The Pat McAfee Show 2.0: Overreaction Monday – NFL Week 7 Recap & MNF Preview

Episode: PMS 2.0 #1433
Date: October 20, 2025
Host: Pat McAfee, with AJ Hawk, Toxic Table (Boston Connor, Ty Schmidt), Tone Digs, Darius Butler
Guests: Adam Schefter, Dan Orlovsky

Episode Overview

This "Overreaction Monday" episode brings a high-energy recap and analysis of NFL Week 7 and previews a Monday Night Football double-header. Pat McAfee and crew deliver their signature mix of insider perspective, humor, relatability, and wild overreactions, joined by Adam Schefter and Dan Orlovsky for key NFL insider updates and preview discussions.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Setting the Stage: Week 7 Recap & MNF Preview

• The show kicks off with a rundown of the past weekend's action and a look ahead to the unique MNF double-header: Texans vs. Seahawks and Buccaneers vs. Lions.
• The panel covers injuries, trends, and betting outcomes, with Pat and the Toxic Table offering shoutouts to fans of the Packers and Patriots.

2. NFL Headlines & Overreactions

Public Betting Finally Wins

• For the first time in a long time, public bettors (teams with 60%+ of bets) beat the books, going 5-4.
• Discussion of how fans and analysts seem to be getting smarter about teams as identity solidifies midseason.

"We're starting to see it, aren't we? That's because we have incredible people on television and on the Internet..."
— Pat McAfee (03:45)

Who Stinks?

• Miami Dolphins and others receive the dreaded “who stinks” verdict after ugly losses—"It stinks down there for the Dolphins. Wow. Bad weather. We should have known."
• Raiders and other consistent underperformers pile up grievances.

3. Game of the Week: Mile High Magic in Denver (06:00-14:40)

Historic Broncos Comeback

• Denver Broncos mount a record-breaking 33-point fourth quarter to come back and defeat the New York Giants, 33–32, on Demaryius Thomas Day.
• Numerous wild stats: Only the second time since 1970 a team overcame an 18+ point deficit in the final six minutes.

"First quarterback ever to have two rushing and two passing touchdowns in the same quarter."
— Darius Butler (11:01)

• Vivid play-by-play breakdown, heavy symbolism (33 points, 33 seconds, #33 for DT), and a focus on mental toughness.
• Credit to both QBs—Bo Nix for grit and Jackson Dart for showing future promise, despite a critical late interception.

"This is football, man. You stick beside your guys. You keep fighting. An unbelievable win for the Broncos."
— Darius Butler (11:01)

4. Wide Open MVP Race & Star Performances (14:57-19:51)

MVP Candidates Emerge

• Several standout performances highlighted:
  • Drake Maye (Patriots): Breaking franchise records, dual-threat efficiency, comparisons to Lamar Jackson and Tom Brady.
  • Dak Prescott (Cowboys): 7–0 vs the Commanders, 22 TD, 0 INT in series; leadership praised.
  • Christian McCaffrey (49ers): 62% of team yards, utility as both rusher and receiver, with growing MVP talk.
  • Daniel Jones (Colts): 4–1 record, possibly saving coaches’ jobs and franchise trajectory.

"Feels like this MVP is more wide open than it's been in years past..."
— Pat McAfee (15:02)

Dallas Cowboys Offense

• Praised for adaptability and finding success even with key receivers out.

"You can tell when a quarterback is just in a flow..."
— Darius Butler (17:56)

5. Colts Offense & "Wagon" Status (22:27-25:45)

Colts Offensive Juggernaut

• Colts dominate Chargers in “horrible uniforms,” led by Daniel Jones and Jonathan Taylor.
• Statistical comparisons: Most points per drive, highest drive score rate—better than ‘07 Patriots and ‘18 Chiefs.
• Progress on both sides of the ball noted, but outside respect still lacking.

"When you talk about branding, when you talk about performance-wise, the Colts are it... The only thing that's bad is people aren't going to want to show these highlights because these damn Chargers uniforms are all over them."
— Pat McAfee (22:27)

6. Rams Roll in London & International Game Strategy (26:41-31:39)

Rams Thrash Jaguars in London

• Discuss late travel strategies (Rams flew in Saturday) and team adaptability.
• Stellar showings from Stafford, Devonte Adams, and without top receiver Puka Nacua.

"They just showed up and absolutely dominated."
— Darius Butler (26:51)

Jaguars Concerns

• Panel debates whether Jaguars’ stumbles are meaningful or just a blip.

7. Are the Chiefs Unstoppable Again? (31:39-34:51)

Offense is Back to "Showtime"

• Chiefs offense looks dynamic and aggressive, reminiscent of pre-2023 seasons:

"Patrick Mahomes is the greatest at football again."
— Pat McAfee (29:29)

Defensive Stands Out

• Chiefs D racking up shutouts and solid performances—danger sign for rest of AFC.

Playcalling Brilliance

• Mahomes’ fake spike lauded, Andy Reid and Spagnuolo praised for creativity.

8. The Colts Are for Real – All Three Phases (35:56-38:29)

• Colts’ chemistry, culture, and new defensive strategies are lauded—now seen as true contenders.

"When you see those type of vibes, like, that's the type of... that just comes through the screen."
— Darius Butler (38:05)

• “We're only learning more about ourselves” as the season progresses.

9. Insider Segments with Adam Schefter (39:13-56:59)

Colts Offense and MVP Watch (39:13–40:05)

• Schefter touts Daniel Jones’s efficiency, crediting minimal third downs, dominance from new QB and TE additions.

Quarterback Carousel & Injury Updates (41:27-47:16)

• Updates on:
  • Bryce Young & Jaden Daniels Out with injuries; expected recovery details.
  • Tua, Geno, Fields: Stability, performance woes, and upcoming benchings.

Trade Deadline Rumors (49:51-53:41)

• Max Crosby, Trey Hendrickson, and others discussed as possible trade bait.

"I never rule out anything in this league. Anything's always possible. We'll see how it shakes out. But to me, I think he's staying in Vegas."
— Adam Schefter (50:20)

Instant Replay, New York Control Controversy (53:47-55:54)

• Concerns over NFL HQ interference with on-field calls, uneven application stoking fan frustration.

MNF Injury Reports (56:00-56:59)

• Major hits to Detroit’s secondary, key Bucs WR statuses, and projected Seattle DB absences.

10. Previewing MNF Doubleheader (58:06-61:53)

Lions vs Buccaneers

• Detroit faces daunting injuries in the secondary; Baker Mayfield is “slinging the pill.”

Texans vs Seahawks

• Two under-the-radar teams with upward mobility; eyes on C.J. Stroud and upstart Houston.

11. College Football Chaos (64:31-84:33)

• Wild year for top-10 upsets, Penn State and Florida job searches, coach movement speculation.
• Vivid breakdowns of trends, upsets, and coaching carousel candidates.

"When you score and when you win big games, that is a recipe to be wanted by a lot of schools..."
— Pat McAfee (65:55)

12. Dan Orlovsky Joins – MNF Analysis (98:48-122:35)

Seattle’s Defense is “Off the Charts” (100:49–102:47)

“I think they got the defensive player of the year right now in Leonard Williams... This is a defense right now that’s just absolutely off the charts.”
— Dan Orlovsky (100:54)

Texans’ Offense Must Protect CJ Stroud (102:59)

• Key: Early down success is critical vs Seattle’s tough D.

San Francisco 49ers: Mac Jones & Brock Purdy Debate (106:44)

• Dan breaks down how the Niners’ offensive design, fullback role, and McCaffrey have added new dimensions.

Chiefs’ Offensive Trust Reestablished (108:56–110:21)

“Conviction and trust, and those are two words that Patrick and Andy Reid and Matt Nagy just did not have a lot of last year—rightfully so... All of a sudden, they’re back to some of the motion stuff... trusting conviction from everybody in that offense.”
— Dan Orlovsky (108:56)

Eagles Find Their Formula (111:00–114:01)

• Jalen Hurts’ growth and playcalling evolution with under-center concepts, play-action, and situational mastery.

13. Around the NFL: Overreaction Monday Calls (129:41-169:44)

Notable Fan Overreactions

• Dolphins Fans: Jover! Era is over—time for a clean sweep.
• Giants Fans: "Invent a new way to lose..." but hope for rookie QB Jackson Dart persists.
• Colts Fans: Team has gone from dumpster fire to contender—dreams of adding Max Crosby heat up.
• Cowboys Fans: Best “offensive trio in league” talk for Dak, Pickens, and Ferguson.
• Chiefs Fans: The dynasty is alive and well; Mahomes is immortal, ignore the PFF grades.
• Commanders Fans: The “cardiac” commanders have flatlined as injuries strike.

14. Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• [03:45] “We're starting to see it, aren't we? That's because we have incredible people on television and on the Internet..." — Pat McAfee
• [11:01] "First quarterback ever to have two rushing and two passing touchdowns in the same quarter." — Darius Butler
• [17:33] "He is cowboy LBJ going into Washington doing his thing." — Pat McAfee (on Dak Prescott)
• [26:51] "They just showed up and absolutely dominated." — Darius Butler (on the Rams in London)
• [50:20] "I never rule out anything in this league. But to me, I think he's staying in Vegas." — Adam Schefter (on Max Crosby rumors)
• [108:56] "Conviction and trust... All of a sudden, they’re back to some of the motion stuff... trusting conviction from everybody in that offense." — Dan Orlovsky (Chiefs offense)
• [100:54] "I think they got the defensive player of the year right now in Leonard Williams..." — Dan Orlovsky (Seattle D)
• [162:29] "What a pickup. The title. A whole new world. We're best team in the NFL. That's so much fun to be here right now." — Pat McAfee (on Colts’ outlook)

Important Timestamps

• [06:00-14:40]: Broncos historic comeback vs Giants – detailed, animated breakdown
• [14:57-19:51]: MVP race, individual QB/skill player analysis
• [22:27-25:45]: Colts offensive output, team identity discussion
• [31:39-34:51]: Chiefs' return to dominance, creative playcalling
• [39:13-56:59]: Adam Schefter’s insider updates, trade rumors, injuries
• [100:49-104:25]: Dan Orlovsky on upcoming MNF, Seattle defense praise
• [108:56-110:21]: Chiefs' offense revitalization
• [114:01-114:36]: Eagles offensive development, Hurts’ growth
• [129:41-169:44]: "I don't want to overreact but..." fan overreactions—funniest calls and reactions
• [170:05]: Announcement of upcoming Rushmore special, birthday fun

Tone, Style & Takeaways

The show retains its rambunctious, irreverent, and highly conversational style. Pat and his crew’s chemistry, laced with humor and ex-athlete authenticity, invites listeners into their world for both serious breakdowns and lighthearted asides. The episode strikes a balance: overreactions fuel the fun, but legitimately sharp analysis emerges on every major NFL storyline.

If you missed NFL Week 7 or want more depth on the narratives and characters driving this season, this episode delivers—mixing headline news, in-depth game analysis, candid player evaluations, league rumors, and a healthy dose of viral overreaction energy.

Summary compiled by ChatGPT, based on a full transcript of The Pat McAfee Show, October 20, 2025 (Episode 1433).