The Rob Carson Show – "New York Elects a Marxist! Rob Carson Breaks Out the Popcorn"

Date: November 5, 2025
Host: Rob Carson (Newsmax Podcasts)
Guests/Contributors: Tom Basilli, Greg Kelly, Bill O’Reilly, Political Analysts, Callers

Episode Overview

In this episode, Rob Carson reacts to the results of the latest New York City mayoral election, focusing on the election of Zoran Mandami, described as a “Marxist” and “radical Islamist communist” by Carson and guests. The conversation spans reactions to local Virginia and New Jersey elections, perceptions of the Democratic Party’s ideological shift, and implications for national politics. The episode is characteristically energetic, combative, and laced with humor, parody, and pointed commentary aligned with Carson's conservative populist style.

Main Themes & Structure

1. Dissection of Election Results
2. Diagnosis of the Democratic Party
3. Exploration of National Political Trends
4. Analysis of Zoran Mandami’s Victory & Its Meaning
5. Concerns about Policy, Crime, and Socialism
6. Strategic Outlook for Conservatives
7. Notable Moments & Quotes

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Election Night Disappointments & Analysis

• Virginia:
  • Rob expresses disappointment in Virginia’s gubernatorial and lieutenant governor races, citing lackluster Republican candidates and money-fueled Democratic campaigns.
  • Quote: “Winsome Sears… has the charisma of an armadillo. Does it surprise us that she lost? No, not really.” (03:09)
• New Jersey & Maryland:
  • Compares Democratic dominance to “a frog in boiling water” where residents are unaware of gradual decline.
  • Observes that left-leaning states continue to elect Democrats despite mounting problems, and opts for humor: “Same goes with Maryland. It is a frog in boiling water. They've been boiling there.” (09:51)

2. New York City’s “Radical” Turn

• Mandami’s Victory Unpacked:
  • Carson insists Mandami’s election is not a surprise, asserting an overwhelming advantage due to funding ($40 million, including George Soros), weak opposition, and political dynasties.
  • Dismisses the idea that Bernie Sanders’ claim of an “upset” is viable: “No, it's not…For the last, I don't know, about six months, I’ve been saying he's going to win. It was a fait accompli.” (04:30)
• Impact:
  • Predicts Mandami will pursue far-left, socialist/Marxist and “anti-cop, anti-capitalist” policies, leading to urban decline, outmigration, and economic failure.

3. National Implications & The State of the “Far Left”

• The “Democrat Party is Dead” Claim:
  • Carson asserts the Democratic Party, led by figures like AOC, Sanders, and now Mandami, is hurtling further left, ignoring the prior year’s defeat.
  • Quote: “The victory of Zoran Mandami solidified the death of the Democrat Party…They’re leaning into the dustbin.” (07:20)
• Republican Outlook:
  • Downplays the influence of blue state results on the rest of the nation, citing Trump’s purported recent successes and suggesting the left’s extremism is a gift to conservatives.
• Bill Maher Reference:
  • Cites Maher’s analogy of Democrats to “Sears” — suggesting irrelevance and obsolescence — and low polling numbers for the party. (08:58)

4. Parody, Humor, & Satirical Commentary

• Incorporates a satirical New York anthem, lamenting progressive governance with musical parody: “…they’ll make a brand new start of it—outside New York…” (11:37)
• Uses repeated analogies:
  • Dysfunctional romance: “What happened in New York City was essentially, if your daughter moved in with an abusive, bad boyfriend…All you can do is watch her live through it.” (12:05)
  • Culinary disgust: “A crap sandwich. You had a choice between the actual crap and the crap stained bread.” (05:10)

5. Guest Contribution: Tom Basilli on “The Mandami Effect”

• Marxism’s Institutional Progression:
  • Basilli traces a “march through the institutions” culminating in Mandami’s unapologetic socialism.
  • Quote: “This is an inflection point…You will see a Momdami effect where there will be more Islamic, there will be more socialists, there will be more Marxists who will start running for office…” (22:33)
• Legitimacy & Mainstreaming:
  • Warns Mandami’s win will encourage similar candidates in other cities, normalizing radical platforms nationally.
• Comparison to de Blasio & Obama:
  • Basilli likens Mandami to Obama as a “media creation” but, unlike de Blasio, more charismatic and promising utopian ideas.
• Policy Predictions:
  • Forecasts emboldened anti-police measures, possible increase in crime, NYPD retirements, diminished business investment, risk of the city becoming a haven for radicalism, and financial disaster.
  • Quote: “He’s in favor of opening the jails…He wants to go after police officers…I fear that New York will become a safe haven for radical Islamists.” (35:35)
• Call to Action for Conservatives:
  • Urges Republicans and Trump supporters to stay engaged post-Trump, warning that demotivation enables the spread of “Marxist socialists, radical Islamists.”

6. Zoran Mandami’s Own Words

• Victory Speech:
  • Mandami unapologetically names himself a Muslim, a Democratic Socialist, and “far from the perfect candidate.”
  • Quote: “I am young despite my best efforts to grow older. I am Muslim. I am a democratic socialist. And most damning of all, I refuse to apologize for any of this.” (21:03)
  • References Nehru: “A moment comes, but rarely in history, when we step out from the old to the new…”
  • Carson’s sardonic response: “We were suppressed the last four years.” (30:14)

7. Greg Kelly’s Perspective

• Bemoans demise of NYC’s reputation, hails the era under Bloomberg and his father.
• Quote: “Now run by a communist…this man becomes our poster child for the rest of America. You want this in Oklahoma? … Forget that he's just a communist. He's also a supporter of extremist Islamic terrorism.” (18:48–19:05)

8. Bill O’Reilly Analysis

• Says the election results bear no weight on future midterms, predicting “so many things are going to happen” to reshape the country — particularly economic shifts linked to Trump’s policies and Supreme Court decisions. (37:35–38:40)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Exchanges

• Rob Carson:
  • “I mean, honestly, you had an ex governor who had a history of sexual dalliances…You had a choice between the actual crap and the crap-stained bread.” (05:10)
  • “If you are threatened by the victory of Zoran Mandami, don't be…As far as I'm concerned…just watch it fall apart, then move into, you know, help out when it's…dropped into the toilet.” (07:52)
• Tom Basilli:
  • “There will be more Islamic, there will be more socialists, there will be more Marxists who will start running for office in cities and towns…and that’s something people really need to gird themselves for.” (22:33)
• Greg Kelly:
  • “Now run by a communist. … You want this maniac left wing moron? Forget that he's just a communist. He's also a supporter of extremist Islamic terrorism.” (18:51–19:04)
• Zoran Mandami (Victory Speech):
  • “Most damning of all, I refuse to apologize for any of this.” (21:21)
  • “A moment comes, but rarely in history, when we step out from the old to the new, when an age ends and the soul of a nation finds utterance.” (29:56)
• Rob Carson (about Mandami quoting Nehru):
  • “I did find it funny that he quoted Jarala Nehru. Nobody's heard of him. Instead of Washington, Jefferson, or Lincoln.” (30:45)

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Opening Reaction to Election Results (Virginia, New York, New Jersey): 00:17–08:30
• New York City Election Dissected (Parody & Analogies): 09:51–12:52
• Discussion with Political Analyst (Electoral Cynicism): 12:52–13:56
• Analysis of NYC Results & “Let it Fail” Approach: 14:00–18:06
• Interview with Greg Kelly: 18:06–19:20
• Mandami’s Speech Sound Bite: 21:03–21:33, 29:56–30:35
• Newsmax’s Tom Basilli Extended Interview: 21:44–37:06
• Bill O’Reilly’s Assessment of 2025–2026 Midterms: 37:35–38:40

Tone & Style

• Sarcastic, combative, and openly partisan
• Heavy use of analogy and parody (“crap sandwich”, abusive boyfriend, frog in boiling water)
• Regular self-referencing to previous predictions (“I told you this…”), confident in forecasts
• Urges listeners not to despair, but to “ride their asses” (Democrats) and stay engaged

Conclusion

Rob Carson frames the New York City mayoral result as both expected and indicative of the Democratic Party’s terminal leftward drift, arguing that it portends disaster for the city but is ultimately a boon for conservative causes. The recurring message is that blue state setbacks are isolated, that the Democratic Party is in “the dustbin,” and that Republicans must stay mobilized, especially as Trump’s direct political future wanes. The conversation with Tom Basilli provides helpful detail on the ideological lineage leading to Mandami’s win, and the probable “Momdami effect.” Throughout, the show retains its signature satirical, irreverent style, mixing analysis with parody and strong editorial voice.

For listeners new to these developments or unfamiliar with the players, the episode provides a window into conservative populist media’s framing of recent events, with plenty of pointed quotes, colorful analogies, and an ensemble of familiar voices.