The New Yorker Radio Hour: "Does Tim Walz Have Any Regrets?" – Detailed Summary

Introduction

In the February 28, 2025 episode of The New Yorker Radio Hour, hosted by David Remnick, Governor Tim Walz of Minnesota joins for an in-depth conversation titled "Does Tim Walz Have Any Regrets?" The episode delves into the complexities of Democratic strategies in the wake of the Trump administration, the recent election defeat, cultural and economic challenges, and Walz's personal reflections on political leadership and future aspirations.

Democrats' Struggles in Washington vs. State Governance

David Remnick opens the discussion by highlighting the apparent paralysis within the Democratic Party in Washington amidst a surge of far-right appointments by President Trump. He contrasts this with the proactive resistance observed among Democratic governors, including Tim Walz, who feels they possess greater leverage to oppose federal policies.

"Minnesota needs answers. We'll see Trump in court." [00:38]

Remnick emphasizes the Democrats' frustration with national opposition, referencing anecdotes from Democratic leaders like Hakeem Jeffries and Senator John Fetterman, who express concerns over the party's strategic responses to Trump’s maneuvers.

Tim Walz on Democratic Policy Effectiveness and Grassroots Movements

Governor Walz responds by acknowledging the public's desire to disengage from overwhelming negative news but counters that there is still active resistance against policies that harm everyday lives. He draws parallels to the grassroots Tea Party movement that emerged during President Obama’s tenure, suggesting that a similar, albeit evolving, grassroots opposition exists within the Democratic base.

"If I were Republicans, I would be really, really worried about these town halls, because in my opinion, that was the real start that led into the 2016 election." [03:41]

Walz emphasizes the importance of demonstrating the effectiveness of Democratic policies to counteract the persistent and adaptive Republican strategies.

Election Defeat: Reflections and Regrets

The conversation shifts to Walz's recent election loss, which he attributes to a combination of insufficient economic messaging and the overwhelming cultural issues overshadowing tangible policy discussions. He expresses deep personal disappointment, particularly in not securing enough support from white men, reflecting on how the economic disenfranchisement and cultural alienation contributed to the defeat.

"I thought there would be more massive immigration raids on Inauguration Day. I thought they'd be in the schools, things like that." [04:16]

Walz candidly shares his feelings of letting people down and the internal struggle of reconciling his policies with voter expectations.

"I never lost an election before. So the thing for me that gives me the most angst to be candid, was letting people down." [13:38]

Cultural vs. Economic Issues in the Campaign

Remnick probes into the campaign’s focus on cultural issues, questioning whether defending democracy overshadowed more pressing economic concerns like housing, gas prices, and inflation. Walz concedes that while cultural issues are significant, failing to effectively communicate and prioritize economic policies alienated key voter demographics.

"You need to make the decision that what's going to impact your life the most is right in this room on these economic issues." [12:03]

He criticizes the campaign's approach to issues like transgender rights, suggesting that fear-based messaging was ineffective in motivating lasting behavioral change among voters.

Relationship with Kamala Harris and Future Political Aspirations

The dialogue touches upon Walz's partnership with Kamala Harris during the campaign. Despite the electoral outcome, Walz maintains a respectful and professional relationship, highlighting mutual support and personal admiration.

"Watching her around her family, you know, with Doug, with the girls, with her son, that inspired me the most because I loved that they had that our families, when we got time to spend together, was really, really fun." [32:25]

When asked about future political ambitions, Walz expresses openness to national roles but emphasizes his commitment to impact at the state level, citing the effectiveness and immediacy of gubernatorial influence compared to the prolonged path to national office.

"My job is make sure that I'm honoring the system where it is, where it sets in terms of." [29:58]

Views on Donald Trump and His Administration's Impact

A significant portion of the interview addresses Walz's perspective on Donald Trump’s presidency and his appointments. Walz criticizes Trump’s loyalty over competence, expressing concerns over appointments that undermine democratic institutions and promote authoritarian tendencies.

"Every one of those people in all of those positions are loyal to Donald Trump first." [28:56]

He specifically cites appointments like Pete Hag and Seth as troubling examples of policies that could erode democratic checks and balances.

Policy Failures and Economic Concerns

Walz elaborates on specific policy failures, such as Medicaid cuts and the mismanagement of federal funds, illustrating the tangible negative impacts on Minnesotan residents. He advocates for clear, actionable policies that directly address economic hardships faced by everyday citizens.

"If you're really concerned about the safety of women's sports, it's men sexually assaulting female athletes." [20:15]

Personal Reflections on Losing and Public Service

Throughout the conversation, Walz reflects on his journey in public service, underscoring a deep sense of responsibility and commitment to the welfare of his constituents. Despite the electoral setback, he remains resolute in his dedication to governing and addressing the state's challenges.

"I just want the best person who's there. I would support." [35:07]

Conclusion: Preparing for the Future and Democratic Resilience

In concluding the interview, Walz remains hopeful about the Democratic Party's future, expressing confidence in the depth of talent within the party's current leadership and the potential for new leaders to emerge stronger from the recent defeat.

"They will [qualified individuals to take over]." [32:22]

He emphasizes the necessity of maintaining strong state-level governance as a bulwark against federal overreach and continuing the fight for policies that benefit the most vulnerable populations.

"My job as governor is make sure that I'm honoring the system where it is, where it sets in terms of." [29:58]

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• "President Obama... there wasn't somebody on the scene. But what evolved out of that was, was the grassroots Tea Party movement." – Tim Walz [03:41]

• "I use this, David, that President Obama... It wasn't totally organic, I." – Tim Walz [03:52]

• "I thought there would be more massive immigration raids on Inauguration Day." – Tim Walz [04:16]

• "I'm a shadow government guy. I think we need a shadow Department of Transportation secretary." – Tim Walz [07:36]

• "The economic situation of men has changed in proportion to women." – Tim Walz [09:28]

• "If you were really concerned about the safety of women's sports, it's men sexually assaulting female athletes." – Tim Walz [20:15]

• "You need to teach it a different way." – Tim Walz [24:54]

• "I would argue that he’s building an authoritarian government." – Tim Walz [28:56]

• "Yelling at the governor of Maine... we are the law." – Tim Walz [28:56]

• "If you disagree, you go to court." – Tim Walz [29:31]

• "Donald Trump was viewed better than Kamala Harris on the economy." – Tim Walz [12:03]

Final Thoughts

Governor Tim Walz's candid reflections offer a comprehensive look into the challenges faced by Democrats in navigating both cultural and economic landscapes amidst a tumultuous political climate. His insights underscore the importance of effective communication, policy prioritization, and resilient leadership in shaping the future of both Minnesota and the broader national discourse.