Is My Husband Financially Abusing Me?

Summary

Episode Overview

Main Theme:
This episode of The Ramsey Show Highlights tackles the critical issue of financial abuse within marriage. A caller, Maggie, voices concern over her husband’s controlling financial behaviors and seeks advice: Is this simply poor financial management or is it financial abuse? Hosts George Kamel and Dr. John Delony listen, ask clarifying questions, and offer practical and compassionate guidance for anyone in a financially controlling relationship.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

Maggie’s Situation (00:06–03:12)

• Financial Dependence and Control:
  Maggie, a stay-at-home mom of six for over 20 years, describes increasing financial restrictions. Her husband artificially reduces their accessible family income and hides savings accounts from her, where once she had access via budgeting apps.
• Loss of Financial Visibility:
  Maggie no longer has visibility or control over the family’s finances, leading to the exhaustion of readily available savings—especially problematic during a family medical crisis.
• Credit Card Manipulation:
  Maggie’s husband moves her off the family credit card and demands she use a new card solely in her name, threatening to refuse payment if she overspends and to ruin her credit.
  • Notable Quote – Maggie (02:22):
    “He threatened to ruin my credit and not to pay anything that went over. So now I feel really nervous to use that credit card at all...”
• No Debit Card or Full Account Access:
  Maggie doesn't have a debit card—even though her name is (eventually clarified to be) on the family bank account.

---

Identifying Financial Abuse (03:12–04:43)

• Immediate Practical Advice:
  George recommends Maggie go to the bank to get her own debit card so she can directly access funds and avoid accruing debt on a credit card.
  • Notable Quote – George (03:14):
    “You should be able to get access to a card tied to that account. You can go down to the bank and ask for one. Okay, I would do that today.”
• Dr. Delony Confirms Abuse:
  Dr. Delony firmly identifies the behavior as financial abuse, with controlling patterns likely extending beyond money:
  • Notable Quote – Dr. Delony (03:39):
    “This is...100% a financially abusive situation. So tell me. I guarantee you this is not the only place that he’s asserting control.”

---

Emotional and Relational Dynamics (04:43–05:51)

• Asserting Autonomy:
  Maggie has begun working with a therapist to establish personal boundaries (e.g., refusing to be berated in person, opting for email communication).
• Past Patterns:
  The controlling and berating behaviors pre-date their marriage.
• Hope for Change vs. Reality:
  Maggie hopes her husband will change (“The Lord told me”), but the hosts probe the likelihood and conditions under which real change might happen.
• Maggie’s Safety:
  Delony gently suggests that Maggie could be safe and separate while her husband works on his own issues, challenging the belief that she must stay in the house for him to improve.

---

Protecting Herself – Practical & Ethical Guidance (05:55–06:58)

• Handling Separate Money:
  Maggie asks if it’s right or wrong to deposit a Christmas check, given to her, into her own account. Both hosts affirm that at this point she needs to protect herself:
  • Notable Quote – George (06:33):
    “That is actually wise to do in this moment. And I know God told you, but it doesn’t mean that this marriage survives.”
• Unlikely Turnarounds:
  George tempers expectations, suggesting that sudden transparency or change is unlikely without direct intervention:
  • Notable Quote – George (06:57):
    “I’m not a betting man, but I’m betting he’s not going to change tomorrow and just go, wow, I had a revelation...”

---

The Need for Safety and Transparency (06:58–08:32)

• Emphasizing the Children:
  Dr. Delony stresses the importance of safety for Maggie and their six children, prioritizing their well-being over the husband’s comfort.
  • Notable Quote – Dr. Delony (07:31):
    “If you’re home taking care of the kids but you’re not allowed access to money that it takes to do such work. Then what are we even...what are we doing here?”
• Financial Infidelity Suspicions:
  George raises the possibility of deeper financial secrets (“financial infidelity”) and underscores the need for full transparency in healthy marriages.

---

What a Healthy Marriage Looks Like & Next Steps (08:32–09:41)

• Healthy Financial Partnership:
  George contrasts Maggie’s situation with his own marriage, where both partners have full access and there are no secrets in the accounts:
  • Notable Quote – George (08:32):
    “My wife stays at home. She has full access and transparency into everything that we do. There are no hidden accounts. There’s no mine in hers...That is a healthy marriage.”
• “Come to Jesus” Moment:
  The hosts urge counseling as a last resort—ideally together, but Maggie should go alone if her husband won’t participate. The ultimate priority is safety.
• Red Flags Beyond Finances:
  Dr. Delony: Patterns of control and lack of willingness to change or attend counseling are deep red flags.
  • Notable Quote – Dr. Delony (09:03):
    “These characteristics float into all the other areas of our life...And I know based on what you said, what you’re experiencing is not just happening with the bank account. There’s a control issue here.”

---

Important Timestamps

• 00:06 – Maggie introduces her concern about possible financial abuse.
• 00:19–02:22 – Details her financial dependency, hidden accounts, and losing account access.
• 03:14 – George’s advice to get a debit card for direct access to the shared bank account.
• 03:39 – Dr. Delony names the situation as financial abuse.
• 04:06–05:51 – Maggie describes her efforts to assert autonomy; hosts underscore emotional abuse and question safety.
• 06:20 – Maggie asks about handling a check in her name, leading to advice to protect herself.
• 07:31 – Delony’s strong statement on the implications for Maggie and the children.
• 08:32 – George describes financial transparency in healthy marriages.
• 09:03 – Dr. Delony summarizes the core (control) issue and urges Maggie to keep herself and her kids safe.

---

Memorable Quotes

• “This is...100% a financially abusive situation.” – Dr. John Delony (03:39)
• “He threatened to ruin my credit and not to pay anything that went over. So now I feel really nervous to use that credit card at all...” – Maggie (02:22)
• “That is actually wise to do in this moment...” – George Kamel (06:33)
• “If you’re home taking care of the kids but you’re not allowed access to money that it takes to do such work. Then what are we even...what are we doing here?” – Dr. John Delony (07:31)
• “There has to be a come to Jesus moment...If this is going to work, you’re coming with me and we’re going to figure this out.” – George Kamel (08:55)
• “Money touches everything. And it’s never just compartmentalized. It’s never just money. These characteristics float into all the other areas of our life.” – Dr. John Delony (09:03)

---

Tone and Takeaways

• Tone: Compassionate, direct, and urgent—hosts approach Maggie’s situation with empathy but underscore seriousness and risks.
• Takeaways:
  • Financial control, hiding assets, and limiting access constitute financial abuse.
  • Immediate steps: secure direct account access and protect personal funds.
  • True marital partnership requires financial transparency.
  • The deeper issue is unhealthy control, not just “money problems.”
  • Counseling is vital, but individual safety for Maggie and her children is most important.

---

This episode offers real, actionable advice and emotional support to anyone experiencing financial control in a relationship, making it essential listening—or reading—for individuals who need help identifying unhealthy patterns in their own lives.

Transcript

[A]

Brought to you by the EveryDollar app. Start budgeting for free today.

[B]

I'm trying to find out if the way my husband is treating me financially is considered abusive or if it's acceptable and what I should do.

[C]

Tell us more.

[B]

I'm in my mid-40s. So is he. And we have six kids. And I have been financially dependent on him for 20 years. Well, more than that, our entire marriage. I don't work, and I've never worked. Last year, he. He artificially reduced the amount of money in our family income so that it was below how much we needed to have just sufficient funds. And so over the course of the year, we basically blew through all of the extra savings that were in that account. And then towards the end of the year, there were some medical problems with our family, and we really tipped the budget over the top. We did not go into debt because he's putting aside money somewhere else. Also, where do you know he's putting it into savings accounts. I used to be able to see them, but I can't see them anymore because he hid them. He. Like, I don't, because I'm dependent and I'm not really that into the finances stuff. Like, I could see them through a budgeting app, but now I can't.

[C]

So. Yes. And that was all intentional question? Yes.

[A]

And he's doing this to punish you?

[B]

Yes. So he sent me a text saying that since I wasn't ready to talk to him, he just went ahead and made decisions himself. And so he cut me off from the family credit card, which was in his name. Right. It was a card for him. And he told me that he had reduced the amount in our family budget more substantially and that he told me to use a credit card that two months before then he had asked me to open in my own name. And I didn't know that that was going to be a problem, but now he wants me to use that, and obviously that makes me financially responsible. But he said he threatened to ruin my credit and not to pay anything that went over. So now I feel really nervous to use that credit card at all because I'm not the only one drawing from this account like he draws from the account.

[A]

So he's controlling what amount is even in the account for you to spend on the family?

[B]

Yes.

[A]

So can you use a debit card attached to that bank account?

[B]

I don't yet have a debit card, but if that's a good option, then I could go.

[A]

So your name isn't even on the bank account.

[D]

This show is Sponsored by Better Help. No matter if you just met someone or if you have been married forever, no one has all of the relationship answers. But therapy can help you figure things out. And to do that, I recommend BetterHelp. Better Help is an online therapy platform with over 30,000 licensed therapists. And they're trusted by millions of people around the world. When it comes to love and relationships, everyone is still finding their way. Find yours with my friends at BetterHelp. Visit betterhelp.com Ramsey to get 10% off your first month.

[A]

Your name isn't even on the bank account.

[B]

It is. My name is on the bank account.

[A]

So you should be able to get access to a card tied to that account. You can go down to the bank and ask for one. Okay, I would do that today. And that way you don't need to use this credit card. You don't need to even have the chance of racking up any debt. And then it becomes an issue of, hey, we don't have enough to cover the bills. And I don't even know what we need to cover because you have access to everything and won't let me even see it. And so you guys have some deep marriage issues, and the financial part is just a symptom.

[C]

Yeah, this is for me. It's a major problem for me. This has nothing to do with finances. I mean, obviously what George said is important just for the here and now, but this guy is 100% controlling, and that's 100% a financially abusive situation. So tell me. I guarantee you this is not the only place that he's asserting control. Guaranteed.

[B]

Well, I've recently been walking out of that with a therapist because I've just started to assert my own autonomy.

[C]

Okay, what does that mean?

[B]

I stopped presenting things to him as a, can I do this? Or whatever, and just doing what I need to do, like, I'm not doing anything stupid. I'm running a house.

[C]

And what does that work?

[B]

Well, sort of. He's not happy about it, but. Yeah, he's not like. Like, the only escalation is him. I don't know. I guess you could call it like, berating or that kind of thing. Not. He's not like, physical or anything, but.

[C]

And you're okay with that?

[B]

Well, I. I do believe that he will get better.

[A]

What makes you believe that?

[B]

The Lord told me.

[C]

How long have you been married?

[B]

Over 20 years.

[C]

And how. How long has he been asserting this berating behavior?

[B]

Since before we got married. But I was also a part of that. Can I ask you A question like that.

[C]

Can I ask you just a. You went there, so I'm going to go there with you. Do you think that you have to be in the house for him to get better, or do you think you could be somewhere safe and he could get better? You think he. Do you think you have to be there for him to berate you, or do you think that you could be somewhere safe, him not berate you and get better?

[B]

So that's kind of like what caused this whole thing is that I basically refused to sit there and listen to him berate me. And I told him that I wanted to have conversations by email, so that's why he said that I wasn't talking to him.

[C]

Understood. But you're still living in the house. No.

[B]

Yes.

[C]

Okay.

[B]

And most of the days are peaceful. It's just. Yeah. He has some growing to do, for sure.

[C]

Understood. Okay.

[B]

Well, I have one other question about money. He. We got Christmas gifts that were like a check. I got one in my name. He got one in his name. And. And I mentioned putting mine in my own private account. He didn't like that. He said that that needed a lot more conversation. So I was really wanting to know if it's wise or foolish of me to put this large cash sum into.

[A]

At this point, you're protecting yourself because I don't know if this marriage is going to survive. And so at this point, you have to then go, I need to create my own bubble over here because this person isn't safe.

[C]

Yeah, I would 100% say that.

[B]

Okay.

[A]

So that is actually wise to do in this moment. And I know God told you, but it doesn't mean that this marriage survives. Sometimes He.

[C]

He.

[A]

Maybe it takes this marriage not working for him to get better. I don't know. I hope this marriage survives, but I'm also not. I'm not a betting man, but I'm betting he's not going to change tomorrow and just go, wow, I had a revelation. I've decided to give you full access to the accounts and be transparent for the rest of my life.

[B]

Right.

[C]

I'm also thinking about your safety and security. You're just not in a financially safe or secure environment. Therefore, your kids are not either. So there's part of me that is. I'm. I'm way more concerned with that. Obviously, you called this show than I am with his comfort at this point at all. Because there's kids involved. And if you can't have. If you can't have access, if you're home taking care of the kids. But. But you're not allowed access to money that it takes to do such work. Then what are we even. What are we doing here?

[B]

Right.

[C]

So I'm concerned about that. I'm with George.

[A]

I have a concern. There's also something more nefarious happening, some financial infidelity on his part of why he's hiding this. If you are correct, and that there is no wild overspending happening, then he's hiding this for a different reason that may be beyond just control because he doesn't trust you. And so that is also something to consider here. And so I would demand transparency. I would demand that you have equal access to the money and that you have an equal vote in this marriage.

[B]

Yeah.

[A]

And if that doesn't happen, then you guys need to go to counseling. And if he's unwilling to go to counseling, you go alone. And then you'll have to make your own decisions on whether this is safe and healthy.

[C]

Does he go to counseling or is he willing to go?

[B]

We've tried in the past, but, yeah, he left it. Didn't want to do it anymore.

[C]

Yeah.

[B]

Maggie, do you think then that it's wrong if he made the decision unilaterally not to put his entire income into the account?

[C]

Yeah, I think that's wrong.

[B]

Yes.

[C]

I think that's very.

[A]

My wife stays at home. She has full access and transparency into everything that we do. There are no hidden accounts. There's no mine in hers. She sees the budget, I see the budget. She can check the savings account at any moment. That is a healthy marriage. And any other picture is going to lead to unhealthy behaviors and an unhealthy marriage. And so we can't continue on this way and pretend like it's all going to work out.

[C]

Yeah.

[A]

There has to be a come to Jesus moment. And that means him going to counseling as a last ditch effort to go, hey, if this is going to work, you're coming with me and we're going to figure this out.

[C]

Yeah. I think, Maggie, from where you sit, you called about a financial issue. But, you know, George and I both know money touches everything. And. And it's never just compartmentalized. It's never just money. These. These characteristics float into all the other areas of our life. And I know based on what you said, what you're experiencing is not just happening with the bank account. There's a control issue here. And the fact that this other person is not interested in bettering themselves, whether it be through counseling or through changes of behavior that's That's a big red flag. And I know you've devoted 20 years to this thing, but, man, oh, man, please, please, please keep yourself and your kids safe and do what you need to do to do that.

[A]

Create your free every dollar budget today. The simplest way to budget for your life.