it... it's our responsibility to do all the little things."

He encourages listeners to stay engaged with The McShay Show for upcoming detailed analyses and mock drafts, promising more in-depth coverage of quarterbacks like Clemson’s emerging stars in future episodes.

Notable Quotes

• Mensch (01:30): "We grind through these winters, right? It's like the payoff you get three, four months."
• Mensch (12:28): "The basics are that technique are the fundamentals."
• Steve (11:26): "It's probably a good thing to do annually and as an evaluator you're always evaluating yourself."
• Mensch (21:23): "Arch is in a different category... he's got a really good balance of serious and lightheartedness."

Conclusion

This episode of The McShay Show offers an in-depth look into the Manning Passing Academy, revealing the intricate processes of quarterback development and evaluation. Todd McShay provides valuable perspectives that not only enhance the listener’s understanding of the NFL draft landscape but also highlight the essential qualities that make a quarterback successful at the professional level. Whether you're a dedicated football fan or new to the sport, this episode delivers rich insights into the future stars of the NFL.

For full 1st Round Coverage and to subscribe to The McShay Report, visit the provided links:

• 1st Round Coverage
• The McShay Report