The Political Scene | The New Yorker
Episode: Samantha Bee Talks to David Remnick About Responding to Tragedies
Release Date: June 20, 2016
Host: David Remnick
Guest: Samantha Bee
Overview
In this candid and thoughtful discussion, David Remnick speaks with comedian and "Full Frontal" host Samantha Bee about navigating the challenges of responding to national tragedies on a comedy program. The conversation centers specifically on Bee's impassioned and unflinching response to the Orlando nightclub shooting, and expands to explore her approach to political comedy, her personal sensibility, and how her show differentiates itself in the crowded landscape of late-night television.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
Responding to Tragedy on Television
-
Immediate Decision-Making After Tragedy
- Samantha Bee and her staff began discussing how to address the Orlando shooting on their Sunday morning editorial call.
- Bee shares that the decision to address the event head-on, setting aside their planned first act, was unanimous and instinctive for her team.
“It was really a no brainer for our show. Everybody got behind that immediately.” — Samantha Bee [03:03]
-
Breaking Away from ‘Standard Operating Procedure’
- Bee refused the usual platitudes of late-night responses ("love wins", etc.), opting for honest anger and direct engagement:
"I am too angry for that. Love does not win unless we start loving each other enough to fix our problems." — Samantha Bee (monologue) [03:55]
- Bee refused the usual platitudes of late-night responses ("love wins", etc.), opting for honest anger and direct engagement:
-
Balancing Grief and Comedy
- Bee admits she wrestled most with her own tone and performance, struggling to keep from crying on air:
“I really didn’t want to cry. I really didn’t want to cry.” — Samantha Bee [04:36]
“It took a long day of crying... I think that's really healthy. ... But I really didn’t want to do it in this performance.” — Samantha Bee [04:57]
- Bee admits she wrestled most with her own tone and performance, struggling to keep from crying on air:
Navigating Anger, Humor, and Purpose
-
Comedy in the Face of Horrors
- Bee’s team operates largely on instinct, working from the gut even amidst tragedy:
“We do recognize that we’re a comedy show. ... Our gut tells us when we can make a joke.” — Samantha Bee [06:22]
- Her writing and research staff contribute heavily to finding this difficult balance.
- Bee’s team operates largely on instinct, working from the gut even amidst tragedy:
-
Influence of Jon Stewart and ‘The Daily Show’ Legacy
- Samantha credits Stewart’s authentic response to 9/11 as transformative for her, shaping the expectation that topical comedy must address major events:
“His reaction was monumental for me. ... There was a Jon Stewart effect from that.” — Samantha Bee [07:09]
- Samantha credits Stewart’s authentic response to 9/11 as transformative for her, shaping the expectation that topical comedy must address major events:
The Unique Voice of “Full Frontal”
-
Making the Show Distinct
- For Bee, the ambition for her show isn't glory, but the shared pleasure and authenticity of creating the program with her team:
“My ambition for the show at the moment is to keep this feeling of pure enjoyment.” — Samantha Bee [08:52]
- For Bee, the ambition for her show isn't glory, but the shared pleasure and authenticity of creating the program with her team:
-
From Shyness to Stage Presence
- Surprisingly, Bee confides she is still quite shy and masks it skillfully. For her, performance is a communal, energetic exchange with the audience:
“Their energy and their desire to be there... feeds my tender ego ... there is a back and forth.” — Samantha Bee [10:03]
- Surprisingly, Bee confides she is still quite shy and masks it skillfully. For her, performance is a communal, energetic exchange with the audience:
Political Climate & Media Responsibility
-
Covering the 2016 Election
- Bee acknowledges this election cycle is uniquely extreme, citing the rise of “authoritarian demagogues,” but maintains that all serious and unserious candidates must be covered:
“Many unserious people have run for president, and you have to cover them. They are running for president.” — Samantha Bee [11:09]
- Bee acknowledges this election cycle is uniquely extreme, citing the rise of “authoritarian demagogues,” but maintains that all serious and unserious candidates must be covered:
-
Comedy’s Obligation to ‘Fairness’
- Bee explains her evolution from the ‘Daily Show’ structure (with its fake reporter persona) toward more transparent and honest conversations with interview subjects, exemplified in her frank exchanges with Trump supporters:
"We’ve just completely lost that artifice here. Now it’s much more about me just having conversations. ... I don’t hide my point of view at all." — Samantha Bee [13:21]
- Bee explains her evolution from the ‘Daily Show’ structure (with its fake reporter persona) toward more transparent and honest conversations with interview subjects, exemplified in her frank exchanges with Trump supporters:
Facing Ongoing Tragedy in America
- The Grim Normalcy of Mass Shootings
- Bee and Remnick reflect on the tragic expectation that more mass shootings will occur. She reluctantly recognizes that preparing to address such events has become a grim routine:
“That is the saddest thing that anyone could say. ... But it’s really not fun to try to put a comedy show together after something like that has happened. And we really deserve better.” — Samantha Bee [14:16]
- Bee and Remnick reflect on the tragic expectation that more mass shootings will occur. She reluctantly recognizes that preparing to address such events has become a grim routine:
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
-
On Rejecting Platitudes After Tragedy:
"I am too angry for that. Love does not win unless we start loving each other enough to fix our problems."
— Samantha Bee (monologue) [03:55] -
On Laughing and Mourning Simultaneously:
“How do you figure out this very uncanny balance of rage and anger and at the same time making some pretty amazing jokes?”
— David Remnick [06:03] -
On Her Goals for 'Full Frontal':
"My ambition for the show at the moment is to keep this feeling of pure enjoyment... how much pleasure it gives me to do the show."
— Samantha Bee [08:52] -
On Audience Connection and Stage Shyness:
“I’m still quite shy. I’m just excellent at masking that now. ... There is a back and forth.”
— Samantha Bee [09:39], [10:03] -
On Media Responsibility in the Trump Era:
“Many unserious people have run for president, and you have to cover them. They are running for president.”
— Samantha Bee [11:09] -
On Open Dialogue and Authenticity:
“I don’t hide my point of view at all. ... That conversation is a great example of that.”
— Samantha Bee [13:21] -
On the Recurrence of National Tragedy:
“We really deserve better.”
— Samantha Bee [14:46]
Suggested Timestamps for Reference
- [03:37-04:05] — Samantha Bee’s post-Orlando monologue, rejecting empty platitudes
- [04:36-04:57] — Bee discusses her emotional struggle not to cry, and the catharsis of grief
- [07:09-07:32] — Samantha reflects on the influence of Jon Stewart's response to tragedy
- [08:52-09:03] — On the ambition and spirit behind "Full Frontal"
- [11:09-11:19] — Samantha on the necessity of covering all candidates
- [13:21-13:42] — Bee on shifting to honest, open field conversations from fake reporter shtick
- [14:16-14:46] — Confronting the likely recurrence of gun violence and mass shootings
Tone & Language
Samantha Bee is frank, self-deprecating, and passionate throughout. The conversation is direct, emotionally open, yet laced with Bee's signature humor—even when the issues are at their most grave. The tone is empathetic, engaged, and never detached.
Summary Takeaway
This episode offers a rare, intimate look into how a satirical news host handles the emotional, political, and creative demands of responding to tragedy on a comedy show. Samantha Bee’s candor about her anger, grief, and ambition for authenticity, as well as her refusal to cloak discomfort with platitudes, sets her apart. The episode is illuminating for media and comedy fans, and for anyone thinking about how public figures articulate a call to action in the aftermath of violence.