The Rest Is History Podcast Summary: Episode 585. Mary, Queen of Scots: The Royal Rivals (Part 2)
Release Date: July 23, 2025

Introduction

In the second part of their deep dive into the life of Mary, Queen of Scots, hosts Tom Holland and Dominic Sandbrook continue to unravel the complex web of political intrigue, personal relationships, and historical events that defined Mary's tumultuous reign. This episode delves into Mary's upbringing in France, her strategic marriage, the shifting political landscapes in Scotland and England, and the rise of the Protestant Reformation, culminating in Mary's precarious position upon her return to Scotland.

Mary's Upbringing in France

Dominic Sandbrook begins by highlighting Mary's early portrayal in France:
"At five years old, Mary was hailed as a figure of romance in France. A brave little queen who had been forced to flee the barbaric Scots, the cruel English, for the safe arms of all-embracing France." (00:00)

Tom Holland elaborates on the political maneuvers that led to Mary's placement in the French court:
"Henry VIII wanted Mary Queen of Scots to marry his son, the future Edward VI. He got the deal, then it got ripped up. He got absolutely irate and sent the English to burn and slaughter and loot, which they then did for eight years." (01:49)

Mary's integration into the French aristocracy is depicted as both charming and strategic. Despite initial skepticism from Sandbrook about Mary's prowess—mocking her betrothed's shortcomings—the hosts acknowledge the historical reality of Mary's advantageous placement:
"Young Mary Queen of Scots steps onto French soil and she does so as a future queen of France, because her betrothed is the dauphin himself." (02:41)

Marriage to Francis and Political Ambitions

Mary's marriage to Francis, the Dauphin of France, is portrayed as a union with significant dynastic implications. Holland describes the grandeur of their wedding:
"Very shockingly, very innovatively, she wears a completely novel color at her wedding, and that is white in France. Unheard of to wear a white dress." (04:28)

This marriage not only elevated Mary's status but also set the stage for broader political ambitions. The hosts discuss how Mary's union was part of her uncles' (the Guises) plan to forge a Franco-British empire:
"They want to forge a kind of Franco-British empire that will be under their thumb." (14:40)

The Treaty of Edinburgh and Its Implications

A pivotal moment in Mary's story is the signing of the Treaty of Edinburgh. This treaty had profound implications for Scotland's sovereignty and Mary's claims. Holland explains:
"Mary signs and seals a promise to uphold, and I quote, Scotland's freedoms, liberties, and privileges." (09:42)

However, behind the scenes, Mary's uncles manipulated the situation to weaken her position:
"She is effectively agreeing to a completely bombshell promise that if people in Scotland knew about it, would cause outrage. Because what Mary says is that if she dies without an heir, then her husband Francis...so Scotland will become part of the French kind of fiefdoms." (18:01)

This betrayal by her own family marked a significant decline in Mary's political standing and set the stage for future conflicts.

The Scottish Reformation and John Knox

The episode shifts focus to the rise of the Protestant Reformation in Scotland, spearheaded by figures like John Knox. Holland narrates Knox's transformation from a Catholic priest to a leading Protestant reformer:
"John Knox had originally been a Catholic priest, and probably he was converted to Protestantism by Patrick Hamilton, who...was Scotland's first Protestant martyr." (35:37)

Knox's influence grows as he returns to Scotland, igniting widespread religious and political upheaval:
"In Perth, he gives a brilliantly inflammatory sermon that sets mobs roaming the city, attacking the city's monasteries." (44:28)

The hosts discuss the formation of the Lords of the Congregation, a group of Protestant nobles determined to oust French influence and establish a Protestant stronghold in Scotland.

Mary's Return to Scotland

Following a series of personal and political setbacks—including the death of her mother, Mary of Guise, and her husband, Francis—the young Mary faces dwindling support in France. Catherine de Medici, Francis's mother, seeks to marginalize Mary further:
"Catherine de Medici... wants her cleared from the chessboard." (52:51)

Despite the turmoil, Mary attempts to broker peace by forming an agreement with her Protestant half-brother, Lord James Stewart (later the Earl of Moray). This compact allows her to recognize the Reformed Church while maintaining her Catholic practices in certain chambers:
"Mary promises to recognize the Reformed Church...in return, she will be allowed to celebrate the Catholic Mass in her own chapel at Holyrood." (57:29)

This compromise, however, alienates both her Catholic uncles and Protestant reformers like John Knox, leaving Mary in an increasingly untenable position.

Conclusion

The episode concludes with Mary's return to Scotland, marked by symbolic moments and rising tensions. As Mary arrives in Leith, the mist symbolizes the unclear and fraught future that awaits her:
"They arrive off Leith and the harbour is thickly veiled by mist so that Mary, in a kind of... can't actually make out the contours of her kingdom through this sea mist." (58:37)

Dominic Sandbrook foreshadows the forthcoming challenges Mary will face upon her return, setting the stage for the next episode's exploration of her struggles to maintain power in a Scotland divided by religion and politics.

Notable Quotes

• "Mary Queen of Scots steps onto French soil and she does so as a future queen of France, because her betrothed is the dauphin himself." – Tom Holland (02:41)

• "John Knox...as the leading light of...the Reformation, is kind of now the leading light of as being Scotland's official church." – Tom Holland (27:45)

• "Mary's status as Queen is still unchallenged... there is no doubt about the strength and prestige of the House of Stuart." – Tom Holland (32:00)

Final Thoughts

This episode of The Rest Is History masterfully intertwines personal narratives with broader political and religious movements, painting a vivid portrait of Mary, Queen of Scots, and the era that shaped her destiny. Through engaging storytelling and expert analysis, Tom Holland and Dominic Sandbrook provide listeners with a comprehensive understanding of the intricate dynamics that defined one of history's most fascinating queens.

Join The Rest Is History Club to access exclusive bonus episodes, early series access, live show tickets, ad-free listening, and more. Visit therestishistory.com or start a free trial on Apple Podcasts.

For more insightful podcasts, explore Goalhanger.