Podcast Summary: The Moth – "The Denver Battle of the SLAMs"

Episode Overview

In the December 12, 2017 episode of The Moth podcast titled "The Denver Battle of the SLAMs", hosts Betsy Lamberson and Kevin Carlin celebrate Denver’s triumph in the 2016 Battle of the Slams—a friendly nationwide competition among local Moth Story Slam cities. This episode features three captivating true stories from Denver storytellers, each delivered with humor, vulnerability, and profound insight. The featured storytellers include Andrew Overdahl, Madeline Berenson, and Harry Fleener, each sharing personal narratives that explore themes of fear, childhood mischief, and youthful misunderstandings.

1. Andrew Overdahl: “Jumping into the Spotlight” (00:01:19)

Andrew Overdahl, a stand-up comic, writer, and actor from Denver, kicks off the episode with his nerve-wracking experience of performing on The Tonight Show. Andrew’s story delves into the intense emotions and self-doubt that accompany stepping onto a national stage.

Key Points:

• First-Time Nerves: Andrew emphasizes the daunting challenge of performing live for the first time. “They’re so supportive. So Andrew's story, I love this one because it sort of speaks to that rush of stuff, stage fright that we're all familiar with” (01:19).

• Prank Turns Reality: Initially believing the Tonight Show invitation to be a prank, Andrew recounts hesitantly preparing for the appearance. “I immediately thought, this is a cool prank. There's no way that this is a real thing” (02:35).

• On-Stage Terror: The pressure mounts as Andrew describes his paralysis on stage. “My microphone hand is locked up like this. It’s like it’s done moving. All the joints have fused together” (04:30).

• Triumphant Realization: Despite the fear, the audience’s positive reception transforms his experience. “The crowd is really enjoying it. They’re clapping like they’re at a magic show” (07:00).

Notable Quote:

“I was worthless. I couldn’t eat any food. I couldn’t have a conversation with someone because, like, halfway through the conversation, I would just sort of, like, fade off and just, like, mentally picture myself, like, tripping on stage in front of all these people watching me on TV. I was like, garbage.” (04:15)

Background: Andrew Overdahl is renowned in the Denver comedy scene, having created the hit storytelling show The Narrators and appearing on Those Who Can’t on TruTV. His storytelling prowess stems from his extensive experience in stand-up and writing, making his narratives both engaging and relatable.

2. Madeline Berenson: “The Perfect Prank” (08:12)

Madeline Berenson, a seasoned storyteller and regular at Denver Story Slams, shares a nostalgic and humorous tale from her childhood. Her story revolves around an elaborate plan to scare her younger siblings using realistic witch and werewolf masks.

Key Points:

• Big vs. Little Kids: Madeline reminisces about growing up in a large family, highlighting the divide between the "big kids" and "little kids." “We big kids were innovators and leaders... the little kids mostly just sat around eating paste and shitting themselves” (08:48).

• The Prank Preparation: Discovering lifelike masks, Madeline and her brother Peter meticulously craft disguises to maximize the scare factor. “We wanted to transform ourselves into an actual witch and an actual werewolf” (11:00).

• Execution and Outcome: The prank takes an unexpected turn when their mother intervenes, turning the tables and leaving the siblings in fear. “We were the ones who ended up getting terrified, right?” (14:15).

• Reflections: Years later, Madeline reflects on the unintended impact of their actions, recognizing her mother’s bravery from her younger brother’s perspective. “Mom’s brave. One night, a long time ago, a witch and a werewolf came into our room. And mom told them, get out” (15:50).

Notable Quote:

“The most important information was that these beautiful costumes were wasted. And they were so realistic and so perfect, and they did not realize their full potential.” (14:00)

Background: Madeline Berenson’s diverse upbringing, moving across states and growing up amidst eclectic surroundings, has fueled her creativity as a writer and ski instructor. Residing in Eaglevale, Colorado, Madeline balances her storytelling with family life, becoming a beloved figure in the Denver storytelling community.

3. Harry Fleener: “A Childhood Misunderstanding” (16:48)

Harry Fleener, the oldest storyteller at The Moth nearing 97 years old, offers a poignant and humorous recount of his childhood misunderstanding about the concept of sex, shaped by his elders’ misleading descriptions.

Key Points:

• Ignorance and Misconceptions: Harry recounts how his lack of understanding about sex, combined with mischievous tales from older kids, led to a series of humorous yet awkward experiences. “I thought about it for a while and I thought, oh, hey, what they want me to do is get in bed with a naked girl” (17:18).

• The Pledge Against Sex: His childhood resolve to avoid the confusion and embarrassment altogether by vowing never to engage in sex driven by a fear of failure and misunderstanding. “I decided for my life, I am never ever going to do sex the rest of my life.” (22:57).

• Life Lessons: Harry’s story underscores the importance of clear communication and the impact of childhood experiences on lifelong perspectives.

Notable Quote:

“I really didn’t appreciate looking at my mom naked. I don’t know if you’ve ever had the experience, but don’t. I don't recommend.” (18:00)

Background: Harry Fleener’s rich life experiences, including studying law and journalism, serving in the U.S. Army during World War II, and fathering nine children, provide a deep well of stories. Currently a car salesman, Harry remains active in his community through dancing, hunting, and participating in local Toastmasters meetings.

Conclusion and Reflections (23:25)

The episode concludes with hosts Betsy Lamberson and Kevin Carlin reflecting on the storytellers’ narratives, praising their ability to encapsulate complex emotions and experiences within the confines of a five-minute tale. They highlight the art of crafting a compelling ending, as demonstrated by Madeline’s story, and commend Harry for his vivid recounting of childhood memories despite technical challenges during his storytelling.

Final Remarks:

“Story crafting can be really difficult sometimes, and the hardest thing can be getting it down to five minutes for a story slam. And what I love about Madeline's story is her ending. She completely nails it on how to cut off a story.” (16:22)

The hosts extend their gratitude to the Denver storytellers and listeners, celebrating the community’s contribution to making the Battle of the Slams a resounding success. They encourage listeners to support The Moth through donations and to attend future Story Slams for more engaging storytelling experiences.

About the Hosts:

• Kevin Carlin: A former stand-up comedian from Buffalo, New York, Kevin transitioned to Denver where he now resides with his family. He brings his comedic background and storytelling passion to his role as the host of Denver Story Slams, enriching the local storytelling culture.

• Betsy Lamberson: As the local producer of the Denver Story Slam, Betsy combines her personal experiences, including surviving a terrorist bombing, with her role in fostering a vibrant storytelling community. She balances her storytelling with motherhood, raising her five-month-old son in Denver.

Production Credits:

• Podcast Production: Timothy Lou Lee
• Presentation: PRX (Public Radio Exchange)

For more information on The Moth and upcoming Story Slams, visit themoth.org.