Our Favorite Picks From Every Round of the 2025 NFL Draft

Podcast Summary: The McShay Show – "Our Favorite Picks From Every Round of the 2025 NFL Draft"

Episode Details:

Podcast: The McShay Show
Host/Authors: Todd McShay and Mel Kiper Jr.
Episode Title: Our Favorite Picks From Every Round of the 2025 NFL Draft
Release Date: May 15, 2025

Introduction

In this episode of The McShay Show, longtime NFL Draft analysts Todd McShay and Mel Kiper Jr. delve deep into their favorite picks across all seven rounds of the highly anticipated 2025 NFL Draft. The duo not only shares their selections but also provides comprehensive analyses, player evaluations, and strategic insights that highlight their expertise in NFL talent evaluation.

Offseason Strategy and Program Launch

Before diving into the draft picks, Todd and Mel discuss their revamped offseason program, aimed at providing unparalleled depth and analysis throughout the year.

Todd McShay [00:43]: "We're going to get you ready as NFL draft fans. We're going to get you ready as college football fans. Everyone wants to know who are the prospects, like who's the top talent? So we're going to do all of that."
They emphasize a commitment to detailed breakdowns, player reports, and interactive segments like mailbags to engage with their audience continually.

Round 1: Favorite Pick – Jalen Walker

Pick: Jalen Walker, Outside/Inside Linebacker, Georgia (#15 to Atlanta Falcons)

Mel Kiper Jr. opens the discussion with his first-round favorite pick.

Kiper [09:12]: "I went with Jalen Walker, the outside, the edge, slash, inside linebacker out of Georgia, went 15th to Atlanta. He was the fourth best player on my board."

Analysis:

Versatility: Walker’s hybrid role as an edge and inside linebacker makes him a dual-threat on defense.
Impact Potential: Expected to be a culture changer in the locker room, bringing leadership and high work ethic.
Strategic Fit: Atlanta Falcons' need for a robust pass rush, given their history of struggling in this area.

Todd McShay’s Insight:

McShay [11:03]: "When the bullets start to fly and you just close your eyes and think about Josh Allen. It's like climbing the pocket, but then sliding horizontal with the line of scrimmage every."
Pick Comparison: Draws parallels between Jackson Dart’s playing style and established quarterbacks like Josh Allen, emphasizing Dart's readiness and potential impact.

Round 2: Favorite Pick – Shemar Turner

Pick: Shemar Turner, Defensive Tackle, Texas A&M (#62 to Chicago Bears)

Mel Kiper Jr. selects his second-round favorite, focusing on defensive needs.

Kiper [24:15]: "I went with Shamar Turner, defensive tackle from Texas A&M. Defensive tackle is arguably their greatest need going into the draft."

Analysis:

Defensive Prowess: Turner’s aggressive playstyle and ability to penetrate offensive lines align perfectly with the Bears' defensive schemes.
Health Considerations: Played with a fractured leg but demonstrated resilience and high performance pre-injury.
Fit within Scheme: Dennis Allen’s vision for a violent and quick defensive line makes Turner a valuable asset.

Todd McShay’s Commentary:

McShay [30:17]: "He can get to a level where he's effective if utilized properly. He is a good passer."
Highlights Turner’s potential to develop under the Bears’ system, balancing athleticism with technical skills.

Round 3: Favorite Pick – Jalen Milro

Pick: Jalen Milro, Quarterback, Alabama (#78 to Houston Texans)

Mel Kiper Jr. opts for a high-upside quarterback in the third round.

Kiper [30:20]: "Alabama quarterback Jalen Milro. He is the best running quarterback in this draft, running by far. Great deep ball thrower."

Analysis:

Skill Set: Milro’s dual-threat capabilities as a runner and passer offer versatility in offensive schemes.
Development Potential: With a three-year deal, the Texans have sufficient time to nurture Milro into a starting role.
Strategic Fit: The Texans are looking to rebuild their quarterback position, and Milro presents a promising long-term solution.

Todd McShay’s Perspective:

McShay [31:40]: "If he can get there and you got that guy at that point in the draft, I'm taking that chance."
Emphasizes the importance of quarterback development and how Milro’s attributes could be transformative for the Texans.

Round 4: Favorite Pick – Jalen Royals

Pick: Jalen Royals, Wide Receiver, Utah State (#50 to Kansas City Chiefs)

Mel Kiper Jr. crowns Jalen Royals as his fourth-round favorite pick.

Kiper [39:19]: "The Kansas City Chiefs get him in the fourth round. He's going to produce after the catch."

Analysis:

Speed and Agility: Royals boasts one of the fastest 10-yard splits at the combine, making him a dynamic threat in the passing game.
Opportunity for Impact: With the Chiefs’ offensive depth, Royals has the potential to stand out and secure significant playing time.
Health and Performance: Despite concerns over past injuries, his productive performances when healthy showcase his talent.

Todd McShay’s Input:

McShay [39:45]: "He's better in the slot, to be honest with you. But he could play outside."
Discusses Royals’ versatility in positioning, enhancing the Chiefs’ receiving corps.

Round 5: Favorite Pick – Mitchell Evans

Pick: Mitchell Evans, Tight End, Notre Dame (#163 to Carolina Panthers)

Mel Kiper Jr. selects Mitchell Evans as his fifth-round favorite, focusing on versatility.

Kiper [45:52]: "Mitchell Evans, the tight end from Notre Dame, ended up at Carolina at 163. He's got more to him as a receiver."

Analysis:

Receiving Ability: Evans’ impressive speed and route-running make him a valuable weapon in the Panthers’ offense.
Blocking Skills: While primarily a receiver, his competitive blocking enhances his versatility.
Durability Concerns: Previous ACL injuries raise questions about his long-term resilience, but his performance when healthy is promising.

Todd McShay’s Evaluation:

McShay [46:25]: "He's a reliable weapon, a decent move blocker for the Rams."
Highlights Evans’ dual-threat capabilities and potential to develop into a primary receiving tight end.

Round 6: Favorite Pick – Kane Medrano

Pick: Kane Medrano, Linebacker, UCLA (#186 to Washington Commanders)

Opting for a multi-faceted linebacker, Mel Kiper Jr. discusses his sixth-round favorite.

Kiper [51:02]: "Kane Medrano, the linebacker from UCLA. He had the fastest 40 time of all the linebackers at the combine."

Analysis:

Athleticism: Medrano’s speed and agility make him an exceptional candidate for special teams and situational packages.
Versatility: Former wide receiver skills translate well into coverage and versatility on the defensive side.
Familiarity with Coaching Staff: Previous experience with linebackers coach Ken Norton Jr. ensures a smooth transition and tailored development.

Todd McShay’s Insights:

McShay [52:20]: "He's got to get bigger, but he has the frame to add some weight. They know this kid and what they can do with him."
Emphasizes Medrano’s potential to grow within the Commanders’ system, filling critical linebacker roles.

Round 7: Favorite Pick – Jakori Crosby

Pick: Jakori Crosby, Running Back, Arizona (#220 to Washington Commanders)

Mel Kiper Jr. finalizes his draft picks with Jakori Crosby in the seventh round.

Kiper [56:27]: "Jakori Crosby, Merit out of Arizona. Super productive in New Mexico in 2023. I love the tape."

Analysis:

Production: Despite eligibility issues, Crosby’s performance when on the field showcases his talent and reliability as a running back.
Technical Skills: Exceptional footwork and change of direction abilities make him a threat in rushing and receiving.
Opportunity for Growth: With an aging backfield, Crosby has ample opportunity to carve out a significant role in the Commanders’ offense.

Todd McShay’s Commentary:

McShay [61:12]: "He has a magic show on his feet and knows how to get open in clutch moments."
Highlights Crosby’s clutch performance and technical prowess, positioning him as a valuable late-round addition.

Conclusion

Todd McShay and Mel Kiper Jr. wrap up the episode by reflecting on their draft analysis process, the excitement surrounding the 2025 NFL Draft, and the strategic moves both have made in selecting their favorite picks. They emphasize their commitment to providing in-depth analysis and continuous coverage throughout the offseason, aiming to keep fans informed and engaged.

Todd McShay [62:36]: "We're doing our thing. And I think people are - I know who’s watching. Keep what you want from us. Please keep watching on YouTube."

The hosts express enthusiasm for the upcoming season, promising more detailed breakdowns and unique content that sets their offseason program apart from others in the industry.

Notable Quotes

Todd McShay [11:03]: "When the bullets start to fly and you just close your eyes and think about Josh Allen. It's like climbing the pocket, but then sliding horizontal with the line of scrimmage every."
Mel Kiper Jr. [09:12]: "I went with Jalen Walker, the outside, the edge, slash, inside linebacker out of Georgia, went 15th to Atlanta. He was the fourth best player on my board."
Mel Kiper Jr. [24:15]: "Shamar Turner, defensive tackle from Texas A&M. Defensive tackle is arguably their greatest need going into the draft."
Todd McShay [46:25]: "He's a reliable weapon, a decent move blocker for the Rams."
Mel Kiper Jr. [56:27]: "Jakori Crosby, Merit out of Arizona. Super productive in New Mexico in 2023. I love the tape."

Final Thoughts

This episode of The McShay Show offers listeners a comprehensive and insightful analysis of the 2025 NFL Draft, showcasing the deep knowledge and strategic thinking of both Todd McShay and Mel Kiper Jr. Their discussions not only highlight potential draft steals but also provide a window into the meticulous process behind each selection. Whether you're a seasoned NFL fan or new to draft analysis, this episode delivers valuable perspectives and engaging commentary that enrich your understanding of the upcoming NFL season.