1441: Birthday Wish by David Groff - The Slowdown: Poetry & Reflection Daily

Summary

Episode Overview

Podcast: The Slowdown: Poetry & Reflection Daily
Host: Maggie Smith
Episode: 1441: Birthday Wish by David Groff
Air Date: January 23, 2026

This reflective episode centers on the theme of knowing—how humans, animals, and plants experience and interpret the world differently. Through a gentle personal anecdote and the thoughtful reading of David Groff's poem "Birthday Wish," host Maggie Smith explores the limitations and gifts of knowledge, and the particular power of poetry to articulate what resists straightforward answers.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

The Age of Instant Knowledge

Modern Convenience vs. Human Experience (00:51 - 02:07)
- Maggie notes how easily we access facts today—via Google, Alexa, or smartphones (“You can Google almost anything or just ask Alexa. I hear my kids doing that sometimes.”).
- She reminisces about the 1980s, when her parents relied on a trivia-savvy friend, Mark, for information, creating a slower, more uncertain process (“If my parents were lucky, Mark would be there and...he'd probably have an answer...Of course, there wasn't a quick way of fact checking him.”).

The Value of Uncertainty

Not Everything Has an Easy Answer (02:08 - 02:29)
- Maggie contrasts "knowable" facts with the "slippery" nature of human experience:
  
  “So much is knowable. But then there's everything else. Human experience is slippery. Not everything has an easy answer."
- Poetry, she argues, excels in helping us grip these less tangible truths:
  
  "This is where poetry really shines and really comes in handy...Poetry helps us articulate what we don't fully understand.”

Introduction to the Poem

The Unique Knowledge of Living Things (02:30 - 02:55)
- Previewing “Birthday Wish,” Maggie highlights its meditation on types of knowing:
  
  "...muses on different kinds of knowing without privileging one over the other—what we know versus what animals know versus what plants know."
- She frames the poem as a reminder that humans "don't need to know or be everything"—that knowledge can be simple, sufficient, and particular.

Poem Reading: "Birthday Wish" by David Groff

(02:56 - 04:03)

Maggie reads the poem, inviting listeners to consider the humble wisdom of dogs and trees:

The dog "doesn't know he's a dog, though he knows all he needs to know to be a dog."
The tree, unconcerned with spelling "chlorophyll" or "chill," simply knows to respond naturally to the seasons.
Both living things accept their cycles and coming ends unselfconsciously.
The final wish:

“May I like the dog, the tree, their limbs, their bark, their barklessness, the coming fall, the fire, the hatchet and the rot know only what I need to be.”

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

On Poetry’s Role (02:16)

“If you want a factoid, go to the Internet or call Mark. If you want a different kind of truth, go to poems. Poetry doesn't make our experience less slippery, but I think it helps us get a kind of grip on it.”
— Maggie Smith

On Life’s Knowledge (02:40)

“I think of us humans as being on a need to know basis, and this poem reminds me that we don't need to know or be everything.”
— Maggie Smith

The Poet’s Wish (03:53)

“May I ... know only what I need to be.”
— Read by Maggie Smith from David Groff’s "Birthday Wish"

Timestamps for Important Segments

| Timestamp | Segment | |------------|---------------------------------------------------| | 00:51–02:07| Reflections on instant knowledge and childhood | | 02:08–02:29| Slipperiness of human experience; intro to poetry | | 02:30–02:55| Introduction to "Birthday Wish" and its themes | | 02:56–04:03| Full reading of "Birthday Wish" |

Episode Takeaway

In her characteristically warm and meditative style, Maggie Smith invites listeners to appreciate not merely the facts we can look up, but the lived, felt, and intuitive knowledge of animals, plants, and ourselves. Poetry, she suggests, has the unique ability to help us hold the unknowable, and reminds us: sometimes, it's enough to simply "know only what [we] need to be.”

Transcript

A (0:00)

We've all been there. You hold on to a coupon but forget about it and suddenly it's expired.

B (0:04)

Expired in 2012. Dang it.

A (0:06)

Fortunately, by switching to Geico, you could save about $900 on car insurance without ever touching a coupon.

B (0:12)

It feels good to save big. It feels good to Geico.

C (0:16)

Lowe's knows how to turn big plans into real results, whether it's new appliances or a home refresh. Get started with 12 month special financing on purchases of $299 or more with a Mylo's rewards credit card January the 30th, so you can invest in your upgrade now and pay over time. Lowe's we help you save offers subject to credit approval and cannot be combined. Minimum monthly payment required. See store lowe's.com for details.

D (0:51)

I'm Maggie Smith and this is the slowdown. Right this moment, so much is knowable. You can Google almost anything or just ask Alexa. I hear my kids doing that sometimes. Alexa, what's the Spanish word for catastrophe? What time is it in Australia? Who sings Funky Town? Between our phones and our other devices, we have almost any fact at our fingertips instantly. When I was a kid, my parents friend Mark was basically their Alexa. This was pre Internet, so if they wanted to know something, who was the guy in that movie? What's the name of that Van Morrison song? They would pick up the phone and call Mark's house. The phones back then were all landlines, mind you, because this was the 1980s. If someone wasn't home, you just couldn't reach them. If my parents were lucky, Mark would be there and because he was a master of trivia, he he'd probably have an answer to their question. Of course there wasn't a quick way of fact checking him. They had to trust him. Or they had to be reminded of something they already knew but couldn't access. A movie title, a song lyric, the name of an old classmate or neighbor. So much is knowable. But then there's everything else. Human experience is slippery. Not everything has an easy answer. This is where poetry really shines and really comes in handy. If you want a factoid, go to the Internet or call Mark. If you want a different kind of truth, go to poems. Poetry doesn't make our experience less slippery, but I think it helps us get a kind of grip on it. Poetry helps us articulate what we don't fully understand. The parts of life that are hard to wrap our heads around. Today's poem muses on different kinds of knowing without privileging one over the other what we know versus what animals know versus what plants know. For instance, I think of us humans as being on a need to know basis, and this poem reminds me that we don't need to know or be everything Birthday Wish by David Groff the dog doesn't know he's a dog, though he knows all he needs to know to be a dog. That tree over there, the one with two branches conducting green music, can't spell chlorophyll or chill. It does not bark like a dog. The tree knows to shed its coat when autumn comes and the dog senses he sheds his fur in spring. Such contrary seasons unconscious of being seasons or seasons passing Just as the dog won't know when he's not a dog and the maple won't comprehend the hatchet coming or the rot or fire. May I like the dog, the tree, their limbs, their bark, their barklessness, the coming fall, the fire, the hatchet and the rot know only what I need to be. The Slowdown is a production of American Public Media in partnership with the Poetry Foundation. To get a poem delivered to you daily, go to slowdownshow.org and sign up for our newsletter. Find us on Instagram at slowdownshow and bluesky.downdownshow.org the slowdown is written by me, Maggie Smith. Our lead producer is Micah Kielbon and our associate producer is Maria Wurtel. Our music is composed by Kyle Andrews, engineering by Derek Ramirez. Our editor and digital producer is Jordan Turgeon. Additional production help by Susanna Sharpless, Cece Lucas, Marcel Malachibu, and Lauren Humpert. Our executives in charge are Chandra Kavati and Mark Crowley. Hi, it's Maggie. The Slowdown is the only poetry podcast in public media. That means your support is vital to keep us going. No matter how much you give, your contribution makes a real difference. Head to SlowdownShow.org donate today to Power More Poems into the Future.