The SkyePod – Liberalism

Date: October 31, 2025
Host: Skye Jethani
Guest: Caitlin Schess

Episode Overview

This episode of The SkyePod focuses on liberalism: not as shorthand for the political left, but as the foundational political philosophy underpinning American society. Skye Jethani and Caitlin Schess clarify what they mean when they use terms like "liberalism" on the show, explore the historical roots and philosophical foundations of liberal political thought, discuss its dominance across American culture, and engage with its strengths, weaknesses, and critiques (including Christian perspectives).

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Why Talk About "Liberalism"?

• Skye explains the motivation for clarifying terms: listeners often misunderstand what the hosts mean by "liberalism," assuming it simply aligns with "the political left."
• Skye describes how, due to the influence of commentators like Rush Limbaugh, “liberal” became synonymous with "Democrat" or “woke,” and mostly used pejoratively in American culture.
• The episode aims to distinguish the philosophical and historical roots of liberalism from partisan usages.

  “The word liberal is almost universally associated in American culture as speaking of the political left.” (Skye, 05:19)

2. Defining Liberalism

• Caitlin provides a working definition:
  • It’s a political philosophy centered on the individual, seeking primarily to secure individual liberty.
  • As both a philosophy and as a political system, it has deeply shaped all of American history—right and left.

  “Liberalism is a political philosophy that prioritizes and focuses on the individual as the basis for what is politics and what is a political problem.” (Caitlin, 07:12)

• Key Elements:
  • Individual liberty
  • Freedom of the individual as foundational (“liberty” and “liberalism” are linguistically linked)
  • Government by consent; protection of individual rights and civil liberties

[08:47] – Dictionary Definition of Liberalism

Skye reads:

“Liberalism is a political or social philosophy advocating the freedom of the individual, parliamentary systems of government, nonviolent modification of political, social, or economic institutions… and governmental guarantees of individual rights and civil liberties.” (Skye, 08:47)

• Both highlight that this is not inherently “blue” or “red”—both U.S. political parties are products of liberal philosophy.

3. Evolving Concepts of Liberty and Rights

Ancient/Medieval vs. Liberal Liberty

• Caitlin:
  • Ancient “liberty” meant self-mastery for virtuous ends;
  • In liberalism, liberty is mostly freedom from constraint: do what you wish unless it directly harms others.

“Historically, the concepts of liberty or freedom … didn’t mean freedom from things, it typically meant freedom for things.” (Caitlin, 10:21)

On Rights

• Liberalism frames society as individuals possessing rights; conflict is seen as rights clashing.
• Contrast with older models based on responsibilities to the community.

“Most of our political language in America isn’t nourished by the idea of responsibility or a virtue, or even of a common good mentality. Most of it is, I have rights that come into conflict with your rights.” (Caitlin, 15:31)

4. Liberalism in American Systems

(18:04) – Manifestations in Law and Society

• The First Amendment: Freedom of speech, assembly, and religion—core liberal values.
• Democracy: Major societal changes are by peaceful, collective vote rather than violence (“nonviolent political change”).
• Free Markets: Capitalism echoes liberalism’s focus on freedom of individual enterprise.

[19:39] Democracy vs. Liberalism

• Caitlin’s Objection: Democracy and liberalism are sometimes at odds. Majority rule (democracy) can conflict with safeguarding individual rights (liberalism).

“I think actually, what a lot of our conflicts in the American political context for the last fifty, hundred years have been, are a real conflict between democracy and liberalism.” (Caitlin, 18:47)

• Skye notes that some liberal protections (e.g., minority religious rights) are undemocratic, by design, to prevent tyranny of the majority.

5. The Role of Illiberal Institutions

[22:54] – Virtue Formation: Family & Church

• Founders (esp. Alexis de Tocqueville): The liberal state relies on “illiberal” or non-liberal institutions (e.g., families, religious communities) to cultivate virtues and restraint.

“Families are not liberal... And most churches are not liberal.” (Skye, 23:04)

• Healthy liberalism assumes these virtuous, communal environments are operating at lower levels of society.

6. Roots & Story of Liberalism: The Social Contract

[24:31] – Social Contract Theory

• Liberalism is rooted in the social contract: the basis of authority is consent of individuals, not God-given roles or hierarchy.

• Philosophical background emphasizes individual isolation in the “state of nature,” where life is “solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short” (Hobbes).

• Individual rights are surrendered only as minimally necessary to gain security.

• Caitlin's Theological Critique: The social contract’s anthropology (the belief that humans start as isolated and in conflict) is alien to a Christian understanding of human nature as communally ordered and relationship-based.

"The story that has animated a lot of this... has given us a really thin and poor idea of what a human is and what a human community is.” (Caitlin, 28:56)

7. Critiques of Liberalism & The Christian Response

[30:49] – Where Have Things Gone Wrong?

• Liberalism’s focus on individual liberty has sometimes seeped into families and churches, eroding virtues those “illiberal” institutions were meant to support.

• Some Christian nationalists and post-liberal critics now want to replace liberal rules with top-down Christian laws, but Skye notes:

  “…rather than pointing the critique where it belongs, which is the failure of the church to disciple people in the way of Jesus, they're pointing their critique at government or society or the liberal foundations of American democracy...” (Skye, 33:03)

• The duo debate: Is our problem too much liberalism, or a breakdown in cultivating virtue through church and family?

  • Skye: Liberalism works well if paired with robust virtues from families and churches; he resists dismantling political liberalism.
  • Caitlin: It’s not just a problem of levels (government vs. community), but the story liberalism tells about what it means to be human—a story that can be subtly absorbed by Christians and communities.

“I’m not saying we shouldn’t have [liberalism] all the way down. I’m saying we have to find a way to value the political system without also swallowing the story about what it means to be human.” (Caitlin, 32:04)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

Opening Joke / Callback

"Hey, get your hands off my uterus."
(A, 00:00 & callback at 11:52—liberty applied to both right- and left-leaning issues.)

On the Ubiquity of Liberalism

“A lot of historians and philosophers will say this is a philosophy that comes out of Western history that has dominated a lot of Western countries... America... is kind of like the prototypical, like the paradigmatic example of a liberal country.” (Caitlin, 07:02)

On the Limits of Democracy

“The First Amendment... is actually undemocratic… because we're going to protect the individual rights of minorities against the will of the majority.” (Skye, 19:39)

On Liberalism’s Success and Its Story

“The goods that liberalism has secured are wonderful and we should not treat them flippantly at all. And yet somehow we have to find a way to do that while going, ‘The story… has given us a really thin and poor idea of what a human is and… a human community is.’” (Caitlin, 28:56)

Defending Liberalism’s Place

“Liberalism on the… has given us great goods that we should not treat flippantly… I'm not in favor of liberal ideals all the way down… I just disagree that there is something fundamentally ungodly and wrong about the ideals that founded the American Republic.” (Skye, 31:40 & 32:00)

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 00:00 – Opening banter and topic introduction
• 05:19 – “Liberal” as pejorative, culture’s partisan confusion
• 07:12 – Caitlin defines liberalism as political philosophy
• 08:47 – Skye reads dictionary definition of liberalism
• 10:21 – Caitlin on historic conceptions of liberty & freedom
• 15:31 – “Rights” language and its pitfalls
• 18:04 – How liberalism appears in law/constitution (1st Amendment, markets, etc.)
• 19:39 – Democracy vs. liberalism: built-in tensions
• 22:54 – Tocqueville, the need for non-liberal institutions in a liberal society
• 24:31 – The social contract, origins, and anthropology of liberalism
• 28:56 – The Christian critique: the story behind liberalism
• 30:49 – Where has liberalism gone wrong? The spread into family/church, and today's Christian nationalist/post-liberal backlash
• 32:04 – The essential question: Can we affirm liberalism's structures without adopting its anthropology?

Tone & Style

Conversational, thoughtful, occasionally witty (especially in their callbacks), and geared toward listeners who want to think deeply about faith, culture, and politics. Skye and Caitlin challenge each other's ideas respectfully and encourage listeners to question assumptions about both political philosophy and Christianity.

End of public episode. To hear the full discussion, listeners are asked to subscribe to Holy Post Plus.