Podcast Summary: The McShay Show – "Todd’s Updated Top 100 Big Board! Cam, Shedeur, and the QB Carousel"

Release Date: March 13, 2025

1. Introduction and Episode Overview

In this episode of The McShay Show, NFL Draft and College Football Analyst Todd McShay delves deep into the evolving landscape of the NFL Draft, with a particular focus on quarterback movements in free agency and their implications for this year's draft. Accompanied by longtime analyst Mel Kiper Jr., the duo navigates through their updated Top 100 Big Board, highlighting key prospects and their potential impacts on the draft.

2. Addressing Audience Feedback and Schedule Adjustments

Todd McShay [02:36]: "I say all this because I noticed we got some backlash last week or last show. Too much about the schedule... I won't do it anymore. So no more about the schedule. The mock draft 2.0 drops next Thursday, by the way."

Responding to listener feedback, Todd acknowledges previous criticisms about the show's scheduling content and commits to focusing more on draft-related discussions moving forward.

3. Premiere Announcement: Top 100 Big Board

Todd McShay [03:11]: "We just dropped in the newsletter if you want to go see the entire top 100. And by the way, men, this is not humble. It's just a brag."

Todd proudly announces the release of his first Top 100 draft board in two years, available through The McShay Report newsletter. He emphasizes his consistent ranking, having maintained the top spot on Huddle Report for four consecutive years.

Mel Kiper Jr. [03:34]: "You're good at this, man. You are good."

Mel commends Todd's expertise and consistency in draft evaluations.

4. Quarterback Carousel: Free Agency Moves and Draft Implications

The main discussion centers around the significant movements of NFL quarterbacks in free agency and how these shifts influence the upcoming draft, especially the quarterback selections.

Key Players Discussed:

• Aaron Rodgers: Speculation about his potential move to the New York Giants as a strategy to secure a veteran presence while preparing for future draft picks.

  Todd McShay [08:07]: "But Aaron Rodgers is the only one that makes sense to me or makes the most sense..."

• Kirk Cousins and Russell Wilson: Their uncertain futures post-free agency and potential impacts on their respective teams' draft strategies.

  Mel Kiper Jr. [10:28]: "Yeah, that would not surprise me on that range."

• Derek Carr: Possibility of his move after June 1st, adding another layer of complexity to teams' quarterback plans.

Todd McShay [07:25]: "We know that they're in the market early in the draft for a corner and that doesn't take them out of the market because Slay now comes in..."

The discussion highlights how teams like the Steelers are balancing immediate wins with long-term quarterback development, especially with the influx of veterans like Aaron Rodgers potentially joining their ranks.

5. Top 100 Big Board Highlights

5.1 Shedeur Sanders and Jackson Dart

Todd emphasizes Shedeur Sanders' potential to succeed as an NFL quarterback, despite some setbacks in recent performances.

Mel Kiper Jr. [29:28]: "Shedeur can succeed as a starting quarterback in the NFL."

Todd McShay [32:04]: "He is the best pocket passer in this class... when he's got some protection and they get him on rhythm..."

5.2 Tyler Shuck

Shuck is positioned in the early second round, with discussions around his consistency and physical attributes.

Todd McShay [15:17]: "I do think it's interesting. They're picking at 21. Would that mean a move back? Would that..."

Mel Kiper Jr. [21:14]: "Bingo."

The analysts debate potential scenarios where Shuck might be drafted, considering team needs and his projected round.

5.3 Jalen Milro

Placed at number 76, Milro's athleticism and areas needing development are scrutinized.

Todd McShay [41:31]: "...Jalen Milro, you just mentioned. I put him in at 76. It seems reasonable..."

Mel Kiper Jr. [51:56]: "I think that's totally fair."

6. Offensive Line and Wide Receiver Evaluations

6.1 Offensive Line: Will Campbell and Jihad De Campbell

Todd and Mel discuss the prospects for offensive linemen, focusing on Will Campbell's versatility and the challenges posed by shorter arm lengths.

Todd McShay [58:46]: "Why do players, why do teams keep taking chances on those kind of players?"

Mel Kiper Jr. [58:08]: "...guys 6 foot 195. That's what Burden and Igbuka are. Nolan's. Noel's a little bit smaller..."

6.2 Wide Receivers: Ameca Ibuka and Jalen Noel

The conversation shifts to slot receivers, debating their draft positions based on physical attributes and on-field performance.

Mel Kiper Jr. [60:42]: "I love them in the second round. Love slot receivers in the second."

Todd McShay [61:22]: "That's why he's getting bumped up into round one."

7. Draft Predictions and Mock Draft Insights

The analysts provide their mock draft insights, predicting where key players might be selected and discussing the strategies behind these decisions.

Todd McShay [44:38]: "I've got Jackson Dart and Tyler Shuck in my top 32. Still 31 and 32. ... If you're the Giants no. 34, I've got the second pick in the second round."

Mel Kiper Jr. [45:24]: "You're gambling, man."

They explore various scenarios, considering team needs, player strengths, and potential draft moves.

8. Notable Quotes

• Todd McShay [08:07]: "Aaron Rodgers is the only one that makes sense to me or makes the most sense..."

• Mel Kiper Jr. [29:28]: "Shedeur can succeed as a starting quarterback in the NFL."

• Todd McShay [15:17]: "I do think it's interesting. They're picking at 21. Would that mean a move back? Would that..."

• Mel Kiper Jr. [33:42]: "He's different in the way he reads the quarterback, gets his eyes on the receiver and breaks on balls is elite."

9. Conclusion and Upcoming Content

Todd wraps up the discussion by reiterating the release of his Top 100 Big Board and teasing the upcoming Mock Draft 2.0 set to drop next Thursday. Both hosts express enthusiasm for the draft week and encourage listeners to subscribe to The McShay Report for more in-depth analysis.

Todd McShay [72:00]: "...this mock draft next Thursday... the top 100 is out right now. Go get it."

Mel Kiper Jr. [71:25]: "...yes, I know you have... Let's go."

10. Final Thoughts

This episode offers a comprehensive analysis of the current state of NFL quarterbacks, their movement in free agency, and the subsequent effects on the draft. Todd McShay and Mel Kiper Jr. provide valuable insights into team strategies, player evaluations, and draft predictions, making it a must-listen for NFL enthusiasts looking to stay ahead of the draft curve.

Note: For the complete Top 100 Big Board and more detailed draft analysis, subscribe to The McShay Report here.