wavePod

Get Wave AI

Why 2,500 Subscribers Is All You Need For $1M - The Startup Ideas Podcast | Wave AI Podcast Notes

Back to The Startup Ideas Podcast

Why 2,500 Subscribers Is All You Need For $1M

The Startup Ideas Podcast

Wed Jan 22 2025

Summary

The Startup Ideas Podcast – Episode Summary

Episode Title: Why 2,500 Subscribers Is All You Need For $1M

Host: Greg Isenberg
Guest: Jonathan (“Jay Ice Cream”)
Date: January 22, 2025

Episode Overview

This episode dives deep into one of the most underrated tools for building a successful, scalable business: sales funnels. Greg Isenberg hosts Jonathan (“Jay Ice Cream”), a funnel expert and serial founder, for a candid, practical, and often humorous look into how even a small email list (think 2,500 engaged subscribers) can translate into a million-dollar business. Together, they unpack the mechanics of effective funnels, share stories from their own businesses, and discuss why most founders make funnel-building overly complicated or overlook it entirely.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Why Funnels Matter (00:00 - 03:00)

Greg introduces the topic, emphasizing that building a sales funnel is foundational yet underappreciated in the startup world.
Jonathan explains the “dirty word” reputation of funnels and how, when demystified, they are the key to predictable growth.

2. Personal Reflections, Transitions, and Setting Goals (03:10 - 13:30)

Light-hearted banter about New Year's reflections and personal growth goals—including Greg’s humorous take on self-improvement.
Jonathan shares his own transition story: stepping down as CEO of facilitator.com to become an advisor, splitting his company into three parts, and regaining headspace.
Key moment: Jonathan describes the challenge of letting go and the risks of stepping away as a founder.
- Quote: “It’s easier for me to assume the worst...but facilitator.com now is a well-oiled entity with all the funnels and everything.” (13:34)

3. Founder Identity, Letting Go, and Advisor Role (13:25 - 19:30)

Both discuss the difficulty for founders in transitioning to an advisory role.
The challenge isn’t just giving up control—it’s staying valuable without being overbearing.
They swap stories of stepping in and out of leadership, drawing parallels in their respective journeys.
Quote: Greg: “When a company is doing well, they don’t want me involved. They want strategic advice...but not me in the weeds.” (17:33)

4. Funnel Fundamentals: The Million Dollar Recipe (19:34 – 25:41)

Jonathan shares that the basics of funnels are still the most effective.
- Quote: “Most of the real basics work so goddamn well. Today, we can launch a product using basically just the same webinar...that’s still the multimillion-dollar recipe we’re reusing over and over.” (20:10)
The simplest version: Build a list, drive them to a webinar, pitch the product, send follow-ups.
The process is repeatable for coaching, info products, and even SaaS.

5. Step-by-Step: The 2,500 Subscriber Funnel (25:41 – 30:14)

Jonathan walks through a specific funnel for his own 2,500-person “Unscheduled CEO” email list:
- Invite list to a free live training (webinar) tailored to their interests.
- At the end, pitch an in-person paid event or coaching.
- Outcomes: Emailing a cold list yields very few sales; a webinar boosts conversion substantially.
Quote: “If I do a live training...maybe 200 people turn up. I’ll get like 20 people buying tickets right there.” (26:39)
He breaks down a typical webinar structure:
- 20 mins: Personal story showcasing relatable struggles.
- 10-15 mins: “Discovering the vehicle” — introducing the key solution.
- Another 20 mins: Explaining how the solution changed the game.
- Wrap-up: Offer two next steps—DIY (learn on your own) or fast-track (buy the product/event).

6. From Content to Cash: The Deeper Funnel (32:50 – 35:41)

They diagram the funnel:
- Email List → Free Live Training → Paid Live Event → High-ticket Coaching/Advisory/Equity Deals.
Note: This structure isn’t just for info products; it can serve as a pipeline for high-value equity/partnership opportunities.

7. Applying Funnels to SaaS and Software (37:08 – 44:07)

They discuss adapting these mechanics to SaaS startups:
- Example: Using a “Challenge Funnel” (e.g., a 30-day ‘build your second brain’ challenge for Notion, in partnership with an influencer).
  - Free access starts the habit, group coaching enables engagement, a percentage become paying users.
Quote: “A challenge can be a fun and useful way to get people actually into some routine...” (43:26)
Even non-cheesy, high-profile brands use “stealth funnels” under the hood and benefit hugely.

8. The Importance of a ‘Warming Up’ Step (45:04–46:19)

Jonathan’s advice: Don’t just email your list a sales link. Always include a warming-up step—webinar, info session, or challenge—to prime your audience.
Real-world examples: Stanford’s info sessions, corporate challenge funnels, and more.
Quote: “Most of the time, you need to have this middle step to get people warmed up and excited enough to actually spend their money.” (45:56)

Memorable Quotes & Moments

On Losing to a 94-Year-Old at Tennis:
- Greg: “I lost the game to a 94 year old man. He absolutely destroys me.” (05:57)
On Funnel Simplicity:
- Jonathan: “The real basics work so goddamn well. Just email your list, send them to a webinar, follow up, and you can make millions.” (20:10)
On Letting Go as Founder:
- Greg: “When a company is doing well, they don’t want me involved...They want the strategic advice, but not me in the weeds.” (17:33)
On Funnel Warmups:
- Jonathan: “If you just email everybody or just post...It’s unlikely that it will work without this middle warming up step.” (45:13)

Key Timestamps

00:00–03:00: Why funnels are overlooked, and why they shouldn’t be.
03:10–06:23: Humorous New Year’s goals and personal stories.
11:16–14:41: Jonathan’s transition out of day-to-day CEO, risk of “hands-off” gone too far.
19:34–21:38: How simple webinar-based funnels drive revenue.
25:41–30:14: 2,500-subscriber funnel, webinar structure, precise conversion numbers.
37:08–44:07: Challenge Funnel explained; adapting the approach for SaaS (e.g., Notion).
45:04–46:19: The absolute necessity of a warming-up/priming step.
47:25–50:25: Favorite products (“Fellow” kettle appreciation), lighthearted outro.

Final Thoughts & Actionable Advice

Start Simple, Stay Consistent: Even a small, well-nurtured list can outperform huge, unengaged audiences if you use the right funnel strategy.
Always Warm Up Your Audience: Webinars, live trainings, and challenges are essential “middle steps” between content and purchase.
Funnel Types Are Universal: The same toolkit works for info products, SaaS, in-person events, and even high-ticket advisory/partnership gigs.
Don’t Neglect Your Story: Craft and refine personal or product stories as the backbone of your offers.

Explore more startup ideas and funnel inspiration:
https://gregisenberg.com/30startupideas

“Don’t let anyone tell you how to drink your coffee. Especially not the funnel guy.”
— Greg Isenberg (50:45)

Loading summary...

Transcript

A (0:00)

Right behind where I'm sitting, you can see this whiteboard and there's this funnel that Jonathan jaiscream goes through with us that's printed him millions of dollars. We go through exactly how to do it, why funnels matter. And honestly, I don't know why people sleep on funnels. It's kind of a dirty word. But today we're going to have a fun chat and just go through how to think about structuring a funnel that works for your business. So this means you're going to get more customers, you're going to create more sales, and it's just going to be a big friend for you to grow your business and give your business the highest chance of success. This is a fun conversation. Always with Ice Cream is always a blast. And let me know what you think in the comment section. I read every single comment. Hope you enjoy.

B (1:29)

What's up, Greg?

A (1:31)

What's going on? Could I call you Jay Ice Cream?

B (1:34)

You can call me Jay Ice Cream. I mean, you're the only one who does it. But I like, that's not true, dude.

A (1:40)

The comment section.

B (1:41)

Always your comment section. And your people on X called me that.

A (1:50)

But what does your girl call you?

B (1:54)

John Ice Cream.

A (1:56)

John Ice Cream.

B (1:57)

Jonathan Ice Cream. She calls me Jonathan Ice Cream. Yeah, it's. I think I never intended it to be spoken out loud because it was my Xbox gamer tag. You know, it was one of those things where I was, like, trying different things and then I was just like, ice Cream. And then J Ice Cream became my Twitter name or X name, also my Instagram name. But I don't think anything else besides my original Xbox account.

A (2:28)

And then besides from your whole identity.

B (2:32)

Well, besides the fact that you noticed it or some. Or your audience noticed it literally 20 years after I did it. Like, no, there was, I think, like one person on one podcast. Maybe 10 years ago, a German podcast said in a very friendly and naive way, why is your name Jizz Cream? And I was like, oh, oh, no, it's J Ice Cream. And then that was the whole. Then there was 10 years of nothing. And then now you and your podcast.

B (30:28)

I can tell you also, like, okay, we've got two webinars coming up for two different clients. They're always almost the same structure because they're always like, jonathan, but what do we do on the live training? And I'm like, all right, guys. So both are launching a new product and both are launching almost sequels to their previous product. So they had something in their. They're launching new things. So in both cases, I will say, first, talk about why you created the first product. Like, why did you create it? What problems were you having? What was the journey? Now talk about in the meantime, since you created that product, what were the things you realized about that product that are no longer working for you as you've developed and become better at what you've done? Cool. Talk about that for a while now. What are the things that you've discovered that have improved and helped you on the new part of your journey? And I'm going to give you an exact example in a second. And now talk about, well, there's a gap between the thing you've created and now the thing that you would need to have existed for you to get to this point, and that's the new product. An example is I'm learning. I'm doing climbing, bouldering. It's like a. Bouldering, whatever. Climbing, indoor climbing. That's probably the easiest thing that it's called. So I'm currently one year into learning indoor climbing, and I'm completely stuck. And what always happens when I get stuck is I try a million different things to get past that point. I. I'm currently watching loads of YouTube videos. I am this, this, this, this, this. But I have a very strong feeling what's going to happen is now I've booked a coach. This coach will probably be able to tell me, like, oh, yeah, no, you need to move your leg a little bit like this and this and this and this and that will have, like, completely short circuited the entire process of learning. Like, me doing it by myself might have taken another year for me to go up one grade with a coach. It might take me another two weeks to go up one grade. And so if I were telling the story, if I were later trying to sell coaching, like, for climbing, for some reason, I would just tell the story of if I was the coach. I had this client who was stuck on grade 5B. Don't laugh at me if you actually know climbing 5B. For six months, he tried all of this. He bought new shoes, he kept spending Loads of money on it. Eventually he was giving up. He wasn't having any more fun with it. Then we met and I realized actually it was just this one thing. That's why it's better to get a coach sometimes than trying to learn everything yourself. Webinars are just always about showing this gap between where you think your audience is, where you'd like them to be, and because you're usually there where they want to be, what needs to go into this gap to bring them over there as fast as possible. And webinars are mostly that in a nutshell.

Summary

The Startup Ideas Podcast – Episode Summary

Episode Title: Why 2,500 Subscribers Is All You Need For $1M

Host: Greg Isenberg
Guest: Jonathan (“Jay Ice Cream”)
Date: January 22, 2025

Episode Overview

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Why Funnels Matter (00:00 - 03:00)

Greg introduces the topic, emphasizing that building a sales funnel is foundational yet underappreciated in the startup world.
Jonathan explains the “dirty word” reputation of funnels and how, when demystified, they are the key to predictable growth.

2. Personal Reflections, Transitions, and Setting Goals (03:10 - 13:30)

Light-hearted banter about New Year's reflections and personal growth goals—including Greg’s humorous take on self-improvement.
Jonathan shares his own transition story: stepping down as CEO of facilitator.com to become an advisor, splitting his company into three parts, and regaining headspace.
Key moment: Jonathan describes the challenge of letting go and the risks of stepping away as a founder.
- Quote: “It’s easier for me to assume the worst...but facilitator.com now is a well-oiled entity with all the funnels and everything.” (13:34)

3. Founder Identity, Letting Go, and Advisor Role (13:25 - 19:30)

Both discuss the difficulty for founders in transitioning to an advisory role.
The challenge isn’t just giving up control—it’s staying valuable without being overbearing.
They swap stories of stepping in and out of leadership, drawing parallels in their respective journeys.
Quote: Greg: “When a company is doing well, they don’t want me involved. They want strategic advice...but not me in the weeds.” (17:33)

4. Funnel Fundamentals: The Million Dollar Recipe (19:34 – 25:41)

Jonathan shares that the basics of funnels are still the most effective.
- Quote: “Most of the real basics work so goddamn well. Today, we can launch a product using basically just the same webinar...that’s still the multimillion-dollar recipe we’re reusing over and over.” (20:10)
The simplest version: Build a list, drive them to a webinar, pitch the product, send follow-ups.
The process is repeatable for coaching, info products, and even SaaS.

5. Step-by-Step: The 2,500 Subscriber Funnel (25:41 – 30:14)

Jonathan walks through a specific funnel for his own 2,500-person “Unscheduled CEO” email list:
- Invite list to a free live training (webinar) tailored to their interests.
- At the end, pitch an in-person paid event or coaching.
- Outcomes: Emailing a cold list yields very few sales; a webinar boosts conversion substantially.
Quote: “If I do a live training...maybe 200 people turn up. I’ll get like 20 people buying tickets right there.” (26:39)
He breaks down a typical webinar structure:
- 20 mins: Personal story showcasing relatable struggles.
- 10-15 mins: “Discovering the vehicle” — introducing the key solution.
- Another 20 mins: Explaining how the solution changed the game.
- Wrap-up: Offer two next steps—DIY (learn on your own) or fast-track (buy the product/event).

6. From Content to Cash: The Deeper Funnel (32:50 – 35:41)

They diagram the funnel:
- Email List → Free Live Training → Paid Live Event → High-ticket Coaching/Advisory/Equity Deals.
Note: This structure isn’t just for info products; it can serve as a pipeline for high-value equity/partnership opportunities.

7. Applying Funnels to SaaS and Software (37:08 – 44:07)

They discuss adapting these mechanics to SaaS startups:
- Example: Using a “Challenge Funnel” (e.g., a 30-day ‘build your second brain’ challenge for Notion, in partnership with an influencer).
  - Free access starts the habit, group coaching enables engagement, a percentage become paying users.
Quote: “A challenge can be a fun and useful way to get people actually into some routine...” (43:26)
Even non-cheesy, high-profile brands use “stealth funnels” under the hood and benefit hugely.

8. The Importance of a ‘Warming Up’ Step (45:04–46:19)

Jonathan’s advice: Don’t just email your list a sales link. Always include a warming-up step—webinar, info session, or challenge—to prime your audience.
Real-world examples: Stanford’s info sessions, corporate challenge funnels, and more.
Quote: “Most of the time, you need to have this middle step to get people warmed up and excited enough to actually spend their money.” (45:56)

Memorable Quotes & Moments

On Losing to a 94-Year-Old at Tennis:
- Greg: “I lost the game to a 94 year old man. He absolutely destroys me.” (05:57)
On Funnel Simplicity:
- Jonathan: “The real basics work so goddamn well. Just email your list, send them to a webinar, follow up, and you can make millions.” (20:10)
On Letting Go as Founder:
- Greg: “When a company is doing well, they don’t want me involved...They want the strategic advice, but not me in the weeds.” (17:33)
On Funnel Warmups:
- Jonathan: “If you just email everybody or just post...It’s unlikely that it will work without this middle warming up step.” (45:13)

Key Timestamps

00:00–03:00: Why funnels are overlooked, and why they shouldn’t be.
03:10–06:23: Humorous New Year’s goals and personal stories.
11:16–14:41: Jonathan’s transition out of day-to-day CEO, risk of “hands-off” gone too far.
19:34–21:38: How simple webinar-based funnels drive revenue.
25:41–30:14: 2,500-subscriber funnel, webinar structure, precise conversion numbers.
37:08–44:07: Challenge Funnel explained; adapting the approach for SaaS (e.g., Notion).
45:04–46:19: The absolute necessity of a warming-up/priming step.
47:25–50:25: Favorite products (“Fellow” kettle appreciation), lighthearted outro.

Final Thoughts & Actionable Advice

Start Simple, Stay Consistent: Even a small, well-nurtured list can outperform huge, unengaged audiences if you use the right funnel strategy.
Always Warm Up Your Audience: Webinars, live trainings, and challenges are essential “middle steps” between content and purchase.
Funnel Types Are Universal: The same toolkit works for info products, SaaS, in-person events, and even high-ticket advisory/partnership gigs.
Don’t Neglect Your Story: Craft and refine personal or product stories as the backbone of your offers.

Explore more startup ideas and funnel inspiration:
https://gregisenberg.com/30startupideas

“Don’t let anyone tell you how to drink your coffee. Especially not the funnel guy.”
— Greg Isenberg (50:45)