wavePod

Your Money Problems Aren't Math Problems (They're People Problems) SB1751 - The Stacking Benjamins Show | Wave AI Podcast Notes

Back to The Stacking Benjamins Show

Your Money Problems Aren't Math Problems (They're People Problems) SB1751

The Stacking Benjamins Show

Wed Oct 22 2025

Summary

The Stacking Benjamins Show

Episode: Your Money Problems Aren't Math Problems (They're People Problems) SB1751
Release Date: October 22, 2025
Featured Guest: Carl Richards – NYT columnist, financial planner, creator of “The Behavior Gap”

Episode Overview

This episode takes a deep dive into why financial challenges are rarely pure math problems but are usually deeply rooted in human behavior, emotion, and relationships. Joe Saul-Sehy and OG are joined by Carl Richards (“Mr. Behavior Gap”) for a candid, wide-ranging, and philosophical discussion on the nature of money, how our stories and perspectives shape our finances, and practical ways to create more meaningful, resilient financial plans. The show’s signature friendly, witty tone makes this episode both insightful and entertaining, striking that “fun and functional” balance.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Money Isn’t Just Math—It’s Stories, Emotions, and Lenses

Starts ~09:55

Carl Richards shares that despite his “very big calculator,” he realized after a decade in finance that math isn’t what derails us with money—emotions and stories are:

“If money is a math problem, how come I end up in a fight?...two plus two always equals four, but two plus two never equals envy.” (10:25 – Carl Richards)
Money is a “series of stories” and conversations about it can be like “an electric fence you didn’t know was electric.” (11:38 – Carl Richards)
Everyone sees the same “cube” (situation), but from different sides—shaped by unique histories and beliefs.
Example: Carl’s wife once shifted his perspective by simply asking:

“What if it was fun and easy?”
This stunned Carl, who had never considered money-making could be anything but hard. (12:07–14:13)

2. The Power of Perspective & Conversation

Starts ~14:13

Money, like politics, is often filtered through such varied lenses that people experience “different realities.”
The antidote is layered, nuanced talk—sharing stories and being genuinely curious about others’ views and money memories.

“What if we just started learning to talk about money in a layered and nuanced way?” (15:47 – Carl Richards)

Strategy: Start close in, at home or among immediate circles, with questions like, “What’s your first memory of money?”
Even industry veterans (Joe or guest Josh Brown) struggled when first asked this—most listeners never ask or answer these with partners, family, or friends. (17:51–20:34)
Tactical Tip: Begin gentle, non-judgmental conversation about formative financial experiences to foster understanding and empathy.

3. Turning Stories Into Lessons, Not Shame

Starts ~23:12

The real work in effective financial planning is often psychological—recognizing that shame serves no purpose.
"Responsibility says, 'That was a dumb idea.' Shame says, 'I am dumb.' There's a very big difference." (37:43 – Carl Richards)
Trauma from money mistakes can linger for years and impact future choices. The key is to reframe losses as lessons and move forward.

4. The Role of the Financial Advisor: From Technician to Guide

Starts ~23:12

The best planners today act more as behavioral coaches or “money psychologists,” not just technical experts.
“The job, the calculator side of the job is incredibly important as a technical skill… and it's worthless in the long term if we don’t know where we’re going.” (26:46 – Carl Richards)
Humans add value by offering presence, curiosity, and empathy—skills AI won’t replicate.

5. Regaining Control Through Organization (The Maxine Story)

Starts ~27:45

Carl tells the story of Maxine, a widow overwhelmed with financial paperwork. By organizing it into a binder, Carl helps her regain a sense of control.
"I said, hey, could I carry that box? Could I carry that weight for you?... And when she came back, this three ring binder… the sense of relief.” (28:12–30:51)
For anyone overwhelmed, a small act—organizing paperwork, weeding a garden, cleaning a desk—can expand control and prompt more proactive engagement.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

On divergent views:

"You're standing shoulder to shoulder at a car accident and police reports are so different you wonder if you watched the same event." (13:31 – Carl Richards)
On planning vs. chasing products:

"We spend a lot of time talking about ladders and walls…but not if they're leaning against the wrong wall." (16:13 – Carl Richards)
On the emotional load in financial documents:

“That balance sheet is a non fictional document woven with fictional stories…every line…has a story.” (36:56 – Carl Richards)
On moving on from regret:

"You can’t hedge yesterday." (35:42 – Joe Saul-Sehy recalling Carl’s new book)

Practical Takeaways & Tactics

Have “money story” conversations: Ask your partner/parents/kids about their earliest money memories and what those meant.
Root discussions in understanding, not solutions:

"What did that feel like?" is a more powerful question than, “Why did you do that?”
Reduce shame, foster responsibility: Reframe past mistakes into lessons for growth.
Organize to regain agency: When overwhelmed, tidy a small area of your financial life (or literal workspace) to trigger broader momentum.
Planners: prioritize purpose: Technical skills matter, but understanding clients’ emotional lives and motivations distinguishes great advisors.

Related Segment: Options as a Hedge (Joe & OG)

Starts ~47:15 (Headline Segment)

A separate section of the episode focuses on options trading as a strategy for managing concentrated stock positions—a topic of growing interest as big winners like Nvidia dominate investors’ portfolios.

Options 101 Recap:
OG and Joe discuss using put and call options as “insurance policies” on existing stocks—e.g., if you want to protect Nvidia gains, you buy a put at a price you’re comfortable with.
Key Point: The costs of options (premiums) often outweigh their practical benefits for most investors, especially those with limited portfolios.

"Most people don't have the appetite for the amount of money it's going to cost..." (55:42 – Joe Saul-Sehy)
OG’s Core Argument:
Diversification trumps complex insurance-based strategies for long-term investors. Volatility is not the enemy; it’s also the source of investment growth.
Options are for advanced investors:
For most, an overreliance on options adds complexity for little or no long-term outcome improvement.

Timestamps for Key Segments

09:55 – Carl Richards joins the basement
10:25 – “If money is a math problem….why do we fight about it?” (Carl)
15:47 – “Start close in. What if we just started learning to talk about money in a layered and nuanced way?” (Carl)
17:51 – Money memory exercise (“What’s your first memory of money?”)
28:12 – Maxine’s story: The power of organizing the overwhelming
35:42 – “You can’t hedge yesterday.” (from Carl’s book)
47:15 – Discussion of options as a hedge in investments
55:42 – “Most people don’t have the appetite for the amount of money it’s gonna cost you.” (Joe)

Conclusion

Simplify and humanize financial planning: Strip away unnecessary complexity; focus on core questions and gentle self-inquiry.
Talk about money early and often: Your financial well-being is less “calculator” and more “kitchen table.”
Professional tools are only half the answer: Emotional awareness and thoughtful conversations drive real success.

Further Listening and Resources

Check show notes at stackingbenjamins.com for book links and additional resources from Carl Richards.
Carl's Book: Your Money: Reimagining Wealth in 101 Simple Sketches

"All options end at the end of their term at zero. Everything…is all volatility and speculation…you can't get rid of volatility—it's what gives you upside."
— OG (59:36)

“When I feel nervous…I'm just going to try and rewire my response. And my response can go from shame to responsibility…I'm not going to try to resist the stimulus…we're going to just try and rewire the response.”
— Carl Richards (40:38)

Loading summary...

Transcript

Progressive Insurance Announcer (0:03)

This episode is brought to you by Progressive Insurance. Fiscally responsible financial geniuses, monetary magicians. These are things people say about drivers who switch their car insurance to Progressive and save hundreds. Because Progressive offers discounts for paying in full, owning a home and more. Plus, you can count on their great customer service to help you when you need it. So your dollar goes a long way. Visit progressive.com to see if you could save on car insurance, Progressive Casualty Insurance company and affiliates. Potential savings will vary. Not available in all states or situations.

NBA on Prime Announcer (0:43)

This Friday, the NBA on prime tips off with their debut doubleheader. First up, Boston brings the action to the Garden as the Celtics face the New York Knicks. Then out west, it's a battle of the superpowers as the Lakers try to go against the relentless pace of of the Minnesota Timberwolves. Celtics, Knicks, Timberwolves, Lakers. Coverage starts Friday at 7 o' clock Eastern only on Prime.

Carl Richards (1:09)

All right, here we go.

OG (1:11)

Hold your ears, folks.

Joe Salsi (1:13)

It's showtime.

Doug (Joe's mom's neighbor) (1:20)

Live from Joe's mom's basement, it's the Stacking Benjamin show. I'm Joe's mom's neighbor, Doug. And today we simplify saving, investing and financial planning with a legend in the space. New York Times columnist and financial planner Carl Richards joins us for a wide ranging discussion about how to manage your money, goals and life in a simple and effective way. In our headline segment, advisors are wondering about options. How exactly do options work? Should you add them to your strategy? We'll chime in and you know it. I'm also going to swoop in halfway through the show with my mind bending trivia that you can totally show off to all your friends or both of them like me. And now two guys who are the best friends your money could have. It's Joe and.

OG (2:20)

Oh.

Doug (Joe's mom's neighbor) (2:20)

J.J. juju G.

Joe Salsi (2:26)

That's right. Welcome to your money mentors show. I am Joe Salsi. I'm so happy that you're here. It's another Wednesday and that means. Oh, geez on the mic. How are you, buddy?

OG (2:39)

I'm live in living color.

Joe Salsi (2:42)

Carl Richards (12:07)

Yeah, it's astonishing. I remember coming home one day from a tough day of work in the coal mines. I was feeling that way, sort of like beast of burden. And I walked in. I'm sure I was using this voice and making this face, and I was like, oh, it's so hard. And I'm sure I groaned a few times, and my wife was like. I mean, there was a little bit of like, get over yourself in her voice, which I appreciate, but there was also this, like, she said this crazy thing, and it was astonishing to me. And I love this language around, like, this thought had never crossed my mind because I was like, making money is so hard. It's so tough. And she was like, hey, what if it was fun and easy? And I remember this is a hundred percent metaphor. But I remember wanting, like, actually, I won't even use the metaphor, but I just remember being angry, sort of like, what? What do you mean? Because that thought had never crossed my mind. And she was viewing it from a completely different perspective. At least in that moment, she was viewing it from a completely different perspective. She was thinking something that had never even occurred to me. Not only do I not Know how to think that way. I didn't even know you were allowed to think that way. That, to me is such an important piece. That's why travel is important. It's why conversations. We were talking about regional differences. It's why hearing from people who are different from you, who bring different perspectives, different traditions, like some of the stories, I mean, I've traveled all over the world. We lived in New Zealand for four years, in London for a year. And some of the stories you hear from people about their relationship with money, you're suddenly like, whoa, there's a different way of thinking about this. I think that's how it all happens. I mean, we get into the science of standing at the corner and seeing a car accident. You're standing shoulder to shoulder with somebody and you have police reports taken. And the police reports, you're just like, I don't even know what that guy was watching. I mean, you could go to a movie with your spouse, come out of the movie, see your best friends, you hear your spouse describe the movie, and you're like, you were in a different movie.

Carl Richards (20:40)

Yeah, Josh had no problem with the story. But I asked him, I'm like, how come you've ever talked about that? He's like, I haven't talked about that in 25 years or 30 years. How come you haven't? He's like, no one ever asked, which is amazing. So tactically, I didn't know that about my wife of 27 years at the time. When I asked her publicly on the show, I didn't know the answer. I've been having that conversation with my kids. Here's another interesting one. Sort of like what I would have asked you at the end, because that's such a great story. I would have loved to have said, like, what do you make of that now? I would have loved to have said like, hey, can you go back there for a minute? Like, what did that feel like when you had that realization that you spent your whole summer? What was the feel? I would be really curious about the feeling. And then I'd probably move on to like, hey, in junior high, were you one of the rich kids or the poor kids? And then you would probably tell me some story and then I'd remember to ask and you'd say something like, oh, we didn't have a lot. People say that all the time. Oh, we were middle class or oh, we didn't have a lot of favorite question there. And again, this is all tactical. Start close in. These are the kind of conversations. This isn't about a budgeting app. Is my favorite question around anybody saying something like, we didn't have a lot, but we were fine, or any statement favorite question is to say, hey, how did you know? And then you get to this super. Like one day I was at school and I didn't realize it, but I only had one pair of tough skin jeans and I was at. This is a real story for my friend Aaron. I was at school and there was this girl I really liked and she was showing some interest in me, you know, like teenage sort of stuff. We were playing football after school and I got grass stains on my jeans and I didn't even think about it. I wore it the next day and this girl was from a more well to do family and she said, why didn't you wash your jeans? And I told her I only had one pair, and she never talked to me again. And you're like, come on. How is that informing? Josh's story is informing Josh's life. His story about losing $100 at sleepaway camp, you know, my friend Aaron's story. I could go on and on, but that tactically, that's what I'm talking about. What if we had some of those conversations gently, with deep empathy, just to understand, not to teach anybody anything, but just to. I mean, I get so excited, like, I could barely contain myself about how badly I want to ask you more questions. So it becomes an addiction of giving people space. That, to me, is how we solve this problem.

Carl Richards (24:37)

I completely agree. I think there's also a gulf between even the. I'm going to use this word in an old definitional sense, not in a layered cultural sense. Even the privilege of having these sorts of conversations. Like, there's a little bit of time and space that's required to even have the. You're just like, I don't know what you're on about, bro. I'm trying to pay my bills. I get that. But even at that level because I've had those conversations with people who are just like, I don't even know what you're talking. Even at that level. There's some idea of like, why, like, what's it for? What's the, like even to be seen and heard in a spot where you're like, I don't even have time for that. I'm paying my bills. Oh my gosh, I can make room for that. And you're right about the planning piece. And I've been really thinking a lot about what is uniquely human because AI is really good at doing. Humans have the potential of being really good at being. And I think what we're talking about here is the need for more presence, the need for more listening, the need for more curiosity at all levels of income and financial struggles. Like, I mean if I'm barely scraping by and I'm angry about it, which is reasonable just to have somebody go, yeah man, there's a reason you're feeling that way. There's a reason you're barely. There's a systematic reason. It's not just you. There's a systemic reason you're feeling that way. And let's get it out and let's throw some things in the backyard and let's do whatever. And then when it's time, let's think about like, are there some things we could do? And I think planners are becoming more and more aware of this. The job, the calculator side of the job is incredibly important as a technical skill, but it's also. And you can. And this, it's incredibly important and it's worthless in the long term if we don't know where we're going. And so both of those become true. And last analogy, I was in a self driving car recently and I'm a huge fan of self driving money. I can't wait for it. In that waymo ride. I'll tell you, it felt much safer than the Uber ride right before it.

Carl Richards (28:12)

Yeah. It's such a real story because there's this huge metaphor. Maxine got referred to me when I was running my financial planning firm. Her husband had recently passed away. It had been weeks, right? They had taken care of all the stuff you do. And she was coming out of the really intense mourning phase and saying, okay, I got some stuff I got to deal with. And some of the stuff was this pile of mail that had arrived. And in Maxine's relationship, her husband was the one that took care of most of the financial matters because she took care of a bunch of other stuff, incredibly important stuff. So Maxine didn't know much about the money, as often is the case with one spouse or the other. And she came in with this literally like a banker's box. Like it looked heavy when she walked in. There was opened mail and half open mail and then a whole bunch of completely unopened mail. And I remember the emotional but the very real physical feeling of saying, hey, could I carry that box? Could I carry that weight for you? And we sat down and I said, hey, what if we just took this meeting and talk about, we talked and then I said, hey, would it be okay if between now and the next meeting I'll go through all this mail? I won't throw anything away, but I'll open it all, I'll organize it in a binder and I'll put the stuff I think you should throw away in the back and we'll just go through it. And she was like, yeah, of course. And I remember when she came back, it was a, you know, a half inch three ring binder, you know, that whole box, that entire weight, a nicely organized half inch, three ring binder, everything hole punched, no more envelopes. And we went through it together. And both the sense when I first took the box, took is not even really the word I like when I first was able to help her with the box, the sense of relief. And then when she came back, this three ring binder just. And what that points to me is like there's a very specific application. But I think the broader application too is like anytime I'm worried or stressed or weighed down with anything but financial. Like for instance, if I've been reading the news lately, which is just not a good idea, and I feel overwhelmed, I found it helps a lot to organize the garage or weed the garden. This isn't some woo woo goofball thing. It's not some California drum circle idea.

Carl Richards (33:12)

But I hinted earlier about, like, the drums. Like, it feels ethereal. I think it's part of my job to take things that feel complex and crazy and ethereal and reduce them down. Because what you're talking about with your client story, there's a framework for that. And I just think it's so helpful when people understand what's going on in their minds. The framework is at the top of a pyramid. If you imagine products, like if we had a pyramid, you imagine products or the foundation of a house. The very, very, very, very top is this product idea. And in product, you could put news, market, economy, investments, you know, credit card budgeting out, like, whatever, tactical product. And your concerns are almost always at that level. And when you're talking about concerns at that level, you're way out in the branches of the tree. So your idea of, like, you know, it feels crazy. Yeah. There's a storm blowing, and the branches move a lot. And all you're doing is saying, look, you had intuitively figured out that if I could pull them back to the roots of the tree. And that roots is plan. And I think there's one root foundation underneath plan, which is purpose, a sense of purpose. But I think largely we're all thinking embedded in the plan is a sense of purpose. If we can get out of those branches. I would just start to set up habitually. If you feel like you're. Whoa. Unmoored, concerned, worried, to your point, you don't even have to get on a plane. I love getting on a plane. But you don't even have to get on a plane. Go on a walk. And if you can rewire your brain that way so that when you feel that way and you can start noticing, like, I promise you, you will feel that way every time. Right now you read the news. When you feel that way, you think, go someplace higher. And I like the higher metaphor. Like, even if you're in, like, the. Wherever the you are. I had a buddy, and I think he was in Iowa, and he was like, yeah, it's a bridge. Like, just somewhere where you get perspective Suddenly you feel a little bit like, oh man, get outside, get your hands in the dirt, touch a tree. And again, not woo woo. It's just like it has this ability to go, oh, oh, I was out in the branches of the tree. I'm here now. Guess what? What you were dealing with out in the branches didn't go away. Right. Like that decision about which credit card or which investment or what to do is still there. You just have a different perspective when you're looking at it now.

Joe Salsi (47:23)

Comes to us from Investment News. I found this really a compelling discussion on investment news. And for those of you that don't know investment news, which is most people, I'm sure this is a resource for advisors. It's an industry rag, as they call it. So I love when we do a headline from Investment News because of the fact that it's life on the other side of the table. And they had this discussion on investment News. I won't link to it in the Show Notes page. Advisors weighing in on the benefits of options as a hedge against concentrated stock risk. And it is interesting. We've had a market that's gone up great. In fact, this piece starts off by saying shares of Nvidia are up 1,250% over the past five years. So if somebody was fortunate enough to have purchased Nvidia five years ago, at that time, OG it wasn't a concentrated position in your portfolio, right? And now because of the market run, it truly could be a problem in your portfolio. Because your portfolio now, if you haven't sold any off, it's going to go where Nvidia goes. Well, you have a couple choices. You can, number one, you can sell it right now, or number two is you could maybe use an option strategy to hedge against the risk that it wrecks your portfolio. Clearly, if Nvidia goes up, a lot of people would want a piece of that, which is why you might have an option to sell instead of selling it. So the way this works, Stackers, is that instead of selling off your Nvidia or a piece of your Nvidia, you instead do an option to sell. And that option to sell says, I'm going to sell it at a predetermined price. And in this case it would be the price that is trading at right now. And instead of selling it, I'll wait and see if it goes up or down. If it goes down, I'll just sell the option and get the price it's at today. If it continues to go up, then, heck, then the option expires. I paid a little bit for this quote insurance policy and then I'm good. But what do you think about using options instead of selling off a piece of your portfolio that might be too concentrated? OG Instead of using options to mitigate some of the risk in the portfolio.

OG (49:37)

I think we have to talk about the difference between like, use the right terminology here because I think a lot of people will confuse this or could confuse this with part of your compensation, right? So you'll say, well, I get options for my pay. I get, you know, I get restricted options for my bonus, or I get non qualified options for my bonus. It works somewhat similarly in that, you know, you have this grant that has a specific exercise price, but this is a little different. The way that an option contract works on a stock that you already own is just like you talked about. You're making a promise in exchange for either a premium that you're gonna receive or some cash today or a premium that you're going to pay to fulfill the obligation. So Nvidia is at $180 a share. And you say, I'm okay with the bouncing around because that's what stocks do. But I don't want it to go below 150. And so you can buy insurance at 150 and say, you know, if it dips below 150 between now and the end of March next year, then I get to get out at 150. So if it goes down to 160, then nothing happens. If it goes to 151, nothing happens. If it goes to 132, I've got this piece of paper here that says, whoa, whoa, whoa, says here I get to sell at 150. I'm going to exercise it now. I'm going to use my option to get out at 150. And you can do it the other way too. You can say, you know, it's at $180 and if it ever went to 225, I would sell that thing like a hotcake. And in exchange for that promise, you can get some money today. So you can say, well, how strongly do you feel about that? I feel real strongly. If that hits 225 between now and March, I would 100% get out, guaranteed. Put your money where your mouth is, write it down on a piece of paper and say, I promise to do it. In exchange for that promise, they'll give you some cash today. So you can do both sides of this transaction and you can do it with or without owning the stock, which makes it even more, more risky on top of it, ultimately, from an investment standpoint, let's talk about it that way. So you've got the stock, you've got a thousand shares. It's $180,000 of your portfolio. It's 85% of your portfolio. And you go, I feel like I should. The right answer is to diversify, right? Oh, gee, Joe, like that's the right answer. But man, I just don't Want to. Because if I do and this thing goes from 180 to 360, I just lost out on 180 grand. I need you to take that out of your mind. You have to evaluate your investment decision based on what it is today. The information that you have today. If you have $180,000 of Nvidia stock and you have a $200,000 investment portfolio, it's overweighted. And you have to diversify that if you want to be smart from an investment perspective. That doesn't mean it's not going to go up. That doesn't mean you say, well, I'm not going to do that. I'm going to keep it concentrated and it doesn't go up 10x from here. And you say, I told you so. I knew. I was glad I didn't diversify that. Now I've got a million dollars. This is a way better deal. Absolutely, that could happen. But the thing that happens with diversification is you trade away the opportunity to make a killing in exchange for never getting killed. That's the trade. I can't tell you what's going to happen with any individual stock, nor can anyone. Which is why buying an ETF or buying a diversified portfolio of big companies and small companies and US based ones and non US based ones makes a lot of sense to me. Because it's way easier to say, what is the overall economy going to do over the next 30 years of my life? It's going to grow. That's what I believe in my soul. I'm not smart enough to say which AI chip manufacturer is going to pull out ahead, which raindrop is going to hit the bottom of the, of the windowsill, the first, the fastest. I'm not smart enough to pick that.

OG (55:42)

I mean, so if the stock is 180 and you want to insure it for 150. So A, you're taking a $30 per share loss to get your insurance to pay out, right? And then it costs you eight bucks for the next, what, five months. So $8 on 180 is 5%, a little bit less than 5% of the. Like, you have to make so much money just to offset the premium of the insurance, the option cost that it's really hard. So I think one of the risks is this 8,000 bucks. You could be doing other things with it. The second thing is, is that it ignores the volatility and the fact that generally speaking, the market goes up. And I can't talk about Nvidia saying, I know it's going to go up today could be the high price, the highest price it ever has. There was a day where Kodak was at an all time high and then it went down from there and ceases to exist today. That's happened and it's happened for Pan Am and it's happened for thousands and thousands of other companies. Which is why buying an ETF that's largely diversified is such a great idea. Because you don't have to play the game of which one of these tech companies is going to be great tomorrow. Like, who cares? You just own everything. And it's self cleaning. When something just doesn't do well, it falls off and it's replaced by the thing that is. So it's totally fine. But if you look at this purely from a volatility standpoint, so there's some chance the stock's at 180 right now. I got my piece of paper that says I can get out at 150 and it goes to 148 and you go, ha, ha, ha, ha ha. I'm out at 150. And three days later it's back to 180. Now what happened? You lost 30 bucks a share to save $2 a share to save yourself from the volatility. That is the very thing that gets you the upside that you're looking for. This is the thing that people have to wrap their head around. Volatility is both sides. When you see a stock goes, oh my gosh, this stock goes up, you know, it's up 10x in the last five years. That's one side of volatility. It's the good side, it's the side we like. It's the fun part. But it can work the other way just as easily. And so when the Stock goes from 120 to 180, what was the most recent one that went crazy? AMD or something. So I think it was AMD just skyrocketed one day. The people who had those other side of the options, they thought they were, hey, we got this free money, we can get these. You know, they had a huge risk there too. So there's no such thing as a free lunch here. This is the biggest piece. If you're worried about over concentration in your portfolio because of a stock, you have to do one of two things. You have to either sell the stock and diversify it or build more money around that the stock that you have.

Summary

The Stacking Benjamins Show

Episode Overview

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Money Isn’t Just Math—It’s Stories, Emotions, and Lenses

Starts ~09:55

Carl Richards shares that despite his “very big calculator,” he realized after a decade in finance that math isn’t what derails us with money—emotions and stories are:

“If money is a math problem, how come I end up in a fight?...two plus two always equals four, but two plus two never equals envy.” (10:25 – Carl Richards)
Money is a “series of stories” and conversations about it can be like “an electric fence you didn’t know was electric.” (11:38 – Carl Richards)
Everyone sees the same “cube” (situation), but from different sides—shaped by unique histories and beliefs.
Example: Carl’s wife once shifted his perspective by simply asking:

“What if it was fun and easy?”
This stunned Carl, who had never considered money-making could be anything but hard. (12:07–14:13)

2. The Power of Perspective & Conversation

Starts ~14:13

Money, like politics, is often filtered through such varied lenses that people experience “different realities.”
The antidote is layered, nuanced talk—sharing stories and being genuinely curious about others’ views and money memories.

“What if we just started learning to talk about money in a layered and nuanced way?” (15:47 – Carl Richards)

Strategy: Start close in, at home or among immediate circles, with questions like, “What’s your first memory of money?”
Even industry veterans (Joe or guest Josh Brown) struggled when first asked this—most listeners never ask or answer these with partners, family, or friends. (17:51–20:34)
Tactical Tip: Begin gentle, non-judgmental conversation about formative financial experiences to foster understanding and empathy.

3. Turning Stories Into Lessons, Not Shame

Starts ~23:12

The real work in effective financial planning is often psychological—recognizing that shame serves no purpose.
"Responsibility says, 'That was a dumb idea.' Shame says, 'I am dumb.' There's a very big difference." (37:43 – Carl Richards)
Trauma from money mistakes can linger for years and impact future choices. The key is to reframe losses as lessons and move forward.

4. The Role of the Financial Advisor: From Technician to Guide

Starts ~23:12

The best planners today act more as behavioral coaches or “money psychologists,” not just technical experts.
“The job, the calculator side of the job is incredibly important as a technical skill… and it's worthless in the long term if we don’t know where we’re going.” (26:46 – Carl Richards)
Humans add value by offering presence, curiosity, and empathy—skills AI won’t replicate.

5. Regaining Control Through Organization (The Maxine Story)

Starts ~27:45

Carl tells the story of Maxine, a widow overwhelmed with financial paperwork. By organizing it into a binder, Carl helps her regain a sense of control.
"I said, hey, could I carry that box? Could I carry that weight for you?... And when she came back, this three ring binder… the sense of relief.” (28:12–30:51)
For anyone overwhelmed, a small act—organizing paperwork, weeding a garden, cleaning a desk—can expand control and prompt more proactive engagement.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

On divergent views:

"You're standing shoulder to shoulder at a car accident and police reports are so different you wonder if you watched the same event." (13:31 – Carl Richards)
On planning vs. chasing products:

"We spend a lot of time talking about ladders and walls…but not if they're leaning against the wrong wall." (16:13 – Carl Richards)
On the emotional load in financial documents:

“That balance sheet is a non fictional document woven with fictional stories…every line…has a story.” (36:56 – Carl Richards)
On moving on from regret:

"You can’t hedge yesterday." (35:42 – Joe Saul-Sehy recalling Carl’s new book)

Practical Takeaways & Tactics

Have “money story” conversations: Ask your partner/parents/kids about their earliest money memories and what those meant.
Root discussions in understanding, not solutions:

"What did that feel like?" is a more powerful question than, “Why did you do that?”
Reduce shame, foster responsibility: Reframe past mistakes into lessons for growth.
Organize to regain agency: When overwhelmed, tidy a small area of your financial life (or literal workspace) to trigger broader momentum.
Planners: prioritize purpose: Technical skills matter, but understanding clients’ emotional lives and motivations distinguishes great advisors.

Related Segment: Options as a Hedge (Joe & OG)

Starts ~47:15 (Headline Segment)

Options 101 Recap:
OG and Joe discuss using put and call options as “insurance policies” on existing stocks—e.g., if you want to protect Nvidia gains, you buy a put at a price you’re comfortable with.
Key Point: The costs of options (premiums) often outweigh their practical benefits for most investors, especially those with limited portfolios.

"Most people don't have the appetite for the amount of money it's going to cost..." (55:42 – Joe Saul-Sehy)
OG’s Core Argument:
Diversification trumps complex insurance-based strategies for long-term investors. Volatility is not the enemy; it’s also the source of investment growth.
Options are for advanced investors:
For most, an overreliance on options adds complexity for little or no long-term outcome improvement.

Timestamps for Key Segments

09:55 – Carl Richards joins the basement
10:25 – “If money is a math problem….why do we fight about it?” (Carl)
15:47 – “Start close in. What if we just started learning to talk about money in a layered and nuanced way?” (Carl)
17:51 – Money memory exercise (“What’s your first memory of money?”)
28:12 – Maxine’s story: The power of organizing the overwhelming
35:42 – “You can’t hedge yesterday.” (from Carl’s book)
47:15 – Discussion of options as a hedge in investments
55:42 – “Most people don’t have the appetite for the amount of money it’s gonna cost you.” (Joe)

Conclusion

Simplify and humanize financial planning: Strip away unnecessary complexity; focus on core questions and gentle self-inquiry.
Talk about money early and often: Your financial well-being is less “calculator” and more “kitchen table.”
Professional tools are only half the answer: Emotional awareness and thoughtful conversations drive real success.

Further Listening and Resources

Check show notes at stackingbenjamins.com for book links and additional resources from Carl Richards.
Carl's Book: Your Money: Reimagining Wealth in 101 Simple Sketches

"All options end at the end of their term at zero. Everything…is all volatility and speculation…you can't get rid of volatility—it's what gives you upside."
— OG (59:36)

“When I feel nervous…I'm just going to try and rewire my response. And my response can go from shame to responsibility…I'm not going to try to resist the stimulus…we're going to just try and rewire the response.”
— Carl Richards (40:38)