The McShay Show
Episode: LIVE NFL Draft Day 2 Recap and Analysis! Reaction to Shedeur Falling to Day 3
Release Date: April 26, 2025

Introduction

In this electrifying episode of The McShay Show, Todd McShay dives deep into the unexpected developments of Day 2 of the 2025 NFL Draft. The primary focus centers around the surprising fall of quarterback Shador Sanders to Day 3, a move that has left analysts and fans alike baffled. Joined by co-host Steve Mensch, Todd dissects the factors contributing to Sanders' draft position, compares him to his peers, and evaluates the strategic decisions made by various NFL teams.

Shador Sanders' Unexpected Fall

[00:57] Todd McShay:
"I warned people of the shrinking pool and that he didn't fit every scheme and that when he came to town there was going to be a media circus that came with it."

Todd begins by expressing his surprise over Shador Sanders not being selected in the first round. Despite ranking Sanders as the third-best quarterback and 21st overall prospect, several factors led to his slide:

• Scheme Fit: Sanders doesn't seamlessly fit into every team's offensive system, limiting his appeal.
• Media Circus: The intense media attention surrounding Sanders created uncertainties for teams considering high-profile picks.
• Physical Attributes: Concerns about Sanders' arm strength, size, and mobility played a significant role in teams' hesitation.

Todd emphasizes Sanders' strengths, highlighting his fast processing, accuracy, and leadership, which he deems unparalleled in his class.

Media Influence and Team Decisions

[07:05] Todd McShay:
"It's about fast processing, accuracy, quick decisions."

The discussion shifts to how media narratives and public perceptions can impact a player's draft stock. Todd draws parallels with past quarterbacks like Caleb Williams and Tim Tebow, illustrating how media portrayal and off-field behavior can sway team decisions.

[20:47] Todd McShay:
"Why would you try to shrink the pool unnecessarily?"

Todd critiques the NFL media landscape, suggesting that networks and reporters often overlook nuanced evaluations in favor of sensational stories. This oversight, he argues, contributed to the skepticism surrounding Sanders despite his evident talent.

Comparative Analysis: Shador Sanders vs. Peers

Todd compares Sanders to other quarterbacks in the draft, notably Dylan Gabriel and Caleb Williams:

• Dylan Gabriel:
  "Dylan Gabriel processes fast we joked around, mentioned it's like watching like the mate, not the Matrix."
  Despite Gabriel's speed, Todd believes Sanders possesses superior accuracy and decision-making abilities.

• Caleb Williams:
  "He is a mobile running threat. He does have an outstanding Arm."
  While Williams offers mobility and arm strength, Todd questions whether these attributes are sufficient in the current NFL landscape dominated by powerful defensive ends.

Impact of Team Schemes and Needs

The episode delves into how different teams' offensive schemes affect their quarterback evaluations:

• Cleveland Browns & Miami Dolphins:
  Todd praises coaches like Kevin Stefanski and Mike McDaniel for their ability to maximize quarterbacks who fit their specific systems, suggesting that Sanders would thrive under their guidance.

• New England Patriots:
  Despite acquiring multiple offensive players, the Patriots' quarterback situation remains a focal point. Todd discusses their recent picks, emphasizing the importance of protecting and enhancing the offensive line to support their existing quarterback.

[38:29] Steve Mensch:
"I'm curious. I'm sure you did."

Steve Mensch interjects, prompting Todd to shift focus and analyze team-specific draft outcomes beyond Sanders.

Team-Specific Draft Recaps and Analysis

Cleveland Browns

• Key Picks:
  Mason Graham, Carson Schlesinger, Darius Alexander
  Todd lauds Cleveland for strengthening their offensive line and adding versatile players who can bolster both the running and passing games.

[51:34] Steve Mensch:
"He gets a guy."
Steve highlights their strategic picks, emphasizing the Browns' commitment to building a robust offense.

Seattle Seahawks

• Key Picks:
  Jalen Milro, Nick Immon, Elijah Royo
  Todd appreciates Seattle's focus on developing a strong defensive backfield while securing immediate offensive weapons.

[59:12] Steve Mensch:
"I didn't want to bring it up."
Steve commends Seattle for their patience and strategic approach in building a balanced team.

New Orleans Saints

• Key Picks:
  Tyler Schuck, Vernon Broughton
  Todd notes New Orleans' preference for versatile offensive linemen and defensive playmakers, ensuring depth and flexibility.

Notable Quotes and Insights

• On Shador Sanders' Traits:
  "He’s the best pure passer in this class in terms of layering the ball touch, delivering the ball accurately, leading receivers to yards, leaving leading receivers open, then the fast processing."
  [02:15] Todd McShay

• On Media Impact:
  "It's about fast processing, accuracy, quick decisions."
  [07:05] Todd McShay

• On Team Scheme Fit:
  "In the right system, he absolutely can thrive. He can absolutely be on a team and lead that team and win 10, 11 games."
  [07:04] Todd McShay

• On Comparative Talent:
  "Shador is still on the board for all of those reasons that I just explained."
  [13:30] Todd McShay

Lessons and Conclusions

Todd McShay concludes the episode by reflecting on the unpredictability of the NFL Draft and the multifaceted factors influencing draft decisions:

• Holistic Evaluation: Teams must consider not just a player's physical attributes and skills but also their fit within specific offensive schemes and their ability to handle media scrutiny.

• Media Narratives: The perception and portrayal of players in the media can significantly impact their draft stock, sometimes overshadowing tangible talents.

• Strategic Team Building: Successful teams like the Browns and Seahawks demonstrate the importance of building a balanced roster, addressing immediate needs while planning for future development.

• Resilience of Drafted Players: Despite setbacks, players like Shador Sanders possess the resilience and skill to succeed in the right environment, underscoring the unpredictable nature of player development and team dynamics.

Final Thoughts

This episode of The McShay Show offers a comprehensive analysis of the second day of the NFL Draft, with a particular spotlight on Shador Sanders' surprising slide. Todd McShay, alongside Steve Mensch, provides insightful commentary on the interplay between player skills, team needs, and media influence, painting a nuanced picture of the complexities inherent in NFL Draft decisions. For fans and analysts alike, the episode serves as a valuable resource in understanding the multifaceted elements that shape the journey of emerging NFL talent.

For more in-depth analysis and exclusive draft content, subscribe to The McShay Report.