The Rise and Fall of Diddy

Podcast: The Rise and Fall of Diddy
Host: Jesse Weber
Episode: Bad Boy For Life? – Episode 8
Date: November 4, 2025

Episode Overview

This gripping finale covers the conclusion of Sean "Diddy" Combs’ high-profile federal trial on racketeering, sex trafficking, and related charges. Host Jesse Weber and key legal analysts provide a front-row seat to the deliberations, strategies, closing arguments, verdict, and far-reaching implications for Combs, his accusers, and the cultural understanding of abuse, consent, and power in the celebrity world.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Battle Over Jury Instructions

• Jury’s guidance became a major battleground (02:00–06:31). The defense and prosecution fought heatedly over phrasing and precision relating to definitions of conspiracy, forced labor, and trafficking.
  • Conspiracy definition dispute: Defense wanted clarity that all members must share a goal; prosecution preferred a broader application.
    Judge sided with defense on this point (02:38).
  • "Actions speak louder than words": Judge allowed the addition, influencing how jurors weigh evidence ([03:40], Elizabeth Milner).
  • Sexual services as labor: Prosecution wanted to equate sexual services with labor (R. Kelly precedent). Judge opted for a narrow reading, letting prosecutors argue the point ([04:28], Elizabeth Milner).
  • Crucial Mann Act wording: Changed from “intent… would engage in prostitution” to “an act of prostitution,” enabling prosecution to argue intent without labeling transported individuals as sex workers ([05:36], Elizabeth Milner).

2. Prosecution Closing Arguments

• A "small army of staff" and an "enterprise": Prosecutor Kristi Slavik’s narrative painted Combs as orchestrating crimes through a network of enablers ([07:19], Elizabeth Milner).
• Key witness testimony: Cassie Ventura’s detailed accounts of years of abuse; Jane’s testimony about grooming, drugs, and coercion; and references to Dr. Dawn Hughes’s trauma expertise ([07:41–09:43], Milner).
• Violence and drugs: Slavic argued these were tools of control, not side effects:

  "She called them chemical handcuffs used to keep women compliant, awake, and disoriented." ([09:28], Jesse Weber)

• Paper trail: Extensive travel and financial records, particularly involving escorts like Jules and Clayton Howard ("Dave"), used as evidence of criminal enterprise ([11:06–12:32], Milner).
• Call to action:

  "She told [the jury] it was time to hold Combs accountable." ([13:53], Jesse Weber)

3. Defense Closing Arguments

• Mark Agnifilo’s strategy: Contrasted two trials—one of evidence, one of "prosecutors’ word of mouth." Asserted Combs was a "self-made, successful Black entrepreneur" victimized by exaggeration ([14:17–14:50], Milner).
• Admitted to flaws:

  "If domestic violence was a charge here, he would have pled guilty to it." ([15:03], Jesse Weber)

• Alternate narrative: Characterized participants as consenting adults, not trafficked victims:

  “This was just an alternative lifestyle, that these were just swingers… adults, making choices… not sex trafficking.” ([16:14], Milner)

• Cast doubt on motives and credibility: Emphasized lack of hard evidence of a conspiracy and suggested civil lawsuits (e.g., Cassie’s) motivated government action.
• Emotional direct appeal:

  “…today you… the jury, are the United States of America. I’m asking you to acquit Sean Combs on all counts and return him to his family…” ([16:50], Milner)

4. Prosecution’s Rebuttal & Verdict

• Assistant U.S. Attorney Maureen Comey:

  “He is not a God.” – Rebuttal against defense’s portrayal of Combs as untouchable ([17:10], Jesse Weber)

  • Refocused on victim credibility and the seriousness of the pattern of violence and control.

The Verdict (20:45–22:30)

• Convicted: Two counts of transportation to engage in prostitution under the Mann Act.
• Acquitted: On racketeering, conspiracy, and sex trafficking by force/fraud/coercion.
• Public and legal fallout begins immediately as crowds and media react.
• Attorneys declare victory:

  “Today’s a great victory… You saw that the Southern District… came at him with all that they had.” ([21:05], Combs' attorneys)

5. Immediate Reactions & Legal Analysis

• Dan Abrams (Law&Crime CEO):

  “The fact that he was acquitted of all of the most serious charges is a big win.” ([22:30], Abrams)

  • Noted that convictions on Mann Act counts were expected due to hard evidence, but lack of proven coercion led to acquittals on greater charges ([23:12], Abrams).

• Elizabeth Milner:

  “Consent was really a topic of discussion… yes, while it was on and off for an 11 year period, but she kept on the relationship even after these instances of violence…” ([23:41], Milner)

• Cassie Ventura’s testimony:

  • Despite dramatic evidence (e.g., viral hotel video), the jury didn’t find proof "beyond a reasonable doubt" on the central sex trafficking charge due to the ongoing consensual relationship.

6. Sentencing and Collateral Consequences

• Mann Act felonies:
  • Each count can carry up to ten years; sentencing range expected to be 51–63 months, but Combs may get credit for time served ([29:03–29:24], Matt Murphy).
  • Sex offender registration possible, but not automatic in federal cases ([27:24], Abrams & Corman).
• Asset forfeiture:
  • Unlikely, as illegal income could not be traced directly to Combs' fortune ([31:21–32:21], Murphy).
• Civil suits:
  • 60+ pending; lower burden of proof, but no criminal conviction to leverage ([32:55–33:48], Murphy).

7. Impact of the Acquittals & Social Commentary

• Jury dynamics:

  • Older male majority may have impacted understanding of coercion and consent ([43:57], Brennan).
  • Defense’s portrayal of "private kink" vs. coercion landed with the jury.

• Brennan on strategy:

  “Once you bring violence into the picture, every subsequent act is influenced by that specter.” ([46:04], Brennan)

  • Defense didn’t call character witnesses—risk of cross-examination outweighed potential benefit.
  • Candidly admitted flaws to enhance credibility:

    “…aw, shucks. I ain’t perfect, but I’m sure not a sex trafficker. Juries tend to really like that.” ([51:00], Brennan)

• Systemic implications:

  • Prosecution forced to use federal offenses due to statutes of limitations on sexual violence; NDA use shields abusers and silences witnesses ([53:41–55:26], Brennan).

  • “It sends a really unfortunate message to future victims and prosecutors about where we are socially right now… We’re not in the thick of the MeToo movement anymore. I think we’ve taken some steps back…” ([53:14], Brennan)

Notable Quotes & Timestamps

| Speaker | Quote | Timestamp | |----------------------|----------------------------------------------------------------------------|-----------| | Jesse Weber | “Was this the collapse of a criminal enterprise or just the unraveling of a complicated life?” | 01:22 | | Elizabeth Milner | “The judge says that he will change the sentence in context of conspiracy, actions may speak louder than words.” | 03:40 | | Kristi Slavik (recounted by Milner) | “Sean Combs has a small army of personal staff. No one could stop him. He used his inner circle and money to cover up his crime…” | 07:19 | | Mark Agnifilo | “It’s a tale of two trials. The first trial is about witnesses and videos and texts and evidence… The second trial was just the word of mouth by the prosecutors.” | 14:17 | | Maureen Comey | “He is not a God… This ends in this courtroom. Hold him accountable.” | 17:10 | | Dan Abrams | “This isn’t a question of did he do it or didn’t he do it—We know he did really bad things. The question is, did those really bad things fall into the legal definition…” | 27:57 | | Matt Murphy | “He didn’t make any money from the freak offs… He may be a villain, but he made that money legally… I think it’d be a very poor move if they tried to take a bunch of his stuff.” | 31:34 | | Mackenzie J. Brennan | “Cassie was 19 when she met Diddy, and he was pushing 40… That’s a really common dynamic… multiple fronts of dependence and pressure…” | 44:45 | | Mackenzie J. Brennan | “Once you bring violence into the picture, every subsequent act is influenced by that specter.” | 46:04 | | Mackenzie J. Brennan | “It sends a really unfortunate message to future victims and future prosecutors about where we are socially right now.” | 53:14 | | Jesse Weber | “The courtroom waited, and so did the world.” | 26:46 |

Verdict Segment Timeline

• Deliberations & Verdict Announcement: [19:50–22:30]
• Legal and media analysis: [22:30–30:00]
• Sentencing, civil lawsuits, asset implications: [30:00–35:00]
• Bail, custody, and logistics: [35:00–40:45]
• Deep legal/social analysis with Mackenzie J. Brennan: [40:45–56:16]

Tone & Style

The episode maintains a somber, suspenseful, and analytical tone, balancing courtroom drama with clear-eyed legal analysis and social commentary. Insightful and unflinching, the speakers treat the material with gravity—never shying from uncomfortable truths, yet always rooting their commentary in the evidence and law.

Summary for Non-Listeners

This episode provides an in-depth, vivid retelling of the climax and aftermath of Sean "Diddy" Combs’ federal trial. It recaps the intricate legal maneuvers, the emotionally charged closing statements, and the split verdict that, while sparing Combs from life sentences, still left him convicted of serious Mann Act violations. Legal experts unpack why the most serious charges failed to land, how cultural attitudes about power, consent, and celebrity shape outcomes, and what Combs’ future holds inside and outside the courtroom. If you’re seeking to understand how celebrity, legal strategy, social norms, and the justice system intersect in the case of Diddy, this episode is essential listening—and this summary captures the heart of the discussion.

For further episodes and more crime series, join Wondery+ for ad-free access.