C (26:42)
Okay, so what this guy just said is completely, totally, unequivocally, without exception, wrong. Totally wrong and crazy. Now look, he's not a theologian, he's a filmmaker. So I don't know how seriously he takes religion. I don't know how much he's thought about this. But in any case, he's made an egregious error by saying that Christianity is socialist. And it's tragic because he could have made a good point. There is a good point that he could have made. But he didn't. The way I know that Christianity is not socialist is. On the one hand we have this guy Nathan Apfel, who says Christianity at its core is socialist. On the other hand, we have blessed Pope Pius ix who describes socialism as a wicked theory that would, quote, overthrow the entire order of human affairs. Pope Leo XIII calls socialism a hideous deformity of the civil society of men and almost its ruin, calls socialists a seditious society. Pope Pius XI says that socialism is fundamentally contrary to Christian truth, says that socialism is based nevertheless on a theory of human society peculiar to itself and irreconcilable with true Christianity. Religious socialism, Christian socialism are contradictory terms. No one can be at the same time a good Catholic and a true socialist. Pope John xxiii, who's actually a pretty liberal pope, unlike Pius ix, who started out liberal, became very, very conservative. Pope Leo xiii, who was kind of. He appeals to both the left and the right, but he's more of a conservative figure then Pope Pius xi. Very conservative. Pope John XXIII is considered a more liberal pope. He said, in no uncertain terms, no Catholic could subscribe even to moderate socialism. Socialism is anathema from the Christian perspective. I could go on. I could quote St. Paul VI, St. John Paul II, Pope Benedict XVI. You get the point. No, Christianity is not in any sense socialist. It is a major theological and historical misunderstanding that would lead anyone to say that. Now, the point that Tucker's guest could have made that is worth pointing out, is that there are problems with capitalism too. It's not that we say Christianity is not socialist, therefore it is entirely capitalist. That is not the case. There is an important aspect of capitalism for Christianity. You see this in the writings of Pope Leo xiii. You see this reaffirmed by John Paul II in Chantesimus annus on the 100th anniversary of Pope Leo XIII's encyclical Rerum Novarum. Capitalism, which is just to say private property and markets, can be a good thing. John Paul II said that free markets are the most efficient way to allocate goods around society. And Pope Leo XIII went further to say that people have a right to their private property. The socialists and the communists say, you have no right whatsoever to your private property. Leo XIII says, no, you do have a right to private property. However, this is the crucial part. It is not an absolute right because of something that Christians call the universal destination of goods, the. That is to say that created goods are for ultimately humanity. However, it is important as a matter of dignity, as a matter of the efficient allocation of resources. As a matter of functioning societies that we have private property, but it's a conditional right. It's conditioned on the notion that there is in fact a universal destination of goods. So what we would say is not three cheers for capitalism. We would say two cheers for capitalism. Capitalism is good, but we don't want the tail to wag the dog. We're not a society, we're not human beings living in service of an economic market. However, the economy is to be arranged in such a way that it is conducive to human flourishing. Socialism gets no cheers. Socialism is wicked, evil, totally contrary to the Christian faith. People who think Christianity is socialist just don't get it. You know they're not gonna make it. However, there are critiques of pure capitalism, laissez faire capitalism, hyper individualist capitalism that are legitimate from a Christian perspective. But folks, let's not be so contrarian that we're gonna pretend that socialism goes along with Christianity. Quite the opposite. Socialism and communism arising from false premises about human nature have been enemies of the church from day one. Okay, speaking of Christianity, great news. Conversion's way way up and the libs fighting Christians tooth and nail. Catholic nuns now being punished. Catholic nuns who are caring for terminally ill poor people being punished cuz they won't accept transgenderism. And a new trans initialism comes out in Canada. First though, I want to tell you about PureTalk. Go to PureTalk.com knowles K N A W L E S I've worked with PureTalk for a long time now. I've been a Pure Talk customer for a long time now. In part, it's because I wanted to work with a wireless company that shares my values. PureTalk is veteran led. Helping veterans is extremely important to them. They've donated over half a million dollars to America's Warrior Partnership, a terrific organization on the front lines of preventing veteran suicide. PureTalk is creating American jobs with a US only workforce. I love that it'd be a lot cheaper to send jobs overseas like the other companies do. PureTalk is committed to delivering the best experience possible for customers. So I love that, both for the jobs and the fact that people speak English when I call them. I also, and this is the most important, I love PureTalk Service because they give you the same towers, the same Network, the same 5G coverage as one of the big guys for a fraction of the price. Not saying similar coverage, I'm not saying similar towers, saying the same ones. I love it. I've had my Pure Talk phone for what, six years now? It's great. It even works overseas. I choose to do business with a company that shares my values, supports veterans every single day, creates American jobs. You can, too. PureTalk.comKnowles just switch to PureTalk. PurerTalk.comKnowles switch to my wireless company, America's wireless company, PureTalk. We've seen percolations of this story coming up for months, even years, that conversions, baptisms, Christianity and Catholicism specifically way, way up. Well, now we have the numbers. After Easter Sunday, after a lot of people were received into the church in the United States, adult conversions were up 38%. 38%. After 2025, in which conversions were already way, way up. There is something happening. It is happening broadly to religion. New atheism, deader than disco. Religious faith is back because new atheism is dumb and indefensible. And it's not even as good as the old atheism, which is also dumb and indefensible. Whereas religion speaks to the eternal questions and the eternal longings of man and eternal truths. And Catholicism in particular is way, way up. Why is Catholicism in particular way, way up? I've mentioned on the show before Alexei de Tocqueville, who wrote Democracy in America, the greatest analysis of American democracy ever. He writes it in around 1830, Alexis de Tocqueville predicted that even though America is a Protestant country, it would tend in two directions as time went on. It would tend toward atheism on the one hand and toward Catholicism on the other. And the reason, Tocqueville said, is because in democracies, you heard Tucker's guest actually say that democratic republican government is the greatest form of government ever. That's in itself a dubious claim, but we'll leave that for another time. Tocqueville observed that if you're gonna have democracy, people under democracy are gonna wanna throw off all authority, including religious authority. So they're gonna become atheists. However, if they are going to accept religious authority at all, because man is a religious creature, he can't get away from those eternal questions. If he's gonna accept religious authority, he wants it to be uniform and universal, which is what you get in Catholicism. There's a distinction between the clergy and the laity, perhaps, but among the laity, everybody's equal. And so he saw, not just because of migration, not just because there were Irish coming into America and Germans coming into America. Those mass waves of immigration actually didn't happen for years after Tocqueville published Democracy in America. What Tocqueville was seeing was something intrinsic, too, in the nature of American Democracy, democracy generally, that would tend toward Catholicism. That's one reason. The other reason is that man is a liturgical creature. And a lot of. A lot of modern Protestantism, not High Church Protestantism, not the Presbyterians and the Anglicans and the Episcopalians, but more of the low church, Evangelical, Baptist, non denominational, capital N, capital D, that kind of Protestantism is less liturgical. They don't have rights and rituals. They often don't have icons. It's much more personalist, it's much more emotivist, and some people like that. I'm not even knocking your tastes or your preferences. I'm just pointing out, man, because we're embodied creatures, we're liturgical creatures. We're creatures of habit. We do things with our bodies, and we do things in patterns, and we do things in cycles and in habits. And so liturgical religion is going to speak to that. We've neglected our physicality for so long. You saw that peak, I think, during the transgender moment, where we said, our bodies have nothing to do with who we really are. And I think it's no coincidence that that year was the turning point. And after that madness had passed, you saw a huge tick up, specifically in liturgical religion. And then the other reason is that subjectivism is exhausted. We've been quoting a lot of popes today. Pope Benedict XVI talked about the poison of subjectivism, this tyranny of subjectivism that had overtaken the west, where we don't really know if anything's true or false. And it doesn't just go back to the 1960s. It goes back much earlier, really. It goes back to Descartes, Rene Descartes, who said, I think therefore I am. And what he concluded was that the only thing that we can really know for certain is that we think things. In other words, the only certain knowledge that we have is what's banging around in our own head, that we don't necessarily interact with reality as such. That was a major break from the scholastics of the Middle Ages, from antiquity, and it, in my view, marked the beginning of the end of a stable civilization. So that trend has been building for hundreds and hundreds of years. I think that reached a tipping point also, really, with the transgender craze, where you say, I can't even know what my sex is. You can't know what anyone's sex is. We can't know anything at all. It tends toward almost a philosophical solipsism. And at that point, people said, nah, you know what? I'm pretty sure there is truth, and I want to touch truth. And I want to touch reality, and I want to be grounded in something real. And that would tend toward the more mainline Protestant churches, the more liturgical churches, but then ultimately toward the Catholic Church, which is the only institution in the west that has survived since antiquity. That's why it's up. Look, I also believe the reason it's up is because of the moving of the Holy Spirit and also because I think that the Catholic Church is divinely instituted. So I obviously believe that. But I'm just observing the sociological reasons why Catholicism in particular is having such a resurgence. Now. No one should be surprised by that. This has been something 500 years in the making. Now, because of that, the libs are really on the move, fighting Catholics in particular. Christians generally, religious people generally, but Catholics in particular, there's this fight. Catholic nuns serving dying patients are now being punished by New York legislators because the New York legislators are insisting on a transgender mandate for pronouns and for rooming. So you have these sisters in New York. It's the Dominican Sisters of Hawthorne. We love our Dominican sisters, one of the great religious orders of all time. The Dominican Sisters of Hawthorne in New York are 125-year-old organization that has done one thing. Taken care of poor, dying people. All you have to do to be taken care of by these sisters is show up, say, I have a terminal illness and no one can take care of me, and they will take care of you. This is as wonderful an organization as ever there was. And the New York legislators are trying to punish them. Cause they're saying, listen, sisters, if a guy shows up and he's a man, but he says that he's a woman, you need to call him a woman. You need to violate your conscience. You need to lie, you need to commit a mortal sin. You need to deny reality. And furthermore, you need to room him with the women. And the sisters say, we can't do that because that's a sin and that's a lie, and it's dangerous, and it's for a billion reasons we can't do that. And the New York legislators are saying, well, we're gonna punish you. This reminds me of Joe Biden when he was vice president in the Joe Biden, nominally a Catholic. It's the Obama administration. What did they do? They sued nuns. Nuns really are a specific type of religious sister, but colloquially, we refer to all religious sisters as nuns. I guess he was suing nuns. He was suing nuns, the little sisters of the poor, because they wouldn't pay for abortions. And I just think as a rule of Thumb. This is hideous stuff. Obviously, if you're in New York, call your legislators. This is disgusting. More persecution of the Church. Christianity being the most persecuted religion in the world, by the numbers. Not even close. But as a general rule of thumb, you know me, I'm not the loftiest intellectual in the world. No false modesty. I'm not. I'm not saying that I'm the deepest theologian or philosopher. I'm a simple man. I'm a political creature. And I like rules of thumb and I like shortcuts. And here's a political shortcut for you. Whichever side of politics is suing nuns, that's the bad guys. And you should be on the other side. Whether we're talking about New York state legislators, whether we're talking about the Spanish Civil War, where the Republicans, the freedom fighters in the Spanish Civil War, open up the war by shooting at a statue of Jesus and then attacking nuns and priests. Those aren't the good guys. Those are the bad guys. They were communists, by the way. They were socialists and communists. A perfidious and wicked society that is contrary to the Christian faith. Just a good rule of thumb. Whatever side is attacking the nuns, be on the other side, okay? Now, speaking of weird sexual identities, a Canadian member of Parliament has dropped a new initialism. LGBTQ is out. There's a new one. We'll get to that momentarily. First, though, wanna tell you about tacovous. Go to tokovis.com knowles anywhere worth going is worth going in good shoes and boots, and our sponsor, Tokovas makes the best. Can I do? Am I flexible enough to show you? Let me see if I can. These are probably my absolute favorite shoes that I wear every day now. It's hard for me to pull off the boots, though I do have my Tokova's boots, and I do wear them sometimes. The shoes are also magnificent. I have a Tokova's wallet on me, which a very prominent person and style magnate was just. He looked at. He said, michael, where'd you get that wallet? I want that wallet. It's Tokovis wallet. They're all great. All their stuff is just absolutely terrific. And you need to get it to look good to feel Good. Right now, get 10% off@tokovis.com Knowles K A W L E S When you sign up for email and texts, that is 10% off at t e c o v a s.com knowles canada w-tokovas.com knowles c site for details to Covis point your toes west. A lot is happening Right now, it's hitting everything from your paycheck to your freedom. So you can either guess or you can know. The Daily Wire gives you live breaking news, investigative reporting, ad free daily shows, and experts who are actually part of the story. This is really exciting. I've been pushing on this for a while now, and I'm very glad we're doing it. We're adding a ton of investigative journalists. We have this great new show with Cabot Phillips, Wired in live, leaning heavy into reporting and journalism. On top of the most important thing, of course, which is certain of the opinion shows with nice cigars and nice candles and all the rest of certain jeune sais quoi. Dailywire's giving you all of that, plus entertainment, plus community experience. You gotta join right now. DailyWire.com subscribe Now. I did not pick the comment today. I was too excited to discover that I am a cousin of Winston Churchill. We are specifically cousins through the Mayflower. And I am smoking a Mayflower Dawn Churchill cigar today. How glorious providence is. And you can get yours. So I didn't pick the comment. The producers picked the comment. And here's the comment they picked. We'll see if I like it. From colexn7. No. As a certified person who's never worked in firefighting, never spoken with a fire marshal, please trim that candle wick before it burns the place down. Stay safe. Okay, you know, what is this? Members of the makeup and wardrobe staff writing it to me right now because they tell me all that they say, michael, you gotta trim your wick. So is that a euphemism? They said, no, you have to get this thing. They gave me a thing. Did you know this, men? I'm sure the women knew this in the audience. Did you know there's such a thing as a wick trimmer? And you're supposed to cut. You're supposed to clip with this little tool. Looks like a medieval torture device. You're supposed to clip the wick on your candle. I'm a candle mogul and I didn't know that for a very long time. Anyway, lots of combustibles on the table today that I have produced the candles and the Mayflower. Dawn Churchill, a new initialism has dropped. Just when you had learned the LGBTQ lmnop Just when you learned that that one's out because a member of Parliament in Canada has a new one.