Podcast Summary: The Ryen Russillo Podcast – "So Is Indiana In? A Full CFB Playoff Selection Show With Todd McShay. Plus Saquon’s MVP Case"

Release Date: November 25, 2024

Introduction

In this episode of The Ryen Russillo Podcast, host Ryan Russillo dives deep into the intricacies of the College Football Playoff (CFP) Selection alongside Todd McShay, a renowned college football analyst from ESPN. Additionally, Ryan explores the compelling case for Saquon Barkley as a top contender for the NFL MVP award. The discussion sidesteps the NFL recap to focus entirely on the evolving landscape of college football as the playoff selections approach.

College Football Playoff Selection with Todd McShay

Overview of the Selection Process

Ryan and Todd initiate their discussion by outlining the criteria and challenges faced by the CFP committee. They emphasize the importance of evaluating teams based on recent performances, strength of schedule, and the ability to compete against top-tier opponents.

Top 12 Teams Analysis

Tier 1: Oregon, Ohio State, Texas, Georgia

• Oregon, Ohio State, Texas: These teams are unanimously recognized for their robust performances and strong resumes. Ryan notes, "There's no other option" for these selections, highlighting their dominance and consistency throughout the season.

• Georgia: Despite some inconsistencies, Georgia's battle-tested nature and talent pool make them a formidable candidate. Todd remarks, "Their defense scares me because they are battle-tested and they haven't, you know, it was one half against Alabama. They look good. One half, they look terrible."

Tier 2: Tennessee, Penn State, Notre Dame

• Tennessee, Penn State, Notre Dame: These teams occupy the next echelon, each with compelling reasons for inclusion. Ryan expresses a preference, stating, "I have Tennessee 7. I could flip Tennessee with Notre Dame or Penn State. I wouldn't get mad about it."

  • Tennessee: Appreciated for their strong offensive capabilities despite some defensive vulnerabilities.

  • Penn State: Recognized for their talent and potential to rise, though they’ve faced challenges against high-ranking opponents.

  • Notre Dame: Despite being lower than Georgia in the tier system, Notre Dame's impressive victories bolster their playoff credentials.

Tier 3: Miami, SMU, Boise State, South Carolina, Clemson

• Miami, SMU, Boise State: These teams are acknowledged for their competitive performances but lack the consistent excellence seen in higher tiers. Ryan mentions, "I think Miami belongs in tier three. I think SMU belongs in tier three."

• South Carolina, Clemson: With Florida and Alabama grappling with tough losses, Todd deliberates their placement, ultimately placing them in Tier 3 but expressing reservations about their playoff viability.

Tier 4/5: Controversial and Potential Wildcards

• Alabama: A significant point of contention, Ryan outright expresses disapproval of Alabama's inclusion due to their recent performance issues: "I can't do B. So let's go back to the tears. First two tiers covered seven teams."

• Indiana: Despite a historic win over Ohio State, Indiana's inclusion is hotly debated. Ryan strongly opposes their ranking, stating, "I have Indiana at 12 and I don't like it."

Notable Team-Specific Discussions

• Indiana's Performance: The pivotal game where Indiana upset Ohio State is dissected extensively. Ryan criticizes Indiana's overall performance despite their win, highlighting inconsistent drives and lackluster offensive metrics.

• SEC Teams' Shake-Up: With several SEC teams facing unexpected losses, the stability of the conference's strength is questioned. Todd emphasizes Georgia's resilience, contrasting it with the faltering performances of Alabama and Ole Miss.

• Big 12 Outlook: Texas remains a strong contender despite recent inconsistent performances. Both hosts agree on their potential, citing talent depth and strategic gameplay as strengths.

Saquon Barkley’s MVP Case

Ryan shifts focus to the NFL, presenting a formidable case for Saquon Barkley as an MVP candidate. Drawing parallels with Adrian Peterson's 2012 MVP season, Ryan underscores Barkley's impressive statistics and impact:

• Statistics: Barkley boasts nearly 1,400 rushing yards, 10 touchdowns, and significant receiving contributions, positioning him on track for over 2,150 total yards if the trend continues.

• Injury Considerations: Acknowledging Barkley's injury history, Ryan debates the wisdom of pushing him to achieve 2,000 yards, weighing his importance against team dynamics and potential long-term health implications.

• Comparative Analysis: While Lamar Jackson remains Ryan's preferred MVP contender, he appreciates Barkley's resurgence and the "running back back in the mix," marking a rare and valuable presence in the MVP race.

Ryan Russillo [16:57]: "If you love him, set him free. Right? Because Barclays down, MVP candidate, it's like we can even throw that into the Giants."

MVP Race and Running Backs

Ryan reflects on the historical context of running backs in the MVP race, questioning the sustainability of such candidates being frontrunners. He contrasts Barkley's potential with Lamar Jackson's consistent performance, ultimately leaning towards Lamar for the MVP title despite Barkley's strong case.

Worst Loss Award: Washington Commanders vs. Dallas Cowboys

The episode tags the Washington Commanders’ defeat against the Dallas Cowboys as the "worst loss" of the week. Detailed analysis covers:

• Game Breakdown: The game featured multiple pivotal moments, including missed extra points, strategic punts, and critical turnovers that sealed Washington's fate.

• Emotional Impact: Ryan shares personal anecdotes about watching the game with friends, highlighting the emotional rollercoaster and the absurdity of certain plays and decisions.

• Coaching Critiques: Criticism directed at Washington's strategy and management, particularly focusing on quarterback decisions and defensive lapses.

Ryan Russillo [30:08]: "They do not have a Big 12 team in your top 12. Correct."

Conclusion

As the podcast wraps up, Ryan and Todd reiterate their top contenders for the CFP and reflect on the complexities of team performances leading up to the playoff selections. The episode underscores the unpredictability of college football and the nuanced factors influencing playoff standings. Additionally, Saquon Barkley’s discussion leaves listeners contemplating the evolving criteria for MVP contenders in the NFL.

Notable Quotes

• Ryan Russillo [16:57]:
  "I think finally like this push also was a reminder of how incredibly impressionable we can be."

• Todd McShay [21:17]:
  "And Big 12 too."

• Ryan Russillo [31:25]:
  "I think if you're just looking at the record, then you don't have to watch anything. You never have to watch anything."

• Todd McShay [35:03]:
  "I can't schedule up Bama. I can't be like, hey, you guys aren't. You guys don't get it."

• Ryan Russillo [50:22]:
  "Get out of here."

• Todd McShay [54:48]:
  "They're probably going to be in the top 12."

This comprehensive summary encapsulates the critical discussions and analyses presented in the episode, providing insightful perspectives on the CFP selections and Saquon Barkley’s MVP candidacy. Listeners gain a thorough understanding of the considerations influencing team rankings and individual accolades as the college football season culminates towards the playoffs.