Podcast Summary: The Prosecutors - Episode 322: The West Memphis 3 Part 21 -- Alternative Suspects

Introduction

In Episode 322 of The Prosecutors, hosted by Brett and Alice from PodcastOne, the focus shifts to exploring alternative suspects in the infamous West Memphis Three case. This episode delves deep into various individuals who have been considered or rumored to be involved in the 1993 murders of three young boys in West Memphis, Arkansas. The hosts aim to provide a comprehensive overview of these suspects, examining the evidence and discrepancies surrounding each case.

Main Discussion: Alternative Suspects

1. L.G. Hollingsworth and Richard Simpson

   • Background: L.G. Hollingsworth, a 17-year-old at the time, and his friend Richard Simpson, a 49-year-old building inspector, became points of interest for police shortly after the murders. Both were associated with Tri State Word Ministries.

   • Evidence and Alibi Issues:

     • Motive and Behavior: Charlie Suggs reported that the duo were involved in devil worship, finding hand tools, plastic ties, and handcuffs in their vehicle. Their departure from West Memphis shortly after the murders raised suspicions.
     • Polygraph Results: Richard Simpson passed a polygraph test, but the examiner noted potential countermeasures, suggesting deceit ("[04:09] Brett: …try to elevate your heart rate, elevate your breathing…").

   • Inconsistencies:

     • Alibi Discrepancies: Richard Simpson stated he did not see L.G. Hollingsworth on the night of the murders, conflicting with L.G.'s claim of being with Simpson during the critical time frame.
     • Revised Statements: L.G. revised his alibi multiple times, leading to questions about the authenticity of his confessions and statements.

   • Notable Quote:

     "If you think that Jesse Misskelley in his Bible confession is just pulling from things he learned in the trial...," Alice comments on the credibility of confessions influenced by trial testimonies. ([06:30])

2. James Martin

   • Profile: A registered sex offender described by police as "crazy," James Martin provided a lengthy and detailed interview suggesting insights into the crime based on his experiences with other offenders.

   • Key Insights from Martin:

     • Murder Modus Operandi: Martin theorized that a single perpetrator, motivated initially by sexual molestation, mistakenly killed the boys to silence them.
     • Location and Evidence Considerations: He suggested the murders occurred in a secluded area close to the scene to hinder police investigations.

   • Polygraph Test:

     • Results: Mixed outcomes were reported, with indications of deception regarding the bindings and the perpetrator's identity, yet no direct involvement.

   • Notable Quote:

     "He would probably kill all three individuals," Alice summarizes Martin's depiction of the murder scenario. ([28:00])

3. Richard Cummings

   • Background: Known as a resident of Mayfair Apartments and notorious for drilling holes in walls, Richard Cummings surfaced as a suspect due to his suspicious behavior and proximity to the crime scene.

   • Evidence:

     • Lost Evidence: Police reportedly found a box in his apartment that they refused to open, leading to speculation about concealed evidence.
     • Misidentification Issues: Multiple individuals named Richard Cummings have caused confusion, including a wrongly identified convicted sex offender from Alabama.

   • Challenges:

     • Dead End: The real Richard Cummings unrelated to the case has led to misinformation, complicating genuine investigative leads.

   • Notable Quote:

     "If I were the police and I did that DNA testing and I found any unknown DNA, I might consider seeing if I could test it against Richard Cummings," Brett remarks on the lost blood evidence. ([47:30])

4. Mr. Bojangles

   • Incident Overview: A distressed man, referred to as Mr. Bojangles, was found bleeding and muddy at a Bojangles restaurant shortly after the murders. His visit raised immediate red flags due to the proximity and condition resembling potential involvement.

   • Police Handling:

     • Evidence Mismanagement: Blood samples collected from the restaurant were lost, eliminating a potential key lead.
     • Timeline Discrepancies: The timeframes of Mr. Bojangles' presence and the murders conflict, casting doubt on his involvement.

   • Behavioral Analysis:

     • Inconsistencies: Brett and Alice discuss how Mr. Bojangles' disoriented and public behavior post-incident does not align with typical perpetrator profiles seeking to conceal crimes.

   • Notable Quote:

     "It's a massive, massive screw up," Alice criticizes the police's mishandling of Mr. Bojangles' evidence. ([52:05])

5. Terry Hobbs

   • Profile: Terry Hobbs, the stepfather of one of the victims, became a prominent alternative suspect due to allegations of abuse and inconsistencies in his timeline on the day of the murders.

   • Evidence Against Hobbs:

     • Abuse Claims: Allegations from family members point to Terry's abusive behavior towards his stepson, Stevie Branch.
     • Hair Evidence: A hair found in the ligature binding was linked to Terry, although DNA analysis could not definitively connect it due to low specificity.
     • Timeline Conflicts: Terry's statements about his whereabouts on the day of the murders do not align with witness testimonies, creating significant doubt about his involvement.

   • Legal Actions:

     • Defamation Lawsuit: In 2009, Terry sued Natalie Maines of the Dixie Chicks for defamation after she publicly supported the innocence of the West Memphis Three, leading to further scrutiny of his actions and statements.

   • Notable Quote:

     "It would have taken him a lot of effort as well to clean himself off and make sure the car was clean," Brett explains the logistical challenges Terry would face if he were the perpetrator. ([60:24])

Conclusion and Future Episodes

As Episode 322 concludes, Brett and Alice underscore the complexity of the West Memphis Three case, highlighting how numerous alternative suspects present a tangled web of evidence and speculation. They emphasize the importance of scrutinizing timelines and the credibility of each suspect's statements. The hosts also tease upcoming episodes, including an exclusive interview with Terry Hobbs, aiming to shed more light on his potential involvement and to explore the psychological profile of the true perpetrator.

Notable Quotes from Conclusion:

"It's 30 something years later, there's just so much information that is just accepted as fact," Alice reflects on the enduring mystery of the case. ([94:45])

"Once again, as our pedophile expert told us, if you have more than a couple people, somebody's going to talk," Brett cautions against overcomplicating the suspect list. ([95:27])

Final Thoughts

Episode 322 serves as a critical examination of the West Memphis Three case, encouraging listeners to question established narratives and consider a broader range of suspects. By meticulously analyzing each alternative suspect's background, actions, and the evidence against them, Brett and Alice provide a nuanced perspective that invites further discussion and investigation into one of America's most perplexing cold cases.

Follow Us

For more in-depth discussions and access to exclusive content, join The Prosecutors community on Patreon or connect with us via our official channels. Stay tuned for the next episode where we will delve deeper into Terry Hobbs' role and uncover new facets of this enduring mystery.