‘People Are In for a Really Rude Shock’ on Trump’s Economy

Summary

Podcast Summary: “People Are In for a Really Rude Shock” on Trump’s Economy

Podcast Information

• Title: The Opinions
• Host/Author: The New York Times Opinion
• Description: One voice, one opinion, in 10 minutes or less.
• Episode: ‘People Are In for a Really Rude Shock’ on Trump’s Economy
• Release Date: November 12, 2024

---

Introduction

In this episode of The Opinions, hosted by The New York Times Opinion team, economist and columnist Paul Krugman delves into the potential economic ramifications of Donald Trump’s return to the White House. Released on November 12, 2024, the episode titled “People Are In for a Really Rude Shock” focuses on Trump's economic policies and their likely impact on the American economy and everyday citizens.

---

Trump’s Economic Policies and Their Impact

Paul Krugman provides a comprehensive analysis of the key economic strategies Trump is expected to implement, highlighting their inflationary nature and broader consequences.

1. Tax Cuts

   Krugman asserts that Trump’s promise of “massive tax cuts” is a cornerstone of his economic platform. However, he criticizes these cuts as “completely unfunded fantasies,” pointing out that Trump plans to offset the reduced tax revenue through tariffs and significant spending cuts, which are unlikely to materialize.

   • Notable Quote:
     • Trump: “They are massive tax cuts, biggest ever.” [00:51]

2. Tariffs

   Tariffs feature prominently in Trump’s agenda, which Krugman describes as a disguised sales tax on imports. He explains that despite Trump’s claims that tariffs will be paid by foreigners, the economic burden ultimately falls on American consumers through higher prices for goods.

   • Notable Quote:
     • Trump: “To me, the most beautiful word in the dictionary is tariff.” [02:08]

3. Immigration Crackdown

   A significant element of Trump’s economic policy is the aggressive crackdown on undocumented immigrants. Krugman warns that mass deportations could disrupt vital sectors such as agriculture and construction, leading to labor shortages and increased costs for producers, which would, in turn, raise prices for consumers.

   • Notable Quote:
     • Trump: “We will begin, and we have no choice. The largest deportation operation in American history.” [02:24]

4. Federal Reserve Pressure

   Krugman highlights Trump’s tendency to challenge the independence of the Federal Reserve. He anticipates that Trump will exert pressure to lower interest rates even in scenarios where economic indicators, such as rising inflation, would typically warrant higher rates. This interference could undermine monetary policy effectiveness and exacerbate inflationary pressures.

   • Notable Quote:
     • Trump: “I made a lot of money. I was very successful. And I think I have a better instinct than, in many cases, people that would be on the Federal Reserve or the chairman.” [03:29]

---

Analysis and Insights by Paul Krugman

Krugman articulates a grim outlook on the potential economic landscape under Trump’s leadership:

• Deficit Expansion: Trump’s tax cuts and increased spending are expected to balloon the federal deficit, a primary driver of inflationary pressures.

• Inflationary Policies: The combination of tax cuts, tariffs, and labor market disruptions is poised to create a highly inflationary environment, reminiscent of policies deemed historically inflationary.

• Workforce Disruptions: Deportations of undocumented immigrants could lead to labor shortages in critical industries, necessitating higher wages that would translate into increased consumer prices.

• Federal Reserve Autonomy: By pressuring the Fed to adopt accommodative monetary policies, Trump could hinder efforts to control inflation, leading to a self-reinforcing cycle of rising prices.

• Public Backlash: Krugman anticipates significant public dissatisfaction as inflation erodes purchasing power, leading to widespread “buyer's remorse” and potential political repercussions for Trump.

• Economic Accountability: Unlike the previous inflation surge under Biden, which Krugman attributes to pandemic disruptions and the war in Ukraine, the anticipated inflation under Trump would be directly tied to his policy choices, making accountability more pronounced.

---

Conclusions and Implications

Paul Krugman concludes that Trump’s economic policies are set to lead to substantial inflation, higher costs of living, and economic instability. He warns that these outcomes will likely result in a strong negative reaction from the voting public, potentially reshaping future political landscapes. Krugman emphasizes the danger of diminished checks and balances, particularly concerning the Federal Reserve’s independence, which is crucial for maintaining economic stability.

---

Key Takeaways for Listeners

• Anticipated Inflation: Expect significant rises in food prices and other essentials due to Trump’s policies.

• Policy Accountability: Unlike previous inflationary periods caused by external factors, the forthcoming inflation would be directly attributable to Trump’s domestic policies.

• Political Consequences: The economic fallout may lead to voter dissatisfaction and influence future elections.

---

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Trump on Tax Cuts:

  • “They are massive tax cuts, biggest ever.” [00:51]

• Trump on Tariffs:

  • “To me, the most beautiful word in the dictionary is tariff.” [02:08]

• Trump on Immigration:

  • “We will begin, and we have no choice. The largest deportation operation in American history.” [02:24]

• Trump on Federal Reserve:

  • “I made a lot of money. I was very successful. And I think I have a better instinct than, in many cases, people that would be on the Federal Reserve or the chairman.” [03:29]

• Krugman on Inflation Accountability:

  • “This time, if we have the inflation that I think is coming, it will be somebody's fault. It will be Trump's policies that do it.” [06:45]

---

Final Thoughts

Paul Krugman’s analysis in this episode serves as a cautionary perspective on the potential economic challenges posed by Donald Trump’s return to power. By dissecting Trump's proposed policies and forecasting their implications, Krugman provides listeners with a thorough understanding of the possible economic adversities ahead, emphasizing the importance of policy decisions in shaping the nation's financial health.

Transcript

[Instacart Advertiser]

With Instacart, you can get all your holiday essentials delivered in as fast as 30 minutes, whether it's the white elephant gift everyone will want to steal or the secret ingredient that makes great Grandma Jo's cookie recipe so great. Just download the Instacart app to find recipes, shop ingredients and whip out dishes so delicious your aunts and uncles will forget to ask about your love life. Enjoy free delivery on your first three orders. Service fees and terms apply.

[Podcast Host]

This is the Opinions, a show that brings you a mix of voices from New York Times opinion. You've heard the news. Here's what to make of it.

[Paul Krugman]

Hi, I'm Paul Krugman. I'm an opinion writer for the New York Times and an economist on the side. With Trump going back to the White House, as a citizen, I'm terrified. Very much so. This is a guy with authoritarian impulses, and it looks like very few guardrails. So God knows what America will look like in a couple of years. As an economist, there's a great irony here, which is that the biggest single factor in Trump's victory was the fact that there was a burst of inflation. It's in the rearview mirror now, but people are still annoyed at how much things cost. And yet Trump's economic program, as far as we can tell, is the most inflationary program probably that any American president has ever tried to implement. So people voted against what they're probably actually going to get. There are a few big reasons why Trump's plan looks seriously inflationary. One is he is going to explode the deficit. He's got all of these tax cut promises.

[Donald Trump]

They are massive tax cuts, biggest ever.

[Paul Krugman]

Completely unfunded fantasies about raising the money through tariffs or massive spending cuts, which are not going to happen. And when you have an economy that's already running pretty hot, deficits are inflationary. Second thing, tariffs.

[Donald Trump]

To me, the most beautiful word in the dictionary is tariff.

[Paul Krugman]

A tariff is a tax on imports. It's a sales tax. As much as Trump insists that foreigners will pay it, that's not how it works. Third thing is crackdown on undocumented immigrants.

[Donald Trump]

We will begin, and we have no choice. The largest deportation operation in American history.

[Paul Krugman]

Which will probably end up catching a lot of people who are legally here anyway. So that's an important part of our workforce, and particularly heavily in the agricultural sector, actually. Also the food processing center. So the food on your table is largely put there by immigrants, many of whom will end up being deported. What's going to happen is that farm owners are going to have to pay much, much higher wages to get people to do those jobs, which farmers will have to pass on in the form of higher prices. And then secondarily, people are upset about housing costs and rent. And the answer to that is build more houses. Who builds houses? And the answer is a large part of the construction force is foreign born, too. So those are the two places where you're really going to see a major impact. If Trump actually goes through with his plans to round up undocumented immigrants. And finally, there's what he wants to do with the Federal Reserve.

[Donald Trump]

I made a lot of money. I was very successful. And I think I have a better instinct than, in many cases, people that would be on the Federal Reserve or the chairman.

[Paul Krugman]

We have an independent, quasi, independent agency that sets interest rates, that controls monetary policy. That's not in the Constitution. It's not even something that we always had in the United States. But that's the solution that most advanced countries have come around to as the best way of achieving stability. And most US Presidents in the modern era have been extremely cautious about respecting the independence of the Fed. We've decided to outsource this piece of policy to technocrats. Trump, even during his first term, broke with that tradition. He lectured the Fed, saying, I want you to cut rates. Even said, I want rates to go negative. It didn't have much effect first time around. But if we have the situation that I believe we're going to have, where inflation has taken off because of Trump's policies, and the Federal Reserve, following its normal procedure, wants to start hiking interest rates to put a lid on that inflation, very, very likely that Trump will go through the roof. He'll say, how dare you? I have found this guy who tells me you should be cutting interest rates instead of raising him. And again, the Fed's independence is not set in stone. So I would consider it very likely that the Fed will not react as it normally would to put a lid on the inflation that tariffs and deportations are causing. If there's one thing that we've learned from watching Trump, it's that he dismisses facts he doesn't like. He tells us that we have rampant crime, when in fact, murder is plunging. He says that all the jobs are going to immigrants, which is not true. And so I have very little reason to believe that Trump will acknowledge that his policies are actually producing inflation. Much more likely that he'll start putting pressure on government statistical agencies to report better numbers. That is what autocratic regimes have done around the world in the past. So it's quite unlikely that he will actually reverse course either on the tariffs or on the deportations. What should listeners take from this? First of all, I would say you should probably be aware that some things, especially I think food is about to get substantially more expensive. It's funny because the big run up in prices that we had under Biden was actually nobody's fault. It was consequences of the pandemic disruption and to a limited extent, the war in Ukraine. And it happened everywhere. There's almost an eerie similarity in the track of inflation across major economies. This time, if we have the inflation that I think is coming, it will be somebody's fault. It will be Trump's policies that do it. There will be a lot of buyer's remorse, a big backlash from the voting public. Now, how that actually translates and what the next election looks like is a whole other question. But I do think that people are in for a really rude shock and they will be very upset.

[Podcast Host]

If you like this show, follow it on Spotify, Apple or wherever you get your podcasts. This show is produced by Derek Arthur, Sophia Alvarez Boyd, Vishaka Durba, Phoebe Lett, Christina Samulewski and Jillian Weinberger. It's edited by Kari Pitkin, Alison Brusek and Annie Rose Strasser. Engineering, mixing and original music by Isaac Jones, sonia Herrero, Pat McCusker, Carol Sabaro and Afim Shapiro. Additional music by Amin Sohota. The Fact Check team is Kate Sinclair, Mary Marge Locker and Michelle Harris. Audience strategy by Shannon Busta, Christina Samulewski and Adrian Rivera. The executive producer of Times Opinion Audio is Annie Rose, Dresser.