The Smart Communications Podcast: Episode 181 Summary

Title: Seven Steps to Foster Healthy Group Participation
Host: Sarita Joseph
Guest: Josh Kelly
Release Date: March 5, 2025

The Smart Communications Podcast, hosted by Sarita Joseph of Big Duck, is dedicated to empowering nonprofit leaders to enhance their communication skills and develop their organization's unique voice. In Episode 181, titled "Seven Steps to Foster Healthy Group Participation," Sarita is joined by her colleague, Josh Kelly, to delve into strategies that promote effective and inclusive group interactions within nonprofit settings.

Introduction to Healthy Group Participation

The episode opens with Sarita introducing the topic of fostering healthy group participation, emphasizing its critical role in the success of nonprofit projects. She highlights the challenge many organizations face: assembling a diverse group of stakeholders but struggling to maintain engagement and collaboration over time.

Josh Kelly elaborates on this by stating at [01:44], “Healthy group participation is one way to talk about, once we get people together in a room, how do we treat each other well, and in such a way that we all want to keep showing up in the room together.” He underscores the importance of not just gathering diverse voices but ensuring that the environment encourages sustained and meaningful participation.

Why Healthy Participation Matters

Sarita probes deeper into the significance of healthy participation, prompting Josh to explain its impact on project success. At [03:04], Josh asserts, “Healthy group participation improves outcomes… The more new ideas and perspectives will enter the chat.” He highlights that when participants feel valued and heard, they are more likely to contribute actively, leading to richer ideas and stronger buy-in for the project’s goals.

Josh further notes the relationship between healthy participation and organizational buy-in: “There’s some clay metaphor in there somewhere. But it’s also buy-in… there’s some clay metaphor in there somewhere. But it’s also buy-in, right? Like you'll have more people, you'll be more likely that you will see people supporting what you're doing if they were included meaningfully and healthily in the process” ([04:57]). This inclusion helps prevent scenarios where excluded voices might covertly or overtly undermine the project.

Three Key Steps for Healthy Participation

In discussing the seven steps outlined in his blog post, Josh selects three pivotal strategies that can significantly enhance group dynamics:

1. Being Generous with Time ([05:30]): Josh emphasizes the need to allocate ample time for meetings to avoid rushing discussions. “Maybe you need to schedule a 30-minute conversation, but maybe you schedule it for 45 minutes,” he advises. This flexibility ensures that conversations are thorough and participants do not leave with unresolved issues or feelings of incompleteness. Additionally, adjusting meeting norms, such as allowing a five-minute buffer before officially starting, can help participants settle in and be fully present.

2. Embracing Silence ([07:15]): Recognizing that many are uncomfortable with pauses, Josh advocates for allowing moments of silence during discussions. At [07:15], he explains, “Silence is giving folks time to internalize, to reflect, to form a thought.” This practice can lead to the emergence of thoughtful ideas that might otherwise be suppressed in a hurried conversation. Sarita relates to this, noting the challenge in the remote work environment but acknowledging its importance.

3. One Size Fits None ([08:27]): Josh challenges the notion of a universal approach to healthy participation. “Healthy participation for me might not look like healthy participation for other people,” he states. Instead of relying solely on checklists, he advocates for personalized strategies tailored to the specific dynamics and needs of each group. This involves having open conversations with participants about what healthy participation means to them, ensuring that the methods employed resonate with everyone involved.

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Transitioning from strategies to potential obstacles, Sarita asks Josh about practices to steer clear of to maintain healthy participation. Josh identifies three primary pitfalls:

1. Control ([10:13]): The desire to control every aspect of a meeting can stifle genuine participation. Josh notes, “This impulse for control can be really good to check, because I think that often motivates the habits that get us out of healthy participation” ([10:13]). Over-managing meeting dynamics can prevent the natural flow of ideas and make participants feel constrained.

2. Perfectionism: Striving for flawless meetings can be counterproductive. Josh humorously admits, “If any of you figure out how to do that, please call me because I would like to have a very long conversation with you about how that happened” ([13:52]). Accepting that imperfections are part of the process allows for more authentic interactions and reduces the pressure on facilitators and participants alike.

3. People Pleasing: Trying to make everyone happy can lead to diluted outcomes and frustration. Josh explains, “It’s not going to be perfect… you can be so comfortable with silence and that’s going to do nothing for your other colleague who still is not comfortable with silence” ([13:52]). Balance is key; facilitators should strive to accommodate different preferences without compromising the integrity of the discussion.

Final Takeaways

As the episode nears its conclusion, Josh offers a poignant reminder about the nature of healthy participation. At [14:26], he states, “Healthy participation is a process, not an outcome.” This perspective encourages organizations to view participation as an ongoing journey of growth and adaptation rather than a finite goal. Embracing this mindset can help teams navigate the inherent discomforts and complexities of group interactions, ultimately fostering a more resilient and collaborative environment.

Sarita echoes this sentiment, reinforcing the idea that embracing imperfection and maintaining open communication norms are essential for nurturing healthy participation.

Conclusion

Episode 181 of The Smart Communications Podcast provides valuable insights into cultivating healthy group participation within nonprofit organizations. By focusing on generous time allocation, embracing silence, and customizing participation strategies, leaders can enhance collaboration and achieve more effective outcomes. Additionally, being mindful of avoiding control, perfectionism, and people-pleasing behaviors further supports a healthy and inclusive group dynamic. As Josh aptly concludes, viewing participation as an ongoing process rather than a fixed outcome can lead to sustained growth and stronger team cohesion.

For more resources on developing strategic communications for nonprofits, visit Big Duck's Insights or listen to other episodes of The Smart Communications Podcast.

Notable Quotes:

• Josh Kelly [01:44]: “Healthy group participation is one way to talk about, once we get people together in a room, how do we treat each other well, and in such a way that we all want to keep showing up in the room together.”

• Josh Kelly [03:04]: “Healthy group participation improves outcomes… The more new ideas and perspectives will enter the chat.”

• Josh Kelly [05:30]: “Maybe you need to schedule a 30-minute conversation, but maybe you schedule it for 45 minutes.”

• Josh Kelly [07:15]: “Silence is giving folks time to internalize, to reflect, to form a thought.”

• Josh Kelly [08:27]: “Healthy participation for me might not look like healthy participation for other people.”

• Josh Kelly [10:13]: “This impulse for control can be really good to check, because I think that often motivates the habits that get us out of healthy participation.”

• Josh Kelly [13:52]: “If any of you figure out how to do [perfect participation], please call me because I would like to have a very long conversation with you about how that happened.”

• Josh Kelly [14:26]: “Healthy participation is a process, not an outcome.”

Connect with Big Duck:

Interested in enhancing your nonprofit's communication strategy? Visit bigduck.com for more insights, blogs, and podcasts. Share your feedback or topics you'd like us to cover by writing to hello@bigduck.com.