Podcast Summary: The Rest Is History - Episode 523. Charlemagne: Return of the Kings (Part 1)

Release Date: December 19, 2024
Hosts: Tom Holland and Dominic Sandbrook

Introduction

In Episode 523 of The Rest Is History, hosts Tom Holland and Dominic Sandbrook embark on an in-depth exploration of one of Europe’s most pivotal figures: Charlemagne. The episode, titled "Charlemagne: Return of the Kings (Part 1)", delves into the complexities surrounding the Merovingian dynasty, the rise of the mayors of the palace, and the foundational events that set the stage for Charlemagne’s ascent.

The Decline of the Merovingian Dynasty

Dominic opens the discussion by examining the waning power of the Merovingian kings, highlighting King Chilperic III's deposition by Pope Stephen II:

Dominic Sandbrook [09:33]: "All that was left to the king was that he should sit on the throne with his hair long and his beard flowing and act the part of a ruler."

He explains how the Merovingian kings had become largely ceremonial figures, with real authority residing in the hands of the mayors of the palace. These officials wielded supreme power, reducing the king to a symbolic leader devoid of substantive control.

The Role of Charles Martel

Tom Holland introduces Charles Martel, a formidable mayor of the palace whose military prowess and administrative reforms significantly strengthened Frankish power:

Tom Holland [09:38]: "He absolutely is. And this redounds greatly to his reputation."

Charles Martel is credited with unifying Austrasia and Neustria, expanding Frankish territories, and decisively defeating Muslim forces at the Battle of Tours. His strategic maneuvers not only secured his realm but also set a precedent for Frankish dominance in Western Europe.

Bishops and the Transformation of Gaul

The conversation shifts to the influential role of bishops in Frankish society. Initially heirs to the Gallo-Roman aristocracy, bishops maintained religious and cultural continuity:

Tom Holland [13:55]: "And so it's all looking good. But then, weirdly, in 747, he goes to Rome and he prays before the Pope and he says, I don't want to be a king anymore. I want to become a monk."

However, Charles Martel sought to curtail their independence to consolidate his authority. By appointing loyalists over traditional bishops, he effectively dismantled the old Roman-based power structures, paving the way for a more centralized Frankish state.

The Mythical Intervention: Charles Martel’s Tomb

In a dramatic turn, Dominic recounts a legend involving the exiled Bishop Eucharius who claims to witness supernatural evidence of Charles Martel’s damnation:

Tom Holland [19:59]: "Therefore, they went to the aforementioned monastery where Charles's body was buried, they opened his tomb, and suddenly, Dominic, a dragon emerged."

This mythical narrative serves to illustrate the deep-seated tensions between the old Roman ecclesiastical authorities and the emerging Frankish power.

Pepin the Short and the Alliance with the Papacy

Pepin, Charles Martel’s son, emerges as a central figure poised to transform the Frankish realm further. Facing internal divisions and external threats from the Lombards, Pepin seeks legitimacy through an alliance with the Pope:

Tom Holland [34:27]: "And so this is the hope of the Pope. But before we look at why he might be willing to do this, we should just go back and see what's been happening in Frankia while all these events have been happening in Italy."

Responding to Pope Zachary's call for assistance against Lombard aggression, Pepin asserts his authority by defeating the Lombards and subsequently obtaining the Pope’s endorsement. This pivotal alliance not only legitimizes Pepin’s rule but also marks the decline of the Merovingian dynasty:

Tom Holland [39:19]: "Pepin can now feel that God wants him to do what he wants to do, which is to make himself king."

Conclusion and Cliffhanger

As the episode progresses, tensions rise with the division of Frankish territories among Pepin’s sons, Carloman and Charles. An unexpected death disrupts this fragile balance, leaving Charles as the sole ruler and setting the stage for his legendary reign:

Dominic Sandbrook [50:31]: "But if you are Scrooge or the Grinch, then I'm afraid you're gonna have to wait till next week because we'll be back on Monday and then on Christmas Day with the final two episodes of our mighty series on the life of Charlemagne."

The episode concludes on a thrilling note, teasing the continuation of Charlemagne’s story in subsequent parts.

Notable Quotes

• Dominic Sandbrook [09:33]: "All that was left to the king was that he should sit on the throne with his hair long and his beard flowing and act the part of a ruler."

• Tom Holland [13:55]: "And so it's all looking good. But then, weirdly, in 747, he goes to Rome and he prays before the Pope and he says, I don't want to be a king anymore. I want to become a monk."

• Tom Holland [19:59]: "Therefore, they went to the aforementioned monastery where Charles's body was buried, they opened his tomb, and suddenly, Dominic, a dragon emerged."

• Tom Holland [34:27]: "And so this is the hope of the Pope. But before we look at why he might be willing to do this, we should just go back and see what's been happening in Frankia while all these events have been happening in Italy."

• Tom Holland [39:19]: "Pepin can now feel that God wants him to do what he wants to do, which is to make himself king."

Final Thoughts

Episode 523 masterfully sets the stage for understanding Charlemagne's rise by meticulously dissecting the decline of the Merovingians, the rise of powerful mayors like Charles Martel, and the strategic alliances that would ultimately redefine European power structures. With engaging storytelling and insightful analysis, Holland and Sandbrook provide listeners with a comprehensive foundation for the upcoming episodes focused on Charlemagne's extraordinary legacy.

For more detailed discussions and exclusive content, consider joining The Rest Is History Club at therestishistory.com.