Episode Summary: The MeatEater Podcast - Ep. 691: BONUS DROP - Bear Grease: Confessions of a Former Outlaw

Release Date: April 17, 2025

In this special bonus episode, The MeatEater Podcast presents an exclusive collaboration with the Bear Grease podcast, featuring a deeply personal and transformative story of redemption from Johnny Johnston, a former outlaw turkey hunter. Hosted by Steven Rinella, this episode delves into Johnny's tumultuous past, his illicit hunting activities, struggles with addiction, and his eventual path to sobriety and spiritual renewal.

I. Introduction to the Bonus Episode

The episode begins with Clay Newcomb, host of the Bear Grease podcast, introducing an episode titled "Confessions of a Former Outlaw." Clay expresses his initial reservations about featuring Johnny Johnston, fearing it might glorify poaching. However, after listening to Johnny's compelling story of redemption, Clay endorses the inclusion, highlighting the uniqueness and honesty of Johnny's journey.

Notable Quote:

Clay Newcomb (01:36): "The man you're going to hear from is like no one else on this planet."

II. Johnny Johnston’s Early Hunting Experiences

Johnny Johnston recounts his introduction to turkey hunting in the mid-1970s. Initially unfamiliar with turkey calls and hunting techniques, Johnny quickly developed a passion for the sport after his first encounter with wild turkeys. His friendship with Ben Rogers Lee, a renowned turkey caller and five-time world champion, significantly influenced his hunting prowess and ethical considerations.

Notable Quote:

Johnny Johnston (05:46): "When turkeys are right, you go get you one."

III. Life as an Outlaw Turkey Hunter

Johnny's hunting activities extended beyond legal boundaries. He participated in illegal early-season hunts, often evading game wardens and manipulating hunting laws to his advantage. Johnny shared vivid anecdotes of his covert operations, including hiding guns in the woods and outsmarting law enforcement agencies.

Notable Quote:

Johnny Johnston (20:06): "When turkeys are right, you go get you one."

Anecdote: At [25:33], Johnny describes a daring escapade where he evades detection by game wardens using smoke and concealment tactics, showcasing his resourcefulness and disregard for hunting regulations.

IV. Struggles with Addiction and Personal Turmoil

Beyond hunting, Johnny's life was marred by substance abuse. He openly discusses his battles with alcoholism and drug addiction, which strained his relationships with family and friends. His lifestyle choices led to significant personal losses, including his marriage and professional life.

Notable Quote:

Johnny Johnston (27:08): "I did things the hard way and I made a lot of bad choices. But I'm not that way anymore."

V. The Turning Point: Embracing Faith and Redemption

The pivotal moment in Johnny's life occurred when a persistent preacher visited him regularly, prompting introspection and spiritual awakening. One morning, amidst a severe bike mishap and the subsequent loss of his hearing, Johnny experienced a profound transformation. He embraced Christianity, which instilled in him the strength to overcome his addictions and rebuild his life.

Notable Quote:

Johnny Johnston (48:42): "When I gave my life to him, he took that addiction from me."

Key Moment: At [53:42], Johnny vividly describes his conversion experience at a fire pit on Horseshoe Mountain, where he felt a divine intervention that catalyzed his journey toward sobriety and personal restoration.

VI. Reflections on Hunting Laws and Conservation

Throughout the episode, Johnny reflects on his past disregard for hunting laws, rationalizing his actions as a pursuit driven by passion rather than malice. He acknowledges the negative impact of his actions on turkey populations and expresses a newfound respect for conservation ethics.

Notable Quote:

Johnny Johnston (40:33): "Way our turkeys are down, they don't need to be over hunted like that."

Discussion: The conversation transitions into a broader reflection on how societal views on hunting laws have evolved. The hosts explore generational shifts in conservation attitudes, emphasizing the importance of respecting wildlife regulations to ensure sustainable hunting practices.

VII. Current Life and Continued Advocacy

Post-redemption, Johnny has transformed into a community-oriented individual, serving as a deacon and ordained minister. He has reconciled with his family, regained his professional standing, and continues to engage in ethical hunting practices. Johnny emphasizes the significance of faith and personal accountability in maintaining his reformed lifestyle.

Notable Quote:

Johnny Johnston (53:34): "I went from being an alcoholic with a drug addiction to a deacon and an ordained minister."

VIII. Conclusion: A Story of Redemption and Renewal

The episode concludes with a heartfelt acknowledgment of Johnny Johnston's remarkable journey from an outlaw hunter to a beacon of hope and integrity. His story serves as a testament to the power of personal transformation, the importance of ethical hunting, and the enduring impact of faith and community support.

Final Reflection: Steven Rinella emphasizes that Johnny's honesty about his past provides valuable insights into human nature and the complexities of ethical decision-making. The narrative underscores the significance of second chances and the capacity for individuals to change profoundly.

Final Thoughts:

The MeatEater Podcast successfully intertwines a gripping tale of illicit hunting with a deeply moving redemption story. By presenting Johnny Johnston's confessions, the episode not only entertains but also educates listeners on the importance of adhering to conservation laws and the transformative power of personal growth and faith.

Call to Action: Listeners are encouraged to share Johnny's story with others who may benefit from its messages of struggle and redemption, fostering a community that values both ethical hunting and personal integrity.

Recommended For:

• Hunting enthusiasts interested in the ethical and legal dimensions of the sport.
• Individuals seeking inspirational stories of personal transformation.
• Listeners of Bear Grease looking to explore interconnected narratives within the outdoor community.

Note: This summary excludes commercial segments and focuses solely on the core content of the episode.