The MeidasTouch Podcast: Cait Conley Responds to Trump West Point Disaster

Episode Overview Release Date: May 29, 2025
Host: Ben Meiselas
Guest: Kate Conley, West Point Graduate and Congressional Candidate
Topic: Analysis and response to former President Donald Trump's controversial speech at West Point, juxtaposed with insights from a military leader running for Congress.

Introduction and Context

In this episode of The MeidasTouch Podcast, host Ben Meiselas delves into the recent controversy surrounding former President Donald Trump's commencement speech at West Point. The speech, widely criticized for its tone and content, has sparked significant debate about leadership and the direction of American politics. To provide a deeper understanding, Ben welcomes Kate Conley, a decorated West Point graduate and candidate for New York's 17th congressional district, to share her perspectives on the matter.

Ben Meiselas on Media Noise vs. Signal

Ben opens the discussion by addressing the pervasive "noise" in today's media landscape, which often drowns out critical issues. He laments how significant events, such as Trump's contentious speech, are frequently reduced to fleeting headlines without meaningful analysis. Ben emphasizes the importance of enduring conversations that scrutinize such events to prevent society from swiftly moving on without addressing underlying concerns.

Ben Meiselas [01:00]: "When we watch Donald Trump with his red political hat in front of the army grads giving this disastrous speech at West Point, yes, it's ridiculous, yes, it's deranged, yes, it's dangerous. But it frequently becomes a one day story."

Kamala Harris's Commencement Speech Clip

To contrast Trump's speech, the podcast features a clip from former Vice President Kamala Harris's commencement address at West Point. Harris's speech is highlighted for its focus on service, leadership, and the honoring of military traditions.

Kamala Harris [02:41]: "Today, then, to the class of 2023, you join the greatest fighting force the world has ever seen."

Comparing Trump’s Speech to Kamala Harris's

After the clip, Ben critiques Trump's speech by contrasting it with Harris's laudable address. He points out that while Harris emphasized unity and the noble aspects of military service, Trump's speech was derailed by personal anecdotes and controversial statements that detracted from the gravity of the occasion.

Ben Meiselas [04:26]: "So I want to introduce you now to a West Point grad... Kate Conley, welcome to the Midas Touch podcast. And first and foremost, thank you for your service."

Introduction of Kate Conley

Ben introduces Kate Conley, highlighting her impressive credentials:

• Education: West Point graduate with degrees from MIT and Harvard.
• Military Service: Sixteen years in active duty, deploying six times to conflict zones like Iraq and Afghanistan.
• Current Endeavor: Running for Congress in New York's 17th district against Republican Mike Lawler.

Discussion on Leadership and National Security

Kate Conley's Perspective [05:50]:
Kate underscores the importance of genuine leadership in addressing national security challenges. She contrasts her disciplined military background with the perceived lack of seriousness in current political discourse.

Kate Conley [09:18]: "When you look at our nation and the challenges we still have ahead of us, we need leaders that are laser focused on the very real national security challenges our country faces."

She elaborates on her military experiences, including operations against Al-Qaeda and ISIS, emphasizing the critical nature of disciplined and accountable leadership. Kate criticizes the current political climate for focusing on trivial matters rather than pressing national security issues.

Kate Conley [10:58]: "We have things like a war in Ukraine that are still raging. We have terrorist groups that are still plotting against the United States and Americans."

Critique of Republican Leadership

Ben extends the discussion by criticizing the behavior of Republican leaders, particularly referencing Donald Trump's actions and rhetoric. He expresses concern over the normalization of immature and irresponsible conduct within the party, which he believes undermines the integrity of American leadership.

Ben Meiselas [10:00]: "Why is it being normalized as like whatever... It feels... it's like if a little child was doing these things... I would say I'm not okay with it."

Kate supports this critique by highlighting the discrepancy between leaders' words and actions, stressing the need for consistency and accountability.

Kate Conley [12:00]: "We are showing them its amateur hour... The American people deserve better."

Kate Conley's Vision for New York's 17th District

The conversation shifts to Kate's campaign for Congress. She outlines her commitment to addressing the needs of working-class families, advocating for affordable healthcare, and opposing significant Medicaid cuts that threaten vulnerable populations.

Kate Conley [13:58]: "I hear about families who are working two jobs and still can't pay the rent or are cutting back on grocery bills... We have to focus on making this more affordable and taking care of the people."

Kate emphasizes her dedication to true leadership that prioritizes the welfare of constituents over political gain. She criticizes her opponent, Mike Lawler, for lacking genuine commitment and leadership qualities, asserting that New York's 17th district deserves better representation.

Kate Conley [14:30]: "We need true leaders to step up who are going to do what's right for this country, for all Americans."

Conclusion

Ben wraps up the episode by thanking Kate Conley for her service and insightful contributions. He reinforces the podcast's mission to provide meaningful discussions that transcend superficial news coverage, aiming to engage listeners in substantive conversations about democracy and leadership.

Ben Meiselas [16:01]: "Kate Conley, thanks for your service and thank you for your perspective on the West Point grad and thanks for everything you do and for joining us."

Key Takeaways

• Importance of Genuine Leadership: Both Ben and Kate emphasize the need for responsible and accountable leaders who prioritize national security and the well-being of citizens over personal or political interests.

• Critique of Current Political Discourse: The episode highlights concerns about the trivialization of significant issues within political narratives, particularly criticizing the Republican Party's handling of leadership and national security.

• Kate Conley's Campaign Vision: Kate outlines a platform focused on supporting working-class families, opposing detrimental healthcare policies, and advocating for thoughtful, deliberate leadership in Congress.

Notable Quotes

• Ben Meiselas [01:00]: "But we can't move on from these things and just go on to the next crisis or the next scandal or the next him making a fool of himself."

• Kate Conley [05:50]: "This is really one of the most beautiful things I think that represents who we are as a nation."

• Ben Meiselas [10:00]: "Why are we supporting it when it's in a Republican, when it's a political party?"

• Kate Conley [13:58]: "We have to focus on making this more affordable and taking care of the people who are throwing everything they have in to make this country the incredible place that it is."

Stay Connected For more insightful discussions and updates, subscribe to The MeidasTouch Podcast and join the MeidasMighty community. Follow live episodes on the MeidasTouch YouTube channel every Monday and Thursday at 8 PM ET/5 PM PT.