Can't Get My Family Together To Agree On A Will

Summary

The Ramsey Show Highlights: "Can't Get My Family Together To Agree On A Will"

Release Date: April 5, 2025
Host/Author: Ramsey Network

---

Introduction

In this episode of The Ramsey Show Highlights, the Ramsey Network tackles a poignant and often sensitive topic: family disagreements over wills and estate planning. Titled "Can't Get My Family Together To Agree On A Will," the episode provides listeners with real-life scenarios, expert advice, and practical solutions to navigate the complexities of estate planning within a family dynamic.

Caller’s Background and Situation

The episode begins with a heartfelt call from a listener who experiences the aftermath of her father's sudden passing due to cancer in 2012. The caller shares that her father did not leave a well-structured will, leaving directives vague and incomplete. This lack of clarity led to significant confusion and complications following her father's death.

Notable Quote:
Caller (00:13): "My dad passed away suddenly from cancer. I'm sorry. And he didn't have a very concise will put together. He had, you know, directives."

Complications Arising from the Lack of a Clear Will

The caller explains that her father was responsible for caring for his mother, who was suffering from dementia and Alzheimer's. Six months after her father's death, her grandmother also passed away, further complicating the estate distribution. Due to the incomplete will, assets that were supposed to be allocated to the children, grandchildren, and cousins were left unresolved, ultimately resulting in everything being transferred to the caller’s aunt's name without probate proceedings.

Notable Quote:
Caller (00:47): "Everything's in my aunt's name because my dad's will was not in good shape, but my grandmother's was, and she died after my dad, so nothing went to him."

Current Challenges and Family Dynamics

The caller highlights her current predicament: she is the sole family member with a steady job, and she is now responsible for managing the inherited properties. Her aunt, who now holds the assets, is experiencing mental decline, further complicating matters. Despite the apparent consensus on who should inherit what, familial tensions surface over personal effects and properties owned by her aunt and her late husband.

Notable Quote:
Caller (02:06): "The biggest struggle is my aunt's two children. The only bicker is over her own personal effects that she had, and her husband had the properties."

Advisors’ Insights and Recommendations

The advisors on the show delve into the legal and emotional facets of the situation, offering practical advice to the caller. They emphasize the importance of having a clear and legally binding will to prevent such conflicts. The advisors discuss the potential loss of the caller’s properties if the aunt does not formalize her intentions through legal documentation.

Notable Quote:
Advisor (03:00): "If your aunt does not leave them to you or deed them to you prior to your death, you're going to lose them because you do not have any standing in this family anymore."

Proposed Solutions and Legal Steps

The advisors suggest actionable steps to rectify the situation. They recommend that the caller and her siblings engage in a direct and honest conversation with their aunt to urge her to create a will. Additionally, they propose the use of quitclaim deeds to transfer property ownership legally and minimize potential tax implications.

Notable Quote:
Advisor (06:08): "Go see an attorney, have that drawn up for each property and then have a notary notarize them and then you file them at the courthouse and the property is then in your name."

Addressing Familial Resistance

Understanding the emotional barriers, the advisors recognize that direct confrontation, such as using a headlock metaphorically, may not be effective given the family's dynamics. Instead, they advocate for respectful yet firm discussions about fairness and the necessity of formalizing the estate to prevent future disputes.

Notable Quote:
Caller (04:28): "But headcuts won't work. They're a bunch of hillbillies, so. Yeah, we all are, actually."

Advisor’s Compassionate Approach:
Advisor (04:42): "Do you think it's fair that I lose these properties because you won't sit down with your mom and get this other stuff worked out? I don't think that's fair."

Tax Implications and Legal Formalities

The conversation also touches upon the potential tax consequences of transferring property without proper legal channels. The advisors explain the gift tax and estate tax considerations, highlighting the importance of legal documentation to avoid unnecessary financial burdens.

Notable Quote:
Advisor (05:10): "She'll have a shove a gift tax on them. Well, she could, actually, but she could avoid it by doing a unified estate tax planning document."

Final Counsel and Emphasis on Will Creation

Concluding the discussion, the advisors reiterate the critical importance of having a will, regardless of the complexity of the estate. They encourage listeners to take proactive steps in estate planning to ensure clarity and fairness among family members, preventing similar disputes.

Notable Quote:
Advisor (07:27): "Everyone needs a will. Hello, everybody needs a will if you need it. If you got a simple estate, go to Mama Bear Legal forms dot com. It's very inexpensive."

Conclusion

This episode of The Ramsey Show Highlights serves as a crucial reminder of the importance of comprehensive estate planning. Through the caller's experience, listeners gain insight into the potential pitfalls of neglecting to formalize a will and the ensuing family conflicts that can arise. The expert advice provided underscores the necessity of clear legal documentation to safeguard one's assets and ensure equitable distribution, fostering harmony and preventing familial strife.

---

For more insights and advice on life and money, tune into The Ramsey Show Highlights, part of the Ramsey Network, available seven days a week.

Transcript

[Host]

Brought to you by chm, a biblically based alternative to health insurance. Learn [e-mail] Budget In 2012, my dad.

[Caller]

Passed away suddenly from cancer. I'm sorry. And he didn't have a very concise will put together. He had, you know, directives. When he died, he was taking care of his mother, who was suffering from dementia and Alzheimer's. Six months after he died, she died. And that left everything that was supposed to go to kids and grandkids and cousins kind of up in the air. And then eventually everything was in my aunt's name.

[Advisor]

How so?

[Caller]

Yeah. So how now end up in her name?

[Co-Advisor]

Probate. She was the deciding that.

[Caller]

No. No probate. No probate. Somehow we skated by probate. Nobody was arguing about anything. My aunt happened to be the last surviving child, and it just. It just went everything into my aunt's name because my dad's will was not in good shape, but my. My grandmother's was, but she died after my dad, so nothing went to him. So I am in a position now to where, like, I'm the only person who has a steady job out of my siblings. And I'm trying to get my siblings and my cousins together because my. My aunt's husband is also dead. So it's just my aunt, and she's kind of going into a little bit of a mental decline. My siblings are. Are. Okay. Everybody knows who's supposed to get what from the end. My cousins. Yeah, from. From the aunt, because she's okay with everybody getting what they were supposed to get in the beginning. Oh, the cousins. Nobody's arguing about anything that they're supposed to get.

[Advisor]

She's not put it down in a.

[Co-Advisor]

Will, and there's no judge involved.

[Caller]

Correct. Okay, so what we've got. This. This is. This is the. The biggest struggle is my aunt's two children. The only bicker is over her own personal effects that she had, and her husband had the properties. Nothing to anything my grandmother had. They're fighting over those things, and it's making it difficult for any of the rest of us to get a regular will set up.

[Advisor]

Okay, well.

[Co-Advisor]

What'S the value of all this stuff? This, if you had to guess.

[Caller]

Okay, so I. I'm gonna be. I'm. I'm collecting rent on two homes. There's no mortgages. Everything's paid for. There's no mortgages. I'm collecting rent on two together, they're about 375.

[Advisor]

Those are to become yours.

[Caller]

Yeah.

[Advisor]

Okay. All right. If I were in your shoes, have you sat down in person and talked to your aunt and asked her to do a will?

[Caller]

Yes, I have.

[Advisor]

And what did she say?

[Caller]

She is reluctant to go along with it unless her two kids agree on what is supposed to be divided. That was my aunt's and her husband's.

[Co-Advisor]

Do either of her kids. Have you said she's got mental decline? Do either of them have, like, power of attorney or is that on track to start at any point?

[Advisor]

Are the two. The two houses that you have, are they in your name or your aunt's name?

[Caller]

Everything's in the aunt's name.

[Advisor]

You're going to manage those, okay? If your aunt does not leave them to you or deed them to you prior to your death, you're going to lose them because you do not have any standing in this family anymore. She has confiscated all the assets into her name. Her assets, if there is no will, will go to her children. You're going to lose these houses, and I.

[Caller]

That. That's my struggle.

[Advisor]

No, you are. I mean, there's no question. If you don't get this done, this is a $400,000 problem for you and your brother and your sister. So if I'm you and your brother and your sister, I'm gonna grab my cousins and put them in a headlock and go, all right, you twerps, we need to get this straightened out, because I'm not letting you take these houses. They all need to get over there with your mama and get this written.

[Caller]

Down that that's what we're struggling to do. Do you have, like, any suggestions and, like, how to speak to them in such a manner? Because headlock. Headlocks won't work. They're a bunch of hillbillies, so. Yeah, we all are, actually.

[Advisor]

But, you know, I mean, I just sit down with them and go, okay, do you think it's fair that I lose these properties because you won't sit down with your mom and get this other stuff worked out? I don't think that's fair.

[Caller]

Okay.

[Advisor]

And the other thing you could do is you could go to your aunt and ask her to quit, claim, deed the properties to you.

[Caller]

Okay, so when. If that was to occur, would there be, like, some sort of, like, net gain tax?

[Advisor]

Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. She'll have a shove a gift tax on them. Well, she could, actually, but she could avoid it by doing a unified estate tax planning document. But that. That's. It's easier to just do a will. But I can. You know, there's a thing. Write this down. Unified Estate tax. Okay. If the estate tax is still in place and Trump, the GOP is currently looking at doing away with it on the federal level. But if that's still in place, you can use up some of her estate tax exemptions by, against her gift tax. So she would not have gift tax if she files that document. But I've got a feeling this bunch of people doesn't file documents. They just kind of make up whatever they want to do and think it works.

[Caller]

And that's how it's been.

[Advisor]

Yeah, that's their problem, though. They have the gift tax, not you. So I'm going to go over there and say, auntie, here's two, here's two quick claim deeds. I need you to sign these so the properties are in my name.

[Caller]

Okay?

[Advisor]

That's the easiest, cleanest thing you can do here. And your brother sisters do the same thing because I'm afraid, because otherwise this is going to go to your kids and that's not fair. I need you to sign them right now. I'm not getting up from this table until you sign these because they were supposed to go to my dad and they're supposed to go to me, and you know that. And I need you to sign these and put these properties in my name. That's a, that's a one page document, a quit claim deed. Go see an attorney, have that drawn up for each property and then have a notary notarize them and then you file them at the courthouse and the property is then in your name. It's over. Now, she technically would have been due gift tax on that, and she can avoid that within 12 months of her signing that over to you if she files under the Unified Estate Tax Credit Program. But I got a feeling this lady's not doing any of that.

[Caller]

She doesn't. This is a lady. She's never even never had a job.

[Advisor]

Yeah, I know. I can tell.

[Caller]

I mean, she's raised, she's raised kids. I mean, that's work, too. I mean.

[Advisor]

No, I don't mean that she's not got any level of financial sophistication.

[Caller]

Not at all.

[Advisor]

Yeah, and so I'm like, yeah, and so you got it. You got to roll over there and you're. Otherwise you're going to lose $400,000. That, that's the problem here, folks. In America, everybody needs a will. Hello, Everybody needs a will if you need it. If you got a simple estate, go to Mama Bear Legal forms dot com. It's very inexpensive. You can have it done by morning if you got a complicated estate, sit down with an estate planning attorney. But everybody needs a will. It's not fair to the people. You look at what his dad and his grandmother have done to him by screwing around and not writing this stuff down. That's wrong, y'all. You need to take care of your family better than that.

[Host]

CHM isn't health insurance. It's a health cost sharing ministry. Check it out for [e-mail] budget.