The Rubin Report
Host: Dave Rubin
Episode: Fox Hosts Stunned by Piers Morgan's Dark Prediction for NYC Under Zohran Mamdani
Date: November 4, 2025
Overview
On election day, Dave Rubin devotes the episode to dissecting the high-stakes New York City mayoral race, casting it as a pivotal moment for America. The episode focuses on the predicted victory of Democratic Socialist candidate Zohran Mamdani, the implications for the city and country, and reactions from key conservative voices—most notably former NYC Mayor Rudy Giuliani. With themes of socialism, political radicalization, flight from blue states, media disinformation, and the future of the Democratic Party, Rubin and his guests sound the alarm about Mamdani’s platform and what it means for New York’s—and America’s—future.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. Setting the Stage for a Pivotal Election ([00:30]–[05:30])
- Dave Rubin frames the NYC mayoral race as a “seminal day for the country,” with national consequences, noting that prediction markets show a 92% chance of victory for Zohran Mamdani (Democratic Socialist), and negligible chances for Andrew Cuomo or Curtis Sliwa.
- Rubin connects Mamdani's ideology—combining “communism, Marxism, a dash of jihad”—to historical failures of socialism worldwide.
- Cites Piers Morgan’s warnings about New York importing London’s issues under Sadiq Khan.
Quote:
“According to Polymarket right now the prediction is this: 92% chance that Zorhan Mamdami will be the next mayor of New York City. A communist, a Marxist, a socialist, whatever you want to call him, with a dash of jihad.” — Dave Rubin [01:30]
2. Radical Policies Under Scrutiny ([02:40]–[05:30])
- Rubin and Piers Morgan mock the normalization of “defund the police” rhetoric and socialist economics.
- Point out Mamdani’s stated support for city-run grocery stores, rent freezes, and heavy taxation as surefire ways to chase away businesses and landlords, drawing comparisons to “Venezuela or Cuba.”
Quote:
“City run grocery stores. I mean, Lord, go to Venezuela or Cuba and see what's going on over there. Every single idea is wrong, and yet it is being sold to you with a guy, with a smile, with the lo fi music in the background and the soft lens.” — Dave Rubin [04:30]
3. John Fetterman and Democratic Party Identity ([05:46]–[07:56])
- Rubin plays clips of Sen. John Fetterman, who distinguishes himself from Mamdani's socialism and suggests New York’s fate will be decided by New Yorkers alone.
- Fetterman insists, “Socialism is not the future of my party,” but leaves open the door for a shift if NYC and other places choose such leadership.
Quote:
“We all know how socialism works out. Ask anybody that’s lived under those kinds of systems all across the globe.” — John Fetterman [06:12]
4. Rubin’s Prognosis: National Domino Effect ([07:57]–[09:35])
- Rubin warns that Mamdani’s impending victory could serve as a blueprint for radical leftism nationwide, citing other Democratic Socialist candidates like Omar Fatteh in Minnesota.
Quote:
“Once this guy gets in New York City, the most important city in the world, watch how that scales across the country.” — Dave Rubin [07:58]
5. Interview with Rudy Giuliani ([09:36]–[30:57])
New York’s Trajectory & Giuliani’s Legacy ([10:15]–[12:36])
- Giuliani describes deep depression over the election, feeling his and Bloomberg’s years of “rescuing” NYC have been erased.
- Reminisces about how practical, honest policies once turned NYC around.
Quote:
“It’s as if I was never mayor, Bloomberg was never mayor, and we never had maybe the best 20 years in our history.” — Rudy Giuliani [10:33]
Mamdani’s Dual Threat: Socialism & Extremism ([12:36]–[14:04])
- Giuliani expresses more concern about Mamdani’s alleged support for Islamic extremists than for his socialism—claiming his associates are literal enemies of the state.
Quote:
“I’ve never seen anybody as enthusiastically support Islamic terrorism as he does… His association with [an imam] will make it impossible for him to get a security clearance.” — Rudy Giuliani [12:54]
Changing Electorate and Civic Apathy ([14:04]–[15:49])
- Giuliani bemoans “apathy” and a dramatically changed city demographic, with low voter turnout allowing radical candidates to advance.
- Warns that fiscal policies like free public transit and government grocery stores will accelerate NYC’s budgetary collapse and corruption.
Trump’s Statement and the GOP Dilemma ([15:49]–[19:43])
- Rubin reads Trump’s Truth Social post, vowing to withhold federal funds from NYC if Mamdani wins and urging unity behind Cuomo.
- Giuliani refuses to support Cuomo, blaming him for previous policy disasters and arguing that Republicans must present a real alternative even if losing, to preserve down-ballot strength.
Quote:
“For us to build, the most critical thing is for us to build an alternative party in New York… Cuomo is the author of all the reasons why we have more crime.” — Rudy Giuliani [17:44]
The Media, Disinformation & Accountability ([21:15]–[24:33])
- Plays and critiques a CNN clip where Mamdani claims federal money will be denied to NYC because Trump is funding a White House ballroom—a claim Rubin and Giuliani call a “complete fabric[ation].”
- Giuliani attacks the mainstream media for enabling radicalism by refusing to challenge obvious lies.
Quote:
“She knows he’s lying, and they simply do not care.” — Dave Rubin [22:34]
6. Giuliani on High Taxes and Population Flight ([24:33]–[30:03])
- Rubin and Giuliani examine Mamdani’s proposed top 1% tax and corporate tax rate hike, warning this will drive even more earners and businesses out of NYC.
- Giuliani issues a historical reminder of population and business exodus under similar policies, predicting Mamdani’s victory will precipitate a historic flight to Florida and elsewhere.
Quote:
“New York and New Jersey and California are in a race for who loses the most people…” — Rudy Giuliani [26:12]
Security, Terror Threats, and Final Warnings ([27:10]–[30:03])
- Giuliani reiterates fears about terrorism, referencing his tenure’s anti-terror programs and Mamdani’s “sympathy” for extremists.
- Suggests there’s a slim chance of an electoral upset: “I’ve rarely seen an election in New York where the polling is correct.” [29:19]
7. Flight from NYC & National Consequences ([31:10]–[32:30])
- Rubin references New York Post and Daily Mail polls indicating 765,000 New Yorkers could definitely leave if Mamdani wins, with many more considering it.
- “These are the earners, these are people who build things… There’s never a fair enough share that they want.” ([31:50])
8. Democratic Party Leaders Disown Socialism—Ambiguously ([34:57]–[36:00])
- Plays Hakeem Jeffries’ noncommittal answer on whether Mamdani represents the party’s future—Rubin derides his lack of clarity.
- Critiques “progressive” NYC voters for being naïve about economics and socialism; lampoons Upper East Side liberals.
9. Grassroots Voter Interviews & Cultural Commentary ([37:00]–[39:45])
- Rubin shares on-the-street interviews with Mamdani supporters who minimize tax flight concerns and embrace government grocery stores.
- Satirically skewers “middle-aged white liberals” as “perfect people who will be dragged out of their beds when the revolution comes…”
10. Pelosi’s Retirement, California’s Collapse, and Democratic Future ([41:10]–[47:00])
- Marks Nancy Pelosi’s announced retirement and her endorsement of Gavin Newsom for President, critiquing the “Pelosi-Newsom machine” for California’s decline.
- Clips of Newsom’s wife lambasting Trump—Rubin’s sarcastic retorts.
11. Mainstream Media as ‘The Bubble’ ([48:51]–[50:09])
- Targets CNN’s Abby Phillip, arguing she misunderstands (and misrepresents) MAGA motivations, while her show constitutes the “information silo.”
- Briefly roasts Whoopi Goldberg for on-air retractions and lack of nuance on The View.
12. Closing Thoughts – The Silver Lining ([53:00]–[53:53])
- Rubin plays a clip from Palantir CEO Alex Karp on why “Democrats are going to lose the election… because people want to live in peace.”
- Rubin concludes—with grim irony—that perhaps NYC’s collapse under Mamdani is necessary for the national GOP to gain strength: “What an unbelievable Faustian bargain that is, like just terrible.” ([53:53])
Notable Quotes & Moments with Timestamps
- “According to Polymarket right now... 92% chance that Zorhan Mamdami will be the next mayor of New York City. A communist, a Marxist, a socialist... with a dash of jihad.” — Dave Rubin [01:30]
- “It’s as if I was never mayor... and we never had maybe the best 20 years in our history.” — Rudy Giuliani [10:33]
- “His association with [the imam] will make it impossible for him to get a security clearance.” — Giuliani [12:54]
- “For us to build, the most critical thing is for us to build an alternative party in New York… Cuomo is the author of all the reasons why we have more crime.” — Giuliani [17:44]
- “She knows he’s lying, and they simply do not care.” — Rubin [22:34]
- “New York and New Jersey and California are in a race for who loses the most people...” — Giuliani [26:12]
- “What an unbelievable Faustian bargain that is, like just terrible.” — Rubin [53:53]
Segment Timestamps for Quick Reference
| Topic/Guest | Start | End | |-----------------------------------|------------|------------| | Show Introduction (Rubin) | 00:00 | 02:40 | | NYC Mayoral Race Stakes | 02:40 | 05:46 | | Fetterman & Dem Party Identity | 05:46 | 07:56 | | National Implications | 07:57 | 09:35 | | Rudy Giuliani Interview | 09:36 | 30:57 | | NYC Flight & Economic Fallout | 31:10 | 32:30 | | Dem Party, Street Interviews | 34:57 | 39:45 | | Pelosi, California, Dem Future | 41:10 | 47:00 | | Media Bubble, Whoopi, The View | 48:51 | 51:44 | | Karp on Dems Losing Election | 53:00 | 53:53 | | Closing Remarks | 53:53 | 55:06 |
Tone & Style
True to The Rubin Report's signature, the tone is deeply skeptical, often sarcastic or alarmist, and full of cultural/political hyperbole. Rubin and Giuliani share nostalgia for a “better NYC” and disdain for mainstream media and leftist “virtue signaling.” The conversation is targeted at an audience wary of socialism, political correctness, and media bias.
Summary
This episode operates as a warning signal for those concerned about the ascendancy of radical left-wing politics in America’s largest city. Rubin, Giuliani, and clips from other commentators frame Mamdani’s predicted win as both a tragedy and—ironically—a potential boon for national conservative momentum, should the consequences of his policies fuel a backlash. Though laced with humor and sarcasm, the throughline is clear: the hosts deeply fear that NYC under Mamdani portends social, economic, and demographic disaster for the city and potentially for the nation.