1452: A Backstory Beyond My Recounting by Paulann Petersen - The Slowdown: Poetry & Reflection Daily

Summary5 min read

Episode Overview

Podcast: The Slowdown: Poetry & Reflection Daily
Episode: 1452: "A Backstory Beyond My Recounting" by Paulann Petersen
Host (Guest Host): Samia Bashir
Date: February 9, 2026

In this episode, guest host Samia Bashir explores themes of self-identity, bodily experience, judgment, and agency, using Paulann Petersen’s poem “A Backstory Beyond My Recounting” as a springboard for reflection. Bashir brings a personal and contemplative tone, connecting her own body narrative to the universal questions raised by the poem. The episode invites listeners to reconsider their relationship to themselves in the face of societal scrutiny, emphasizing both our cosmic origins and our daily autonomy over self-definition.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Personal Inquiry: “Who or What Am I?”

Timestamps: 01:16 – 02:31

Bashir recounts a conversation—a friend asks, “who or what I thought I was.” Her offhand answer: “even stardust.”
- Quote: “I replied casually, offhandedly, even stardust. And I mean, that's technically true, but I don't think it was the answer my interlocutor was looking for.” (01:24)
She reflects on how such existential questions are sometimes intended not to probe for deeper meaning but to “cut the respondent down to... a more appropriate size.”

2. Body, Judgment, and Social Context

Timestamps: 02:31 – 03:25

Bashir meditates in solitude: “stretched out in a bathtub with nothing at hand but the poetry of my own body and the water in which it's immersed.”
She describes being made to feel “wanting” by others’ standards and recounts personal bodily experiences, including surgical correction of polydactyly (born with six fingers and toes).
- Quote: “A rather curvy black American woman, I long ago grew accustomed to my body being subjected to the judgment of others and found wanting.” (02:54)
Broader concern about the “deleterious effects of social media on young women and girls,” citing both anecdotal and scientific evidence.

3. Agency in Self-Identity

Timestamps: 03:25 – 03:57

The episode pivots to the empowering aspect of self-determination:
- “What I know too, is that at the end of the day, the makeup of the body in question does not even matter to those who would throw their biting grenades.”
Bashir draws a line between social judgment and personal agency, suggesting we “get to choose the answer to that question every moment of every day.”
- Quote: “We get to choose the who at least, and what a gift that the what remains what it's always stardust. All we have to do is shine.” (03:48)

4. The Poem: “A Backstory Beyond My Recounting” by Paulann Petersen

Timestamps: 03:57 – 05:37

Bashir reads Petersen’s poem, which contemplates the cyclical creation of the world and the interconnectedness of all matter.
Key lines from the poem:
- “Unaccountably old, the world is a world class self starter, ever used to making itself anew again and again out of the makings of itself from that first stellar stuff.”
- “I'm writing myself onto this paper that was once a pine, that was cone, that was cloud not so long before having been ocean, that was the prior glint of rain.”
- “With care I must choose the words to write onto this sea that too is a seed, that too is the sky's overcast.”
- “The pen in my hand has just five words ago contrived to make that mark of its own name. And now we'll do so one more time before I end, Calling itself Reconfigured Star.” (05:20)

5. Reflection and Takeaway

Timestamps: 05:37 – 05:59

The act of writing — and, by extension, living — is portrayed as an act of ongoing reconfiguration and renewal, linking us back to the “stardust” of our origins.
The poem offers a meditative affirmation that our daily actions contribute to our ongoing sense of self.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

On Identity and Stardust
- Samia Bashir: “I replied casually, offhandedly, even stardust. And I mean, that's technically true, but I don't think it was the answer my interlocutor was looking for.” (01:24)
On Bodily Judgment
- Samia Bashir: “A rather curvy black American woman, I long ago grew accustomed to my body being subjected to the judgment of others and found wanting.” (02:54)
On Agency and Choice
- Samia Bashir: “We ourselves get to choose the answer to that question every moment of every day. We get to choose the who at least, and what a gift that the what remains what it's always stardust.” (03:40)
On Cosmic Connection and Creation
- Paulann Petersen (via Bashir): “Unaccountably old, the world is a world class self starter, ever used to making itself anew again and again out of the makings of itself from that first stellar stuff.” (04:00)
- Paulann Petersen: “The pen in my hand has just five words ago contrived to make that mark of its own name. And now we'll do so one more time before I end, Calling itself Reconfigured Star.” (05:20)

Segment Timestamps

Musings on Self-Definition and Stardust: 01:16 – 02:31
Body and Social Judgment: 02:31 – 03:25
Agency and Self-Determination: 03:25 – 03:57
Poem Recitation (“A Backstory Beyond My Recounting”): 03:57 – 05:37
Final Reflections and Credits: 05:37 – 05:59

Tone and Language

Samia Bashir delivers the episode in a warm, candid, and poetic style. She seamlessly blends personal narrative with philosophical and literary reflection, echoing the contemplative and hopeful ethos that defines The Slowdown.

Summary Takeaway

This episode gently but powerfully invites listeners to question and reframe their own stories of self. Through personal vulnerability and the luminous lines of Paulann Petersen’s poem, Bashir encourages embracing the agency to define oneself, holding both our ordinary humanness and our cosmic origins with equal reverence. The poem acts as a reminder of our perpetual renewal — that we, too, are “reconfigured stars,” writing and rewriting ourselves each day.

Loading summary

Transcript4 lines

[00:00]
Tremphya Advertisement Voice
For adults with Crohn's disease or ulcerative colitis symptoms. Every choice matters. Tremphya offers self injection or intravenous infusion from the start. Tremphya is administered as injections under the skin or infusions through a vein every four weeks, followed by injections under the skin every four or eight weeks. If your doctor decides that you can self inject Tremphya, proper training is required. Tremphya is a prescription medicine used to treat adults with moderately to severely active Crohn's disease and adults with moderate, moderately to severely active ulcerative colitis. Serious allergic reactions and increased risk of infections and liver problems may occur. Before treatment, your doctor should check you for infections and tuberculosis. Tell your doctor if you have an infection, flu like symptoms or if you need a vaccine. Explore what's possible. Ask your doctor about tremphya today. Call 1-800-526-7736 to learn more or visit trempharadio.com hey there.
[01:01]
Maggie
Today's episode is hosted by the poet Samia Bashir. Enjoy and I'll be back on February 18th.
[01:16]
Samia Bashir
I'm Samia Bashir and this is the Slowdown. The other day a friend asked who or what I thought I was. I replied casually, offhandedly, even stardust. And I mean, that's technically true, but I don't think it was the answer my interlocutor was looking for. Oftentimes these questions are lobbed with the intention of cutting the respondent down to what the questioner believes is a more appropriate size. Stretched out in a bathtub with nothing at hand but the poetry of my own body and the water in which it's immersed, I often find myself asking that same question. As I take in each of my physical so called flaws, that question of what or who I am can turn markedly unkind. I see scars here, stretch marks there, the ruptures on my hands and feet where my infant self having been born, perhaps strangely with six fingers on each hand, six toes on each foot, was forcibly surgically corrected. A rather curvy black American woman, I long ago grew accustomed to my body being subjected to the judgment of others and found wanting. I know I'm not alone here, based on anecdotal evidence and on study after study, including those which have shown the deleterious effects of social media on young women and girls. What I know too, is that at the end of the day, the makeup of the body in question does not even matter to those who would throw their biting grenades. Today's poem, too, asks who we think we are. That existential question can feel like judgment or threat, but the poet turns it back toward the daily realities of our own agency. What I mean is we ourselves get to choose the answer to that question every moment of every day. We get to choose the who at least, and what a gift that the what remains what it's always stardust. All we have to do is shine a backstory beyond my recounting. By Paul Ann Peterson Unaccountably old, the world is a world class self starter, ever used to making itself anew again and again out of the makings of itself from that first stellar stuff. I must take care in such a world, careful of where I place my feet, of what I pick up, of how I use the pen gleaming so old in my hand. I'm writing myself onto this paper that was once a pine, that was cone, that was cloud not so long before having been ocean, that was the prior glint of rain. With care I must choose the words to write onto this sea that too is a seed, that too is the sky's overcast. This moment's ink lays down its darkness, giving off a wet light before it dries. The pen in my hand has just five words ago contrived to make that mark of its own name. And now we'll do so one more time before I end Calling itself Reconfigured Star, The Slowdown is a production of American Public Media in partnership with the Poetry Foundation. To get a poem delivered to you daily, go to slowdownshow.org and sign up for our newsletter and find us on Instagram @downdownshow and blueskylowdownshow.org. Foreign.
[05:59]
Maggie
Hi, it's Maggie. The Slowdown is the only poetry podcast in public media. That means your support is vital to keep us going. No matter how much you give, your contribution makes a real difference. Head to SlowdownShow.org donate today to Power More Poems into the Future.