This Is A Risky Way To Save For A House

Summary

---

The Ramsey Show Highlights - “This Is A Risky Way To Save For A House”

Date: July 29, 2026
Host: Dave Ramsey and Co-host (Financial Expert)
Main Topic: Should you keep house down payment funds in the stock market or move them to a safer account?

---

Episode Overview

In this episode, Dave Ramsey and his co-host take a call from a listener seeking advice on how to manage the $250,000 he and his wife have saved to buy a home in Orange County—an expensive real estate market. The discussion centers around the risks of keeping house savings invested in the stock and bond markets versus moving it to a safer high-yield savings account, especially given their desire to purchase within the next year or so. The hosts share practical advice for anyone navigating similar decisions while also discussing the volatility of various investment vehicles.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

The Caller’s Situation (00:06–01:24)

• Background: The caller and his wife have saved $250,000, currently invested 80% in various equities and 20% in bonds/fixed incomes, aiming to buy a house in Orange County where single family homes average $1.1–$1.3 million.
• Current Position: Renting cheaply from family, no rush to buy, but uncertain how to manage their savings amid market volatility.

Dave’s Philosophy on Market Timing & Risk (01:42–02:19)

• On Timing the Market:

  "I don't time the market either, so I don't know. I would not do it based on what I think the market's going to do, because most people don't have any idea." — Dave Ramsey (01:42)

• Market Unpredictability: The co-host emphasizes no one predicted the recent bull runs, reinforcing the unpredictability of the market.

Why Not Buy Now? (02:19–03:09)

• Dave’s Challenge:
  Dave questions why, with $250,000 saved, the caller has delayed purchasing, especially given the high and likely persistent home prices in their area.
• Caller’s Hesitation: Prefers to maximize down payment and is cautious due to commission-based (inconsistent) income.

Evaluating Investment Risk (03:09–04:24)

• High-Yield Savings vs. Stock Market:
  Dave presents the option of swapping all savings into a high-yield account for “zero volatility.”
• Potential Losses:

  "If the market dropped 10%, that would be like one of the worst drops in a year. In history. And that would be $25,000, which would not keep you from buying a house." — Dave Ramsey (04:12)

• Portfolio Performance:
  The caller admits his portfolio is up 8% year-to-date, lagging behind the S&P 500 due to the bond allocation.

Dave’s Action Plan (05:23–06:10)

• Recommended Move:

  "What would I do if I woke up in your shoes? I would move it all to an HSA or I would move half of it or high yield savings account or I would move half of it there and the other half into just an S&P 500." — Dave Ramsey (05:23)

• On Bonds: Strongly discourages individual stocks and bonds for this type of savings.

Strategic Buying Decisions (06:04–06:10)

• Set a Concrete Goal:

  "Have a name, have a name on it and then let's go do it. Because the sense of I'm in sales and I'm scared of volatility is never going to go away... So that's not going to change based on the expense of the real estate or based on the interest rate environment." — Dave Ramsey (06:10)

Investment Vehicles for Non-Retirement vs. Retirement (07:36–08:22)

• Non-Retirement Accounts:
  Keep down payment funds in high-yield savings or, sparingly, in broad, less volatile index funds.
• Retirement Accounts:

  "In retirement accounts, we suggest putting money across four types of mutual funds." — Dave Ramsey (07:40)
  The four types: aggressive growth, growth, growth & income, and international, to achieve diversification and balance volatility.

Memorable Finance Analogies (07:47–08:24)

• Investment Analogies:

  "Large cap... these are like the cruise ships. It's going to be hard for them to move much. And then as you get down to the small cap and these aggressive growth, it's like a jet ski. These things are moving. And sometimes it's great, sometimes there's low lows..." — Financial Expert/Co-host (07:47)

Crypto and Gold Humor (08:22–09:01)

• On Crypto and Gold Losses:

  "So what's crypto? A pirate boat." — Dave Ramsey (08:22)
  "At this point I'm not sure who the pirates are and who's taking them down. I think they're taking themselves." — Co-host (08:24)
  "Crypto bro. Bragging about yourself and you're all 5, 6%, 56, baby, lost half your money." — Dave Ramsey (08:36)
  Light humor about crypto and gold investors’ silence when values drop dramatically.

---

Key Timestamps

• 00:06–01:24: Caller shares his financial situation and investment allocation.
• 01:42–02:19: Dave and co-host discuss impossibility of timing the market.
• 02:19–03:09: Discussion on local housing prices and waiting strategy.
• 03:09–04:24: The risk of leaving house savings in the market.
• 05:23–06:10: Dave's direct recommendations for repositioning funds.
• 07:36–08:22: Differences between non-retirement and retirement investing strategies.
• 08:22–09:01: Lighthearted take on crypto and gold investments.

---

Memorable Quotes

• Dave Ramsey:

  "I don't have a dime in a portfolio that looks like [yours]. Not one. I don't play single stocks and I for sure as crud don't play bonds." (06:04)

• Financial Expert/Co-host:

  "Have a name, have a name on it and then let's go do it." (06:10)

• Dave Ramsey (on crypto):

  "So what's crypto? A pirate boat." (08:22)

• Co-host:

  "At this point I'm not sure who the pirates are and who's taking them down. I think they're taking themselves." (08:24)

---

Takeaways

• Don’t leave short- to mid-term house down payment funds exposed to stock/bond market volatility—prefer high-yield savings or, if comfortable, a split with a broad market index fund.
• Avoid single stocks and bonds for non-retirement savings goals.
• Always set a specific savings number and a timeline (“name and date”) to bring discipline and clarity to big purchases.
• Humor can help disarm investment hype—think critically about where you “park” important savings.

---

For first-time listeners and longtime fans, this episode underscores Ramsey’s time-tested focus on simplicity, security, and prudence when preparing for one of life's largest purchases.

Transcript

[Dave Ramsey]

Brought to you by the EveryDollar app. Start budgeting for free today.

[Caller]

Got married a little over a year and a half ago, and wife and I have done pretty well and we're trying to buy a house. We live in Orange county specifically, and it's super pricey to live here. As you probably know. Our goal is to buy a home. We've been smart. Our parents have raised us right. My dad put me in touch with all your stuff, and I've been hooked to the show ever since. So it's been a pleasure and a blessing in my life and my wife's. So. Yeah. So we. We've been smart with our money, and we feel like we've done well with it. But I'm kind of reaching a point as we get maybe a little bit closer to figure out how we should move it around from here, I guess. It's currently invested in the stock market.

[Dave Ramsey]

In. What's that mean?

[Caller]

In the stock market?

[Dave Ramsey]

I know. In what?

[Caller]

In the stock market, 80% is in equity investments, and then 20% is in bonds and fixed incomes.

[Dave Ramsey]

Equity investments. What's that mean? You got it in single stocks?

[Caller]

No, it. Well, yeah, it's kind of spread out across multiple different stocks. And the advisor that's helping me is put it in the market.

[Dave Ramsey]

Okay. All right. Well, that's not what we teach. You know, that.

[Caller]

Yeah, that's. That's one thing that's very risky. Yeah, it is. And it's done.

[Dave Ramsey]

The bonds. The bonds are worse. Yeah, the bonds are risky, too. Yeah. Okay.

[Caller]

So that's where we have it right now. I mean, we've done well with it, but the market, you know, we're concerned that it's going to come down, and when it comes down, how far is that going to set us back? And I think it's time that we maybe reconsider where we have our money right now.

[Dave Ramsey]

Okay.

[Caller]

Yeah.

[Dave Ramsey]

I don't time the market either, so I don't know. I would not do it based on what I think the market's going to do, because most people don't have any idea.

[Financial Expert/Co-host]

No one could have guessed the market was going to be up as high as it was three years in a row these last couple years.

[Dave Ramsey]

Yeah. In the last five years, it's doubled. And nobody could have guessed that.

[Caller]

Sure.

[Dave Ramsey]

You know, if you. Now that's not in the portfolio you've got, but the portfolio that I've got has doubled. Yours may or may not have done that because those stupid bonds probably were an anchor on your dragging it down. Anyway, when, how much is in there and when will you be buying the house?

[Caller]

I've got about 250,000 in it right now, not counting, like my emergency fund and other savings that we have. And our, our goal is, I mean, we're renting for really cheap from family right now. A house from our, one of our family members that they own.

[Dave Ramsey]

And why with 250,000, why have you not bought yet?

[Caller]

It's so expensive. Like for a single family home, it's

[Dave Ramsey]

not going to go down.

[Caller]

I know, but for our area, it's between 1.1 to 1.3, but it's not

[Dave Ramsey]

going to go down. And you have 250,000.

[Caller]

I'm in a sales role and it's commission based, heavily commission based. So it's been kind of my goal to throw down as much as I can at a home. And since my rent is so cheap and I'm not really pushed up against a wall to move out. I mean, my wife and I have the goal of moving out. Right. We don't want to take advantage of it, but.

[Dave Ramsey]

Okay. So are you willing to trade the volatility of the portfolio that you have and the returns it has for zero volatility and moving 250,000 into a high yield savings account?

[Caller]

No, that, that's, that was what I was kind of questioning. Is it better to have it in high yield savings or don't wait for

[Dave Ramsey]

the interest rate to be perfect? Before buying or refinancing a home, talk to Churchill Mortgage. Smart buyers buy the home they can afford now and then refinance later if rates improve. Churchill helps you make decisions with confidence instead of guessing. And Churchill Mortgage has a webpage with special offers just for our audience. Go to Churchillmortgage.com Ramsayoffer this is a

[Financial Expert/Co-host]

paid advertisement in MLS. Id 1591mlscontumerexcess.org Equal housing lender.

[Caller]

Is it better to have it in high yield savings or if you're going

[Dave Ramsey]

to buy within 12 or 14 months, yes.

[Caller]

Okay.

[Financial Expert/Co-host]

Because your heart's gonna sink when 12 months from now your money's down.

[Dave Ramsey]

If the market dropped 10%, that would be like one of the worst drops in a year. In history. In history. And that would be $25,000, which would not keep you from buying a house.

[Caller]

Right.

[Dave Ramsey]

So it's not that big a deal. But I don't know what kind of mess your portfolio is and how volatility you've got, how much volatility you've gotten yourself signed up for. But if you were just told me you're like in an s and P500 index fund and you're just sitting there writing the actual market. I mean it's up 10% for the year right now, today, year to date. So you have any idea what your portfolio's up this year?

[Caller]

I'm up at 8%, a little over 8% this year.

[Dave Ramsey]

So you're not even keeping up with the basic S and P500.

[Caller]

Yeah, probably because those bonds and fixed incomes are keeping it back right there.

[Dave Ramsey]

Almost like what I said earlier. Yeah, you got to anchor on this. And you know what bond values do when interest rates go up, right?

[Caller]

To go down.

[Dave Ramsey]

Yeah, they're an inverse relationship. Exactly. So that's going to be bad.

[Caller]

We were thinking, I mean, waiting, I guess.

[Dave Ramsey]

Let me quit mouthing around the edges of this. What would I do if I woke up in your shoes? I would move it all to an HSA or I would move half of it or high yield savings account or I would move half of it there and the other half into just an S&P 500.

[Financial Expert/Co-host]

That way you get the best of both worlds.

[Dave Ramsey]

Yeah, you got a little mix. Whatever the market does, you're going to get. But that gets rid of The S&P 500 is probably half as volatile as what you've got right now. I wouldn't be in what you've got right now for anything. I don't have a dime in a portfolio that looks like that. Not one. I don't play single stocks and I for sure as crud don't play bonds.

[Financial Expert/Co-host]

And I would have an end goal and end date instead of just vibing going, well, maybe a couple years from now, just go, Hey, 12 months from

[Dave Ramsey]

now, our amount of money, when I get to 400k we're going, or when I get to 300k we're going, or whatever the number is. Have a name, have a name on it and then let's go do it. Because the sense of I'm in sales and I'm scared of volatility is never going to go away, that you're going to have that as long as you're in sales. And so that's not going to change based on the expense of the real estate or based on the interest rate environment. It's not going to change based on any of that. And so yeah, that's, that's what I would do. I would take all the money out of that right now. I would put either all or half of it in a high yield savings and not worry about it anymore. If I put half of it in, I'd put the other half in. The most volatile thing would be an S&P 500. And I use personally an S&P 500 to park money in while I'm saving up to buy my next real estate project, which is some of my favorite investing. And so I'll let it sit there. And so I've made 10% on my money this year. You know, that's been sitting there year to date. And I'm fine with that. And if it went down 4% or 5%, I'm not gonna kill me. Be fine with. Not desperate, but. And I don't have to sit there and make, you know, high yield savings rates, which is what, three or four right now?

[Financial Expert/Co-host]

Yeah, three and a half. About. Yeah, somewhere in there.

[Dave Ramsey]

So that, that's the thing. So

[Financial Expert/Co-host]

it's a good call out that this is. We're talking non retirement accounts here.

[Dave Ramsey]

Yes, yes, absolutely. In retirement accounts, we suggest putting money across four types of mutual funds.

[Financial Expert/Co-host]

Yeah, you're going to have your aggressive growth, growth, growth and income. And international. So that's kind of like large cap, mid cap, small cap. And we're talking about, you know, the huge companies, those are the safer bets. These are like the cruise ships. It's going to be hard for them to move much. And then as you get down to the small cap and these aggressive growth, it's like a jet ski. These things are moving. And sometimes it's great, sometimes there's low lows, but you're riding that wave to capture it over a long period of time. And then international, we saw this happen. International actually went up as the US market went down. So it's a good hedge against the market here stateside. So all of that helps you to sleep better at night.

[Dave Ramsey]

So what's crypto? A pirate boat.

[Financial Expert/Co-host]

Oh, gosh. At this point I'm not sure who the pirates are and who's taking them down. I think they're taking themselves.

[Dave Ramsey]

They're sinking. I know that.

[Financial Expert/Co-host]

It's like 56% down from what happened to you.

[Dave Ramsey]

Crypto bro. Bragging about yourself and you're all 5, 6%, 56, baby, lost half your money.

[Financial Expert/Co-host]

They get real quiet when it's crypto.

[Dave Ramsey]

Bros get real quiet when it's not.

[Financial Expert/Co-host]

They took their ball and they went home.

[Dave Ramsey]

Yeah, they just go hide in the corner of TikTok over there. In the deep corners of recesses of TikTok. Go back where they came from.

[Financial Expert/Co-host]

When investments not based on anything and it's just hype as soon as everyone jumps off the boat.

[Dave Ramsey]

Yeah, I hadn't noticed anybody bragging about gold lately either. Create your free every dollar budget today. The simplest way to budget for your.