The McShay Show: Day 1 from the NFL Scouting Combine Release Date: February 27, 2025

Hosts: Todd McShay & Mike Greenberg

Overview

In this episode of The McShay Show, hosts Todd McShay and Mike Greenberg delve deep into the happenings at the 2025 NFL Scouting Combine. As the countdown to the NFL Draft tightens to just 57 days, the duo discusses significant news such as Shedeur Sanders opting out of workouts, speculation surrounding Matthew Stafford's potential team moves, and pre-workout draft tiers. The conversation is rich with player evaluations, mock draft insights, and behind-the-scenes anecdotes, providing listeners with a comprehensive view of the draft landscape.

1. Setting the Scene at the Combine

Todd McShay kicks off the episode by recounting their eventful day at the NFL Scouting Combine. From early morning flights to last-minute hotel changes, Todd shares the challenges faced, including delays in hotel check-ins due to production logistics and a lack of NFL Network access, forcing them to stay outdoors.

Quote:
Todd McShay [03:00]: “We had a hell of a day. Up at 4:30, landed here on time. Bags came out quick... but then we just couldn't get in the hotel and we found out they don't have NFL Network for when we're back...”

Despite these hurdles, Todd remains enthusiastic about the day's interviews, including a notable conversation with Howie Roseman, General Manager of the Philadelphia Eagles.

2. Major News Highlights

a. Shedeur Sanders Sitting Out Workouts

A significant portion of the discussion revolves around Shedeur Sanders, who has decided not to participate in the Combine workouts. Todd attempts to contextualize this decision, comparing it to admitting guilt in a DUI situation—essentially, by not showcasing his abilities at the Combine, Sanders reinforces certain perceptions about his skills.

Quote:
Todd McShay [05:34]: “Shador Sanders is not going to throw. I equate it... he's admitting guilt.”

Todd emphasizes that while Sanders may not have the elite arm strength typical of top quarterbacks, his instincts and game intelligence make him a formidable pure passer. He also reassures listeners that NFL teams prioritize tape evaluation, interviews, and personal assessments over Combine performances when making draft decisions.

b. Matthew Stafford’s Potential Move

Another hot topic is Matthew Stafford's rumored interest in joining the Las Vegas Raiders or possibly the New York Giants. Todd speculates on the Raiders' potential pursuit of Stafford, highlighting Tom Brady's influence within the organization and suggesting that Stafford could serve as a bridge quarterback while teams like the Jets explore their options.

Quote:
Todd McShay [14:00]: “Matthew Stafford reportedly went skiing with Tom Brady... I think the Raiders absolutely have interest in Matthew Stafford.”

3. Pre-Workout Draft Tiers and Player Evaluations

Todd and Mike transition into a detailed analysis of players who are either unable or choosing not to work out at the Combine. They categorize these players into tiers based on their draft potential and injury histories.

a. Top Tier Defenders and Offensive Players

• Abdul Carter (Penn State): Considered the best player on Todd's board, Carter will not be working out.
• Mikel Williams (Georgia) & Jalen Walker (Georgia): Both ineligible to participate due to injuries.
• Colson Loveland (Michigan Tight End): Although recovering from shoulder surgery, he's expected to fully participate in training camp.

Quote:
Mike Greenberg [05:34]: “Abdul Carter, probably the best player in the draft... Jalen Walker from Georgia, also not going to work out.”

b. Impact of Injuries and Decisions

Todd discusses how injuries and decisions like not working out can influence a player's draft stock. He notes that while some may view opting out negatively, NFL teams look beyond these factors, valuing overall tape and potential.

c. Defensive Backs and Specialists

The conversation shifts to defensive backs, with particular emphasis on Jade Baron from Texas. Todd lauds Baron's versatility, ball skills, and football intelligence, considering him one of the top defensive backs in the class despite concerns over his speed.

Quote:
Todd McShay [59:43]: “You can't tell me there are 10 better football players in this 25 class than John A. Baron. You just can't.”

4. Mock Draft Insights and Tier Rankings

Todd shares his mock draft tier rankings, categorizing players into top tiers based on their potential and performance.

a. Quarterbacks

• Shedeur Sanders: Although not showcasing at the Combine, Sanders remains a top pure passer.
• Cam Ward: His potential remains fluid, with teams like the Cleveland Browns and Giants showing interest.

b. Running Backs and Defensive Linemen

• Ashton Genty (Boise State): Expected to rise in draft tiers.
• Shemar Stewart: Highlighted for his impressive physical attributes and potential impact.

c. Tight Ends and Wide Receivers

Todd debates the placement of tight ends like Tyler Warren and Colson Loveland, emphasizing Loveland's exceptional route-running and receiving capabilities.

Quote:
Todd McShay [48:20]: “He is so savvy. And run support... He can protect it 95% of the time.”

d. Wide Receivers

He evaluates receivers like Jaden Higgins from Iowa State, praising his route-running and potential to be a significant asset in NFL offenses.

5. Statistical Correlations and Player Performances

Todd introduces an analytical angle by discussing RTG (Run-to-Give) rankings from Pro Football Focus (PFF) and how last year's rankings correlate with draft outcomes and rookie performances.

Quote:
Todd McShay [80:25]: “If you were to rank the top rtgs from last year's class... my point is the rookie play on the field, much more was correlated much more with the RTG rank than where the draft pick was.”

This insight underscores the importance of objective metrics in evaluating player potential beyond traditional scouting methods.

6. Looking Ahead: Upcoming Workouts and Final Thoughts

As the episode nears its end, Todd and Mike anticipate the upcoming days at the Combine, particularly focusing on the defensive line and linebackers. They express excitement about the depth of talent and the potential for standout performances that could significantly impact draft positions.

Quote:
Todd McShay [84:32]: “The running backs are going to steal the show... We haven't seen that in seven, eight years.”

The hosts encourage listeners to tune in for daily updates and further analysis as the Combine progresses, promising in-depth coverage and continued mock draft refinements.

Conclusion

This episode of The McShay Show offers an exhaustive look into the 2025 NFL Scouting Combine, blending real-time observations with in-depth player evaluations and strategic mock drafting. Todd McShay and Mike Greenberg provide listeners with valuable insights into how the Combine's outcomes could shape the upcoming NFL Draft, making it an essential listen for football enthusiasts eager to stay ahead of the draft curve.

Notable Quotes:

• Todd McShay [05:34]: “Shador Sanders is not going to throw. I equate it... he's admitting guilt.”
• Todd McShay [14:00]: “Matthew Stafford reportedly went skiing with Tom Brady... I think the Raiders absolutely have interest in Matthew Stafford.”
• Todd McShay [59:43]: “You can't tell me there are 10 better football players in this 25 class than John A. Baron. You just can't.”