The Stephen A. Smith Show Episode Summary: Interview with Governor Josh Shapiro Release Date: February 11, 2025

In this special edition of The Stephen A. Smith Show, renowned sports commentator and media personality Stephen A. Smith sits down with Josh Shapiro, the 48th Governor of Pennsylvania. The conversation delves deep into pressing national and international issues, offering listeners a comprehensive look into Governor Shapiro's perspectives on politics, societal challenges, and his vision for the future.

1. Introduction: A Distinguished Guest

Stephen A. Smith opens the episode by expressing his honor in hosting Josh Shapiro, highlighting Shapiro’s role as Pennsylvania’s governor during a significant time when the Philadelphia Eagles were competing in the Super Bowl. The conversation sets the stage for an in-depth discussion beyond the realms of sports, touching on critical societal and political issues.

2. The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict and U.S. Foreign Policy

Stephen A. Smith:
"You've seen The President... wanting to take over Gaza. What was your reaction?"
[02:09]

Governor Josh Shapiro:
"I thought it was an unserious proposal that, if carried out, violates international law and is deeply disrespectful to the Palestinian people."
[02:18]

Governor Shapiro criticizes former President Donald Trump's stance on the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, particularly Trump's suggestion to annex Gaza. He emphasizes the importance of a two-state solution, advocating for peaceful coexistence between Israelis and Palestinians. Shapiro also scrutinizes Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's response, suggesting that Netanyahu is prioritizing short-term political survival over long-term regional stability.

Governor Josh Shapiro:
"Netanyahu is playing a short-term game... He’s not thinking about the long-term interests of Israel."
[04:45]

3. Navigating Party Politics and Leadership

The discussion shifts to the dynamics within the Democratic Party and Shapiro's position as a leader who often receives criticism for his pro-Israel stance. Shapiro underscores his commitment to his principles despite facing opposition and highlights the importance of evolving on issues based on informed perspectives.

Governor Josh Shapiro:
"I stand where I stand. I don’t let the love or hate I receive force me to change my views."
[07:48]

He contrasts his approach with that of Republican leaders who, in his view, often capitulate to Donald Trump's influence without upholding constitutional responsibilities.

4. Executive Orders and Governance

A significant portion of the interview focuses on President Trump’s use of executive orders. Governor Shapiro expresses deep concern over Trump’s decision to pardon individuals involved in the January 6th Capitol assault, viewing it as a disrespectful gesture towards law enforcement and the rule of law.

Governor Josh Shapiro:
"When he pardoned people who assaulted cops on January 6th, it showed an utter lack of respect for law enforcement."
[32:34]

Shapiro also critiques Trump's broader use of executive orders to bypass the legislative process, arguing that such actions undermine democratic institutions and the Constitution.

5. Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI)

Governor Shapiro discusses his stance on DEI initiatives, advocating for a society that respects and includes all individuals without creating divisions. He criticizes the erosion of DEI under Trump’s administration, emphasizing the need for policies that provide equal opportunities rather than fostering resentment between different groups.

Governor Josh Shapiro:
"We need to build a society where everybody has opportunity, not where one is pitted against the other."
[37:57]

He further explains his efforts in Pennsylvania to promote inclusivity and equal opportunity, rejecting the notion that DEI should be confined to specific offices or individuals.

6. Immigration Policy: A Balanced Approach

The conversation turns to immigration, where Governor Shapiro presents a balanced perspective. He acknowledges the challenges posed by illegal immigration while advocating for secure borders and a clear, humane path to citizenship for those already residing in the country.

Governor Josh Shapiro:
"We need a comprehensive immigration solution that secures our borders and provides a pathway for those who are here illegally."
[46:15]

Shapiro contrasts his views with both the Trump and Obama administrations, highlighting the complexities of immigration reform and the necessity for bipartisan efforts to address workforce needs and economic contributions of immigrants.

7. The Role and Future of USAID

Addressing President Trump’s actions concerning the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID), Shapiro emphasizes the importance of adhering to legal processes in altering or defunding governmental agencies. He criticizes unilateral executive actions that undermine established laws and budgets.

Governor Josh Shapiro:
"Trump can’t just sign an executive order and overhaul USAID unilaterally."
[47:34]

Shapiro advocates for responsible governance, aligning state-level efforts to eliminate wasteful spending with federal initiatives that respect legislative processes.

8. Trump's Influence on the Republican Party and American Politics

Governor Shapiro provides a critical analysis of Donald Trump's impact on the Republican Party, describing Trump as a dominant yet divisive figure who has reshaped the party's dynamics. He expresses frustration with GOP leaders who prioritize loyalty to Trump over constitutional duties.

Governor Josh Shapiro:
"The members of Congress who are not standing up and doing their part are the ones I have a real problem with."
[51:21]

Shapiro also discusses the challenges of countering Trump's influence, suggesting that the Democratic Party needs to showcase multiple leaders who can unify and address the country's issues effectively.

9. Future of Democratic Leadership and Unity

In contemplating the future, Governor Shapiro speaks about the importance of collective leadership within the Democratic Party. He dismisses the notion of a single face leading the party, advocating instead for a diverse group of leaders who can resonate with a broad spectrum of Americans.

Governor Josh Shapiro:
"There's not going to be one person that rises up tomorrow, but there are many good things happening among Democratic leaders in the states."
[52:42]

He emphasizes his role as a pragmatic governor focused on common-sense policies that bridge gaps between different communities and political affiliations.

10. Concluding Remarks and Reflections

As the interview wraps up, Stephen A. Smith reflects on Governor Shapiro’s potential as a presidential candidate, praising his leadership and vision. Governor Shapiro humbly acknowledges the support he receives and reiterates his commitment to serving the public with empathy and effective governance.

Governor Josh Shapiro:
"I'm proud to be a Democrat and to be a voice within the party that aims to heal and move it forward."
[58:18]

Stephen concludes by highlighting Shapiro’s significant contributions and expressing optimism about his future influence in American politics.

This episode offers a candid and insightful conversation with Governor Josh Shapiro, shedding light on his perspectives on international conflicts, party politics, executive governance, social equity, and the future of American leadership. Listeners gain a nuanced understanding of Shapiro’s commitment to inclusive and effective governance, as well as his strategic vision for overcoming the political divisions that challenge the nation.