The Monopoly Report: Episode 29 Summary Privacy Enhancing Technologies with Brian May
Podcast Information:
- Title: The Monopoly Report
- Host: Alan Chappell
- Guest: Brian May, Senior Technology Leader and Privacy Technologist
- Release Date: May 14, 2025
- Description: In-depth coverage of big tech's antitrust woes from Marketecture.tv, focusing on the Google search and ad tech trials and more.
Introduction
In Episode 29 of The Monopoly Report, host Alan Chappell engages in a comprehensive discussion with privacy technologist Brian May. With over 40 years in software and systems architecture and a notable focus on privacy within the ad tech space, Brian brings a wealth of experience to the conversation. The episode delves into the intricacies of Privacy Enhancing Technologies (PETs), their impact on the advertising ecosystem, and the broader implications for the industry's future.
1. Historical Context: Adware and Lessons Learned (00:32 – 04:13)
Adware's Dark Past: Alan Chappell begins by drawing parallels between contemporary ad tech challenges and the problematic era of adware from two decades ago. Adware, often bundled with software like music file-sharing applications, was notorious for intrusive advertisements and poor user experiences.
Brian May's Insight:
"You need to be respectful of everybody who you're engaging with, from consumers to partners to business associates. You don't last long in a new frontier if the rules that you're making for that frontier are self-serving to the point where nobody else is getting the value they need."
[02:42]
Brian emphasizes the importance of mutual respect and value within the ecosystem, highlighting lessons learned from the adware days. He references Tim O'Reilly's philosophy on providing more value to the ecosystem than what is captured, underscoring the foundation for sustainable ad tech practices.
2. Privacy Enhancing Technologies in Ad Tech (07:36 – 14:18)
Defining PETs: The conversation shifts to Privacy Enhancing Technologies (PETs), with Alan prompting Brian to elaborate on their core value within the ad space.
Brian May’s Perspective:
"The real value of privacy Enhancing technologies is that they control access to data in meaningful ways."
[08:00]
Brian explains that PETs are designed to manage data access securely, ensuring that data pipelines respect user privacy. However, he cautions that PETs are often implemented as point solutions, addressing specific data leakage concerns without considering the entire data lifecycle—from collection to consumption.
Challenges Highlighted: Alan echoes these concerns, questioning the effectiveness of PETs in ensuring comprehensive privacy safeguards. Brian concurs, pointing out the dual nature of ad tech as both independent and interdependent, which complicates the implementation of standardized privacy measures.
3. Data Minimization and Its Challenges (13:49 – 16:32)
Regulatory Pressures: Data minimization—a principle requiring the collection of only necessary data—is a significant focus, with Alan noting its implementation across various jurisdictions like the EU and several US states.
Brian May’s Analysis:
"A clean room is a place where two people bring together a data set each or a couple data sets each and then combine those data sets to create a new one."
[14:18]
Brian discusses how data clean rooms facilitate collaboration while preserving privacy, contrasting them with data stockpiling practices. He acknowledges the ad tech industry's inherent reluctance to limit data collection, emphasizing the need for external push to adopt data minimization effectively.
4. Standards and Collaboration in Privacy (17:23 – 21:27)
The Complexity of Data Governance: Alan and Brian explore the challenges smaller ad tech companies face in implementing robust data governance and privacy programs, highlighting the resource-intensive nature of these efforts.
Brian May’s Proposal:
"We can identify a subset, I would guess somewhere around maybe a dozen attributes for an ad and a campaign that will tell advertiser how to optimize their campaign and is their campaign worthwhile."
[18:39]
Brian advocates for industry-wide standards that delineate essential data attributes necessary for effective advertising. By standardizing these elements, smaller players can streamline their processes, ensuring compliance and efficiency without heavy resource burdens.
5. Critique of Big Tech’s Implementation of PETs (22:41 – 26:04)
Transparency and Accountability Issues: Alan raises concerns about Big Tech's PETs implementations, citing a lack of transparency and the potential for trading one privacy issue for another.
Brian May’s Response:
"We haven't taken the time to look at what data we are providing to other participants. Is this data sufficient to solve their use cases? Is it more than they need?"
[24:31]
Brian agrees, pointing out that current PETs often fail to address the broader implications of data sharing. He warns that without comprehensive oversight, these technologies can inadvertently facilitate anti-competitive behaviors.
6. Privacy Sandbox and Google’s Approach (26:04 – 30:30)
Assessing Google's Privacy Sandbox: Alan probes Brian's thoughts on Google's Privacy Sandbox, questioning its effectiveness and implementation strategy.
Brian May’s Critique:
"If you start by saying, hey, we're going to deprecate cookies and oh, by the way, we're going to need to figure out how to backfill for them, that throws everybody into a panic."
[26:40]
Brian critiques Google's approach to phasing out third-party cookies, arguing that the abrupt announcement led to industry-wide panic rather than collaborative problem-solving. He suggests that a more gradual, consultative approach could have fostered better industry cooperation and innovation.
7. Lessons from Apple’s Cohort System vs. Google’s FLoC (30:54 – 32:16)
Comparative Analysis: Alan contrasts Apple's cohort-based advertising model with Google's Federated Learning of Cohorts (FLoC), highlighting the differing receptions and implementations.
Brian May’s Insights:
"Apple generally is very careful to control as much of the context as possible."
[31:16]
Brian explains that Apple's cohort system is perceived as more privacy-conscious because it tightly controls the context and minimizes data exposure, whereas Google's FLoC faced criticism for enabling browser fingerprinting and insufficiently protecting user privacy.
8. Future Vision for Ad Tech and Consumer Relations (32:16 – 34:21)
Reimagining Consumer Interaction: In discussing the future, Brian envisions an ad tech ecosystem where consumers are active participants rather than passive targets.
Brian May’s Vision:
"If we worked with consumers, collaborated, asked what they are interested in, and used our data science to align ads with those interests, we'd provide more value to consumers."
[32:16]
Brian advocates for a shift from adversarial data mining to collaborative, value-driven interactions. By aligning advertising practices with genuine consumer interests, the industry can foster trust and enhance the overall marketplace health.
Conclusion
The episode concludes with Alan highlighting the need for more principled voices like Brian's in the ad tech space. Emphasizing the scarcity of unbiased consumer research amidst substantial industry investments, Alan underscores the importance of balanced perspectives to navigate the complex interplay of privacy, competition, and transparency.
Final Thoughts from Brian May:
"We would come out with a marketplace that was hugely prosperous and that enabled all sorts of great things socially going forward."
[33:49]
Brian calls for a collective effort to prioritize the ecosystem's health, advocating for standards and practices that support trust and prosperity for all stakeholders involved.
Key Takeaways:
- Respect and Value: Sustainable ad tech practices hinge on mutual respect and delivering more value to the ecosystem than what is extracted.
- Comprehensive Privacy Solutions: PETs must address the entire data lifecycle, not just isolated points of data leakage.
- Industry Standards: Developing standardized data attributes can streamline privacy compliance, especially for smaller players.
- Collaborative Approach: Transitioning away from third-party cookies requires a collaborative, rather than panicked, industry response.
- Consumer-Centric Models: Shifting to consumer collaboration can rebuild trust and enhance the advertising ecosystem's overall health.
Subscribe for More Insights: Stay informed on the latest in antitrust and ad tech by subscribing to The Monopoly Report on Spotify, Apple Podcasts, YouTube, or your preferred podcast platform. For weekly updates and strategic insights, visit Markitecture.tv.