Podcast Summary: "Best in Show" Episode of The Rewatchables

Episode Information:

• Title: Best in Show
• Hosts: Bill Simmons, Mallory Rubin, Joanna Robinson
• Release Date: March 11, 2025
• Podcast: The Rewatchables by The Ringer

Introduction

In this episode of The Rewatchables, hosts Bill Simmons, Mallory Rubin, and Joanna Robinson delve into the beloved mockumentary film "Best in Show." Originally released in 2000, the film has become a staple in the rewatchable movie canon, celebrated for its sharp humor and endearing characters. The trio explores various facets of the movie, sharing personal anecdotes, favorite scenes, and insights into its enduring appeal.

Exploring "Best in Show"

Overview of the Movie

"Best in Show" is a mockumentary directed by Christopher Guest that satirizes the world of competitive dog shows. The film follows several dog owners and their canines as they prepare for the prestigious Mayflower Dog Show. The ensemble cast, including notable performances by Catherine O'Hara, Eugene Levy, and Fred Willard, brings to life a comedic portrayal of the eccentricities within the dog show community.

Favorite Scenes and Characters

• Congress of the Cow ([29:05]): A standout moment where a woman engages in a peculiar pose, sparking laughter and confusion among the hosts.

  John Michael Higgins [29:25]: "I put myself in a position that wasn't very easy for me emotionally. It's called the Congress of the Cow."

• Busy Bee Moment ([45:01]): The heartbreaking yet hilarious scene where a prized dog named Busy Bee goes missing, leading to frantic searching and comedic tension.

  Bill Simmons [45:25]: "We have to pick the spirit of most rewatchable scenes. I don't think I'm constitutionally capable of looking away if I know we're about to see Cookie."

• Final Showdown ([44:50]): The tension builds as competitors vie for the top spot, culminating in a suspenseful and humorous finale.

  Parker Posey [44:52]: "This was like Rocky, not three peing Craig."

Character Highlights

• Harlan Pepper ([90:47]): Fred Willard's portrayal is lauded for its depth and comedic timing, embodying the passionate dog handler.

  Fred Willard [70:35]: "Best in Show. It's hall of Fame."

• Cookie Fleck ([30:13]): The charismatic and somewhat roguish owner whose interactions add layers of humor and pathos to the narrative.

  Amy Poehler [30:10]: "She had dozens of boyfriends. Hundreds."

Behind-the-Scenes Insights

Christopher Guest's Creative Process

The hosts discuss Guest's meticulous approach to creating mockumentaries, emphasizing his reliance on improvisation and character-driven humor.

Amy Poehler [16:28]: "It's the opposite of our strategy where we just have long podcasts and we don't edit anything."

Parker Posey [16:54]: "I feel like this comedy's for adults, not because of necessarily the subject matter, but I don't know the 15-year-old."

Improvisation vs. Scripted Comedy

The conversation highlights the challenges and triumphs of improvisational filmmaking, with Guest's work upholding high standards through extensive editing and character development.

Fred Willard [50:14]: "Most improv sucks."

John Michael Higgins [54:30]: "It is the perfect game."

Personal Anecdotes and Pet Stories

Dog Ownership and Experiences

The hosts share their own experiences with pets, drawing parallels to the film's depiction of dog owners' quirks.

Amy Poehler [08:12]: "We just got a new puppy. It had to have an ie human name because that's what the other seven golden retrievers they've had over 40 years have."

John Michael Higgins [09:19]: "I have nothing left for anyone else in my life, including my husband. It all goes to Halo."

Rewatchable Moments and Their Enduring Appeal

The episode underscores why "Best in Show" remains a favorite for repeated viewings. Its blend of heartfelt moments and relentless humor makes it a quintessential rewatchable film.

Parker Posey [87:31]: "It's a fair case that normal people."

Amy Poehler [87:55]: "You do occasionally have golden retriever energy. Look how happy you were when I just said that."

Concluding Thoughts

As the episode wraps up, the hosts reflect on the film's impact and speculate on potential sequels or spin-offs, highlighting the film's rich character dynamics and timeless humor.

Fred Willard [100:05]: "What a great idea. Did you have any Rocky thoughts while you're here?"

Amy Poehler [101:53]: "This movie is all that guys and that girl. That is because, like, Larry Miller, the one whose son goes on the shed, he's kind of Larry Miller."

Notable Quotes

• Amy Poehler [16:28]: "It's the opposite of our strategy where we just have long podcasts and we don't edit anything."

• Fred Willard [50:14]: "Most improv sucks."

• John Michael Higgins [54:30]: "It is the perfect game."

• Parker Posey [87:31]: "It's a fair case that normal people."

• Fred Willard [100:05]: "What a great idea. Did you have any Rocky thoughts while you're here?"

Conclusion

"Best in Show" exemplifies the essence of The Rewatchables—a film that not only entertains but invites repeated viewings to uncover its layered humor and endearing characters. Through engaging discussion and personal insights, the hosts celebrate the film's enduring legacy in the realm of rewatchable movies.

For more episodes and in-depth discussions on your favorite rewatchable films, visit The Ringer's Rewatchables page or watch on the Ringer Movies YouTube Channel.