Nowhere Left to Run: 3

Summary

The Rise and Fall of Diddy: Episode "Nowhere Left to Run: 3"

Release Date: March 4, 2025
Host: Jesse Weber
Available Exclusively on Wondery+

---

Introduction: The Arrest of Sean "Diddy" Combs

The episode opens with a vivid portrayal of the morning of September 16, 2024, in Midtown Manhattan. Jesse Weber narrates the meticulously orchestrated operation that led to the arrest of Sean "Diddy" Combs, a figure once revered as hip-hop's reigning mogul. Agents from the Department of Homeland Security, in collaboration with local law enforcement and federal prosecutors, executed a well-coordinated warrant at the Park Hyatt Hotel, where Diddy had been residing for a week anticipating his imminent arrest.

Notable Quote:

• Legal Expert ([02:40]): "Whatever happens, Diddy is facing up to life in prison."

The arrest was swift and professional, devoid of the dramatics one might expect from a high-profile celebrity. As Diddy was processed into the Metropolitan Detention Center in Brooklyn, the media frenzy began, signaling the beginning of a dramatic fall from grace for the mogul.

Unveiling the Indictment: Serious Allegations Surface

On September 17, 2024, U.S. Attorney Damian Williams held a press conference to unseal a three-count indictment against Diddy. The charges were severe, encompassing racketeering, conspiracy, sex trafficking, interstate transportation for prostitution, and more. Williams detailed a pattern of abuse, coercion, and criminal activities that spanned over a decade.

Notable Quotes:

• Damian Williams ([06:41]): "Today I'm announcing the unsealing of a three count indictment charging Sean Combs with racketeering, conspiracy, sex trafficking, interstate transportation for prostitution."
• Legal Expert ([08:47]): "I think the freak offs were the most shocking thing in the indictment... he didn't care about getting caught because he thought he would never get caught."

One of the most shocking aspects of the indictment was the revelation of "freak offs"—extended sex parties involving multiple commercial sex workers and the use of narcotics to control and abuse victims. These activities were not only illegal but were allegedly orchestrated to protect Diddy's reputation and eliminate any threats to his empire.

Bail Hearing: Denial and Its Ramifications

Following the indictment, the legal team faced a crucial bail hearing on September 18, 2024. Prosecution argued against bail due to the gravity of the charges, Diddy's flight risk, and his alleged history of witness intimidation.

Notable Quotes:

• Legal Analyst ([12:59]): "There are three main reasons... he's a danger to the community... he's a flight risk... he had been known to obstruct and tamper with witnesses."
• Defense Attorney ([14:21]): "To have him detained without being convicted, I think is cruel and unusual punishment."

Judge Robin Tarnowski ultimately denied bail, citing the severity of the crimes and the potential risks if Diddy were released. This decision intensified public and media scrutiny, setting the stage for a prolonged legal battle.

Escalation of Legal Troubles: Emerging Allegations and Lawsuits

As the case against Diddy progressed, additional allegations surfaced, particularly concerning the trafficking of minors. By late October 2024, two more lawsuits emerged:

1. 2005 Incident: An anonymous plaintiff, a 10-year-old aspiring rapper, alleged being drugged and sexually assaulted by Diddy during a purported audition.
2. 2008 Incident: A 17-year-old male claimed sexual assault by Diddy and a bodyguard during an audition for the MTV reality show "Making the Band."

Notable Quotes:

• Victims' Advocate ([19:23]): "Our team has had at this point More than 3,285 individuals contact us... we now represent 120 individuals who intend to bring civil claims."
• Legal Expert ([19:10]): "I do think the issue of minors will come up because of the testimony of Don Richard who alleged that there were minors who were victims here."

These allegations significantly escalated the case, drawing parallels to high-profile scandals like that of Jeffrey Epstein, and hinted at the possibility of additional charges and defendants.

Prosecution and Defense Strategies: Building the Case

As the trial date approached, set for May 5, 2025, both sides meticulously prepared their strategies. The prosecution focused on establishing a criminal enterprise led by Diddy, emphasizing the non-consensual nature of the "freak offs" and the use of coercion and narcotics to control victims.

Notable Quotes:

• Legal Commentator ([23:29]): "Is that the only way to control and stop that so that they can have integrity in their case is to keep him incarcerated... all of his phone calls will be intercepted."
• Legal Analyst ([25:23]): "The prosecution has to prove in this case that people were in fact sex trafficked... for Sean Combs' benefit."

Conversely, the defense aimed to portray the events as consensual activities among adults, challenging the prosecution to prove coercion and lack of consent. Mark Agnifolo, Diddy's attorney, expressed confidence in their ability to demonstrate innocence and counter the allegations.

Notable Quotes:

• Defense Attorney ([27:10]): "That these freak offs are between consensual adults... What makes it illegal is whether the person committed those acts under fraud, force or coercion."
• Legal Expert ([28:27]): "The Feds have a 97% conviction rate... they really don't mess around."

Potential Implications and Public Perception

The case against Diddy not only threatened his personal freedom but also his legacy and influence in the entertainment industry. Legal experts and commentators weighed in on the potential outcomes, with some predicting a challenging path for the prosecution despite the strong allegations.

Notable Quotes:

• Legal Analyst 2 ([29:07]): "I think Sean Combs, the mogul as we know it, is over. He will never be that person again."
• Legal Expert ([25:35]): "The key to proving lack of consent is putting the victim on the stand... It's a high stakes prosecution."

Conclusion: A Pivotal Moment in Entertainment and Law

As the trial looms, the episode underscores the profound impact of the case on all involved parties. Diddy's fall from grace serves as a stark reminder of the intersection between power, fame, and accountability. Regardless of the trial's outcome, the legal proceedings against Diddy are poised to redefine perceptions of misconduct within the entertainment sphere.

Notable Quotes:

• Jesse Weber ([30:10]): "What's happening to him now is one of the greatest tragedies that we're gonna ever read about. This is going to be one of the greatest tragedies that Shakespeare couldn't write and he brought it on himself."
• Diddy's Attorney ([29:48]): "It's important to learn a lesson right now and ensure the next generation understands how to move differently with transparency and integrity."

The episode concludes by highlighting the scheduled trial date of May 5, 2025, hinting at further developments and the continuing unraveling of Sean "Diddy" Combs' empire.

---

Key Takeaways:

• Arrest and Indictment: Diddy's arrest was the culmination of a lengthy investigation uncovering severe allegations of abuse and criminal activities.
• Legal Proceedings: The denial of bail and the emergence of additional lawsuits, especially involving minors, have intensified the legal battle.
• Prosecution vs. Defense: The prosecution presents a strong case based on multiple victim testimonies, while the defense challenges the consensual nature of the alleged activities.
• Public and Media Impact: The case has captivated public attention, drawing parallels to other high-profile scandals and raising questions about accountability in the entertainment industry.
• Legacy at Stake: Beyond legal repercussions, the trial threatens to irreparably damage Diddy's legacy and influence.

---

For those intrigued by this high-stakes legal drama, "The Rise and Fall of Diddy" offers an in-depth exploration of power, fame, and accountability in the life of one of hip-hop's most influential figures.

Transcript

[Jesse Weber]

You're listening to a law and crime series available exclusively on Wondery. To listen to the remaining episodes, join Wonder plus and enjoy ad free listening to over 50,000 episodes, including more thrilling law and crime series like Karen and Sidebar with Jesse Weber, Join Wondery plus in the Wondery app, Apple Podcasts, or Spotify.

[Legal Analyst]

This is a lawn crime presentation. This podcast contains references to sex, abuse, violence and crime and may contain harsh language. All individuals mentioned are presumed innocent until proven guilty in a court of law. Please listen with care.

[Jesse Weber]

It was a surreal morning in Midtown Manhattan on September 16, 2024. The city moved to its usual rhythm. Taxis honking, pedestrians hustling, the noise of construction mixing with the hum of conversation. But in one corner of the city, a quiet storm brewed. The operation began in the early hours, with agents fanning out across multiple locations tied to Diddy. The Department of Homeland Security had worked closely with local law enforcement and federal prosecutors to ensure that every detail was in place. It wasn't just about securing a single arrest. It was about dismantling what the indictment would later describe as a network engaged in years of criminal activity. Jesse I'm Jesse Weber, and this is the rise and fall of Diddy at the Park Hyatt Hotel in midtown Manhattan, where Diddy had been holed up for a week. Anticipating his imminent arrest, agents executed their warrant with precision. A convoy of unmarked vehicles rolled up to the luxury building, their arrival swift and calculated. Within moments, the team entered, securing the premises. Diddy, accustomed to commanding rooms with his presence, was caught off guard by the quiet professionalism of the agents as he entered the hotel, his entourage in tow. There were no raised voices, no dramatics, only the cold, methodical process of taking him to a back room, reading him his rights, placing him in handcuffs, and taking him into federal custody. The convoy wove through Manhattan, heading toward the federal Detention center in Brooklyn. Diddy, seated in the back, was silent, his mind likely racing. The charges weren't just allegations. They were an indictment of his life, his choices, his very identity.

[Legal Expert]

Whatever happens, Diddy is facing up to life in prison.

[Jesse Weber]

By the time Diddy reached Brooklyn's Metropolitan Detention center, the news of his arrest had already broken.

[Legal Expert]

You go from living large with your multimillion dollar mansion and your private plane and your fancy cigars, to living in a rat infested detention facility until you're wearing an orange jumpsuit and a pair of steel bracelets. It's not real. Now it's real.

[Jesse Weber]

Media outlets blared headlines. Sean Diddy Combs arrested on federal charges Outside the facility, protesters and supporters gathered, their voices mixing into a chaotic cacophony. But inside, Diddy was processed like any other detainee. His fingerprints were taken. His mugshot captured a stark departure from the red carpets and flashing lights he was used to. As the cell door closed behind him, Diddy was left with the cold, hard reality of his situation. The man who had once towered over the music industry, who had transformed culture and built an empire, now sat alone, stripped of power and privilege. The clang of the metal bars reverberated in his ears, a sound that would mark the first chapter of the fight for his freedom. Simultaneously, other teams were busy collecting evidence from key properties associated with the Mogul. Offices, storage units and a private estate were all targeted with agents confiscating documents, electronic devices and other materials. Every move was coordinated down to the minute, ensuring that no detail was overlooked and no potential leads were lost.

[Legal Analyst]

It took six months, ish from when the raid happened to when the arrest happened. I thought that it would take anywhere up to a year, quite, quite frankly, for an arrest to be made. I think folks don't fully understand how long it takes to go through digital evidence. It takes so long because there is so much hours and hours and hours and hours of video, hours of phone texts, hours of phone calls. All of those things take a lot of resources to process and a lot of time. And then you have to go through and identify the, these nameless individuals that are in these videos. So then that whole process takes a while as well. They actually, in my opinion, probably actually made this a priority in terms of processing through all of that. So I think it happened quickly.

[Jesse Weber]

As the day unfolded, news of the arrest went global. Paparazzi and reporters swarmed outside the building, their cameras flashing as federal vehicles departed the scene. Social media exploded with speculation, disbelief and debate. For some, the arrest was shocking. For others, it was the long awaited reckoning of a powerful figure. Yet this was only the beginning.

[Damian Williams]

Don't miss the Hulu original docu series Devil in the Family the Fall of Ruby Frankie. My wife created a YouTube channel.

[Jesse Weber]

Thumbs up. Subscribe, but only what we wanted to show.

[Damian Williams]

I'm still recording a three part series event.

[Jesse Weber]

She said the children were demonically possessed. Get out. That blew the powder keg.

[Damian Williams]

Ruby crossed the line to psychotic 900 emergency.

[Defense Attorney]

Open the door.

[Jesse Weber]

Hulu Stabil in the Family the Fall.

[Damian Williams]

Of Ruby Frankie all episodes now streaming on Hulu.

[Jesse Weber]

On the morning of September 17, 2024, the press briefing room at the Southern District of New York's U.S. attorney's office was abuzz with anticipation. Journalists, legal analysts and curious onlookers filled the space, all awaiting a significant announcement. At precisely 10am Damian Williams, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, stepped up to the podium, his demeanor composed yet resolute.

[Damian Williams]

Today I'm announcing the unsealing of a three count indictment charging Sean Combs with racketeering, conspiracy, sex trafficking, interstate transportation for prostitution.

[Jesse Weber]

The room fell silent as Williams detailed.

[Damian Williams]

The allegations between at least 2008 and the present. Combs abused, threatened and coerced victims to fulfill his sexual desires, protect his reputation and conceal his conduct. Sean Combs led and participated in a racketeering conspiracy that used the business empire he controlled to carry out criminal activity, including sex trafficking, forced labor, kidnapping, arson, bribery and the obstruction of justice.

[Jesse Weber]

Behind him, a display showcased images of evidence seized during the raids on Combs residences in Los Angeles and Miami. The photographs included AR15 rifles with deface serial numbers, high capacity ammunition magazines, and electronic devices containing explicit images and videos. Williams pointed to these items, underscoring the severity of the charges. Then he shared the allegation that got everybody's attention.

[Damian Williams]

Combs allegedly planned and controlled sex performances which he called freak offs and he often electronically recorded them. The freak offs sometimes lasted days at a time, involved multiple commercial sex workers and often involved a variety of narcotics such as ketamine, ecstasy and GHB which Combs distributed to the victims to keep them obedient and compliant as alleged. When Combs didn't get his way, he was violent and he subjected victims of physical, emotional and verbal abuse so that they would participate in the freak offs and that Combs hit, kicked, threw objects at and dragged victims at times by their hair.

[Jesse Weber]

The confirmation of the freak offs spurred audible gasps.

[Legal Expert]

I think the freak offs were the most shocking thing in the indictment. It's one thing to know that he had wild parties, but then the fact that Diddy filmed himself and filmed others showed that he didn't care about getting caught because he thought he would never get caught.

[Legal Analyst]

The freakoffs are really kind of a focus of this indictment. All of this kind of came together there and that was these individuals who were basically being trafficked across state lines to engage in these kind of multi day, if not week sometimes sex parties where they were being basically assaulted and being made to do things against their will, being drugged, being tied up and then being beaten so badly that they couldn't go back out in public for days after.

[Legal Commentator]

At its core, what the government is saying is that there's a criminal enterprise that Sean Combs is the leader of that transports women and male prostitutes for the purpose of having these freak offs, these sex parties where people are drugged and they have sex for days on end. There are a number of charges underneath them, but the freak offs in these parties are really at the heart of this case.

[Jesse Weber]

One would assume that once Combs knew he was being targeted by federal authorities, he would have straightened up his act. But that's not what happened.

[Legal Analyst]

The freak offs continued after that March raid, but I guess the reality is is did he has gotten off with so much in terms of law enforcement that it's not surprising that he would feel that brazen and emboldened to continue them.

[Jesse Weber]

And as he concluded his remarks, Williams made a direct appeal.

[Damian Williams]

This investigation is ongoing, and I encourage anyone with information about this case to come forward and to do it quickly.

[Jesse Weber]

The gravity of the announcement was palpable, and the reverence for the victims who spurred the indictment was not lost on anybody.

[Damian Williams]

I want to express my deep appreciation for the victims and witnesses who have used their voices and helped bring this criminal conduct to light. We would not be here without them.

[Jesse Weber]

For Damian Williams, it was a pivotal moment in his tenure as U.S. attorney, marking a significant step in the pursuit of justice.

[Damian Williams]

He used his business and employees of that business and other close associates to get his way. A year ago, Sean Combs stood in Times Square and was handed a key to New York City. Today, he's been indicted and will face justice.

[Jesse Weber]

For Diddy and his team, this was a nightmare, albeit predictable.

[Legal Expert]

Diddy knew what was coming, and that's what his lawyers said. He came to New York because he knew this could happen.

[Jesse Weber]

He could be arrested outside the courthouse. After his arraignment, Diddy's attorney, Mark Agnifolo, made a statement of his own.

[Diddy's Attorney]

I spent. I spent the evening with him. I was with him until about 1:00. His spirits are good. He's confident. He is dealing with this head on the way. He's dealt with every challenge in his life, and he's not guilty. He's innocent of these charges. We're gonna fight this case without everything we have, as is he. And eventually he's going to be shown to be innocent. And so tomorrow we fight again. And we fight. We'll fight every day until we don't have to fight anymore.

[Jesse Weber]

And if he loses the fight, the.

[Legal Commentator]

Charges in the latest indictment are very serious from a jail time perspective. The racketeering conspiracy, minimum minimum of 20 years to life. Trafficking, minimum 15 to life, and the transportation for the purpose of prostitution up to 10 years. For someone who's in their mid-50s, that's a lot of jail time, Even if he gets the low end of it being in prison for the rest of his life.

[Jesse Weber]

But before he'd face the trial, Diddy's defense would have to contend with the battle for bail. The hearing was set for September 18, 2024. As the session commenced, US Magistrate Judge Robin Tarnowski presided over the proceedings. The prosecution, led by Assistant U.S. attorney Megan Smith, presented a compelling argument against granting bail. Smith detailed the severity of the charges and emphasized the potential risks associated with Combs release.

[Legal Expert]

There are three main reasons why. Number one, the allegations show he's a danger to the community. Number two, he's a flight risk. I mean, here's a guy with lots of resources, lots of connections around the world. And third, he had been known to obstruct and tamper with witnesses to try to intimidate them. Why wouldn't he try to do that if he's out?

[Jesse Weber]

In response, Combs defense attorney Mark Agnifolo presented a robust case for bail. He proposed a comprehensive bail package, including a $50 million Bond Co signed by Combs and several family members, the surrender of his passport, home detention with electronic monitoring, and regular check ins with pretrial services. Agnifolo argued that these conditions would mitigate any flight risk or potential for witness tampering. After considering the arguments, Judge Tarnofsky delivered her decision. She acknowledged the defense's proposed conditions, but ultimately sided with the prosecution, citing the gravity of the charges and the potential risks. She denied Bailey, ordering that Combs remain in federal custody pending trial. Her decision garnered mixed reactions.

[Legal Analyst]

The fact that he wasn't granted bail is not necessarily a bad thing. He has a history in that indictment of seriously intimidating witnesses.

[Defense Attorney]

I was disappointed in the judge's decision because with such a bail package that was presented, it was more than enough to secure his presence in court. But to have him detained without being convicted, I think is cruel and unusual punishment.

[Jesse Weber]

And inside the courtroom, Combs, known for his composed demeanor, maintained his stoic expression. Though the weight of the ruling was evident, his legal team immediately indicated plans to appeal the decision, setting the stage for further legal battles in the weeks to come. Outside, a throng of media personnel and onlookers awaited. The news of the bail denial spread rapidly, adding another layer of complexity to the high profile case that had already captured public attention. Legal experts began analyzing the potential ramifications of the charges. Discussions emerged about the likelihood of a.

[Legal Commentator]

Plea deal plea deals are always possible. And I think people in my position as legal analysts, contributors, hosts, whatever the title we have, we're always hesitant to make predictions because oftentimes we're wrong. But this is my thought process. This case is going to trial. The reason why I say that is because I can't imagine a plea deal that the government would give Sean Combs that one society would be okay with and that two Sean Combs would take. Because if he's looking at a minimum of 20 years to life on the RICO, what deal is the government going to give him? 15 years? 10 years? I mean, if he's offered 10 or 15 years, he'd better take that and run. As horrible as that sounds, Thumbtack presents.

[Legal Analyst]

The ins and outs of caring for your home. Out uncertainties, self doubt, stressing about not knowing where to start in plans and guides that make it easy to get home projects done. Out word art, sorry Live laugh lovers in knowing what to do, when to do it and who to hire. Start caring for your home with confidence. Download thumbtack today.

[Jesse Weber]

Meanwhile, Combs legal team prepared for the upcoming court proceedings, emphasizing his presumption of innocence and vowing a vigorous defense. The days following the arrest marked the beginning of a complex legal battle, with the public and media closely monitoring each development and a lot of speculation about what might come next.

[Legal Expert]

Now that he's behind bars pretrial, you'll see more people come forward who otherwise would have been scared.

[Defense Attorney]

Definitely other people will be subpoenaed. I'm curious to see whether other people have been mentioned and the prosecution has struck deals with them to have them cooperate and testify against Sean Combs or whether down the line there'll be additional charges and additional defendants on the indictment.

[Legal Expert]

This is a serious case against Diddy. Additional allegations could come out against him. There could be a superseding indictment.

[Legal Analyst]

I believe that there is far more evidence that the government has that they didn't need to disclose to get this arrest warrant for him. You said we are not done and.

[Jesse Weber]

That Combs did not do this alone. Do you foresee that there could be.

[Legal Analyst]

Other charges related to this case?

[Damian Williams]

I'm not taking anything off the table.

[Jesse Weber]

Could other elites be implicated in the fallout?

[Legal Expert]

Already you're hearing rumors of other celebrities associated with this. No one wants to be mentioned in the same sentence as Diddy. Right now this is getting towards Jeffrey Epstein levels and no one wants to be in that neighborhood. So I think that as this moves forward, I think you'll see a lot more attention paid to It I think you'll see celebrities running away from it and I think you'll see additional charges and victims come out.

[Jesse Weber]

While DA Williams mentioned both victims and witnesses in his news conference, in the actual indictment, no victims are listed specifically, but one is implied.

[Defense Attorney]

When we look at the indictment, they mentioned victim number one. But when you look at the allegations specifically about a hotel incident that was captured on video where allegedly Sean Combs had beaten on Cass Ventura, you can only infer that the person that they're talking about as victim number one is Cassi Ventura. Other victims haven't been named in the indictment itself. It could be possibly because when it comes to sexual assault cases, usually you do not mention their name. You keep them under a pseudonym or as a victim number one or victim number two.

[Jesse Weber]

And more shockingly, besides the victim's names, something else was left out of the indictment.

[Legal Analyst]

In Ronnie Jones's civil lawsuit, he alleges potentially the trafficking of minors.

[Jesse Weber]

Rodney wasn't the only one to make this claim.

[Legal Expert]

I do think the issue of minors will come up because of the testimony of Don Richard who alleged that there were minors who were victims here. It just hasn't been charged yet.

[Jesse Weber]

It did come back up.

[Victims' Advocate]

The wall of silence has now been broken and victims are coming forward. Our team has had at this point More than 3,285 individuals contact us with people claiming to have been victimized by Sean Combs. After vetting, we now represent 120 individuals who intend to bring civil claims in civil court against Sean Diddy Combs, as well as claims against many other individuals and entities that we will name as defendants as we file these individual cases.

[Jesse Weber]

In late October 2024, the legal troubles of Sean Diddy Combs intensified with the emergence of two more harrowing lawsuits alleging sexual misconduct involving minors. The first lawsuit, filed by an anonymous plaintiff, recounts a 2005 incident where a 10 year old aspiring rapper was invited to a New York hotel under the pretense of an audition. There he alleges he was drugged and sexually assaulted by Combs. The second lawsuit details events from 2008. A 17 year old male attended an audition eager to participate in the MTV reality show Making the Band, which Combs hosted and produced. The lawsuit alleges that during this audition, Combs and a bodyguard sexually assaulted the teenager. And attorney Tony Busby claims there's more than just these two.

[Legal Analyst]

How many minors are making accusations in total? And are the feds aware of the allegations of minors in the case?

[Victims' Advocate]

I don't know what the feds are aware of. Okay, but I do know it's 25 out of this 120.

[Jesse Weber]

In response to these mounting allegations, Combs has consistently denied any wrongdoing. His legal team has characterized the claims as baseless and has vowed to vigorously defend against them. Despite these denials, the sheer volume and nature of the allegations have led to increased scrutiny from both the public and law enforcement agencies as victims continue to come forward. In the months following his arrest, Diddy, confined within the austere walls of the Metropolitan Detention center in Brooklyn, continued digging a hole for himself. Despite the physical barriers, prosecutors allege that Combs orchestrated a clandestine campaign to manipulate the forthcoming legal proceedings. Prosecutors have accused Diddy of attempting to influence witnesses and potential jurors from jail, alleging he used unauthorized communication methods to contact individuals involved in the case. Utilizing the prison's communication systems, Combs reportedly circumvented monitoring protocols by employing other inmates phone accounts and engaging in unauthorized three way calls. Through these channels, he allegedly reached out to potential witnesses, exerting pressure to alter their testimonies or dissuade them from cooperating with authorities. Beyond direct contact, Combs is accused of leveraging his influence to sway public perception. Prosecutors claim he orchestrated social media campaigns, enlisting family members to post content aimed at garnering sympathy and casting doubt on the allegations against him. One notable instance involved a birthday video shared by his son, which prosecutors argue was intended to influence potential jurors. By portraying Combs in a favorable light. These alleged actions have intensified the legal scrutiny surrounding Combs. Prosecutors contend that his alleged attempts to manipulate witnesses and public opinion from behind bars underscore a blatant disregard for the judicial process, further complicating his attempts to be granted bail and his defense's work as the trial approaches, the government's argument.

[Legal Analyst]

Is that the only way to control and stop that so that they can have integrity in their case is to keep him incarcerated so that they can legally intercept his communications. He has no right to privacy. All of his phone calls will be intercepted.

[Advertisement Voice]

You know that ding means you're going somewhere exciting, but do you know what this one means? It's the sound you hear when learning a new language with Babbel. Babbel's quick 10 minute lessons, handcrafted by over 200 language experts, get you to begin speaking your new language in three weeks or whatever pace you choose. Let's get more of you talking in a new language. Babbel is gifting our listeners 60% off [e-mail] truecrime get up to 60% [e-mail] trueCrime spelled B-A-B-B-E-L.com truecrime babel.com truecrime rules and restrictions may apply.

[Jesse Weber]

A federal judge has scheduled Combs trial to begin on May 5, 2025. As the legal battle continues, both the prosecution and defense are preparing for a complex trial that will scrutinize the allegations against Combs and the evidence presented. Given all the videotapes, personal accounts and lawsuits, will the trial of Diddy be an easy win for the Southern District of New York?

[Legal Commentator]

I don't think that this case against Sean Combs is a slam dunk for the prosecution, but I do think it's a layup on a five foot rim. I think it is a very easy case for them to put together.

[Legal Expert]

The strength of the prosecution's case is the multiple individuals who have come forward with similar stories. The victims are the key here. And when those allegations are corroborated by others who say similar things, that's the strength of the prosecution's case.

[Legal Analyst 2]

The prosecution has to prove in this case that people were in fact sex trafficked, meaning that people were brought in to perform sexual favors and sexual acts for someone else for Sean Combs benefit.

[Jesse Weber]

But for the sdny, it could be an uphill battle to prove lack of consent without putting victims on the stand.

[Legal Analyst]

There are people that have claimed that Diddy put drugs in some of their drinks and that they were coerced into these freak offs and that he filmed them and then used the video footage of these freak offs to intimidate or bribe certain people that were involved in these sessions.

[Legal Expert]

The key to proving lack of consent is putting the victim on the stand and saying I did not agree to this. This is a high stakes prosecution and the feds are going to cross every T and dot every I. You don't want to lose a case when the entire world is watching. When you had a press conference to make very serious allegations. And the target, the defendant, you is a billionaire loved by millions around the globe with the best lawyers money can buy.

[Jesse Weber]

And the defense team faces the critical task of challenging the prosecution's case to prevent a conviction. In criminal trials, the prosecution bears the burden of proving the defendant's guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. The defense is not required to prove innocence but must effectively cast doubt on the prosecution's evidence. Their main argument, the freak offs were consensual.

[Legal Analyst]

His attorney has said that he is going to employ the defense that these were all consenting individuals. Everyone wanted to be there and everyone was partaking in all of this.

[Defense Attorney]

That these freak offs are between consensual adults. And it's not a crime to be a freak or to engage in sexual activity with multiple partners. What makes it illegal is whether the person committed those acts under fraud, force or coercion.

[Jesse Weber]

The jury will ultimately decide. So who can we expect to take the stand?

[Legal Commentator]

I think we'll see people like Cassie and Rodney Jones who filed these lawsuits. Potential other victims or alleged victims who also filed civil lawsuits could potentially be testifying as well to help corroborate. I think at the most part, I think Cassie is the star witness because this case seems to be predicated and built on her allegations.

[Jesse Weber]

And how likely is it that Diddy himself will testify?

[Legal Analyst 2]

I think Sean Combs will likely take the stand. It's in his benefit. And he has the personality, the Persona and the experience speaking to people in order to be successful at doing so.

[Jesse Weber]

Diddy's team may very well be banking on it as their God shot.

[Diddy's Attorney]

He testified in his last trial and he got acquitted. You know, he's a man who knows what it's like to have a jury of 12 New Yorkers look at you and say, not guilty. And he's looking forward to that happening again.

[Jesse Weber]

But these are the feds we're talking about.

[Legal Expert]

The Feds have a 97% conviction rate for a reason. They've got lots of resources. They take limited cases. So they're not filing cases they don't think they can win.

[Legal Analyst]

If the federal government comes for you in an indictment, you're probably going to go to jail. They really don't mess around.

[Jesse Weber]

However it all plays out, it's sure to be life changing for many people. Alleged victims, witnesses, and the accused perpetrator himself, Sean Diddy Combs, whether or not he actually serves prison time, his imminent trial has shifted attitudes about accountability and misconduct within the entertainment world.

[Legal Analyst 2]

I think Sean Combs, the mogul as we know it, is over. He will never be that person again. Even if he's found not guilty of these charges.

[Legal Analyst]

Even at the criminal level, there are certain things that are just unforgivable. And I don't think anyone's going to want to align themselves with him.

[Legal Expert]

But as far as whether people will still listen to his music, I don't think this will be the end of Diddy on our airwaves.

[Jesse Weber]

We're talking about a person who contributed so much to culture, you know what I'm saying? You're talking about a person who helped provide soundtracks to our lives. You had to be inspired by Sean Combs in some way, shape or form.

[Diddy's Attorney]

Diddy's been an icon for decades. We've all listened to his music, we've all been around him that at least in my era and have looked up to him. And in this situation it's super unfortunate, but it's important to learn a lesson right right now and ensure the next generation understands how to move differently with transparency and integrity.

[Jesse Weber]

What's happening to him now is one of the greatest tragedies that we gonna ever read about, bro. This is going to be one of the greatest tragedy that Shakespeare couldn't write and he brought it on himself. Sean Combs trial is currently slated for May 2025. Since it's a federal case, there won't be cameras in the courtroom, or even audio for that matter. But wherever this story goes, we'll be there. Stay Subscribed to be the first to know when we drop new episodes. This has been a law and crime production. I'm your host Jesse Weber. Our executive producer is Jessica Lowther. Our writer and producer is Cooper Maul. Our editor is Anna McClain. Additional writing and guest booking by Lisa Feit and Julie Wheeler. Legal review and fact checking by Elizabeth Voulai. Key art design by Sean Penzera and special thanks to our contributors Dave Aronberg, Brian Buckmire Minalona, Dante Mills, Tracey Walder, Natalie Whittingham Burrell and Bernarda Villalona. Follow long Crimes the Rise and Fall of Diddy on the Wondery App. You can listen to more episodes exclusively and ad free right now on Wondery plus. Join Wondery plus in the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts or Spotify and get ad free access to more thrilling law and crime series like Karen and Sidebar with Jesse Weber. Start your free trial today.