Top GOP Leader Suddenly Quits as Party Implodes

Summary

The MeidasTouch Podcast

Episode: Top GOP Leader Suddenly Quits as Party Implodes
Date: December 21, 2025
Host(s): Ben, Brett, and Jordy Meiselas
Network: MeidasTouch

---

Episode Overview

This episode unpacks the political implosion of the Republican Party, focusing on the abrupt resignation and total withdrawal from politics of Elise Stefanik, a once-prominent GOP House leader and would-be New York gubernatorial candidate. The Meiselas brothers—known for their sharp analysis, comedic banter, and unfiltered pro-democracy takes—break down the deeper meaning behind Stefanik's exit, the MAGA movement's corrosive dynamic, and what this signals for the future of Republican leadership. The episode also briefly touches on the retirement of another Republican, Senator Cynthia Lummis of Wyoming.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Elise Stefanik’s Sudden Resignation (03:20 – 08:38)

• Stefanik’s Fall from Grace:

  • Once a Harvard grad, staffer for George W. Bush, and protégé of mainstream Republicans.
  • She pivoted dramatically to MAGA, becoming an election denier and major Trump ally.
  • Ultimately, Stefanik was "chewed up and spit out" by the MAGA movement just like so many others before her.
  • Despite full loyalty, Trump and “MAGA Mike” (Speaker Mike Johnson) repeatedly sidelined and disrespected her.

• Failed Career Moves:

  • Initially appointed as U.S. Ambassador to the United Nations by Trump, only to be summarily removed and replaced by someone implicated in “Signal Gate.”
  • Launched an unsuccessful campaign for Governor of New York against Kathy Hochul. Polls showed her trailing badly, especially after incendiary, defamatory attacks on opponents.
  • Facing certain defeat and a hostile constituency, she decided to quit both her campaign and Congress.

• Ben’s Scathing Assessment:

  • “You destroyed your career by giving up any of your principles to just do whatever Donald Trump wanted. And Trump and MAGA chewed you up and spit you out and treated you like crap… Your legacy is of a disgrace, a pathetic loser.”
    —Ben Meiselas (07:02)

2. Stefanik’s Resignation Statement & Response (06:35 – 08:38)

• Stefanik’s Statement:

  • Framed her exit as a family decision, full of gratitude for “overwhelming support,” and suggested she could have easily won a Republican primary (contradicted by polls).
  • Emphasized looking forward to a “next meaningful personal and professional chapter.”

• Host Analysis:

  • The hosts mock her spin: “That’s not really what the polls were showing.”
  • Predicts she’ll return to her family’s business, and conclusively declare her career over: “See you later. Bye. Bye.”

• Governor Hochul’s Response:

  • Hochul’s spokesperson pounced, framing Stefanik’s withdrawal as accepting inevitable defeat, and doubling down on Hochul’s progressive achievements.
  • “Elise Stefanik has finally acknowledged the reality: if you run against Governor Hochul, you’re going to lose.”
    (07:53)

3. Receipts: Stefanik’s MAGA Radicalism and Public Missteps (10:39 – 14:46)

• “January 6 Hostages”

  • Stefanik repeatedly called January 6 insurrectionists “hostages” and decried their prosecution:
    • “I have concerns about the treatment of January 6 hostages… the weaponization of the federal government against conservatives…”
      —Elise Stefanik, clip (11:21)

• Israel/West Bank Controversy

  • Supported hardline Israeli annexation of the West Bank, aligning with far-right Israeli politicians.
    • “Yes,” she answered when asked if she believed Israel had a biblical right to seize all of the West Bank.
      —Elise Stefanik, clip (13:11)

• Still Denying 2020 Results

  • Would have refused to certify the 2020 election results as Vice President:
    • “I would not have done what Mike Pence did. I don’t think that was the right approach. There was unconstitutional overreach.”
      —Elise Stefanik, clip (13:52)

• Trump’s Disrespect & Public Embarrassment

  • Trump couldn’t pronounce her name and publicly rebuffed her attacks on political opponents.
    • When asked about her labeling a rival as a “jihadist,” Trump waved it off: “You say things sometimes in a campaign.”
      —Donald Trump, clip (16:45)

• MAGA Mike Johnson’s Dismissal

  • After Stefanik called for Speaker Johnson’s ouster, Johnson replied:
    • “I don’t exactly know why Elise won’t just call me. I texted her yesterday… I think she should know this…”
      —Mike Johnson, clip (14:59)

4. GOP in Disarray: The Case of Cynthia Lummis (17:11 – 18:46)

• Announcement of Retirement:

  • Senator Cynthia Lummis declares she won’t seek re-election:
    • “It’s been an incredible honor… but I feel like a sprinter in a marathon. The energy required doesn’t match up.”
      (17:24)

• Hosts’ Take:

  • Frame these resignations as evidence the Republican Party is falling apart. Ben notes, “It’s like the rats are leaving the ship. The rats are fleeing the ship.”
  • Predict more resignations as the MAGA movement continues burning through its own.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Stefanik’s Downfall:

  • “You played yourself. You destroyed your career by giving up any of your principles to just do whatever Donald Trump wanted… Your legacy is that of a disgrace. Your legacy is of a pathetic loser. That’s what your life is now.”
    —Ben Meiselas (06:58)

• On MAGA Faction’s Treatment of Loyalists:

  • “That is what they do in the MAGA movement. They chew you up and spit you out.”
    —Ben Meiselas (03:53)

• On GOP’s Bleak Prospects:

  • “Bye bye Loomis. Bye bye Stefanik. I’m sure I’ll be reporting on more of these losers leaving soon… their life legacy will be that of shame. Shame on you.”
    —Ben Meiselas (18:22)

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Stefanik’s Political Background & MAGA Pivot: 03:20 – 06:35
• Stefanik’s Resignation Statement & Analysis: 06:35 – 08:38
• Stefanik’s MAGA Radical Moves (“Receipts”): 10:39 – 14:46
• Trump & MAGA’s Disrespect toward Stefanik: 14:46 – 16:53
• Cynthia Lummis Retirement & GOP Turmoil: 17:11 – 18:46

---

Tone & Style

The episode is bracingly candid, sarcastic, and sharply critical—especially when discussing former GOP leaders and the self-sabotaging nature of the MAGA movement. The brothers’ conversational energy blends biting humor with serious alarm about the state of American democracy, making for an entertaining yet pointed analysis accessible both to political junkies and casual listeners.

---

In Summary:
This episode exposes the self-destructive dynamics within today’s GOP, using Elise Stefanik’s dramatic exit as a case study in the MAGA movement’s tendency to cannibalize its own. The Meiselas brothers’ analysis wields both substantive political critique and caustic humor, ultimately painting a bleak picture of Republican fortunes while reaffirming their steadfast support for democratic norms.

Transcript

[Podcast Host]

With Venmo Stash. A toggle on one hand and ordering a ride in the other means you're stacking cash back with Venmo Stash.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

Get up to 5% cash back when.

[Podcast Host]

You pick a bundle of your favorite brands. Earn more cash when you do more with Stash. Venmo Stash terms and exclusions apply. Max $100 cash back per month. See Terms of Venmo Me Stashterms. A massage chair might seem a bit extravagant, especially these days. Eight different settings, adjustable intensity, plus it's heated and it just feels so good. Yes, a massage chair might seem a bit extravagant, but when it can come with a car, suddenly it seems quite practical. The Volkswagen Tiguan Packed with premium features like available massaging front seats, it only feels extravagant in the time it takes.

[Elise Stefanik (or clips of her)]

Us to say we're using Folger's instant coffee, seamlessly blended with water and ice. A splash of whatever kind of milk is your thing. And gotta get that caramel drizzle all to make a toasty roasty caramel iced coffee. You could be enjoying it. Every damn sip of it. Damn right it's Folgers Instant.

[Podcast Host]

This episode is brought to you by Buffalo Trace Distillery. Powerful yet smooth contained but never tame. Proudly going their own way but never going along. This is the spirit inside Buffalo Trace Bourbon made at Buffalo Trace Distillery. The world's most award winning distillery, Buffalo Trace is always perfectly untamed. Distilled, aged and bottled by Buffalo Trace distillery, Franklin County, Kentucky 90 proof 45% alcohol by volume. Learn more at buffalotrace distillery.com Please drink responsibly. Some people think nature is like this, but actually it's like. Mother Nature's not all sunshine and rainbows. Nature can be hotter than a sauna and colder than an arctic skinny dip. That's why Columbia engineers everything we make for anything nature can throw at you. Columbia engineered for whatever. MAGA Republican Congresswoman Elise Stefanik, who was running for governor of New York, has suddenly not just quit the governor's race, she has quit politics entirely. She's also resigning as a member of Congress, and she will no longer be involved in politics at all. Everything Donald Trump touches dies. She was once viewed as a rising star within the Republican Party. She worked for George W. Bush in the 2000s. She went to Harvard. She was then a prot of Paul Ryan and Mitt Romney. When Donald Trump came into office during the first regime, she started more closely being an ally of him. She went all in on Donald Trump and maga. She was an election Denier. When Donald Trump lost in 2020, she started calling the January 6th insurrectionist hostages. And she went from being a moderate who was elected in New York's upstate area to now being MAGO radical who turned her entire New York constituency against her. She became a loathe political figure. And she was, even for all of her loyalty, utterly disrespected by Donald Trump and MAGA Mike. Because that is what they do in the MAGA movement. They chew you up and they spit you out. You'll recall that she was appointed by Donald Trump to be the United States Ambassador to the United Nations. And then she was pulled from that role. And then you had the guy who was involved in Signal Gate replace her and get rewarded for leaking classified information on Signal. Elise Stefanik then pivoted back to Congress, where she then said that she would be running for governor of New York against Kathy Hochul. All the polls had Elise Stefanik getting absolutely destroyed. I mean, New Yorkers and hate Elise Stefanik right now. One of the things that Stefanik was trying to, you know, run on is Kathy Hochul endorsed Mamdani. And she would say, mom, Donnie is this radical and extremist and anti Semitic and all of like, you know, just this defamation against. Against Mamdani. And then Donald Trump was asked in the Oval Office when he was standing next to Mamdani, you know, do you think this guy is bad for New York or do you think. And he'd go, elise Stefanik has said all of these things about him. What do you make of that? And Trump's like, yeah, I don't think Elise Stefanik's right about this guy. And so at every step of the way, for all of her loyalty and for all of her just totally throwing out any of, like, what she claimed her principles to be in college and during the early days when she was a young leader in the conservative movement, when that used to exist. Her career is trash. Her career is destroyed. She is done with politics. He is out. And I'll read for you her statement right now. And then I'll read Governor Hochul statement, because Stefanik was going to be running against Hochul for the governorship of New York. Here's what Stefanik said. While spending precious time with my family this Christmas season, I've made the decision to suspend my campaign for governor and will not seek reelection to Congress. I did not come to this decision lightly for our family. I'm truly humbled and grateful for the historic overwhelming support from Republicans, conservatives and independents and Democrats all across the state for our campaign to save New York. That's not really what the polls were showing. The latest Sienna Research poll had you down by 20 points to Governor Hochul. But go on, go on. She goes on to say, thank you to my dedicated staff. It's been a incredible professional honor. She goes, as we've seen in past elections, while we, we, while we would have overwhelmingly won this primary, it's not an effective use of our time or your generous resources to spend the first half of next year in an unnecessary and protracted Republican primary. She goes on to say, I'm proud of the significant results we've delivered. Thank you for your support and encouragement as my family and I look forward to the next meaningful personal and professional chapter. Now going back probably into her family's business. And see you later. Bye. Bye. You played yourself. You destroyed your career by giving up any of your principles to just do whatever Donald Trump wanted. And Trump and MAGA chewed you up and spit you out and treated you like crap. After all the loyalty you showed them, your legacy is that of a disgrace. Your legacy is of a pathetic loser. That's what your life is now. That's what your legacy is. You did that. Hold yourself accountable. You screwed up big time. And what actually could have been a promising career. Horrible. Every day, look in the mirror and know how terrible of a life you've lived. Elise Stefanik. And I'm not trying to be harsh. She's just an awful human being. And I'll come with some receipts shortly. Governor Hochul's campaign spokesperson put out the following statement. Elise Stefanik has finally acknowledged the reality. If you run against Governor Hochul, you're going to lose. As Donald Trump raises costs on New York and targets this state relentlessly, Governor Hochul has cut middle class taxes, put money back in New Yorker's pockets and fought this administration and won. When New York has come under attack, the fact is 100% MAGA Bruce Blakeman traveled all the way to D.C. to celebrate Trump's expensive tariffs. He ran Long Island Safety Net Hospital into the ground by appointing corrupt cronies to run it and let violent crime in Nassau county spike to its highest level in decades. Governor Hochul's message to him or whichever lackey Trump picked to run against her, a simple bring it on. And Elise Stefanik, utterly disgraced right now.

[Advertisement Narrator]

Getting older hits harder than you expect, right? One day you wake up with stiff joints, recovery from the gym takes longer, your hair is thinning, nails are breaking, and your skin just doesn't have that same smooth glow anymore. That's where Bubs naturals collagen peptides come in. Starting in your mid-20s, your body naturally produces less collagen every single year. And collagen is the protein that holds everything together. It's literally the glue of your body. With Bubs, you can help restore collagen levels closer to what your body naturally had in its youth. That means stronger joints, healthier hair and nails, smoother skin and faster recovery. And it's super easy to use. Just mix Bubs into your coffee, smoothie or juice each morning. It's tasteless, odorless and dissolves instantly. No clumps and no weird aftertaste. And here's what makes Bubs truly different. The brand is a tribute to former Navy SEAL the Glenn Bub Daugherty, a national hero who gave his life saving Americans in Benghazi, Libya. Glenn's call sign was Bub and he was the kind of guy who has always pushed for self improvement and helped everyone around him. That DNA is woven into Bubs brand and to honor him, Bubs donates 10% of all profits to charity starting with the Glen Dougherty Memorial Foundation. On top of that, Bubs is built to the highest standard. No junk, zero sugars, sweeteners or fillers. It's third party tested, NSA certified for sport Whole30 approved and sustainably sourced from grass fed pasture raised cattle. It's trusted by over 100,000 customers and was named best collagen of 2024 by Health.com live better longer for a limited time only. Our listeners are getting 20% off at Bubs Naturals by using code Midas at checkout. Just head to b u b s naturals.com and use code Midas and you're all set. After you purchase, they'll ask where you heard about them. Please support our show and tell them that Midas Touch sent you.

[Podcast Host]

Now let me just bring you some receipts right here of Elise Stefanik. So you had Elise Stefanik in the past two weeks saying that Maga Mike Johnson needs to go saying that MAGA Mike Johnson would be voted out if there were to be a vote to remove him as the speaker. That's one of the things she came out with recently. Maga Mike was like, maybe she should just give me a call a little bit. Let me show you that in a moment. But first let me show you over here. This is back on January 7th, 2024. Um, Elise Stefanik referred to the January 6th insurrectionist as the hostages. She called them the hostages. Here, play this clip on the issue.

[Elise Stefanik (or clips of her)]

Of election integrity, though, as you know, Trump took his case to court more than 60 times that there was fraud. He didn't win. But I want to back to this key question. Do you still think it was a tragic day? Do you think that the people who stormed the Capitol should be held responsible to the full extent of. I have concerns about the treatment of January six hostages. I have concerns. We have a role in Congress of oversight over our treatments of prisoners. And I believe that we're seeing the weaponization of the federal government against not just President Trump, but we're seeing it against conservatives, we're seeing it against Catholics. And that's, that's one of the reasons why I'm so proud to serve on the Select Committee on the Weaponization of the Government, because the American people want answers. They want transparency, and they understand that as you look across this country, there seems to be two sets of rules. If your last name is Clinton or it's Biden, you get to live by a different set of rules than if you're an everyday patriotic American.

[Podcast Host]

Now, when Elise Stefanik was potentially going through that confirmation process to be the United States ambassador to the United States United nations, which is her nomination was withdrawn by Donald Trump. Senator Van Hollen asked her a question. Should Israel have a biblical right to take over all of the west bank, to just seize it? Here's what she said. Play this clip.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

Rarely surprised by answers in my office, but I did ask you whether you subscribe to the views of Finance Minister Smotrich, who.

[Elise Stefanik (or clips of her)]

I'm sorry, Smotrich.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

This is the Israeli Finance Minister Smotrich and the former National Security Minister Ben gvir, who believe that Israel has a biblical right to the entire West Bank. And in that conversation, you told me that. Yes. You shared that view. Is that your view today?

[Elise Stefanik (or clips of her)]

Yes.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

Okay. I think when it comes to this very difficult issue, if the president is going to succeed at bringing peace and stability to the Middle east, we're going to have to look at the UN Security Council resolutions, not just the ones on Lebanon, which we should enforce, but other UN Security Council resolutions. And it's going to be very difficult to achieve that. If you continue to hold the view that you just expressed when she was.

[Podcast Host]

Auditioning to be Donald Trump's VP and he ultimately passed her over to pick JD Vance. She was asked, had you been Vice President on January 6, what would you have done here? Play this clip.

[Elise Stefanik (or clips of her)]

And let's talk about the vice presidency. Because you just said that you would be willing to serve in a Trump administration. Had you been Vice President on January 6, 2021, what would you have done? I stood up for the Constitution. I believe in. What would you have done if you were vice president? I would not have done what Mike Pence did. I don't think that was the right approach. I specifically stand by what I said on the House floor and I stand by my statement, which was there was unconstitutional overreach. There was unconstitutional overreach in states like Pennsylvania. And I think it's very important that we continue to stand up for the Constitution and have legal and elections which we did not have in 2020 and the tens of millions of Americans agree with me. Katie. I would say the Supreme Court in the state of Pennsylvania said that that Republican passed changes to their law was.

[Podcast Host]

Constitutional and Donald Trump didn't even know how to pronounce her name. Here, play this clip right here.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

How good did Elise Stepanek do?

[Podcast Host]

And here is what Mike Johnson had to say about her when she was saying that he needs to go, but. But she was the one who ended up going. Play this clip.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

I don't exactly know why Elise won't just call me. I texted her yesterday. She's upset one of her provisions is not being made, I think, into the ndaa. I explained to her on a text message as soon as I heard this yesterday. I was campaigning in Tennessee and I wrote her and I said, what are you talking about? This hasn't even made it to my level. The way regular order works is and I think she should know this. We'll be talking about it, I'm sure today. The way this works is that it has to go through committees of jurisdiction if it'll be attached to the ndaa. And this provision that she's working on I think is under the jurisdiction of Judiciary. And so there's a four corners engagement and agreement that's required. You all know how this works. The two chairs and the two ranking members of the committees of jurisdiction, which would be Judiciary in the House and Senate, all have to agree or at least three out of four have to agree. It's typically unanimous to make sure that it makes it onto the bill. Well, in this case, I found out last night this wasn't even on my radar, that that apparently didn't happen. I haven't even talked to those chairman. I haven't had time because I got in late last night. But apparently those four, the two chairs and the two rankers in both chambers did not agree. And so that provision was dropped out of the ndaa. It doesn't mean it can't become law or even that that is a final decision.

[Podcast Host]

Now, finally, I'll show you this clip where Donald Trump was with Mamdani and he was asked about Elise Stefanik saying that Mamdani is like a jihadist or whatever the hell she would say.

[Advertisement Narrator]

Right.

[Podcast Host]

The New York Post would run her headlines, right? Like New York Post would be like, you know, she says that he's an anti semi terrorist. So Trump was asked that and then Trump threw her under a bus. Again, Trump like gloated in throwing her under the bus.

[Advertisement Narrator]

Here.

[Podcast Host]

Let's play this clip right here.

[Elise Stefanik (or clips of her)]

Republican Elise Stefanik has campaigned multiple times by calling Zoram Hamdani a jihadist. Do you think you're standing next to a jihadist right now in the Oval Office?

[Interviewer/Reporter]

No, I don't. But she's out there campaigning and you know, you say things sometimes in a campaign.

[Elise Stefanik (or clips of her)]

Isn't that sort of thing?

[Interviewer/Reporter]

She's a very capable person, but you really have to ask her about that. But I don't particularly. I think I met with a. I met with a man who's a very rational person. I met with a man who wants to see, really wants to see New.

[Podcast Host]

York be great again.

[Interviewer/Reporter]

And I can say again, because New.

[Podcast Host]

York was great also, by the way, folks, you had another, our major Republican figure resign. Republican Senator Cynthia Loomis of Wyoming will not run for reelection in 2016. Right. It's like the rats are leaving the ship. Right? The rats are fleeing the ship. Here's what Loomis had to say. It's been an incredible honor to represent wyoming in the U.S. senate. And throughout my time here, Wyoming has been my own, my one and only priority, really, because he seemed to have screwed the farmers pretty badly. Donald Trump's tariffs against the world have been an absolute disaster. You ripped away people's health care. What do you like about the people of Wyoming? Torturing them. Okay. What a blessing to serve. What a blessing. I decided not to run. That doesn't represent a change of heart for me. But it's exhausting. I've come to accept that I do not have six more years in me. I am a devout legislature, but I feel like a sprinter in a marathon. The energy required doesn't match up. The energy required doesn't match up. That's one way of saying that the rat is fleeing the ship. There you have it, folks. Bye bye, Loomis. Bye bye, Stefanic. I'm sure I'll be reporting on more of these losers leaving soon. And they deserve it. They've caused such harm to the American people and their life legacy will be that of shame. Shame on you. Hit subscribe let's get to 6 million and thanks for watching.

[Advertisement Narrator]

Love this video, support independent media and unlock exclusive content, ad free videos and custom emojis. By becoming a paid member of our YouTube channel today. You can also gift memberships to others. Let's keep growing together.

[Podcast Host]

Everyone deserves to be connected. That's why T Mobile and US Cellular are joining forces. Switch to T Mobile and save up to 20% versus Verizon by getting built in benefits they leave out. Check the math@t mobile.com switch and now T mobile is in US cellular stores. Savings versus Comparable Verizon plans plus the cost of optional benefits, plan features and taxes and fees vary. Savings with three plus lines include third line free via monthly bill credits. Credit stop if you cancel any lines. Qualifying credit required.

[Elise Stefanik (or clips of her)]

Indulge in holiday cravings with the nutrition you need from Cachava's all in One Whole Body Shake. It's 25 grams of protein, 6 grams of fiber, greens and so much more. Savor the season knowing you're getting the good stuff your body craves. With Kachava, you're getting the highest quality ingredients. No fillers, no nonsense. Holiday nutrition has never been this easy or delicious. Go to Kachava K-A C-H-A-V-A.com and use code SMOOTHIE for 15% off.