Should I Pull Money Out Of The Market?

Summary

Podcast Summary: The Ramsey Show Highlights – "Should I Pull Money Out Of The Market?"

Release Date: April 17, 2025
Host/Author: Ramsey Network
Duration: Under Ten Minutes

---

Introduction to the Caller’s Concern

In this episode of The Ramsey Show Highlights, a listener reaches out with concerns about the current state of the stock market. The caller, identified as James, expresses anxiety over economic instability, tariffs, and declining stock prices. He questions whether it’s prudent to withdraw his investments or continue holding them amidst the volatility.

Caller (00:10):
"Invested in the stock market right now, and with the current economic instability, with the tariffs and everything that's going on, you know, stock prices are dropping, and we're just wondering if I should consider pulling my money out of the stock market or just ride it out."

---

Experts’ Recommendations

Ride the Market Out

The initial response from Financial Expert 1 is straightforward:
Financial Expert 1 (00:31):
"Ride it out, my friend."

Echoing this sentiment, Financial Expert 2 delves deeper into the implications of pulling money out versus staying invested.

Understanding Market Fluctuations

Financial Expert 2 (01:31):
"History tells us when the stock market goes down, it’s always come back up higher than ever."

He reassures James by highlighting historical trends where, despite downturns, the market has consistently rebounded and reached new highs over time.

---

Importance of Consistent Investing

Buying When Stocks Are on Sale

The experts emphasize the strategy of investing consistently, especially during market dips. Financial Expert 2 uses relatable analogies and historical data to reinforce this approach.

Financial Expert 2 (02:13):
"Every time the headlines say, don’t Invest, pull your money out. It’s all coming crashing down. That’s the right time to invest."

He references a notable tweet illustrating that investing during turbulent times often results in significant returns in the following year, citing an average return of 40%.

---

Prioritizing Tax-Advantaged Accounts

Maximizing Retirement Accounts

The discussion shifts to the importance of prioritizing investments in tax-advantaged accounts such as Roth IRAs and Traditional IRAs over brokerage accounts.

Financial Expert 2 (03:00):
"Why aren't you investing in retirement accounts that are tax advantaged?"

James admits that while he has both a Roth IRA and a Traditional IRA, he hasn’t maximized his contributions. The experts advise redirecting investments to these accounts to take advantage of tax benefits, which can significantly enhance long-term growth.

---

Encouragement and Motivational Insights

Educational Resources and Encouragement

To provide James with further guidance, Financial Expert 2 recommends his book, "Breaking Free from Broke", specifically the chapter titled "Wealth is Patience." This resource aims to offer tactical information, encouragement, and a structured approach to investing.

Financial Expert 2 (03:45):
"Hang on the line. I'm going to send you a copy of my book Breaking Free from Broke. Read the wealth is Patience chapter."

Philosophy: Time in the Market vs. Timing the Market

A pivotal moment in the conversation is the introduction of the adage:

Financial Expert 2 (04:20):
"Time in the market beats timing the market."

This phrase encapsulates the core philosophy of maintaining investments over long periods rather than attempting to predict market movements, which can lead to adverse financial decisions.

Financial Expert 1 (04:37):
"That right there, my friend, is an axiom."

The experts exchange personal sayings to reinforce the message, fostering a sense of trust and reliability in their advice.

---

Conclusion

In summary, this episode of The Ramsey Show Highlights addresses common fears about market instability and offers practical, historically-backed advice to listeners. The experts advocate for maintaining steady investments, prioritizing tax-advantaged accounts, and avoiding reactionary decisions based on short-term market fluctuations. Through encouragement and educational resources, they empower listeners to make informed and confident financial decisions.

Notable Quotes:

• Financial Expert 2 (00:50):
  "History tells us when the stock market goes down, it’s always come back up higher than ever."

• Financial Expert 2 (02:13):
  "Every time the headlines say, don’t Invest, pull your money out. It’s all coming crashing down. That’s the right time to invest."

• Financial Expert 2 (04:20):
  "Time in the market beats timing the market."

---

This comprehensive summary equips listeners with key takeaways from the episode, emphasizing the importance of resilience and strategic investing in navigating market uncertainties.

Transcript

[Announcer]

Brought to you by chm, a biblically based alternative to health insurance. Learn [e-mail] budget I have some money.

[Caller]

Invested in the stock market right now, and with the current economic instability, with the tariffs and everything that's going on, you know, stock prices are dropping, and we're just wondering if. If I should consider pulling my money out of the stock market or just ride it out.

[Financial Expert 1]

Ride it out, my friend.

[Caller]

Ride it out.

[Financial Expert 1]

Yeah.

[Financial Expert 2]

What do you think is going to happen if you pull your money out?

[Caller]

Well. Well, it's gonna. It's not. It's not gonna. If I put it in the bank, it's not gonna fluctuate.

[Financial Expert 2]

So you're worried about fluctuation? I'm just trying to get to the root of your fear.

[Caller]

Rust.

[Financial Expert 2]

Okay.

[Caller]

Right.

[Financial Expert 2]

Well, here's what we found. History tells us when the stock market goes down, it's always come back up higher than ever. If you look at any crash, which we are not even close to right now, yes, we're seeing a dip. And if you zoom in, it's scary, but if you zoom out, you go, oh, we're still at, like, record highs. Okay? And so here's what I do. Here's what Ken does. Here's what Dave Ramsey does. We just keep investing when the market's down. You are buying when the stocks are on sale, my friend. When the market's up, we are thankful for growth. And so it's always a good time to invest. And, and you should never pull money out unless you're in retirement. You need a little bit of money for living. There's no reason to pull your money out of the stock market ever.

[Caller]

Okay. How old are you? That's exactly what I needed to hear. Just trying to get some. Some advice on that. Good.

[Financial Expert 2]

Don't. Don't look at. You've been looking at too many headlines going, ah, it's all going to come crashing down because guess what? That gets clicks and views, doesn't it? Little old me. Tonya, just invest every month, every paycheck. Not. Not the most exciting news. No one's clicking on that. And so if it helps, you go look at Some S&P 500 graphs and charts over history, and here's what I found. There's a great, funny tweet. It shows cnbc. Every time there was a headline that said markets and turmoil. If you just put money in the market that year, the following year, the average return you would get is 40%.

[Financial Expert 1]

Yeah, there you go.

[Financial Expert 2]

Every time the headlines say, don't Invest, pull your money out. It's all coming crashing down. That's the right time to invest.

[Financial Expert 1]

And we're talking, James, we're talking about your 401k and stuff like that. We're not talking about single stocks, right?

[Caller]

Well, yeah, I mean, I've got my money. It's in a brokerage account and I have a broker that's. That is managing that for me.

[Financial Expert 1]

Right.

[Financial Expert 2]

Why aren't you investing in retirement accounts that are tax advantaged?

[Caller]

Well, I do have, I do have an ir. I've got a Roth ira. I have a traditional ira.

[Financial Expert 2]

Are you maxing those out every year?

[Caller]

Well, my Roth ira, I just started that and I haven't, I haven't actually maxed those out. No.

[Financial Expert 2]

So why are you funding the brokerage account before the Tax advantage accounts?

[Caller]

Well, it was, it was some money that I had. I had some money that I wanted to move around and I put it in a brokerage account to see, you know, to see if I could make some money there. And the Roth IRA account that I had was, it was rolled over from a previous 401k that I had with the. I worked for the railroad.

[Financial Expert 2]

Okay.

[Caller]

And I got laid off. And that was no longer. So I had to roll. I wanted to roll that money into something that was going to make some money. So.

[Financial Expert 2]

Well, either way, you're going to make money. You're just not getting any tax advantages and that's where you want to go first when it comes to investing. So hang on the line. I'm going to send you a copy of my book Breaking Free from Broke. Read the wealth is Patience chapter. That's going to give you a lot of tactical information as well as some encouragement and motivation and show you the right process and way to invest. Because I believe in you. The fact that you're even investing in the market gives me a lot of hope. Yeah, just never stop.

[Financial Expert 1]

That's right.

[Financial Expert 2]

And you'll look back. We were just talking jump out.

[Financial Expert 1]

We were talking about this during the break. You know, it's like we don't get too hung up on the drops. We're going to keep investing and buy low, baby.

[Financial Expert 2]

Yeah. And here's what I always say. This, I didn't make this up. This is out there somewhere. But time in the market beats timing the market. And so when you try to jump in and out at the right time, that's good. You're going to get burned. And so it's all about just staying in the market over a long period of time. Let compound growth do its thing. Let the economy cook.

[Financial Expert 1]

Would you believe I've never heard that phrase before?

[Financial Expert 2]

Really?

[Financial Expert 1]

Yeah. I enjoy hearing a good phrase. And you just introduced me to a.

[Financial Expert 2]

Phrase that means a lot to me.

[Financial Expert 1]

Time in the market beats timing the market. I'm repeating it because it's so good.

[Financial Expert 2]

It's. It's. You gotta chew on it for a second. You do, but it just helps remind you that, oh, it's not about trying to be a genius. And just.

[Financial Expert 1]

That right there, my friend, is an axiom.

[Financial Expert 2]

That's what I'm all about.

[Financial Expert 1]

You take that to the bank, here's.

[Financial Expert 2]

Another one for you. Literally, you've heard this one.

[Financial Expert 1]

Oh, he's showing off now.

[Financial Expert 2]

James be a crockpot in a world full of microwaves.

[Financial Expert 1]

Yeah, I've heard that one.

[Financial Expert 2]

That one.

[Financial Expert 1]

It's not as exciting.

[Financial Expert 2]

I thought you would like a Crock pot reference.

[Financial Expert 1]

I do, but you know, the play on words, the turn of phrase. That one. The first one was clever and wrapped in truth. The crock pot thing is a little cheesy.

[Financial Expert 2]

All right, all right. Yeah.

[Financial Expert 1]

I appreciate the effort. You're one for two. That's 50%. That's not bad.

[Announcer]

CHM isn't health insurance, it's a health cost sharing ministry. Check it out for [e-mail] budget.