Nik Bhatia on Bitcoin is a Response to Central Banks - WBD161

Summary

Nik Bhatia on Bitcoin as a Response to Central Banks – A Comprehensive Summary

In Episode WBD161 of "The Peter McCormack Show," host Peter McCormack engages in a deep and insightful conversation with Nick Bhatia, a respected figure in the Bitcoin community. Recorded in Los Angeles and released on October 25, 2019, this episode delves into Bitcoin’s role as a countermeasure to centralized banking systems and its potential evolution into a global reserve currency. Below is a detailed summary capturing the essence of their discussion.

---

1. Introduction and Background

The episode begins with Peter McCormack introducing Nick Bhatia and highlighting his contributions to understanding Bitcoin and the banking system. Bhatia shares his enthusiasm for Bitcoin, mentioning his recent participation in events like the Human Rights Foundation Freedom Forum and his involvement with Defiance, another show focused on broader societal issues intertwined with Bitcoin.

---

2. Bitcoin as a Response to Central Banks

Central Banks’ Monopolistic Money Creation

At [05:13], Bhatia articulates Bitcoin as a direct response to the "centralized and monopolistic money creation power" wielded by central banks. He references the message embedded in Bitcoin’s Genesis block: “the chancellor on the brink of second bailout,” emphasizing that Bitcoin was conceived as a remedy to the failing, bailout-dependent financial system.

Bitcoin as Digital Gold and Reserve Currency

Bhatia envisions Bitcoin alongside gold and US Treasuries as part of a "triumvirate of liquidity" ([14:22]). He posits that Bitcoin has the potential to become a global reserve asset comparable to gold and US Treasuries, which are currently viewed as risk-free assets essential for the world's financial stability.

---

3. The Banking System and Fractional Reserve

Understanding Fractional Reserve Banking

At [06:44], Bhatia delves into the mechanics of fractional reserve banking, describing it as a form of leverage where banks borrow to fund the assets on their balance sheets. He explains that this system inherently creates systemic risk, as banks do not hold sufficient cash to cover all their liabilities.

The Repo Market Explained

Bhatia provides a detailed explanation of the repo market at [36:44], likening it to a "pawn shop for bonds." He explains that primary dealers, the few banks with agreements to handle US Treasury securities, rely on the repo market to finance their bond holdings. The recent turbulence in the repo market has exposed vulnerabilities similar to those that led to the 2008 financial crisis.

Impact of Fractional Reserve on Financial Stability

Bhatia highlights how high leverage ratios (e.g., 30:1 or 50:1) in banks make them susceptible to insolvency if asset values decline ([40:16]). He underscores the precariousness of the current banking system, where any significant downturn can trigger widespread financial panic and potential societal collapse.

---

4. Bitcoin’s Role in the Global Economy

Global vs. US Adoption Patterns

At [58:24], Bhatia differentiates between Bitcoin adoption in the United States and globally. While Americans may adopt Bitcoin for long-term savings and as a hedge against systemic risks, individuals in countries like Venezuela and Iran use Bitcoin as a necessary transactional tool to bypass oppressive monetary policies and sanctions.

Democratizing Financial Access

Bhatia emphasizes Bitcoin’s ability to democratize financial access, allowing anyone with internet connectivity to participate in the global financial system without minimum investment thresholds ([51:35]). This inclusivity positions Bitcoin as a tool for financial sovereignty, especially in regions where traditional banking services are unreliable or inaccessible.

---

5. Bitcoin's Future and Volatility

Volatility as Part of Growth

Discussing Bitcoin’s volatility at [17:00], Bhatia argues that extreme price fluctuations are an inevitable part of Bitcoin’s journey toward becoming a multi-trillion-dollar asset. He explains that as Bitcoin’s market capitalization grows, its volatility is likely to persist, reflecting the speculative and adoption-driven nature of its price movements.

Adoption Waves and Sustainable Growth

Bhatia introduces the concept of "adoption waves" at [19:09], where speculative price spikes attract new participants, followed by periods of consolidation. He views these cycles as essential for fostering steady and sustainable Bitcoin adoption, ensuring that growth is manageable and supported by genuine user engagement rather than purely speculative interest.

Institutional Adoption

At [23:55], Bhatia highlights increasing institutional interest in Bitcoin, noting significant inflows into Grayscale’s Bitcoin Trust (GBTC) and the gradual integration of Bitcoin into hedge fund portfolios. He underscores that many global macro hedge funds are beginning to allocate portions of their portfolios to Bitcoin to harness its potential for outsized returns ([23:55]).

---

6. Lightning Network and Bitcoin Usability

Enhancing Bitcoin’s Practicality

Bhatia stresses the importance of the Lightning Network in making Bitcoin more usable for everyday transactions ([60:35]). By enabling instant settlements and supporting microtransactions, the Lightning Network addresses Bitcoin’s scalability and speed limitations, making it viable for a broader range of use cases.

Opennode’s Role in Adoption

Through Opennode, a Bitcoin payment processor, Bhatia explains how they facilitate merchant acceptance of Bitcoin via the Lightning Network. This infrastructure is crucial for integrating Bitcoin into online businesses, allowing merchants to handle instant and low-cost transactions, which is essential for global adoption and practical usage.

---

7. Personal Insights and Analogies

Time Preference and Personal Conviction

Bhatia shares personal anecdotes about his journey to understanding Bitcoin’s significance ([20:46]). His experiences during the 2008 financial crisis and his deep dive into fractional reserve banking reinforced his belief in Bitcoin as a superior form of money based on scarce, verifiable quantities rather than arbitrary paper-based systems.

Behavioral Changes Inspired by Bitcoin

Peter McCormack relates his own experience with time preference, comparing it to his efforts to quit smoking, demonstrating how Bitcoin’s fixed supply mentality encourages behavioral changes towards saving and long-term thinking ([53:48]).

---

8. Human Rights and Geopolitics

Bitcoin’s Role in Empowering Individuals

In the context of the Hong Kong protests ([64:44]), Bhatia discusses how Bitcoin can empower individuals in oppressive regimes by providing financial sovereignty and secure means of conducting transactions outside governmental control. He advocates for Bitcoin as a tool that supports human rights and freedom of speech, especially in regions facing geopolitical tensions.

Supporting Global Human Rights

Bhatia emphasizes the importance of supporting human rights initiatives and recognizing Bitcoin’s potential to aid those fighting for freedom. He encourages listeners to stay informed and support movements that align with the principles of financial freedom and autonomy ([66:21]).

---

9. Conclusion and Final Thoughts

Nick Bhatia concludes by reaffirming Bitcoin’s pivotal role in reshaping the global financial landscape. He invites listeners to explore his writings, such as "Time Value of Bitcoin," and follow his work on platforms like Medium ([66:30]). Bhatia expresses gratitude for the opportunity to discuss Bitcoin’s intersection with economic systems and human rights, emphasizing the ongoing journey towards a decentralized and equitable financial future.

Final Notable Quotes:

• “[05:13] Nick Bhatia: ...Bitcoin is the direct response to that.”
• “[14:22] Nick Bhatia: ...Bitcoin, gold and US Treasuries will be in the same conversation as a triumvirate of liquidity...”
• “[36:44] Nick Bhatia: ...the repo market is basically a pawn shop for bonds.”
• “[51:35] Nick Bhatia: ...Bitcoin you can save at the most micro level of anything.”
• “[17:00] Nick Bhatia: ...we will continue to see extreme volatility from Bitcoin for the next 20 years as it starts to approach a multi-trillion-dollar market capitalization...”
• “[60:35] Nick Bhatia: ...Lightning Network allows you to use Bitcoin online instantly.”

---

Final Thoughts

This episode provides a thorough exploration of Bitcoin’s potential to disrupt traditional banking systems, its role in global financial stability, and its capacity to empower individuals worldwide. Nick Bhatia’s insights offer a compelling vision of Bitcoin not just as an investment, but as a fundamental tool for financial freedom and systemic reform.

For those interested in diving deeper into these topics, Nick Bhatia’s writings on Medium (@timevalueofbtc) and his work with Opennode and Tantra Labs are highly recommended.

Transcript

[Peter McCormack]

Welcome to the what Bitcoin did podcast.

[Nick Bhatia]

Hello there from New York. How are you all? I was at the Human Rights Foundation Freedom Forum yesterday.

[Peter McCormack]

It was amazing.

[Nick Bhatia]

Really cool to catch up with some old friends and make some new friends. I also had the chance to discuss Bitcoin with a bunch of human rights activists which was great. And I also recorded three interviews for my other show, Defiance, which was very cool. Anyway, welcome to the what Bitcoin did podcast which is brought to you by the mighty Kraken. The best place to buy and sell Bitcoin. I'm your host Peter McCormack and today I've got an interview with Nick Bhatia which was recorded in LA a few days ago, discussing why bitcoin is a response to central banks. But before that, you know I have a message from my sponsors. Don't skip, make sure you check them out.

[Peter McCormack]

It's because of these sponsors I get.

[Nick Bhatia]

To make the shows. First off, have you checked out Wire yet? My good friend Michael Dunworth's business? You know what, their name keeps coming up at the moment. Three times in the last week I've been talking to companies who are working with Wyre Deal. Do you know them? Have you checked them out? It doesn't matter whether you are a solo developer or a large team. If you are looking to simplify user onboarding and offer your users an easy, fast way to purchase bitcoin, then you have to talk to Wyre. Since 2013, Wyre has focused on taking care of the heavy lifting in terms of compliance, payments and liquidity so you can focus on building your core offering. If you have an idea for the next killer app, do not let the regulators kill it. Find out more by heading over to Wyre and creating a developer account or getting in touch with the team at sendwire.com, which is s-e N-W-Y-R e.com that is sendwyre.com, which is s-E n- dash W-Y-R e.com and also today's show is brought to you by my friends. Drop it. They've been sponsoring the show for six months now. Got a really solid relationship, doing lots of work to help onboard people to their app. I know lots of people have been messaging me because they want me to send them sats, get them on boarded for lightning. Look, I'm doing the best I can. I'm doing as many as I can. I think I've done around 4 million SATs now. I've got about another 6 million to go. And look, it takes a bit of time. Like each one, I have to do the separate send, I have to get the Twitter account. So just bear with me. I will get as many on you as bored as I possible. And if you haven't checked it out yet, you do really need to go and check out Drop bit. It is the most badass wallet out there for bitcoin. I think they've absolutely nailed the lightning integration. It's the best I've seen. I love it. Add to that that you can tweet and text people. Bitcoin Drop, it really is the coolest mobile wallet for bitcoin out there. So make sure you go and check it out. It's available for the iPhone and Android. Just head over to Dropbit app, which is Drop Bit app. That is Dropbit app, which is Drop bit app. Okay, so onto the show today with Nick Bhatia and this is great. This turned out exactly how I thought it would with Nick. I've wanted to do the show for a while. We tried to get one together when I did my Lightning series, but we couldn't make it happen. But when I saw him at Crypto Springs, we discussed the idea for a show. I was coming out to la. So, yeah, we hooked it up. I visited Open Node and we got this recorded. So it was very, very cool. I was very glad to do this. I'm a massive fan of Nick's work. His medium posts have been very useful for me in understanding concepts about lightning and he does some really good research. So sitting down with Nick, I was like, come on, man, you gotta explain to me the banking system, I don't really understand how it works. And he did, he did something really cool for me. He made me understand one of the problems with fractional reserve lending and that I never consider it as banks leveraging itself. It just hadn't crossed my mind in that way. But that cleared up a lot for me. It was also very cool to hear how he thinks of bitcoin as the perfect response to centralize a monopolistic financial system and also his take on the global economy. It's a fascinating conversation and it does just highlight how convoluted and complex the banking system actually is. So nice one, Nick. Thank you, mate. Thanks for coming on. You know, if you've got any questions about the show, you can reach out to me. My email address is. Hello@what? Bitcoindid.com Also, it's been another great trip. I love coming out here to the States. It's been cool to get Defiance live. I'm loving the feedback. Thank you so much. It means so much to me. I am heading back home to Bedford tomorrow. Can't wait to get back, see my kids. I'm going to be taking a few days off. I'm going to be heading to Ireland. It's my birthday coming up. It's my birthday on Halloween, so I'm going to be out celebrating that with my family. But I will then be back next month. I think I'm going to be back for a few days, hopefully here in Boston, perhaps Austin. I think San Fran, la. Then I might be heading to Hawaii, then New Zealand and then after that there's a small chance I'll be going to Africa. Never been before. Another manic, crazy trip with loads of flights, but doing all I can to get the best shows out for you, for what bitcoin did in Defiance. So listen, you got any questions, do hit me up. I look forward to hearing from you. And yeah, have a great weekend.

[Peter McCormack]

Right. Hi, Nick, how are you?

[Nick Bhatia]

I'm doing great, Peter.

[Peter McCormack]

We finally get to do this. We talked about it a while ago, couldn't make it work, but here we are.

[Nick Bhatia]

Great to have you in la.

[Peter McCormack]

Yeah, man, I love it out here. I absolutely love out here.

[Nick Bhatia]

I went to see Elton John last.

[Peter McCormack]

Night, which was very cool. Sun shining, everyone treats me nicely.

[Nick Bhatia]

Excellent.

[Peter McCormack]

So I think we're in very weird fucking times right now. Very weird times politically in terms of how people are thinking about money, about how the world is. Everything's really fucking weird right now. And money is so central to this. Like, where are you at with everything?

[Nick Bhatia]

Yeah, this is the reason that I'm involved in bitcoin. I come from a global macroeconomics background and I think bitcoin is the future of where global macroeconomics and geopolitics meet. And that's really why I'm involved. So I think that, yeah, a big part of the problem that we see in the world today is in part due to this centralized and monopolistic money creation power that comes from the central banks and banking system. And bitcoin is the direct response to that. You know, Satoshi in the Genesis block put the chancellor on the brink of second bailout. And so the beginning of bitcoin is basically an attempt to respond to the failing bailout, implicit bailout financial system that we live in. And so that transition is why I'm here and why I want to be a part of bitcoin.

[Peter McCormack]

So there's definitely a couple of distinct Use cases that people talk about. And I just did an interview with an interesting chap earlier, this guy Cedric, where we're talking about dark markets and he was actually saying dark markets are really the killer app for Bitcoin because bitcoin, censorship, resistance, he's like, that's the key fundamental property of Bitcoin that we should love and adore. But also a lot of people talk about central banks being a problem. So really there is a goal there to increase adoption to separate money and state. I see them as two separate things. Where do you sit? Have your priorities with this.

[Nick Bhatia]

I think that's a great point. And Bitcoin is definitely a savings technology and definitely a transactional technology. They both are important, they are both essential. They strengthen each other and one can't exist without the other. I approached Bitcoin more from the savings technology standpoint because I have an interest in global markets, how they work. I did a lot of research into gold when I was understanding what was happening during the financial crisis as well. But bitcoin as freedom of speech, money as a transactional platform and technology that allows global participation is as important or if not more important. I think it's hard to say which one is more important. They both exist and they are both part of Bitcoin's heart and soul.

[Peter McCormack]

Well, Nick Carter said he did a whole bunch of unpopular opinions. One of the things he said is that mass adoption is not the goal. The goal is separation of money and state is to take away the power from governments from abusing the monetary system and also to reject tax dollars and the ability to print money at will to create weapons of war and all the bullshit that comes with governments. And I kind of, I never really thought of it that way. I was always like, oh, bitcoin is a chance for everyone just to have their own kind of censorship resistant money. But actually you can kind of start to see the path of the demonetization of state. You can see how that could happen with a circular Bitcoin economy.

[Nick Bhatia]

Yes, I really like Nick Carter's work and his Peaceful Revolution piece was phenomenal. And I do think that it isn't necessarily mass adoption that we're after, but adoption one by one is how we get there. And so if you start to see a government actually come out formally announced that they're going to start allocating their reserves in part to Bitcoin and that unleashes a chain of events in which global central banks and governments are all participating in this grab for scarce bitcoin that can Help bring about this peaceful revolution and try to progress us on a path towards separating money and state. But it does take this adoption one person at a time and convincing, whether it's within the government or central banking system, one person at a time, that can get us there.

[Peter McCormack]

It's potentially really, really strange fucking times, man. I've no doubt there are already governments using bitcoin. So we know that North Korea is using bitcoin. We know that Venezuela is probably using bitcoin and said they plan to use bitcoin. We know they've mined it and stolen the miners. We've heard other countries like Syria and Iran. So in some ways this is like the state level dark markets, right? The states who have sanctions and this is a way to circumvent sanctions, there's.

[Nick Bhatia]

No doubt about it. And gold is the previous version of this where, you know, Iran sells oil for gold because they can't access the traditional oil market set up in London and New York. And so bitcoin is just the modern version of that. That's why gold and bitcoin have so many, so many similarities, is that they are this counterparty free bearer asset that is censorship resistant. Gold can be more censored, I think. And now that, you know, a couple thousand years have gone by in terms of gold, bitcoin still has that censorship resistance.

[Peter McCormack]

So why do you think for a bunch of people, they still can't accept bitcoin as digital gold?

[Nick Bhatia]

I think bitcoin as digital gold is. It's very hard for people to wrap their head around. When gold has a body, it's physical in nature and bitcoin doesn't. When people start to understand that bitcoin is just a number and that number can be considered something physical as well, there's a tangibility there as trace. Mayer likes to say bitcoin is tangible but not corporal. Right. It doesn't have a body, but it definitely is tangible because it's a number. And so it's just a leap of faith that I think more and more people are understanding. But it'll take time.

All right, so before we get into.

[Peter McCormack]

The detail, the other thing I just want to preliminarily get past with you is there's this two sides to bitcoin. There's the base chain and there's lightning and there's definitely some divisions here and that people who are just focused on working on lightning and some on the base chain. Do you think this is healthy? Do you think it's good that they have this kind of separate Kind of entities now got a separate conference, or do you think that's not actually helping Bitcoin? How do you feel about it?

[Nick Bhatia]

Oh, I think it's definitely helpful. And I don't think that Lightning Network development and companies are in a silo by themselves. We all understand that Bitcoin is the base layer, and Bitcoin security allows us to do everything that we do in Lightning Network. So I think it's actually just. It's actually more of an acknowledgement that we are starting to really see bitcoin security lock in. Maybe. You know, I don't. I don't want to speculate on protocol changes because I'm not a developer, but the core tenants to Bitcoin security are there for life. We all know this now, and it's why we're all building on Bitcoin. The Lightning Network community is basically saying that we are ready to speed up the velocity of Bitcoin, we're happy with where the base chain is, and we're ready to make the progress on another layer. Let's leave the base layer alone and let's try to experiment, innovate on higher levels of the blockchain.

[Peter McCormack]

Cool. All right, so let's get into this. You've obviously been working on, you know, you're doing a bunch of writing at the moment. Where's your headspace right now? Where, where are you focusing your time?

[Nick Bhatia]

Sure. So right now I'm with two bitcoin companies, Open Node and Tantra Labs. They're very different from each other. Opennode is a payment processor. We're trying to be the next PayPal. We're trying to be the next Stripe, but based on Bitcoin, we're trying to allow developers to have tools to use Bitcoin and the, you know, very easy to use API tools. And that's something that Stripe did, is they enabled the developers to just build with very easy to use tools. And we're really trying to do the same thing at OpenNote. So my goal at OpenNote is to write content for businesses, for enterprise, the executives and people at companies that are not familiar yet with Bitcoin in terms of its use cases for merchants and bringing them really into the bitcoin era and the future of money. At Tantra Labs, it's a hedge fund also based here in Los Angeles, and we have an algorithmic trading strategy. And my goal there at Tantra is to write bitcoin financial theory, much like some of the stuff that I started writing last year. The time value of Bitcoin lightning network reference rates. How can we think about Bitcoin on its path to world reserve currency and some of those things. So really trying to explore the future of money.

[Peter McCormack]

And your belief is that Bitcoin is the future world reserve currency?

[Nick Bhatia]

I do believe that Bitcoin is the future reserve currency, the reserve asset as well. I think it'll take a long time to get there, but that's where I see Bitcoin going.

[Peter McCormack]

Multi decade.

[Nick Bhatia]

Multi decade. Okay, yes, multi decade. But I think that sometime in the next one to two decades, Bitcoin, gold and US Treasuries will be in the same conversation as a triumvirate of liquidity, a triumvirate of risk free assets, so to speak, that dominate the reserve base of the world.

[Peter McCormack]

Triumvirate, that's a new word to me, triumvirate.

[Nick Bhatia]

So it comes from the Roman Empire where Julius Caesar was ruling, but he was ruling in trio. So it's just another way to say that this is a three headed monster of risk free assets. We all think about Bitcoin in terms of either digital gold or replacing dollars. But I think that the dollar analogy is a little misplaced and mischaracterized. I think we're better to refer to U.S. treasury bonds which are considered the risk free asset in our capital market system. In our dollar based capital market system. That doesn't mean to say that the US treasury will never default. However, the US treasury has the highest creditworthiness perceived by the market and the system. And so we base our system referring to the US treasury rates as our reference rates in the market. And so that treasury bond, those treasury bonds, that is the asset that underpins the financial system. It's not dollars. Dollars out in the system are just banking liabilities. They're not actual money. Right, they're debt. The money is either the physical paper Federal Reserve notes of which there are only a couple trillion of in existence. And I say only a couple trillion because the market of gold is actually almost 10 trillion and the market for US treasuries is over 20 trillion. So yeah, I think that the dollar is the wrong analogy for Bitcoin or at least the wrong target. We should be targeting gold and we should be targeting U.S. treasuries to join this club of world risk free assets.

[Peter McCormack]

And where do you consider the Bitcoin volatility in this? Because when you talk about risk free assets, there is still a lot of risk associated with Bitcoin on certain timescales due to the volatility.

[Nick Bhatia]

Exactly. And it's a great point. And that's why Bitcoin is not ready to join that club from a reserve asset standpoint right now. But it's on its path. And the reason why it's on its path is because the liquidity is what makes Bitcoin similar to gold. It's the fact that you can sell it for dollars or other currencies anywhere on the planet. There is not a defined market or exchange that you have to enter to participate in buying or selling bitcoin. Gold is the same thing. Right. You can go to any corner store really in any country around the world, pawn shop or gold exchange and be able to liquidate that gold into whatever currency. So we see Bitcoin serving this function now getting to a valuation of 10 to 20 trillion dollars in market capitalization versus where Bitcoin is right now, which is only over 100 billion. So only 1/10 of 1 trillion dollars. Getting from 1/10 of a trillion to 10 trillion is going to see some incredibly volatile jumps up and crashes down. And I do believe that we'll continue to see extreme volatility from Bitcoin for the next 20 years as it starts to approach a multi trillion dollar market capitalization as an asset class. It can't just reach multi trillions without having huge gyrations along the way.

[Peter McCormack]

I heard Mirad talked about the same with pomp. Like you can't go from zero to multi trillion dollars without volatility over such a short space of time.

[Nick Bhatia]

No, you can't.

[Peter McCormack]

And Dan Herald also actually talks about the volatility as actually a marketing hype cycle because what happens is the price moves so quickly, it creates lots of media awareness, it brings lots of people in and then obviously there has to be a recalibration. But those are actual. They're marketing cycles.

[Nick Bhatia]

Absolutely. It's. I and I wrote an article about this for opennode. I call them adoption waves.

[Peter McCormack]

Okay.

[Nick Bhatia]

Right. And you basically have people coming into Bitcoin because of the hype. Right. And then staying throughout one cycle and building along the way. But the price behaves in an extreme manner independent from the way that people are adopting it. People are adopting it kind of slowly and steadily, but the speculation creates these massive price swings. And I think it is a feature. It'll prevent Bitcoin from going to getting adopted too fast. Right. We want a nice steady adoption from Bitcoin. And these price bubbles every four years or so do scare away, I think the people that are really only in it for the greed and kind of keeps the, the builders, you know, excited and happy.

[Peter McCormack]

Where does your conviction come from? Because whilst I'm a bitcoiner and I believe in it, I still recognize there is psychologically something there with gold, that it is a physical asset. You know, there is something about owning and holding gold. Right. And I don't actually subscribe to the bitcoin versus gold arguments. I think both have a very important and relevant role in the world. But you're one of these people who does have a conviction for bitcoin longer term. You know, it means we're going to have to survive this bear market. We're going to have to have more bull markets, we're going to have to have more rates at a higher rate of adoption. Where does your conviction come from that this will happen?

[Nick Bhatia]

Well, I think two places. First of all, using bitcoin for the first time was a very empowering experience for me. And I just, I think inside, deep down I knew that this is how money should work and we should, it should be based on scarce numbers and we should be able to transmit those numbers over the Internet. So I think kind of just inherently I knew that it worked. Where does the conviction come from? It comes from seeing 2008, 2009 happen in the financial markets, seeing the multi trillions in explicit and implicit bailouts that came from the banking system, and trying to understand how is this money being created, what is this money system and how is it fair that they can just print all that money? And so I guess the first question I had to ask myself is, are they actually printing money and how are they doing it? And then you have to study how does a central bank work, how does the banking system work, how does money creation work? And understanding all of that, understanding fractional reserve banking in the modern era, it really drove me to gold to understand what gold's role was in monetary history. And bitcoin came about and I said, this is the better version of gold and this is the fix. And that's what I believe.

[Peter McCormack]

Okay, so you have your conviction, you have your belief. What are the hurdles therefore for adoption? What are you looking at? What are you considering? Because we've had this elongated bear market and there's been a lot of talk of, oh, the institutions are coming and then back launches and nothing really happens. There's very little obvious institutional interest. We've kind of just kind of settled into a nowhere land at the moment, like, what's next? What do we need to happen?

[Nick Bhatia]

So I actually really like the realized market cap metric, right? It starts to Strip out this, a little bit of this volatility that we talked about because we're able to now track the actual price at which Bitcoin is transacted and on a cumulative basis and see that the base price for Bitcoin is actually just rising steadily. We reached 20,000. It crashed back down to 3,000, almost up to 14 again and then cut in half once again. You lose sight of the actual slow and steady build in cost basis. Right. And transaction really and this realized market cap level. So I would actually just beg to, you know, differ a little bit and say that this is really, it is adoption from individuals and institutions. We didn't see a spike or anything off of the backed thing. But you know, grayscale is noting massive inflows.

[Peter McCormack]

We're getting record quarter, right?

[Nick Bhatia]

Yes.

[Peter McCormack]

Is it 400 million?

[Nick Bhatia]

I don't recall. But they're getting huge inflows into gbtc. We are hearing from guys like Raoul Paul on Real Vision that every single hedge fund that he knows, that is a global macro hedge fund is exposed to Bitcoin. They have some long position because they realize they cannot afford to be without that convexity. Right. Bitcoin offers a convex return profile where if you only allocate 1% of your portfolio in a few years it can be 10% of the portfolio. That type of outsized return doesn't exist in traditional asset classes. So they actually feel that if they're not long Bitcoin, they're short. And they've talked about this. It's kind of a theoretical short cover in advance where you just have to be long. It so adoption is there, it's building. And yeah, if we think of Bitcoin's price volatility cycles happening over a four year time horizon, at any one point during that four years, it can feel like it's taking forever to get back up there.

[Peter McCormack]

I think it's because of my first one.

[Nick Bhatia]

Yeah.

[Peter McCormack]

Yes. My first time I've lived through a real bitcoin bear market knowing I'm going to be there at the end of it. You know, I experienced 2013, 14, but I just left bitcoin. I was like, I came in, I discovered it and I left. I didn't care, didn't understand it. I was just using Bitcoin for Silk Road. Now I'm in like I'm in for good. And it's not about financial gain. Like I don't really care about that. I'm more interested in just like seeing what can happen as the market grows. But this is My first time through one.

[Nick Bhatia]

Yeah, you know, it's actually my first time through one as well. And you know, I. Part of my background is, you know, watching financial markets and studying price action and looking at price history and studying the price history of Bitcoin has led me to this conclusion that we are in some sort of four year cyclicality. It does coincide with the having cycle, it does coincide with adoption and media hype. And I believe that we're just, you know, basing the next cycle is starting and so maybe in 2021 we'll get the same type of mania that we saw in 17 and 13, maybe not, but that is the way that I'm approaching this. And so, you know, let's see over the next couple of years.

[Peter McCormack]

All right, so you talk a lot about what happened in 2007, 2008, that was essentially a precursor to Bitcoin. Although my assumption is whoever Satoshi is, they were working on it for quite a while, probably many years and involved in many projects, etc. Etc. But it looks like again, the global macro conditions are getting pretty freaky. You know, I've spoken to people like I interviewed Dan Tapiro yesterday. I don't know if you know Dan, I've interviewed Raoul Pal and you know, like, there's lots of weird stuff happening. How do you, what sense are you making of the markets at the moment?

[Nick Bhatia]

Yes, the global economy is expanding at its slowest pace since the financial crisis. So we do have that statistic out there. Global central banks are in ease mode. They are cutting across the world. So we have that there. So generally speaking, the economic outlook is not good. But if you layer that on top of the fact that the US dollar system itself is extremely fragile as we're seeing right now with some of the disruptions in the repo market, the problem that we had in 0708 never was fixed, it was just papered over. And so the next problem is we also, I think people don't believe that it's going to be fixed again. It's just going to be papered over in a much larger way than it was the last time. And that means quantitative easing ad infinitum from every corner of the world.

[Peter McCormack]

It's almost like a game of chicken between different markets, like who's going to give up first? Because for me, as somebody who's not an economist, I struggle to really understand in detail these things. I have to listen to people like yourself or Raoul Pao. But my gut feel is that China, the US and Europe, possibly Japan they're playing a game of chicken now. Who's going to give up first? There just seems to be a relentless printing of money. Every chart I see seems to show government debt is increasing at, like, an alarming rate. It feels like when this does crash, this is going to be a lot worse in 2007. Like, should people be worried?

[Nick Bhatia]

It's really hard to say because what happened in 2008 should have ended the financial system, but the response was large enough that it delayed the problem by a decade.

[Peter McCormack]

Ended the financial system in what way?

[Nick Bhatia]

Well, what happened was that when Lehman Brothers collapsed, what happened to all the other investment banks that had exposure to the Lehman debt that was going to be basically marked from 100 to 0, that drawdown in asset prices across the entire financial system, meaning all the banks that hold the debt that's being marked from 100 to zero, if they have to mark it down to zero, their insurance premiums go through the roof. AIG couldn't insure. They couldn't underwrite the insurance anymore. And the whole thing literally collapsed. Every bank collapsed. So when the bank bailout happened, they did several things all at once. They did quantitative easing to buy toxic assets from the banks themselves. They did quantitative easing to just boost reserves. They bailed out AIG because Goldman Sachs and other investment banks called their credit default swaps. That AIG underwrote, and AIG didn't have the money to pay all of them out. So we had to bail out AIG to bail out the CDS contracts. So you understand, like, the whole system would have collapsed had they not done a multifaceted bailout.

[Peter McCormack]

But, like, have you, you know, have you reflected on it and actually kind of envisage what a collapse would have looked like? I mean, you know, the government has to do something, right? They can't just allow for a collapse.

[Nick Bhatia]

Well, that's my point. They did step in and they prevented any collapse of society or any real societal collapse that could have happened with all the banks going under in a period of 24 hours.

[Peter McCormack]

But is that a good thing? Would it have been a good thing for the banks to collapse and, like, rebuild our financial markets? Or would that have led to absolute, utter chaos and anarchy?

[Nick Bhatia]

Probably utter chaos. But this is why Bitcoiners believe in Bitcoin for the future is that we can build this parallel system. We don't want society to collapse.

[Peter McCormack]

Exactly right. So the bank rescue is important. It should have happened. We want it to happen.

[Nick Bhatia]

Well, we don't want society to collapse. We get upset by the mechanisms in which they bail out because we're like, that's not fair. Why are you bailing out the banks? You're not bailing out everybody. And then you reward bad behavior because the banks are allowed to continue to operate.

[Peter McCormack]

Well, I never bumped that reward bad behavior. It's not rewarding bad behavior. It is protecting the market. It's stopping the collapse of society. Like, I get why it happens. You know, we can look at it with like, oh, this is evil and you know, the bankers have got away with it, blah, blah, blah. Certainly certain people probably should have gone to jail. But at the same time, I don't think it's. I never saw it as rewarding bad behavior. I saw it as protecting people.

[Nick Bhatia]

That's fair. I mean, that's really why the, you know, they do the bailouts. Because they know that, you know, people will lose their jobs as a result if, if they don't. So we're not trying to condone the behavior or say that that's exactly what should have happened. It is what happened and we avoided whatever collapse could have happened without that. But I think the exciting thing about Bitcoin is that we can build something without having to come up with a solution to a problem that just seems so complicated and massive. And like you said, you're seeing debt exploding from all over the globe. What is the end game? What is the solution? It's really impossible to know.

[Peter McCormack]

Well, I see a massive debt write off because I don't see it all being paid. When's this all going to be paid? It's just a situation that seems to be getting worse and worse. I quite like the idea and prefer the idea of bitcoin being built alongside a more healthy system. Not a I don't think it is healthy, but a more healthy system. Because I think you have the opportunity therefore to like, I never like this when something really bad happens for people. But it's good for bitcoin. It's like, yeah, like, oh, look at Venezuela. This is great for bitcoin. Like, I would rather Venezuela was in a healthy position and bitcoin was growing. I can't buy into bitcoin benefiting from bullshit happening to people. I just can't buy into that.

[Nick Bhatia]

Yeah, there are a lot of geopolitical situations around the world that you know, are cause for a worry. Bitcoin does help people in a lot of those situations, but it doesn't mean you have to root for bad things to happen.

[Peter McCormack]

No.

[Nick Bhatia]

Next up, I'll talk to Nick Moore about how the banking system works. But before that, I got a message from my amazing sponsors. So, firstly, this show is brought to you by the mighty, mighty Kraken, the most trusted place to buy and sell Bitcoin. Who's on Kraken? Are you using it? If you're not, let me know why. If you are, tell me what you love about it. It'd be great to hear from you. And I've also waited for Pierre Rochard to turn up. I'm just about to record an interview with him, find out why he joined Kraken and discuss a bunch of other bitcoin stuff. But Kraken, we know they have the best security in the entire industry. But for you traders out there, they've got every possible tool you can want. They've got kraken.com, the best place to buy, sell and trade digital currencies. You've got margin trading with up to 5x leverage. You got futures, you got indices. And with the Kraken OTC desk, you can handle large trades with private and personalized services. They've got crypto watch, where you can trade multiple exchanges from a single platform. And for you advanced traders out there, they have the single best account management service in the business. Listen, there is no better place to trade Bitcoin. So join me in supporting Kraken by heading over to kraken.com, which is k r a k e n dot com. Also, today's show is brought to you by the amazing blockfi. Love you, Florrie. Love you, Zach. Thank you for supporting the show. For so long. It's been like, I don't know, like.

[Peter McCormack]

14, 15 months now.

[Nick Bhatia]

I couldn't do this without you. I'm not just A fan of BlockFi, I am also a customer. I use our interest accounts and as we close down towards the end of the month, I can't wait to do my interest again. I always find it weirdly exciting. And they've had so many cool updates to the interest accounts. Recently, they've dropped all minimum deposits, so interest account holding clients will no longer have to meet a minimum deposit amount for their Bitcoin, Ether or G USD. They've also removed the early withdrawal penalty from their account and they are now offering one free withdrawal per month to all clients. And add to that the recent announcement of BlockFi Flex, where you can choose to receive your interest payments in the currency, your choice. BlockFi really are crushing it with these interest accounts. So if you're interested in finding out more and you want to become a customer I do recommend you do your research, then head over to blockfi.com, which is b, l o c k f I dot com.

[Peter McCormack]

So I still don't think I've got a full answer. Where do you think things are going globally right now? Do you see another crash coming?

[Nick Bhatia]

I, I think the global economy is heading into contraction. What that does to the financial system is anybody's guess. But global trade is slowing and has been for a year now or more. And so the normal recession that happens in the business cycle, you know, every five to 10 years, that's starting to happen now.

[Peter McCormack]

Okay.

[Nick Bhatia]

What happens to the banking system as a result? And if we're going to have a financial panic like we had in 08 is anybody's guess right now. What's happening with the Fed having to do emergency measures, it doesn't feel great again. And I'm definitely watching this repo situation and this liquidity situation with what the Federal Reserve is very, very closely.

[Peter McCormack]

Okay, can you talk through and explain the repo situation? Because I'd never heard of it until two weeks ago when I saw Caitlin Long tweeting about it. What is the repo market? Explain it for people who don't understand.

[Nick Bhatia]

Right. So it's actually considered the inner plumbing or the inner workings of how the financial system operates. So banks are leveraged. Right. That basically means they don't have the cash that is required to pay for all the assets that they have on their balance sheet at any given point.

[Peter McCormack]

And does this go back to fractional reserve?

[Nick Bhatia]

This is fractional reserve. They have to borrow to fund the assets on their balance sheet. So primary dealers are the 20 odd banks that have an agreement with the Federal Reserve and the treasury to traffic treasury debt from the auctions and the primary market. When those treasury securities get auctioned, banks, these primary dealers have to take down excess supply. By law, you have countries asset managers that bid for the bonds. Whatever's left over the banks have to absorb by law. Okay, they have to take these bonds onto their balance sheet and guess what? They don't have the cash to pay for them. So they have to go out and finance them in the repo market. The repo market is basically a pawn shop for bonds. Okay, okay. So the bond is the collateral and you get a loan for it. So banks typically fund their treasury holdings, meaning they post, they go to the pawn shop and the pawn shop is in this case, basically the global cash base. Everybody who has cash and they say, lend us the money, we will post Treasuries to you as collateral. So it's pristine collateral. You don't have to worry about the treasury defaulting. If I default, you can just take the treasury bond and sell it and you're made whole on the loan. So it's like a collateralized loan.

[Peter McCormack]

Okay.

[Nick Bhatia]

Banks should not have problem funding their treasury books because the collateral itself is pristine. So what happened on September 15 is that a bunch of Treasuries settled into the system, that the cash from the world just happened to disappear. Now where did the cash go from the system? Was it just too many Treasuries that hit the market all at once? It's a combination of both. But now we are coming up to the end of October and the Fed is still needing to provide that cash overnight every night to these banks. So there are banks that are short liquidity. They don't want to sell the Treasuries or can't because of reserve requirements, capital ratios, or also safety. Maybe they just don't want to part ways with the collateral because it's so pristine. Because remember when stock markets go down and companies default, the risk free asset are U.S. treasuries. Okay, so what happened in the repo market? Long story short, an influx of Treasuries and you know, an outflow of cash caused a bank or a few banks to be short cash. And the Fed has stepped in to provide that cash and they're doing so nightly right now and we don't know what's next.

[Peter McCormack]

Okay, that sounds kind of scary.

[Nick Bhatia]

It is scary because the repo market was at the center of the beginning of the last financial crisis.

[Peter McCormack]

But what is underpinning the risk this time? Because last time it was the mortgage backed securities. Right. We don't have that as a problem anymore. So what is the risk?

[Nick Bhatia]

The mortgage backed security, the subprime mortgages were one of the risky things that one of the risky activities that the bank was doing. But keep in mind, if the bank is leveraged 30 to 1, 40 to 1, 50 to 1, it, it doesn't matter what asset goes bad.

[Peter McCormack]

Okay?

[Nick Bhatia]

If something goes bad, they're insolvent. That's what leverage does to you. You don't have the ability to withstand losses. So we don't know what. That's why I'm saying let's separate the global recession, incoming global recession, from any banking panic. Because bank assets being written down causes this banking panic.

[Peter McCormack]

And. Okay, okay, I get it. Because fractional reserve banking is essentially leveraging yourself.

[Nick Bhatia]

That's right.

[Peter McCormack]

Yeah. I'd never actually thought of it as leveraging yourself.

[Nick Bhatia]

It's leverage. That's what the fraction is. Yeah, it's the frat. The fraction is the asset or the equity base to the assets that you're holding. And if the number isn't the same, you have to borrow.

[Peter McCormack]

Okay. Okay, So I get it. Right. This is interesting because this part of this I've never fully understood. Right. It's just kind of, you know, when it like all starts to click for you. Right. Okay. So are there laws about how much the banks are allowed to leverage themselves?

[Nick Bhatia]

That's a great question. And this is something that I think it's getting more popular to talk about in the global macroeconomic circles. And I'm excited that it's at the front and center of the conversation, which is that the US Onshore Federal Reserve regulated banking system has leverage ratios that are enforceable and are reasonable. Within the context, they're about 10 to 1. And the federal Reserve has reserve requirements that they mandate continuously. There is an offshore Eurodollar system, and by Eurodollars, I just mean dollars that aren't located here in the United States. Domestically, the offshore Eurodollar system is a system of banking liabilities that gets created within the syndicate of banks without any Federal Reserve or central banking oversight. So we have an offshore system for the settlement and clearing of dollars. But that leverage ratio that's in the offshore US dollar system is something that none of us can know, because only the entities that are creating those liabilities, which are the banks themselves, only they know what that ratio is. And that offshore Eurodollar system is part of the problem with the dollar system. The Fed thinks that they can stoke monetary policy by creating bank reserves and increasing the size of their balance sheet. But if the Eurodollar system globally is in contraction, there's nothing that the Fed can do to actually stoke the global economy. And many people believe that's what has been happening since 07, is that this offshore dollar liability system is in contraction. So even though monetary policy is accommodative in the United States, it's not working.

[Peter McCormack]

So what's the difference between the banks and degenerate Bitmex traders?

[Nick Bhatia]

That's a great question, but is there any difference?

[Peter McCormack]

So do you prescribe to wanting a world of no fractional reserve, fully reserve? Because some people believe that some, like Safety in a Moose is he doesn't believe in fractional reserve at all.

[Nick Bhatia]

No, I think that fractional reserve is just a natural activity for people to do where if they think that they can manage a loan book and leverage it up, then they'll be able to do that activity. I think it'll happen in Bitcoin where obviously you can't create Bitcoin, you can't lend bitcoin, but you can lend bitcoin like instruments into the market. They will trade at a discount to regular Bitcoin. There will be an arbitrage there. And I think that bitcoin will end up end up in a fractionally reserved system.

[Peter McCormack]

But that's going to piss a lot of people off.

[Nick Bhatia]

It will. But the great thing is that here's the great thing about Bitcoin. If you want to have custody of your bitcoin, you can, you can audit the blockchain and know that you have a percentage of 21 million coins forever. If you want a bitcoin substitute to engage in economic activity, we might see that decades into the future. We're not looking at a fractionally reserved bitcoin system tomorrow. And we'll never be looking at a system where you're not able to verify your ownership of Bitcoin with your own full node, thankfully. But we don't know how it's going to evolve.

[Peter McCormack]

So I'm pretty sure it's Wyoming they have now I'd have to double check this, but I'm pretty sure they've passed a law now that you have to like fully reserved banks or fully reserved operations. I know it's one of the reasons Blockfi aren't based out you can't get a blockfi loan or use their interest account in Wyoming. But I do need to double check this. If anyone listening, just let me double check that. But do you know about this?

[Nick Bhatia]

So I know that Trace mayor is working on a lot of great legislation in Wyoming and one of the things that you have to think about is the difference between a vault and a bank.

[Peter McCormack]

Yeah.

[Nick Bhatia]

A vault should, if you're going to call yourself a vault, should have full reserve. Right. But a bank is itself a lending operation and so leverage is built into the concept of a bank. So I do hope that we'll have regulated fully reserved bitcoin vaults. But to expect that people aren't going to want to lend paper bitcoin out into the market, I think it's and worldwide, I think it's unreasonable. And listen, even companies like Blockfi that are offering deposits and interest on what they have now, that person, they have a bitcoin liability. Blockfi has a liability to that client. So they no longer have their Bitcoin anyway.

[Peter McCormack]

Yep.

[Nick Bhatia]

So we're already Starting to get into situations where people are willing to invest their Bitcoin, let go of their custody for a return, not knowing if they're ever going to get it back. And even if it's insured, is the insurance in dollars or is it in Bitcoin? Because if it's in dollars, you're exposed there to a rise in the price of Bitcoin.

[Peter McCormack]

Okay, so the interesting thing there is. So just to help me understand, if a bank can fractionally lend, if they choose to make a loan to you, they're essentially printing money themselves by just changing the digits in your bank account.

[Nick Bhatia]

That's right.

[Peter McCormack]

Banks actually can just print money. They can make money out of, not thin air.

[Nick Bhatia]

Yes. And so when I talk about the monopolistic money creation powers of central banks and banks, what I'm talking about is that central banks on their liability side of their balance sheet have paper currency and bank reserves. So when they print paper dollars, that's a liability for the central bank and they've created money. Now a commercial bank like Wells Fargo or JP Morgan issues a loan to their client and creates those dollars into the bank account as long as those dollars are fractionally reserved by reserves at the Fed, treasuries, et cetera. So the power to create money is both with the central bank and with the banks. And the only way that the banks can create the money is if they have a banking license. So the power to create money is the central bank and the members of its banking club. They are the power. It's actually not just the banks or not just the central bank, it's them as a system. Because the commercial bank is a member bank or a licensed bank under the Federal Reserve, for example, they have the power to create money.

[Peter McCormack]

So like anyone operating with leverage in any market, whether you're a trader or a bank, the job of the bank is to manage risk, Right? It's to manage risk of who they're going to lend money out to and going back to the mortgage backed securities and the, you know, the toxic mortgages that they were offering. You know, that's where risk wasn't being managed. Well, that's where the risk got out of hand. And a lot of these defaults happened and that's whereby essentially they got liquidated, right?

[Nick Bhatia]

That's right. Because what happens is but brought the.

[Peter McCormack]

Whole global economy down.

[Nick Bhatia]

Well, what happens when people stop paying their mortgages? That's a default for the borrower. The borrower is defaulting, but they're defaulting to somebody. The mortgage holder at that point has an asset that's no longer priced at 100, but is now priced at 80, priced at 60, priced at 40. And that price drawdown is what affected the banking system.

[Peter McCormack]

Right. Okay. This is the first time I've jumped through a few hoops I've struggled with before, like things I've not fully understood. I'm starting to get a clearer picture now.

[Nick Bhatia]

And let me just say too, about understanding the banking system, the repo reserve assets, Treasuries and all that. It's something that I've been studying now through myself, school, professional exams, work experience for about 12 years now. And I still feel so dumb because of how complicated it is and really how many moving parts there are to understand the global financial system. I try to add one part every few months, working my way up to a thousand. But you know, it really is, it takes months and years to understand each one of these concepts by itself.

[Peter McCormack]

Tell me about it. I feel dumb as shit all the time, especially doing this podcast because all I do is speak to X experts who spend all day research and writing, research and writer. I like trying to keep up with it all is really, really hard. But you know, today's been really useful. I understand a lot more than I did yesterday, which is great. Okay, so all these considerations for how banking works, central banking works, how governments work, you're obviously a big fan of Bitcoin. What are the key things about Bitcoin that will improve the system for you? Like what are the most important things?

[Nick Bhatia]

Right, so the first thing is think about US Treasuries as the world's risk free asset. Not only are US treasuries not available to all 7 billion people on the planet to hold as a reserve asset, but the minimum denomination of Treasuries far outstrips the ability of most people to save in Treasuries. Bitcoin you can save at the most micro level of anything.

[Peter McCormack]

So it democratizes it to every single person on the planet.

[Nick Bhatia]

Right? It democratizes it to every single person on the planet because it's an open system, but it's also an open system with no minimums. So I guess it's more of the same.

[Peter McCormack]

Well, you have a dust limit, I.

[Nick Bhatia]

Guess a dust limit.

[Peter McCormack]

Right.

[Nick Bhatia]

But I mean it's negligible. Yeah, we're talking about, you know, a system where everybody in the world can participate really at any amount. And so I think that's one of the main things that excites me is it's an open system and everybody can participate and that's actually what I think. Everybody that believes in gold, called a gold bug or whatever that has gold as an investment believes in this ability to own a metal that can't be faked or counterfeited or seized away from you if you have it in your possession. And that sovereignty aspect, the bitcoin as well has the sovereignty aspect to it.

[Peter McCormack]

Okay, what else though about bitcoin improves the system?

[Nick Bhatia]

Yes.

[Peter McCormack]

It's great that everyone else can access it. What are the other things that really stand out for you?

[Nick Bhatia]

Again, I think it comes down to supply. The strictly limited supply. And whatever the supply was, the fact that we know what it is going to be, it's not the fact that it's 21 million or that the block reward will go from six and a quarter and be cut in half at some point in time. It's actually just knowing what the schedule is and having that certainty. We don't really have similar certainty in any other asset class in the world. We know that gold won't just be, you know, the total supply won't increase by 10% next year, but we really don't. Right. It still is a little bit unknown. So I just think that the reason why I love bitcoin, I think that it improves on all the things that gold is lacking. And gold really is the world's best, historically the world's best money.

[Peter McCormack]

Yeah. And also going back to the fixed supply, it changes your behavior. It forces you to rethink your behavior. Like it took me a while, dude. I've got like probably around 10% of the Bitcoin I had at my peak. Right. Because I fucked up so many things. I got into mine and blah, blah. But now, like, now I understand bitcoin.

[Nick Bhatia]

I totally agree with you. It really encourages savings and encourages you to knowing that or believing that it's going to be worth more tomorrow than it is today really just encourages that saving. But thinking of it as better money too, it makes you not want to part ways with it.

[Peter McCormack]

No, but I want to use it. I still think it's important to use bitcoin. So what I have is I want to make sure at the end of each month I've got more bitcoin than I started the month with. But I don't mind using that. But I, you know, I don't do big ticket purchases, but I do the small ticket and I do give like a bunch away. But I'm also always accumulating like some of my invoices are in Bitcoin and 25% stays in Bitcoin. The other goes to Fiat to pay my bills, to run the business. But I've become like this whole time preference thing, like literally a show out today about it. But it's, it has really changed things. Like things I'm thinking about buying, you know, like I gave up smoking this week. Right.

[Nick Bhatia]

I saw that on Twitter. How's it going?

[Peter McCormack]

It was very hard, but getting easier. I've got like, I'm going through gum like a motherfucker, but. So I'm a dual smoker, very occasional cigarette smoker, but mainly a dual smoker. But I took up electric cigarettes to get away from cigarettes. Right, right. But I was like, I didn't smoke most days. I'd smoke here, here and there. Maybe I'll have a few of the beer, you know, less than a pack a week with the jaw. To me, like, you talk about risk free asset, it's risk free smoking, right? Like I could do it on a plane if no one catches me. You can know you can do it in bed.

[Nick Bhatia]

You do it in front of the.

[Peter McCormack]

Tv, you just do it fucking anywhere. It doesn't matter because you didn't feel like it's gonna make you stink and you didn't feel like it was unhealthy. But I got to the point where I was having like two or three pods a day. That's 20 to 40 cigarettes, right? And my body was feeling achy, I was feeling out of breath. I just felt like shit. And I was thinking, do you know what this is? This all comes down to time preference, right? If I get my time preference right, I will handle the breakup with my Jewel. And hopefully that's going to lead to a better, healthier life. Okay? So what I did, I was flying from Portland to San Francisco and I knew that they were banned in San Francisco. So as I got on the plane, I threw it in the bin. I was like, now I'm stuck. There's nothing I can do for 36 hours. I then got to LA and went down the pub and I ended up buying a pack of cigarettes and I had two. And I was like, what the fuck am I doing? I'm using cigarettes to give up the Jewel. So I threw that away. I'm now done, 48 hours nicotine free. So I'm five days, no dual, 48 hours nicotine free. It's really, really, really fucking hard. I gotta be honest, anyone who's been a smoker knows I don't know if you've ever smoked now. It's really, really Hard. Me as a former drug addict who had a very bad class A drug problem at one point. Giving up a jewel is the hardest thing. It's far harder than giving up the recovery from a cocaine addiction.

[Nick Bhatia]

Well, I commend you and I'm really happy to see that bitcoin is a part of that decision.

[Peter McCormack]

Would. You know, someone said to me on Twitter, they said, every day, whatever you would have spent on your jewel, spend it on SATs. And I was like, you know, that's a really great idea. Now I was thinking someone should do a cigarettes for sats app. Like, literally, you accumulate sats instead of smoking. I mean, what a great idea.

[Nick Bhatia]

Yeah, I love it.

[Peter McCormack]

Stacking sets, dumping cigarettes.

[Nick Bhatia]

All right, cool.

[Peter McCormack]

So this has been really super useful for me. Where are you in terms of like, when you kind of like step above bitcoin lightning, you look down. Where do you think we are at the moment? Do you think there's any important areas of development that are being missed? Where's your kind of like, where are you now with everything?

[Nick Bhatia]

So one of the things that I like to think about is the difference in Americans versus the world in terms of bitcoin adoption. Americans, and I'm an American, we don't have a problem in front of us every day that makes us go to bitcoin. Right. The problems are more long term. Right. What I was talking about with my displeasure with trillions and bank bailouts and thinking that it's unfair and wanting a solution that's not a today problem. Right. So my interests in bitcoin are more long term. But there are people around the world where their interest in bitcoin is not as a savings technology necessarily, but as a transactional technology or as a savings technology that they need today to avoid central bank profligacy. So my main interest is in the people that are using Bitcoin because they have to.

[Peter McCormack]

Nice. Okay.

[Nick Bhatia]

It's not people in the United States of America.

[Peter McCormack]

Now I get it. I get it. Let me tell you something. So you know I've launched defiance.

[Nick Bhatia]

Yes.

[Peter McCormack]

So I've gone from like multi coin trader to bitcoin only. And now I've got to the point where I'm like, I want to stop thinking of the bitcoin space. I'll tell you why. Because I've been going to conferences and it's bitcoiners talking to bitcoiners about bitcoin. And then someone will go and put some cool tweet online and we're all sharing it and like talking about it. But in the end, it's still bitcoiners talking to bitcoin about bitcoin. For me, defiance is almost like grouping a bunch of things that feel aligned. You know, drug laws, Bitcoin itself, you know, human rights, censorship, all these things feel aligned. And it feels like bitcoin should be part of that, part of that conversation. So I'm trying to get out thinking in terms of the bitcoin space, and I'm trying to think about the topics and the communities where this all works together. So I think that's got a bit of alignment with what you're saying.

[Nick Bhatia]

Absolutely. I've written a piece called Bitcoin as a Human. Right. I've written a piece that I hope is going to be published soon called Bitcoin Citizenship.

[Peter McCormack]

Okay.

[Nick Bhatia]

So I do believe that bitcoin is a tool that we have the right to use as human beings. It's a tool that is one of the most powerful tools we've ever been given as a species. And it compounds with the Internet. Right? The Internet is the tool itself that allows Bitcoin to be that incredible tool. So it's kind of the Internet plus bitcoin as this one really powerful tool. And so, yeah, it's something that I want to focus on and I want to see it being adopted by the people that need it. And it's really just not in this country. Even though we all get upset about the Fed printing money all the time, this isn't Argentina. It's not the same as the way it is in South America. What's happening? Or with countries that have sanctions. And there are people in those countries that have nothing to do with what their governments are doing. They need to access financial services as well.

[Peter McCormack]

So how do we get. How do we get it out to them? How do we get the message out to them? Because it's kind of like. It's like an obvious answer to people just put a bit into Bitcoin. You know, you can save, you can. You know, like you say it's a savings tool, but, like, why is the message not translating?

[Nick Bhatia]

This is what comes back to what I'm doing here at OpenNow and I think bringing it full circle. Lightning Network. The reason we built on Lightning Network and that we believe in Lightning Network. Lightning Network allows you to use Bitcoin online instantly. Instant settlement. This whole idea that we have to wait for blockchain confirmations is incredibly important for Bitcoin security. It is essential for Bitcoin security. Bitcoin being slow allows us to have that Confidence that the asset is ours with every passing minute or with every passing block. We need that. But we also need to be able to spend it at the speed of light without the burden of block confirmations. Opennode powers this. We allow merchants to accept Bitcoin using the Lightning Network. And the ability to accept microtransactions instantly is going to change the way that we think about doing business on the Internet. Microtransactions will become a real thing. Spending money in the $0.01 to $1 realm will become a real thing on the Internet. And the companies that institute these types of business models will open themselves to 7 billion customers. That's how we'll bring them in. We give them something that they want. Right now they don't know that they need bitcoin. But what if they can use bitcoin online to get something that they really need in their country at the micro level? That's part of my vision for bitcoin. That's why I love the Lightning Network and why I think that Instant settlement and this is something that Jack Mallers Presented on Bitcoin 2019 in San Francisco that we were both at together. Instant Settlement of Bitcoin is so powerful, the blockchain confirmations that happen every 10 minutes or so are essential and part of the security. But we need this also to make it a usable experience.

[Peter McCormack]

Yeah, Jack's going to be so pissed at me recently because it's controversial. You can share your opinion or not, but I kind of right now in terms of ux, I found that some of the non custodial solutions aren't as easy to use as the custodial. Now I need to spend some time on Jax using Zap, but I just think some of the custodial solutions for a small amount of Bitcoin, 10, 20, $30, actually it's a really great experience.

[Nick Bhatia]

I actually completely agree with you. I think that.

[Peter McCormack]

But we're anti Bitcoin if we think that apparently.

[Nick Bhatia]

Listen, keeping your bitcoin in cold storage and knowing how those keys were generated, if that's not part of, you know, who you are, then you're not really a bitcoiner, you're just renting. And so if you choose to rent $20 of Bitcoin to make your user experience better, that's totally fine. I encourage, I encourage that.

[Peter McCormack]

Okay.

[Nick Bhatia]

But don't rent your bitcoin. Your life savings worth of Bitcoin or whatever bitcoin that you have, you can't rent your bitcoin, you have to own it. But yes, Peter, if you want to rent $25 worth of Bitcoin and play around with a custodial wallet, I don't think that's a problem. And I do think that many people in the future will never have a relationship with the bitcoin blockchain. They'll just rent the experience from a company or a service provider, and that'll probably be okay.

[Peter McCormack]

All right, cool.

[Nick Bhatia]

All right.

[Peter McCormack]

Like, any final thoughts you want to leave people with?

[Nick Bhatia]

Well, I really appreciate you coming out here. It was great chatting with you. I really love what you're doing with Defiance. I think that human rights is a big deal. I was. I've been very disappointed with the reaction from, well, let's just say the reaction to Hong Kong. The situation is in Hong Kong is no different than any other human rights situation anywhere in the world. People want a voice and we have to encourage that. And so I, you know, wait.

[Peter McCormack]

To me, it's the most important story in the world right now because this is a, this is a fight for freedom. This is a fight for people who want to live free. And when I say free, like Westerners, like the U.K. and the U.S. like, I think we've also got a lot of problems, but we can stand up and criticize our government. I can go and stand outside 10 down the street and I can criticize our government. We know you can't do that in China, right? So we're watching a group of people fighting for their freedom, and we're seeing it play out in real time online and in social media. And they're either going to win or they're going to lose. And we're going to witness seeing a change to a society if it loses. And we're going to witness, like, the reaction to the society if they win. I mean, it's like it's a real time fight of the people against the state. I mean, shouldn't find it entertaining because it's devastating to watch, but it's. It's just fucking amazing to watch in real time.

[Nick Bhatia]

When the first protests were going on, the first couple days, I literally could not stop watching the YouTube live stream because this is Hong Kong. This is the Chinese Communist Party we're talking about here. This is, this is one of the most important situations in the world and it could dictate a lot of geopolitics. So I'm not some expert on geopolitics. I'm just a keen observer. I like to analyze how these things affect markets and global macroeconomics. But I just encourage and Support everybody that gives attention to these human rights issues, because that's what freedom of speech is all about and we should protect it.

[Peter McCormack]

All right, man. Well, listen, look, tell people how they can keep an eye on your work. Read the stuff you're doing. Some of your amazing writing, obviously. Time. Remind me the name, the time value.

[Nick Bhatia]

Time value of Bitcoin.

[Peter McCormack]

I read that in preparation of my lightning month. I tried to schedule to have you on that month. It never happened, but that was really useful to me. I've obviously read some of the other stuff, but let people know where they can find your work.

[Nick Bhatia]

Sure. So you can find me on Twitter and medium@timevalueofbtc.

[Peter McCormack]

Nice.

[Nick Bhatia]

It's the name is from my original paper that I wrote the time value of bitcoin. And you can also find my work on Opennode's blog and Tantra's Medium page as well.

[Peter McCormack]

Nice one. Okay, I'll share it out in the show notes, but all the best to you, Nick. And thanks for this, man.

[Nick Bhatia]

Thanks so much, Peter. Appreciate it.

[Peter McCormack]

How was that?

[Nick Bhatia]

What did you think of that? Nick's pretty cool, right? It's great to get Nick on. I found it very useful to get an insight into how the banking system works. It is so complicated that to have it laid out was great. And piecing together where bitcoin may fit into this and Nick's views on the current economy made for a really, really great overview for me. So I love Nick's work. His articles on Medium, as I said before, been very useful for me. Make sure you go and check him out. He's a very, very good writer. And if you enjoyed this and you haven't listened to my recent interviews with Dan Tapiro or Raoul Pal, definitely go and check that out. They all kind of fit together. And if you any feedback, do get in touch, My email address is hellohatbitcoindid.com I do try and get back to everyone who reaches out to me. And if you want to support the show, doesn't matter whether you leave a review, become Patreon or even a sponsor, whatever you want to do, it all helps. It all helps me build the best show I can possibly do. Just head over to my website. It's what bitcoindid.com There's a support section that will explain everything for you. All right, listen, I'm going to be heading back to Bedford tomorrow, getting back to see my kids, which I can't wait for. Thank you everyone who supports everything I do. This show defines. Honestly, you're all amazing. I love you all. See you soon. Have a great weekend. And if you've got any questions, do email me as hellohot Bitcoin did come.