Podcast Summary: The McShay Show – "Way-Too-Early 2026 NFL Mock Draft: Nussmeier Goes No. 1, Rams Trade Up for Their QB of the Future"

Introduction

In this engaging episode of The McShay Show, NFL Draft Analyst Todd McShay dives into a "way-too-early" mock draft for the 2026 NFL Draft. Joined by co-host Steve Mensch, Todd presents his predictions, analyses key prospects, and explores potential trades that could shape the future of the league. The episode, released on May 1, 2025, offers a comprehensive look into Todd's unique perspective as an NFL talent evaluator.

Mock Draft Overview

Todd begins by setting the stage for the mock draft, emphasizing its early nature and the challenges associated with projecting a draft set three years in advance.

[02:00] Todd McShay: "It's two and a half hours of reviewing the 2025 NFL Draft, I went back to the hotel here in LA and sat down and did a mock draft. It was grueling, it was punishing. It wasn't fair. I didn't like doing it. But when I got into it, it was kind of fun."

Top Pick: Garrett Nussmeier at No. 1

The centerpiece of the mock draft is Garrett Nussmeier, the LSU quarterback, whom Todd projects as the first overall pick by the New York Jets. He justifies this choice by highlighting Nussmeier's anticipation, throwing mechanics, and leadership qualities.

[12:24] Todd McShay: "I went with Garrett Nussmeier, LSU quarterback. I flipped through a couple way too early mock drafts last night just to get a pulse of what I think people are a lot lower on Nussmeier than I am. I like this guy, man. I like his anticipation. I like the way he throws."

Steve Mensch supports Todd's selection but adds a note of caution, reminding listeners that this is a mock draft and actual draft outcomes may vary.

[14:52] Steve Mensch: "He's in the mix to be QB1. If he's not one or if he's not the first quarterback off the board, he's in the mix, man."

Notable Player Evaluations

1. Caleb Downs – Safety to the New Orleans Saints

   • Todd praises Downs for his mental sharpness and physical prowess, making him a unique talent at the safety position.

     [16:10] Todd McShay: "Caleb Downs is as mentally sharp as he is physically gifted. I love how quickly he reacts and fills the alley."

   • Steve Mensch echoes Todd's sentiments, emphasizing Downs' versatility and impact on the field.

     [16:37] Steve Mensch: "He's versatile, man. He can do everything that you want him to do."

2. Lenore Sellers – Cornerback for the Rams

   • Highlighted for his physical attributes and playmaking abilities, Todd forecasts Sellers as a top defensive pick.

     [46:07] Todd McShay: "He’s built well. He seems to get down the field. I'm excited to see Tate."

3. Jeremiah Love – Running Back for the Chicago Bears

   • Todd underscores Love's explosiveness and potential as a key asset in the Bears' running game.

     [48:08] Todd McShay: "He's going to fight for yards after contact, break tackles, and find seams. I think Jeremiah is special."

Trade Analysis: Rams and Titans

A significant portion of the discussion revolves around potential trades, particularly the Rams trading up to secure their future quarterback. Todd analyzes the Rams' strategic moves and the implications for the Titans, who receive additional first-round picks in return.

[20:08] Todd McShay: "The Rams are trading up to get their guy. This means the Titans get two first-round picks, allowing them flexibility."

Steve Mensch highlights the strategic depth of this move, suggesting it positions the Rams for sustained success.

[20:38] Steve Mensch: "The Rams made a statement with that trade. They’re positioning themselves well for the future."

Team-Specific Picks and Strategies

1. Cleveland Browns

   • Todd anticipates the Browns selecting Cade Clubnick, a promising quarterback from Clemson, to bolster their roster.

     [25:37] Todd McShay: "Cade Clubnick represents one of those guys who could wind up in the third round. He's competitive and a true baller."

   • Steve Mensch discusses the potential impact of combining Clubnick with the Browns' existing talent.

     [27:05] Steve Mensch: "He's got talented wide receivers like Williams, Wesco Jr., and TJ Moore, which creates a dynamic offensive line."

2. Carolina Panthers

   • The Panthers are projected to draft Mario Crystal Ball, an offensive tackle from the University of Miami, addressing their offensive line needs.

     [34:28] Todd McShay: "Mario Crystal Ball needs to take the next step. Protecting Bryce Young better than last year is crucial."

3. Seattle Seahawks

   • Despite recent draft decisions, Todd suggests the Seahawks might focus on wide receivers, selecting players like Evan Stewart.

     [43:36] Todd McShay: "Evan Stewart is explosive and a great fit for the Seahawks' offense. He was a late-round pick but has high potential."

4. Green Bay Packers

   • The Packers are expected to focus on defensive needs, drafting Deontay Lawson from Florida as a key linebacker.

     [46:06] Todd McShay: "Deontay Lawson has 76 tackles and six sacks last season. He’s a strong candidate for the Packers' linebacker needs."

Future Plans and Audience Engagement

Towards the end of the episode, Todd emphasizes the importance of audience feedback and outlines plans for future shows. He encourages listeners to submit their ideas and preferences to tailor upcoming content to their interests.

[56:12] Todd McShay: "We want your feedback. Tell us what you want to hear, and we'll incorporate that into our future shows."

Steve Mensch adds excitement about the collaborative efforts moving forward.

[56:15] Steve Mensch: "Listen, we're going to talk about it. It's going to happen."

Closing Remarks

In his heartfelt closing, Todd reflects on the journey of the show, expressing gratitude for the support and enthusiasm from listeners. He underscores the commitment to delivering insightful and passionate analysis while balancing professional rigor with personal camaraderie.

[62:00] Todd McShay: "This has been the most rewarding year of my entire career. I'm so grateful for the support and excited to keep rolling with you all."

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Todd McShay [02:00]: "It's two and a half hours of reviewing the 2025 NFL Draft... it was kind of fun."

• Steve Mensch [14:52]: "He's in the mix to be QB1. If he's not one or if he's not the first quarterback off the board, he's in the mix, man."

• Todd McShay [16:10]: "Caleb Downs is as mentally sharp as he is physically gifted."

• Steve Mensch [16:37]: "He's versatile, man. He can do everything that you want him to do."

• Todd McShay [20:08]: "The Rams are trading up to get their guy. This means the Titans get two first-round picks."

• Todd McShay [25:37]: "Cade Clubnick represents one of those guys who could wind up in the third round. He's competitive and a true baller."

• Steve Mensch [27:05]: "He's got talented wide receivers like Williams, Wesco Jr., and TJ Moore, which creates a dynamic offensive line."

• Todd McShay [56:12]: "We want your feedback. Tell us what you want to hear, and we'll incorporate that into our future shows."

• Todd McShay [62:00]: "This has been the most rewarding year of my entire career. I'm so grateful for the support and excited to keep rolling with you all."

Conclusion

This episode of The McShay Show offers a detailed and enthusiastic exploration of the upcoming 2026 NFL Draft, blending expert analysis with interactive audience engagement. Todd McShay and Steve Mensch provide insightful projections, highlight emerging talents, and discuss strategic trades that could redefine team rosters. As the listeners await further developments, the hosts invite continuous feedback to enhance the show's content, ensuring it remains a valuable resource for football enthusiasts.