The Pat McAfee Show 2.0 – Ep. 1433 FIRST 15: NFL Week 7 Recap

Date: October 20, 2025
Host: Pat McAfee
Guests/Panel: AJ Hawk, Toxic Table, Tone Digs, Darius Butler, others
Theme: First 15 Minutes Deep Dive – The Five Biggest NFL Headlines from Week 7

Episode Overview

Pat McAfee and the crew break down the top storylines from Sunday’s Week 7 NFL action—the games, players, and moments that defined the week. "First 15" is their attempt to hit key topics in a fast-paced segment but, as always, they enthusiastically dive deep and riff far beyond the time limit. The group blends stats, insider insights, wild banter, and passionate fan takes, providing a unique, energetic recap for hardcore and casual fans alike.

Main Discussion Points and Insights

1. Broncos’ Historic Comeback vs. Giants (00:59–09:35)

Recap and Major Moments:

• Denver, honoring Demaryius Thomas (“DT Day”), falls behind the Giants 19-0 into the 4th quarter, eventually trailing by 18 with just six minutes left.
• Bo Nix engineers an unprecedented comeback, leading the Broncos to a 33-point fourth quarter (NFL record), capped by a last-second field goal from Will Lutz.
• Bo Nix: first quarterback with 2 passing & 2 rushing TDs in a quarter, breaking win probability models.
• Emotional significance with DT’s statue unveiling. Football “gods” seemingly intervened with stunning plays.

Memorable Quotes:

• "Bo does not bow down. He answers. Bo on the move. Thibodeau. No edge, no chance. Bo Nix touchdown in Denver. And all of a sudden…we got a real game." – Pat McAfee (02:25)
• "33 points is the most in the fourth quarter by any team shut out in the first three quarters in NFL history." – Pat McAfee (06:59)
• "You just fight until the absolute end. ... This is football, man. You stick beside your guys." – Darius Butler (05:53)

Stats and Context:

• Teams were 1-3,677 trailing by 18+ inside 6 minutes since 1970; just the 2nd team to win (Indy over Tampa Bay, 2003).
• Win probability peaked at 99.8% for Giants before collapse.

Discussion:

• Panel praises Bo Nix/Sean Payton relationship, likening Nix to Drew Brees; predicts the win as a potential season turning point.
• Discussion of Giants’ positives—rookie QB Jackson Dart promising, but late pick & two missed XPs crucial.

2. The MVP Race is Wide Open (09:49–14:43, 20:38–24:21)

Who’s in the Mix:

• Drake Maye (Patriots Rookie): Breaking Tom Brady franchise marks, called “the best in the business” (10:22), historic dual-threat stats.
• Dak Prescott (Cowboys): 81.4 QBR (7th best ever through 7 weeks), dominance over Commanders—“22 TD, zero INT against them.” (12:27)
• Christian McCaffrey (49ers): Over 200 total yards, 62% of team scrimmage in primetime win, back to MVP form after preseason health questions.
• Danny Dimes (Colts): Huge offensive explosion; see Colts section for details.
• Matthew Stafford (Rams): “Still doing that Matthew Stafford shit” in London.
• Patrick Mahomes: “Greatest at football again”—Chiefs reverting to old offense, Mahomes “putting team on his back.”

Memorable Quotes:

• “This MVP feels more wide open than it has been in years past.” – Pat McAfee (09:53)
• “He’s also basically the greatest dual-threat quarterback in the history of the NFL. ...Stats are telling us…it’s absurd.” – Panelist on Drake Maye (10:22)
• “When Dak Prescott’s there, he’s going to beat their ass.” – Pat McAfee (12:25)
• “CMC, chance he wins another one.” – Darius Butler (14:12)

Key Insight:

• Race is unpredictable this year, with surprise teams and breakout stars (especially young QBs). Many historic/comparative stats, but eye test matters too.

3. Colts Offense Juggernaut – Changing the AFC Landscape (16:30–20:38)

Recap:

• Colts steamroll Chargers, offense compared to greatest in history: “Most points per drive in a season: Colts 3.5, Patriots 2007 3.2.” (19:37)
• Two MVP-caliber leaders: Danny Dimes (Daniel Jones) thriving under pressure, Jonathan Taylor a “dominant force” in run game.
• Colts punt on just 19% of drives—lowest ever—do not punt for “like three weeks” straight.
• Panel praises Shane Steichen’s coaching, offensive line dominance, and team’s fun, unselfish energy.

Quotes:

• "Danny Dimes could be in the MVP conversation. Jonathan Taylor’s going to score three touchdowns a game." – Pat McAfee (17:18)
• "He has a chance to be the very best [Colts RB] when it’s all said and done." – Darius Butler (18:42)
• “It’s fun to watch…they are a mature bunch that hasn’t really been on a stage that much.” – Pat McAfee (18:01)

Insight:

• Colts not getting media respect, but all underlying metrics point to real Super Bowl potential; panel bullish on their upside.

4. AFC and NFC Power Shifts – Rams, Chiefs, and Others (20:38–28:11)

Los Angeles Rams:

• Rams dominate the Jaguars in rainy London, Matt Stafford throws five TDs (without Puka), and Devante Adams erupts.
  • “They look fresher than any team I’ve seen go play international.” – Pat McAfee (24:57)
  • “This was without Puka, who was a top two, top three wide receiver.” – Darius Butler (25:49)
• Defense under Chris Shula is “dominant,” creative, and physical.

Chiefs and Patrick Mahomes:

• Mahomes back to “Showtime” form as Chiefs throttle Raiders; multiple new weapons (Rashee Rice, Worthy, Kelce) emerging.
  • “Patrick Mahomes is the greatest at football again.” – Pat McAfee (22:00)
  • “It’s not a great moment for any teams in the AFC…when this team of red is humming.” – Darius Butler (28:11)
• Trick play moment: Mahomes sells a 4th down fake so well, he “fooled the hell out of Tony Romo.” (29:17)
• Chiefs’ AFC West is suddenly “tough,” hinting at competitive playoff race.

5. QB Carousel and Injury Reports with Adam Schefter (34:05–41:55)

Benchings and Quarterback Questions:

• Tua (Dolphins): “He’ll be the guy…He’s thrown a lot of interceptions…They’ve played bad football. I’m not expecting any changes this week.” – Adam Schefter (36:48)
• Geno Smith (Raiders): On bye. Team in disarray; "ran 30 total plays," lowest since 2002.
• Justin Fields: Uncertain starting status for upcoming week; “wouldn’t surprise me if they go to Rod Taylor.”
• Kyler Murray (Cardinals): Set to return Monday Night Football, Week 9 vs Cowboys. “He’s not going to miss a game in Jerry’s world." – Adam Schefter (41:55)
• Carson Wentz (Vikings): Set to start Thursday. JJ McCarthy likely back after, depending on results.
  • “We are in full Carson Wentz experience time right now with the Vikings.” – Pat McAfee (42:12–44:12; segment is a comedic highlight reel.)

Notable Injuries:

• Bryce Young: Out next week (ankle); Andy Dalton to start. (39:07)
• Jaden Daniels: Hamstring, expected to miss time as schedule gets tough for Commanders.

6. Additional Notable Segments & Quotes

Colts Defensive Vibes (31:41–33:20):

• “You’re just seeing sound fundamental football in all three phases. ... The vibes are immaculate right now of the Colts.” – Darius Butler (32:27)

Closing Thoughts on Surging Colts/Chiefs:

• “We’d like to play the Chiefs right now…We would not be scared of the smoke.” – Pat McAfee (34:56)

Carson Wentz Experience:

• “It literally could be the greatest play or it could be the worst play at any given moment…Amazon needs to be thanking their lucky stars that Carson Wentz is playing prime time.” – Pat McAfee (⚡ Segment: 42:12–44:12 ⚡)

Timestamps of Key Segments

• 00:59–09:35: Broncos-Giants comeback/collapse
• 09:49–14:43: MVP Race overview (Maye, Dak, CMC)
• 16:30–20:38: Colts offensive dominance
• 20:38–24:21: Rams light up London/Jaguars struggle
• 22:00–28:11: Chiefs resurgence/Mahomes magic
• 34:05–41:55: Schefter on QBs (Tua, Geno, Wentz, Kyler, injuries)
• 42:12–44:12: Carson Wentz Experience breakdown (comedic highlight)

Notable (and Fun) Soundbites

• "It’s not like gimmicky shit…you’re just seeing sound, fundamental football in all three phases." – Darius Butler (32:27)
• "We are who we are…Yam what we Yam." – Pat McAfee (00:57)
• “He fooled what Tony Romo…played with 15 years in the league. He fooled the hell out of Tony.” – Darius Butler on Mahomes fake (29:17)
• “They need to have a human wrestle a bear at halftime.” – Pat, musing about Thursday Night Football (44:12)

Takeaways for Listeners

• This episode is full of energy, rapid banter, and strong football knowledge—offering both strategic insights and laugh-out-loud moments.
• The Broncos’ historic comeback is contextualized as one of the greatest in NFL history, emblematic of a wild year for the league.
• The MVP conversation is as open as ever, with underdog teams and QBs front and center.
• The Colts and Chiefs are surging; Rams are sneaky contenders; quarterback play (and chaos) dominates headlines and future storylines.
• Injury and benching updates via Adam Schefter round out the actionable, up-to-date NFL landscape.

For fans who missed the episode:
You’ll want to experience the whirlwind highs and lows—from celebration of record-breaking performances to hilarious anecdotes about uniforms, sideline props, and Carson Wentz–with all the genuine camaraderie and tongue-in-cheek bravado that fuels The Pat McAfee Show.