Podcast Summary: The Superhero Complex - Episode 8: The Hero We Deserve

Introduction

In Episode 8 of "The Superhero Complex," hosted by David Weinberg and produced by Novel for iHeartRadio, the narrative delves deep into the tumultuous journey of Phoenix Jones, Seattle's most renowned real-life superhero. This episode examines the rise and fall of Phoenix Jones, questioning whether he is a genuine protector of the community or merely a facade masking deeper issues.

Phoenix Jones: From Hero to Outlaw

The episode begins by recounting the events leading to Phoenix Jones's fall from grace. On January 6, 2020, at 11:14 PM, Phoenix (real name Ben Fodor) receives a mysterious text message that initiates a series of interactions with an undercover police officer. What begins as a seemingly innocent conversation about social plans escalates into a drug deal. Phoenix finds himself arrested at the Silver Cloud Hotel with his girlfriend, Andrea Berenston, after attempting to sell cocaine and MDMA to undercover agents.

[03:04] Phoenix Jones: "Payment of $45 for three month plan."

Despite the straightforward nature of the sting, Phoenix perceives the operation as a targeted effort by the Seattle Police Department (SPD) to tarnish his reputation.

[08:23] Phoenix Jones: "It's been terrible. Been some of the worst times of my entire life."

Charges and Legal Proceedings

Initially charged with two counts of violation of the Uniform Controlled Substances Act, Phoenix pled guilty in March 2021 to lesser conspiracy charges. This plea resulted in minimal punishment—four days in jail (time served) and a $600 fine—raising suspicions about the validity and intentions behind the prosecution.

[16:15] David Weinberg: "Phoenix did plead guilty to two counts of conspiracy to commit violation of the Uniform Controlled Substances Act."

David Weinberg scrutinizes the police's motives, suggesting that the SPD's past questionable sting operations lend credence to Phoenix's claims of being unfairly targeted.

Seattle Police Department and Public Perception

David Weinberg interviews Rich Smith, a journalist from The Stranger, who provides insight into the SPD's reputation. The department is described as "overfunded" and "moribund," often criticized for biased policing and ineffective sting operations.

[17:39] Rich Smith: "The Seattle Police Department is a moribund institution that's overfunded."

Phoenix's association with the SPD during his arrest fuels his narrative of being a victim of systemic bias, further complicating public perception.

Phoenix Jones's Attempted Comeback Amidst Social Unrest

By May 2020, Phoenix seemingly retires from his superhero activities. However, the outbreak of the George Floyd protests reignites his desire to protect the community. Phoenix announces his return via a tweet, offering assistance to those injured or in need during the chaos.

[31:09] Phoenix Jones: "If you're injured and you need my help, give me a call. Hit me up on Twitter, I'll come help you."

Despite his efforts, including livestreaming patrols and attempting to thwart break-ins, Phoenix's reputation continues to decline. An incident at Cartender, where Phoenix claims to have prevented a break-in, is disputed by the store owner, casting further doubt on his credibility.

Conflict with Other Real-Life Superheroes

As Phoenix Jones struggles with his image, other real-life superheroes like Red Ranger and Justin Service emerge to offer legitimate support during the protests. These heroes distance themselves from Phoenix, highlighting his tarnished reputation.

[39:12] Phoenix Jones: "Phoenix Jones."

[39:13] David Weinberg: "No, he's not a member of our organization."

The conflict culminates in a tragic incident on June 20, 2020, where Phoenix and his team arrive at the scene of a shooting in the Capitol Hill Occupied Protest (CHOP) zone. Despite their efforts, they fail to save 19-year-old Horace Lorenzo Anderson Jr., leading to intense self-reflection and public criticism.

[42:38] David Weinberg: "We ended up losing a poor young man. You know, when we tried to save him, we didn't get the help we needed that night."

Personal Insights and Character Flaws

Accompanying David Weinberg on patrols provides a candid look into Phoenix's personal life and character. Despite his heroic aspirations, Phoenix exhibits traits of arrogance, hypocrisy, and an inability to heed constructive criticism. Instances such as his dismissive attitude towards a radio host's critique and his contentious relationship with his girlfriend reveal a complex and flawed individual.

[56:08] Phoenix Jones: "I popped it in, the machine worked, and I was like, there, problem solved."

The episode highlights the dichotomy between Phoenix's public persona and his private demeanor, questioning the authenticity of his heroism.

Legacy and Future of Real-Life Superheroes

In the concluding segments, Phoenix Jones's influence wanes as his actions become increasingly scrutinized and mocked. The episode ponders the future of real-life superheroes in Seattle, suggesting that Phoenix's downfall has cast a shadow over the movement. However, personal stories, such as Phoenix's son stopping a robbery, hint at the possibility of genuine heroism emerging despite the setbacks.

[68:52] Phoenix Jones: "He just straight kicked him straight in the face."

David Weinberg reflects on whether Phoenix's son might inherit his father's heroic traits, offering a glimmer of hope for the next generation.

Conclusion

Episode 8 of "The Superhero Complex" presents a nuanced and critical examination of Phoenix Jones's journey from a celebrated real-life superhero to a controversial figure entangled in legal issues and public disdain. Through detailed storytelling, interviews, and personal anecdotes, the episode challenges listeners to reconsider the true essence of heroism and the complexities behind those who seek to embody it.

Notable Quotes

• [08:23] Phoenix Jones: "It's been terrible. Been some of the worst times of my entire life."

• [16:15] David Weinberg: "Phoenix did plead guilty to two counts of conspiracy to commit violation of the Uniform Controlled Substances Act."

• [31:09] Phoenix Jones: "If you're injured and you need my help, give me a call. Hit me up on Twitter, I'll come help you."

• [39:12] Phoenix Jones: "Phoenix Jones."

• [42:38] David Weinberg: "We ended up losing a poor young man. You know, when we tried to save him, we didn't get the help we needed that night."

• [56:08] Phoenix Jones: "I popped it in, the machine worked, and I was like, there, problem solved."

• [68:52] Phoenix Jones: "He just straight kicked him straight in the face."

Final Thoughts

This episode serves as a compelling narrative on the blurred lines between heroism and vigilantism, illustrating how personal flaws and external pressures can undermine noble intentions. Phoenix Jones's story is a cautionary tale about the complexities of taking justice into one's own hands and the profound impact such actions can have on one's legacy and community perception.