The Ringer Fantasy Football Show – Episode Summary

Episode Title: Joe Flacco Traded to Cincy, Players You Want to Bench, Fantasy Court, and Heifetz Explains Childbirth
Release Date: October 8, 2025
Hosts: Danny Heifetz, Danny Kelly, Craig Horlbeck

Overview

In this episode, Danny Heifetz, Danny Kelly, and Craig Horlbeck react to the surprise trade sending Joe Flacco from the Browns to the rival Bengals, analyze players fantasy managers are thinking about benching or cutting ("the five stages of grief"), and preside over a hilarious round of "Fantasy Court"—including deliberations on setting lineups during childbirth. The show balances actionable fantasy insights, comedic therapy for frustrated managers, and irreverent tangents.

Main Themes & Discussion Points

Joe Flacco Traded to the Bengals (03:20–10:34)

• Trade Details: Joe Flacco traded from Browns to Bengals for a minor late-round pick swap—remarkable for being an intra-division QB trade and the first-ever Browns-Bengals trade.
• Reactions:
  • Craig: "I laughed... The Browns are fucking with the Bengals. Joe Flacco has been absolutely atrocious... But he's better than Jake Browning." (03:20–03:45)
  • DK: Mocks "fantasy service"—move only matters for fantasy managers of Bengals skill players, not for real NFL upside. Flacco’s old, slow, behind a bad line: “The last quarterback I would pick to withstand the Bengals OL... is 40-year-old Joe Flacco.” (04:15–04:33)
• NFL History: Heifetz explains the longstanding grudge between franchises—first time in history they’ve dealt, breaking a 60-year “Omerta” due to desperation. (05:31–05:50)
• Fantasy Implications: Marginal real-world impact; Bengals WRs might get a "Flacco bump," especially in PPR with checkdowns.

Power Hour: Bench/Cut Candidates – The Five Stages of Fantasy Grief (11:22–40:47)

Using the “five stages of grief” as a framework, the hosts confront the agony of disappointing fantasy draft picks. They debate bench/cut/hold/buy-low value, offering emotional catharsis and analysis.

1. A.J. Brown (Philadelphia Eagles)

• Stats: WR52, 6.98 PPG—worse than Kevontae Turpin (!)
• Hosts: "Five stages of grief... Week 5 is acceptance: 'Okay, I'm just not going to play him anymore.'" (02:10)
• Advice: Don’t cut; still start him, huge buy-low window. Passing offense will rebound.
• Quote: Heifetz: “You’re a monster if you cut him. But people are thinking about benching.” (12:22)
• Stat: "After disastrous Week 1, he’s 7th in targets per game." (14:29–14:39)

2. Derrick Henry (Baltimore Ravens)

• Stats: 28 fantasy points in Week 1, 28 points since.
• DK: “He looks like the Saddam Hussein statue falling over sometimes...” (16:12–16:14)
• Advice: Benchable this week, but strong hold/buy-low. Upcoming schedule (post-bye) is favorable.

3. & 4. Chase Brown & Tee Higgins (Cincinnati Bengals)

• Chase Brown: Massive offseason sleeper, tanked by Burrow injury & poor production. “One of the least efficient RBs in the NFL. Hard to recreate lightning in a bottle.” (18:21–19:15)
• Tee Higgins: Still must-play in most formats. “You still need to be playing [Higgins].” (19:59)
• Advice: Hold both, but bench Chase Brown until further notice.

5. DJ Moore (Chicago Bears)

• Narration: Managers clung to hope after preseason rumors, but “all that stuff actually did matter.” Target share has cratered below even role players.
• Stats: 28% career target rate — now 16%. “DJ Moore’s target rate is less than Olamide Zaccheaus right now.” (21:13)
• Advice: DO NOT cut, but bench. Could get traded.

6. Jameson Williams (Detroit Lions)

• Disappointment: Dropping from preseason darling to WR57.
• Heifetz: “He’s the hardest to bench because the upside is so high... the new DeSean Jackson—two points or 24.” (24:49)
• Advice: Worth a speculative play due to Detroit D injuries and potential shootouts.

7. RJ Harvey (Denver Broncos)

• GK: “Big L for preseason hype... but look, I was right about Sean Payton again, the guy just loves to rotate.” (26:39–27:28)
• Frustration: Rookie hype lost to consistent J.K. Dobbins production and a three-way RB carousel.
• Advice: Easiest 'buy-low' of any name discussed; “Everyone’s sick of him, but you should trade for Harvey.” (31:58)

8. TreVeyon Henderson (New England Patriots)

• Letdown: Massive preseason hype, but “hasn’t looked very good—only four missed tackles forced.” (32:55)
• Recommendation: Bench until proven otherwise, though opportunity may grow due to RB injuries.

9. Ladd McConkey (LAC Chargers)

• Change in role: More underneath, explosive plays gone. Is now “a borderline flex.” (36:16)
• Comparison: More optimistic than DJ Moore, still part of the offense.

10. Brian Thomas Jr. (Jacksonville Jaguars)

• Catch Rate Concerns: “19th in targets, 73rd in catches. Third-worst catch rate among all WRs.” (38:40)
• Outlook: Highly likely for regression to the mean. Still a hold.

Fantasy Court & Listener Questions (45:34–63:44)

Fantasy Scoring Oddities

• Tennessee/Arizona D/ST Scoring: Chronicling a wild fantasy scoring loophole on a fumble/touchdown play—who should get credit, TD or points allowed? Sometimes “the defense turns into the offense” in the stat book. (47:24–48:57)

ER-Visit Lineup Change Dilemma

• Scenario: Listener Justice asks if he should have been allowed to make a lineup change after spending the night in the ER and missing a Thursday game.
• Hosts Debate:
  • DK: “If you’re in the hospital, that takes precedent.”
  • Craig: Insists on knowing what put him in the hospital! “If you go to the hospital because you need your stomach pumped... that’s your fault.” (55:03–55:28)
• Ruling: Generally, a hospital visit deserves leeway, but setting expectation for all.

Blackmail in Delivery Room? (57:10–63:40)

• Emailer: Claims he stalked brother-in-law’s fantasy transactions and found proof he made a waiver move during his child’s delivery; considers blackmailing him for a trade.
• Hosts:
  • “PROTECT THE SHIELD.” – DK (59:46)
  • “What is he doing 17 minutes before the birth?!” – Heifetz (61:05)
• Advice: Don’t blackmail; don't narc. The real risk is the wife finding out.

Childbirth Sidetracks

• Lots of running jokes about labor, what’s acceptable, and how fantasy priorities clash.
• “Email us labor stories!” — Heifetz soliciting stories about what men did during their partners’ deliveries. (63:07–63:14)

Hilarious Childhood Misunderstanding Emails (64:14–76:49)

• Sam’s story: Mistook "jizzed in my pants" for peed, and blurted it out in the family car (72:22).
• Heifetz’s Austin Powers Goldmember misunderstanding: Believed you’re supposed to have three testicles due to a movie gag (73:53–74:32).
• Danny Kelly: Thought brother’s floss in the toilet was... “that’s what semen is.” (75:00–75:54)
• Hosts encourage more childhood confusion anecdotes.

Miscellany: Platform Rants & Personal Catch-up (76:49–79:46)

• Quick venting over U2’s Apple Music auto-download era.
• Spotify plug.
• Closing banter and thanks.

Notable Quotes & Timestamps

• “The five stages of grief align completely with being disappointed by a fantasy player.” – Heifetz (01:43)
• “I'm just a guy who has AJ Brown on his bench. That's just my season.” – DK (02:18)
• “The last quarterback I would pick to withstand the Bengals OL... is 40-year-old Joe Flacco.” – DK (04:33)
• “It’s funny, Joe Flacco should be the NFL’s rental umbrella.” – Heifetz (05:05)
• “That’s why you don’t take victory laps after Week 1!” – DK, about Derrick Henry’s hot then cold start (16:14)
• “He looks like the Saddam Hussein statue falling down sometimes.” – DK on Derrick Henry (16:12)
• “DJ Moore’s target rate is less than Olamide Zaccheaus right now on the Bears.” – Craig (21:13)
• “He has the same target rate as Rashod Bateman. Less than Calvin Austin. This is horrific.” – Craig (21:53)
• “Easiest ‘buy-low’ of anyone—RJ Harvey. No one wants him.” – Heifetz (31:58)
• “The fantasy community is the only place where grown men argue about third-string RBs on winning teams. Sean Payton’s a Hall of Fame coach, but online everyone screams ‘play the rookie!’” – Heifetz (29:22)
• “What do you do if your brother-in-law sets a fantasy lineup during his wife’s delivery? Is blackmail legal in fantasy court?” – Heifetz (59:33)

Timestamps for Important Segments

• Joe Flacco Trade & Reactions: 03:20–10:34
• Power Hour: Bench/Cut Candidates: 11:22–40:47
  • A.J. Brown discussion: 12:03–15:07
  • Derrick Henry: 15:15–16:58
  • Bengals WRs: 17:22–19:59
  • DJ Moore: 20:22–22:57
  • Jameson Williams: 23:01–26:27
  • RJ Harvey: 26:29–31:58
• Fantasy Court (Scoring Oddities/ER Visit/Childbirth): 45:34–63:44
• Listener Emails – Childhood Misunderstandings: 64:14–76:49

Closing Thoughts

This episode is a standout blend of actionable fantasy debate, sharp group therapy for frustrated managers, and hilarious off-topic diversions. The show’s unique flavor leans heavily into the human side of fantasy football, openly acknowledging the pettiness, pain, and comedy of the pursuit. Listeners are encouraged to embrace their “grief,” hold steady through early-season struggles, and share their own stories—on or off the field.

Email stories or fantasy court dilemmas to: ringerfantasyfootball@gmail.com
Follow the show on Spotify for more episodes and Power Hours every week!